Cover Image: The Christmas Swap

The Christmas Swap

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I love Melody Carlson's Christmas stories!
Her books are exactly what you need to find spirit and happiness as this magical season approaches!
This novel takes place in Colorado with snow, and love in the air!
Emma Daley flies to Colorado for Christmas with her friend's family. She always spends the holiday with Gillian and her family.
They decided to swap homes with another family who wishes for warm weather in Arizona. during the holiday.
Ski lesson's from the handsome, strong caretaker of the house, give Emma the feeling that this could be the best Christmas yet!
Tyler Prescott immediately likes Emma.
Should he stay in Colorado for Christmas to get to know her better?
Truly a sweet, quick read that will have you wishing for hot chocolate and a warm blanket!

Was this review helpful?

My first book by this author and I really loved it. An absolutely gorgeous little plot which involves two families swapping houses at the most wonderful time of the year. Romantic and very Christmassy. Likeable characters kept me hooked, especially Emma who I could really identify with. I won’t give the plot away but I highly recommend this book for a bit of lighthearted Christmas escapism.

Was this review helpful?

The Christmas Swap was a cute short story about two families switching homes for Christmas. One home is in steamy Tempe, Arizona while the other is the extreme opposite in snowy Breckenridge, Colorado. One of my favorite things about reading is the opportunity to travel to locations I've never been and I enjoyed my first time visit to Breckenridge.

Successful songwriter West Prescott has his work cut out for him when he finds himself attracted to substitute teacher and part time singer musician Emma Daley. Their cute meeting is a comedy of errors and fate seems to work against them through the manipulations of a so called "friend".

It all works out in the end, but after all the twists and turns of the story I would have really liked to have read an epilogue that had a more complete ending. I rate this story 3.5 stars. I appreciate Revell Publishing, through Netgalley, making a copy of The Christmas Swap available for review.

Was this review helpful?

Tyler’s family volunteers his home for a Christmas home swap but when he gets stuck behind, the confusion grows as he claims to be the caretaker. When he meets sweet Emma, he’s more than happy with the circumstances. It’s her first time seeing real snow and it’s fun to see her experience new things. She’s a delight. Her friend, Gillian, however, isn’t. It’s hard to imagine why they’re friends but you see glimpses of a deeper person at times.

Tyler is such a good ski instructor. I felt like I could go out on the bunny hill and make it down alright. HA It was fun reading about this unusual way to spend Christmas. I’d recommend it. Thanks to Revell for providing me with a free e-copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! It was a short read. I definitely want to read some other books now by Melody Carlson. I wish there was more at the end because it felt like a bit of a cliffhanger in terms of Emma talking to Gillian and what happens when she stayed with West. I would recommend this as a short read for anyone who likes a good romance book.

Was this review helpful?

I have mixed feelings on this book. It's short, sweet, and full of gorgeous scenery and fun mishaps, but I felt a slight disconnect from the characters. I love Christmas stories, and Melody Carlson has written many charming stories with the Christmas atmosphere, but I wanted a bit more from this one. Some of the characters were so unlikable that I couldn't sympathize with them.

I love the holiday backdrop and the premise of the story, and the white Colorado Christmas was the highlight for me, but overall, some of the characters and the insta-romance were a turnoff. I hate to even say that because I usually love this author's books.

I received a complimentary digital copy of this book via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Melody Carlson....you make my heart smile!!! Swapping houses for Christmas! Hmmmm......I'm not sure that it would really make anyone happy, but it sure was an enjoyable read!! Who doesn't love a trip to the mountains for Christmas though and some snow to boot?!?!?!

I received an advanced reader copy of this book and am voluntarily reviewing it.

Was this review helpful?

Lovely book, a quick and light read, and well written.
Emma travels with her friends family in a house swap situation for Christmas.

Emma meets West, who is supposed to travel with his family to the warmer climate and Emma's friend's family home - for this house swap. West pretends he is the caretaker and he and Emma hit it off.

Read the book to find out the ending. A lovely story and I look forward to another light hearted story from Melody in the future.

Was this review helpful?

Oh I really love a good Christmas story! You'd was perfect. It was simple and straightforward, perfect for that busy time of the year.
This story was filled with hope and love and I highly recommend it to anyone.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet Christmas story! Every year I look forward to the new Christmas novels. Yes, they may be short and predictable but readers enjoy the lighthearted stories of this merry time of the year. Recommended!

Was this review helpful?

A short but sweet christmas romance set in the perfect Hallmark christmas location. There are great romantic leads in West and Emma, both of whom are likeable and well suited. Emma is reluctantly involved in a christmas house swap with her friend's (Gillian) family. Instead of spending christmas in the Arizona desert, they get to spend it in the perfect christmas card location of a snowy Colorado. Whilst the awful Gillian and her equally awful mother are dissatisfied and snooty about the exchange, Emma is thrilled, especially when she meets the lodge 'caretaker' West. However, as the two become closer Gillian's meddling and West's secret threaten to tear the two apart.
The perfect short novel to curl up with in front of a roaring fire with a hot chocolate.

