Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The forest is very cold. The edge of the forest is being watched . Feyre ventured further from home than usual out of hunger. Feyre is gangly and has siblings to help feed. There is little food or money after father's injuries. I like the name Feyre.they feast on roasted venison. They use to be slaves to high faes. Faes are still around and cause trouble to the people. Isaac is feyres lover but soon he will be married. Feyre is in trouble. Feyre must travel and leave her family behind. I liked feyre and felt for her.♥️

Was this review helpful?

This book is so good. A great YA fantasy book about a human, teenage girl getting traded into a Fae land because she killed a wolf. Great action, romance and loved the characters! Definitely some graphic scenes so more for older teenagers and adults. Maas has very vivid details so that you feel like you are in the Fae lands of Prythian. This is an amazing series and I love the new cover art for the series.

Was this review helpful?

This book series just isn't for me. I know it is very popular, but there is just too much here that squicks me out. I also don't care for the re-design.

Was this review helpful?

It was interesting but I almost felt like it should have been 2 books instead of 1, like the struggle with Amarantha should have been drawn out. At the same time, Rhysand should have been introduced sooner if he's the main romance of the series. By the same coin, too much time was given to Tamlin. The Beauty and the Beast parallels were wasted on him. Lucien shows promise though and I was delighted by Nesta's evolution. I liked the flaws Feyre was allowed to have and how they were exasperated by her humanity and because of that, I'm interested to see how this evolves or manifests in the future now that she is HIgh Fae now. I want her to still be imperfect and flawed and not just have all of her limitations shoved aside. I'm not sure this book was worth the hype but I did have a decent time reading it.

Was this review helpful?

To this day, I don't get the hype around this book. It's mediocre at best. True, I love the fae elements, and the trials at the end were interesting, but as a whole, it just doesn't live up to its reputation at all. I don't think I need to reiterate the plot; it's well-known enough already.

A few things I truly don't love about this book:
- rapey love interests
- a classic nOt LiKe oThEr gIrLs protagonist, who is constantly whiny and annoying
- very bland writing, with a tendency to repeat certain words a lot
- most male characters exclusively speak in animalistic ways--purred, growled, etc.
- the premise isn't that original?
- so much sex. Like so so so much. I'm fine with sex scenes if they advance plot or character development, but in here, they just don't. Plus, the writing on those scenes is pretty cringe-inducing.

As someone who has read the whole series, I can say the next two books are better--still nothing special, but good--but this one is a lackluster series opener at best.

Was this review helpful?

A Court of Thorns and Roses in the first book in an epic series that centers around Feyre. After accidentally killing a fae warrior she is taken to a strange land and must learn how to survive. I absolutely loved this book and cannot wait until I can continue on to the second one.

Was this review helpful?

I feel there are two types of Mass fans, those who adore ToG and those who worship ACOTAR. I find myself leaning more towards ToG. But don’t get me wrong, I still enjoyed the hell out of this one. I think for me the characters aren’t as strong as I know she’s capable of writing, however, as I have finished the series, I have to say it gets so much better and is absolutely worth diving into.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Bloomsbury for giving me the opportunity to read the new edition of A Court of Thorns and Roses in exchange for an honest review.

There are tales of faeries in the woods disguised as great beasts and when Feyre kills a wolf she's met with a beast that demands her life for the murder of his kind. To keep her family safe she goes with him across the wall to dividing the humans from the Fae.

Half guest and half captive to the Fae that changed her life, Tamlin, Feyre quickly learns that not everything she has been told about the Fae is true and that their world is much more dangerous than she could have imagined. '

A Court of Thorns and Roses will always be one of my favorite books because it helped reignite my love of reading. The world of Prythian is ancient but also a bit modern, Feyre does feel like a very modern protagonist and at times she can be kind of difficult to relate to. I wasn't the biggest fan in my first read, but on my second after the whole scene is put before me I loved Feyre and all the characters.

At times the pacing seems a little slow, but it's just building this new world brick by brick until it threatens to let it crumble to the ground. The intensity builds with each chapter and I was hooked really early on. I couldn't put the book down, I actually read the entire series over a weekend.

The new covers are stunning and I really like that the series is now in the adult section where I think it really belonged in the first place. It was more accessible, even though a little too steamy for the age range when it was in young adult but here I think it will find it's niche.

Was this review helpful?

The first book I ever read from this author and it was a very promising beginning. I definitely struggle with YA, but wanted to see what all the fuss was about a few years ago so I read it and quickly devoured it. In fact, I read it two times (the second reading in preparation for the third installment to be released) and I liked it even better the second time.

It is so creative and the world building really had me in awe of the author's imagination and execution of this idea. There was definitely some drama, but that is to be expected for YA. This is just shy of my favorite YA fantasy book of all time, but it is a very strong beginning. I plan to re-read it for a third time some day. That should indicate to you that there is something real here and it is not just hype.

