Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I had high hopes for The Switch after recently reading Beth O’Leary’s prior book, The Flatshare. While I liked The Flatshare better, I still highly enjoyed The Switch - the story of a grandmother (Eileen Cotton) and her granddaughter (Leena Cotton) who are both in need of a change of scenery and swap homes for a couple of months. Eileen goes from a quiet, rural, close knit community to the hustle and bustle of London, and Leena takes a break from her high intensity life in the city for the more slow-paced existence that her grandmother lives.

I enjoyed the story of each character learning the ropes and acclimating to their new environments, each of them creating their own relationships with those in the other’s life. The story contained its fair share of fluff, but it also dealt with some deeper issues including how the characters process the loss of a loved one, and the isolation often experienced by the elderly. I was moved by the characters’ stories, but overall was left with positive and happy feelings at the end of the book.

My main, and not so significant, issue with the book was that I felt the story was predictable at times. Having said that, I certainly enjoyed the journey that O’Leary took us on as we experienced Eileen and Leena’s stories as they explored their new lives.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so heartwarming and such a relaxing read. From the start I could sympathize with both characters. They were unique and lovable. The #audiobook was perfect for my busy two weeks. The two women reading do a wonderful job of capturing the mood and make the book come to life.

PSA: I didn’t agree with the authors normalization of urinary leakage (urinary incontinence) and increased night time urination (dysuria). It is not normal to experience leakage at ANY age. Waking during the night to urinate is not normal if you are under the age of 65, over the age of 65 it is normal to go 1-2x/night. If you are experiencing urinary incontinence (whether urge or stress) there are treatments available that don’t include medications or surgery – a lot of it is based on education and training your pelvic floor muscles. If you are experiencing leakage ask your primary care doctor about seeing a women’s health physical therapist who specializes in addressing incontinence (whether male or female).

#netgallery #theswitch #betholeary #recommendedreads goodreads #instareads #bookloversunite #mustreads #fiction #bookrecommendations #bookaddict #bookstagram #bookstagrammer #booksofinstagram #bookclub #booksbooksbooks #teabagsandbooks #readingwithJenna #womenshealthphysicaltherapy #womenshealth #pelvicfloormuscletraining #pelvicfloor #urinaryincontinence #olderadults #aging #publicserviceannouncements #physicaltherapy #bookreviews #london #england #summerreads

Was this review helpful?

What a sweet story! I somehow loved this even more than The Flatshare, and I REALLY loved that one!

We follow duel perspectives. After Leena is pushed to brink at work in London and has a panic attack, she's put on sabbatical for three months. Eileen, Leena's grandmother, is yearning for romantic companionship that she can't find in rural Yorkshire. The two decide to essentially switch lives to get a better perspective on the things they need from their lives.

Eileen's perspective was probably my favorite just for how unexpected it was. It was so thrilling to see her start casually dating and make friends in the city. She was just so earnest and wholesome, and I loved seeing her story come to life. Her chapters made my laugh so much and smile so big that I couldn't give this book anything less than five stars.

But I also really felt for Leena in trying to get adjusted to small-town life and taking up her grandmother's responsibilities. I also love her personality and that she's just a genuinely lovely person trying to get through the trauma of losing her sister and repairing her relationship with her mother. If I had one critique though, it'd be that I didn't find it necessary for Leena to have a boyfriend at the start of the book. I would've loved to see her form a natural connection with Jackson without her having a boyfriend being the conflict that holds them back.

Otherwise, I absolutely loved this one! So glad I picked this one up when I did as I definitely needed a change in pace.

Was this review helpful?

The major reason why I am giving the audio format of this book 5 shiny stars is because of the narrators Daisy Edgar-Jones and Alison Steadman. If I had opted to read this book instead, I would not have liked it all that much but these two English actors (one of them also has an OBE) brought the book and the main characters, Lena Cotton and her grandmother Eileen Cotton (plus all the other interesting, funny, quirky supporting characters--both young and old) to life! I absolutely enjoyed listening to both of them! Not one dull moment!

My thanks to NetGalley, the author Beth O'Leary and the publisher MacMillan Audio for the audio ARC. This is the second audio book I have listened to from NetGalley.

🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Was this review helpful?

“I think you should know,' he says. 'I like you. Like I shouldn't. That sort of like.”
Lena has a busy life and stressful job in London. She is still reeling from the loss of her sister. As a result if her unprocessed grief she isn't performing at work as well as she knows she should. After her work forces her to go on a month long sabbatical she goes to visit her grandmother Eileen out in the country. Eileen is a 79 year old woman who wants to find someone to spend the rest of her life with, but the over familiar faces in her small town don't seem very promising. After little to no consideration, Lena proposes that she and her grandmother swap lives for a month.


This felt like the movie The Holiday, but with a little grandmother instead of a depressed middle aged woman. I really enjoyed Eileen's character. I loved watching the contrast between her practicality and the impracticality of her dreams. I wish this book had been more about her than Lena. Her character was more compelling and in some ways even more relatable for me? Am I just a 79 year old woman trapped in a tired 29 year old body??? DON'T ANSWER THAT!