Was this review helpful?

2 stars. It was okay.

It's a very simplistic, very light story. The writing is mostly dialogue and the characters don't have a lot of depth.

It's the perfect story for readers who like quick Christmas stories that don't require a lot of mental energy.

I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I say it every time I read one but I love Melody Carlson's books! She did not disappoint me with this beautiful Christmas story. I have a dream of living in a cabin in our NC mountains. It certainly will not be as elaborate as West's cabin but I loved the visions in my mind of its beauty while I was reading. I'll be on the lookout for Melody's next book!

Was this review helpful?

Christmas is in the air!

This book is about two families with extremely different personalities that swap homes for the holidays. One family is an extremely dysfunctional family from Arizona who invite their daughter’s friend, Emma, who is quite the opposite personality to spend the holiday with them, and the other family member, West, who is focused, is a rich, well-known songwriter who lives in Colorado.

This short Christmas story was a sweet quick read that I enjoyed. I recommend it to those who enjoy Christmas stories of dysfunctional family and friends, new friends and new found love.

I received a copy of this book from Revell and Netgalley and opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Christmas Swap was such a fun book to read. Vacationing in Breckenridge Colorado, taking to the slopes, meeting the caretaker. The Caretaker!!

Emma, a shy substitute teacher and music hopeful, is persuaded by her friend Gillian Landers to tag along when the Landere swap houses with a family in Colorado. Emma is a good go between for the dysfunctional family. When she meets West, the caretaker, she is impressed by his mild manner and easy way of conversing. He offers to teach her how to ski. Her manipulating friend learns of Wests hidden identity and makes for trying times on the slopes.

It was a fun read, short but sweet. Melody Carlson is an expert on writing believable characters.

I received a complimentary ebook copy from the publisher, through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was quick read. Very predicable but I enjoyed it any how.. I just will never understand the whole taking in the poor person then not treating them right. Emma was a good sport and Harris just seems like an add on but Grant did turn out to be a good guy. Poor Mr Landers he has his hands full with Mrs Landers, I afraid that is one women that would need to be slapped.

Was this review helpful?

The Christmas Swap by Melody Carson was very entertaining, with plenty of romance and adventures. You may put everything else on hold while you read one more chapter!
Emma, a teacher who really wants to be a musician, goes to Colorado for Christmas with a friend, Gillian, who is wealthy and spoiled rotten. Gillian's family, who live in Arizona, are swapping houses with Tyler West Prescott, a very talented musician and songwriter who lives in Colorado.
Tyler is not happy with the house swap but agrees to do it because of his mother. Plans change the first day when he meets Gillian and she accuses him of breaking into his own car. He introduces himself as West, the caretaker of the home and the fun begins.
Tyler (West) meets sweet and shy Emma and they have an instant connection. Gillian does not want Emma to see West because he is the caretaker and she doesn't think he is good enough until she finds out his true identity and then she wants him for herself.
Fun story with such a beautiful description of the snow capped mountains that you want to be there.
I thank the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me to read and review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

Reading Melody Carlson's yearly Christmas book is a tradition for me. I never miss one. She always brings her readers a wonderful and delightful story for the holidays. This one is no exception. Sweet characters and a precious little storyline. I enjoyed every single minute.

*My thanks to Revell Publishing for a copy of this book. The opinion here is my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Christmas Swap was a fun read in July for me as I was on vacation in the Rocky Mountains. The book is a light romance focusing on a homeowner, Tyler, who ends up not leaving his home as planned when another family has booked it for Christmas. He quickly becomes attracted to guest Emma, but there is many mishaps on which guest likes whom in the story which causes too much high school style drama. If you want a simple romance for the holidays, you will enjoy this one.

Was this review helpful?

This was a short and sweet romance. I liked West and Emma, they seemed like two genuinely nice people, but most of the rest of the characters were not really likeable. Gillian and her mother, in particular, were unkind. Gillian was manipulative, judgemental, a snob and just plain nasty. I’ve no idea why someone like Emma is still friends with her. Gillian rescued her when they were younger, but that’s no reason to put up with such a toxic “friendship”.

The setting of West’s house and the town, skiing etc was well done, though a little more description would have made the various restaurants etc a little more distinguishable from one another. However, the mountains, snow and decorations in West’s house did give a nice Christmas atmosphere.

I was rather disappointed that Emma and West were somehow in love after only spending a total of one day together. I think it would have been more believable if there’d been more time. However, I think that’s partly down to the book being so short.

If you’re looking for a short and sweet Christmas romance, and don’t mind a manipulative character, then this is the book for you.

I was given a free copy of this book, my opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?