Thanks to Netgalley for the opportunity to review a new edition of this series.

Was this review helpful?

I’m just going to be real, the first time I read this book, I DNF 3 times and it took me a year before I finally finished it. 😐 It was just so bloody boring at first. I’m so thankful that I pushed through and finished because it’s now one of my favorite series ever; but I really hated the beginning at first.
Let’s talk characters; because honestly that’s why we read this series. 😅
I love Lucien. He’s such a snarky and sarcastic little shit.
Feyre was not my favorite at first. She annoyed me but as she grew throughout her time in Prythian; she grew on me as well.
Tamlin. Ugh. I can not stand Tamlin. Just from his actions in the first book, I wanted to throttle him. He’s such a pompous jerk. He is so controlling and aggressive. I felt so bad for Lucien. Tamlin treats him like shit.
Alis is so fun. I just loved everything about her.
Rhysand made me want to simultaneously punch him in the mouth and jump his bones. 😅 He’s such an ass but you can tell he’s not being an ass because he enjoys it. I know a lot of people really dislike the way he treated Feyre Under the Mountain; but I felt like he did that for her. She was so close to breaking until he started getting her drunk enough to forget everything. Obviously, that’s not healthy but WTF else could he have done at that point?

The world-building is phenomenal. Honestly, that’s all I have on that. It is PHENOMENAL.

Basically, after my initial resistance of ACOTAR, I fell in love with it. I will read and re-read it many times over for the rest of my exsistance.

Was this review helpful?

Obviously, by reading this book before, I knew what was going to happen and I also knew the plot later down the road because I have read the books after this one. This is my second time reading this book and while I still love it, my opinions have drastically changed. I was actually surprised at how much they changed.
My opinion of Tamlin changed drastically. Yes, some of it may have to do with what he does in future books but, rereading it, I noticed some things I didn't before. For one thing, he did show signs of being abusive behavior towards Feyre. The scene where he corners her in the hallway after Calanmai in particular. Feyre tells Tamlin to let go of her yet he refuses after she repeatedly tells him to do so. He then bites her against her will. When questioned about it the next morning by Lucien, he says that it is Feyre's fault for disobeying his orders. EXCUSE ME?! I am not even going to get started at how wrong that is. He assaulted her and has the nerve to blame her for it?! That is only one example of his abusive traits. Looking back, I have no idea how blind I was to his abusive behavior when I was first reading it.
One thing that shocked me was that my opinion of Lucien changed. When I read the book the first time, I really liked his character and gave him nothing but praise. I understand he had a really tough life and lost the girl he loved, but he was horrible to Feyre in this book. He flat out admits that he hesitated to save her when she screamed for help when fighting the naga. If Tamlin had not been there, Lucien would have let Feyre die. After rereading this book, I realize that I strongly dislike Lucien as a character now.
On the positive side, I did notice a ton of things that are later a big deal as the books go on. Sarah really did plant a lot of seeds that grow into major plot points later on in the series. I really enjoyed finding little things that I overlooked the first time reading it.
While I still love this series, I feel like I can appreciate it a lot more now because of my change in emotions. I never thought it was possible for my opinion to change that much in a book. If I am being totally honest, this didn't even feel like the same book while rereading it. I think that really speaks to how gifted Sarah is that she was able to do that.

Was this review helpful?

This is a well written, intersting book about a girl thrown into the fae world. While the first few chapters started off slow, but I quickly got hooked on the story and characters. The characters were well written, the world building was excelent, and the ending makes you want to want to instantly pick up the next book.

Was this review helpful?

Ultimately I really loved this book. I love fairytale retellings and this was such a great beauty and the beast story. My only issue is that I feel all the more exciting events were crammed into the last quarter of the book. It starts strong, but bulk of the middle feels mostly like filler. Tamlin is a bit of a Boy Scout of a hero, it gets difficult to see what the heroine really sees in him. But anyway, the story really moved in the later half. Some elements were a bit predictable and not very original, it was easy to pick things out that were taken out of other fairytales. Example: picking the lentils in the fireplace....
But all in all, this was entertaining and I can’t wait to continue the series!

Was this review helpful?

I held off reading this until multiple books were published because I knew my life would revolve around it once I started it. I was right. This book was another masterful tale of love and duty and strength and it amazed me with twists around every corner. While Rhys was rude, he reminded me a lot of Finnick, and Finnick is my ride-or-die, so I kept reading until I was finished and I have no more words. You need this book in your hands.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully done cover with a dazzling tale though the pace of the narrative ruins a lot as the snail's pace of the flow of events does not entice the non-fantasy lover for long. The number of chapters are a lot to take in and the first book itself can be made into two books. The nuances of description holds the reader's attention and it can be said that the book has been marketed really really well. I've been seeing this book on bookstagram and elsewhere and everyone's been talking about it. So clearly great marketing but rather slow, tediously unfolding plot and intense narration. Mixed emotions about this book.

Was this review helpful?

Today started with a storm and the pups and I were stuck inside all day. But I made bulletproof coffee and we cuddled and this was exactly the sort of quiet and dark story I was looking for.

This starts as a Beauty & The Beast retelling, dressed up beautifully in faery lore.

Feyre is the reliable and responsible younger sister, trying to care for her father and two older sisters, who have had a hard time adapting to their loss of wealth. She's become a hunter out of necessity and goes out into the dangerous woods to find food and supplies for her family.

Why are the woods dangerous you ask? Because they lead to faery. After an encounter with a fae in wolf's clothing, literally, Feyra gets taken away by the High Lord of the Spring Court.

Tamlin, said High Lord, turns out to be in quite a bind. He, and his Court, were cursed with permanent masks until a human woman who hated faeries fell in love with Tamlin.

Was this review helpful?

This book has an exceptional way of grabbing me by all the feels and pulling every single heart string!

Like many, this book was my first by Sarah J Maas, and will not be my last. It starts the romantic fantasy adventure of our lifetime.

When Feyres family is starving in winter, she heads out to the woods to hunt. her hunger and need for survival get the best of her when she accidentally shoots a fae wolf in order to bring her family home some dinner. Per the fae and human laws and treaties, Feyre must now be dragged into a magical and vicious world and live her life out in the spring court.

A slight retelling of beauty and the beast that will stay with you for years to come.

Was this review helpful?

Read this back in 2016 and I enjoyed it. I'm happy that the covers in this series were redesigned to be more adult than young adult.

Was this review helpful?

A Court of Thorns and Roses is about the young protagonist Feyre, who lives on the continent of Prythian south of the wall in the land of mortals. After losing her mother and her father's fortune, she is forced to live a life of seclusion and poverty together with her two sisters and her father. Feyre has asserted herself as the family's breadwinner, and has proven herself a gifted hunter, teaching herself how to hunt. One day, during a hunting expedition, she runs into great danger and makes a fateful decision that takes her to a whole new world. This new world not only turns out to be the realm of the seven courts, but it also turns out to be a madly magical world with countless magical creatures as well as new dangers. Whether Feyre can hold her ground in this world unknown to her, which is threatened by a terrible curse and whether she manages to survive among all the Fae is revealed in this opening novel.

Without a real division of the novel the book is unofficially split into two different parts. The plots develop completely in a different direction in both sections, the main focus is set differently and the relationship between the protagonists has shifted to a different level. While the first half of the book focuses mainly on the discovery of the new surroundings, part two is about the consolidation of the newly discovered relationships. I really liked this division. The cut is plausible and is introduced by a decisive event, which connects the two protagonists Tamlin and Feyre in a very emotional and intimate way. The development of the protagonists is always the focus of Sarah J. Maas' story. While Tamlin remains opaque until the end of the book, but at least occasionally shows a few approaches on how to classify him and what motives drive him, with Feyre you are a little more confident. She is clearly in the focus of the story, you get to know her motives and feelings from the very beginning and can therefore put yourself in her shoes. With a few exceptions, Feyre has become quite likeable to me and was able to convince me of herself with her peculiarities and her motives, even if she did get on my nerves from time to time. Nevertheless, this isn't that bad, because this behavior is somehow human and nobody is really perfect. Not even the main character of this fairy tale adaptation. Apart from these two great protagonists, this novel can also convince with its numerous really well sketched side characters and interesting creatures from the realm of the Fae.

Another great aspect of the book is the well thought-out plot, which convinced me from the very first page. Admittedly, this story has some parallels to the fairy tale template Beauty and the Beast, but can still develop enough independence to work well as an own work, as the story seems to move further and further away from the template as the plot progresses. The story is wonderfully well thought-out, with lots of nice details and with one or two cleverly placed cliffhangers it's incredibly thrilling and entertaining to read.

Was this review helpful?

This was everything it promised to be by those who recommended it. This is the first book I've read by Sarah J. Maas and I have to say, that it is well written.

The premise for the book is a beauty and the beast tale. Feyre is a young woman, from a family that once had wealth and position but brought to poverty and near starvation by bad debts. The setting is fantastical, with humans and fairies living in the same lands with a wall separating their kinds. Feyre has become the hunter in her family, keeping them just about fed. It is a stark life with no pleasure. One day she kills a wolf who was one of the fairie. She knew this, but still went ahead. Now Tamlin has arrived from the land of the High Fairie to pursue revenge with her life lived in his lands. This is a twisty, completely absorbing tale. The creatures are light and dark, scary and warm and the relationships are so compelling. The culmination of this tale is utterly unpredictable and it is left wide open for the next book. I cannot wait to read more.

Was this review helpful?