Lena's personality felt a little less thought through. After finishing The Switch I felt like I knew next to nothing about who she was as a person. Her type A attributes and refusal to process grief seemed the most central parts of her characterization but they did a better job keeping me out rather than keeping me connected to her story and emotional journey. I was left wondering if she even grew at all? Lena disappointed on the character front, but I felt the fun story and Eileen's character helped me enjoy this novel more than I would have otherwise!

I listened to this on audiobook and I loved the narration here. I am always looking for audiobooks that add more to the experience of the book than I would have gotten from reading it in hardcover and this was absolutely the case for The Switch!!!

⭐⭐⭐/5 Stars


Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan Publishing for a copy of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Wow, where do I even begin? This book was so heartwarming and incredible. Beth O’Leary is an extremely talented writer! I listened to this book on audiobook, and I loved it so much that I went ahead and ordered the paperback version before I even finished it because I know I will be reading it again.

Leena and Eileen have very different storylines, but the combination of their plots made me so happy. I wish Eileen would be my best friend!

I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves a good rom com or anyone who loves Gilmore Girls. It was one of the best books I’ve read all year!

Was this review helpful?

This one was just pure fun! Lena and her grandmother both have the same name but they are at different places in their lives. Lena suffers a panic attack at work and they insist she take a paid two month vacation and she ends up going to the country to her grandmother's. Meanwhile her grandmum feels in a rut after her husband leaves and with all her work around town. She talks Lena into switching lives/locations with her. She goes to London and stays at her flat. Both have a bit of a surprise, learning there is more out there to life than what they had been living. It was great for both of them to let go and learn to live. I definitely recommend this one! I enjoyed this one in audio and the narrators were superb!

**Received this ARC in audio form from the publisher for review from NetGalley**

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful cute,sweet,funny,emotional and romantic story.
Follow the switch of Leena(granddaughter)and Eileen (grandmother) as they switch their lives for a month one to the country the other to the city..
Enjoyed getting to know theirs lives and friends and how they worked everything out.
Voluntarily reviewed

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced audiobook copy from the publisher via Netgalley for an honest review.

This novel was the best and so what I needed right now! It was a funny, romantic comedy that dealt with really hard grief type situations in a great fluffy way, and I don't mean that in a bad way. This novel helped show ways that people need to work through their grief and troubled situations and realize that everyone is different.

The idea of this story was the BEST and so damn cute! Think the movie The Holiday and it's even better!!! I would absolutely watch this BBC miniseries if someone decided to make it into a show! Leena has a panic attack at work and her bosses tell her she needs to take a break and she is given a two month paid leave, and this workaholic has no idea how to take that break...so she runs over to her grandmother Eileen's house for some comfort. Eileen is also at a new place in her life, she is about to turn 80 years old and newly single when her husband of many decades left her for a younger woman, but her wonderful cozy town does not seem to have a lot to offer for her. Eileen and Leena decide that they need to switch lives and oh does the adventure ensue! This was so wonderful and heart warming and just plain beautiful. This is a book that I would absolutely return to if I was having a bad day and it would just lift me up. SO WONDERFUL!!

Was this review helpful?

I loved Beth O’Leary’s first book The Flatshare SO much. Especially on audio. I couldn’t get enough of the characters and I’m still jealous of people who get to read it for the first time. So, needless to say I was giddy with delight when I found out The Switch was coming.

This book is told from both Leena Cotton and her grandmother Eileen’s points of view. Leena lives in London and works non-stop (partly as a coping mechanism after the death of her sister) until she gets so stressed and run-down that her boss forces her to take time off. Eileen lives in a little village in Yorkshire and frankly, she’s a bit sick of her life. In particular, her romantic prospects are looking a bit thin in the tiny town she lives in. The two decide to switch lives and each take a break from their own. Leena goes to live in her grandmother’s house and her grandmother takes up Leena’s room in the rented London flat (roommates and all).

The Switch does have a healthy dose of romance, but so much more as well. There is grief, healing, family drama, community, friendship, and a lot of rediscovery. And it seems Leena and Eilleen aren’t the only ones working out what they really want out of life, their attitude and can-do spirit seem to rub off on everyone they meet.

It took me a little longer to fall in love with the characters in The Switch than it did while reading The Flatshare, but I definitely got there. And while I didn’t think The Switch had quite as much wonderfully-dry British humor it certainly had some good laugh-out-loud moments. I’ll also admit to letting out a sob or two towards the end as well. It was all-round a delightful book.

The audiobook is just over 10 hours at 1x speed, but I felt like it flew by because I was so wrapped up in the story. It is narrated by Alison Steadman and Daisy Edgar-Jones and I thought both of them did a brilliant job at bringing all the characters to life.

Was this review helpful?

This story was brilliantly written!
And the cutesy story about grandma and granddaughter. With so much about loss and dealing with grief.
Also grandmother (some of them) are the best!
Also the audio book experience was the best. So go listen to the book you will enjoy it!

Was this review helpful?

This audiobook was an easy listen. Leena is a workaholic who has a panic attack during a presentation and is forced to take a sabbatical for her health. Leena and her grandmother decide to switch places for the duration of Leena's time off. Leena goes back to her small hometown while her grandmother, Eileen, heads to London to find love. I was a tad bit iffy on following a 79 year old trying to find love but I loved Eileen so, so much! She was hilarious with her sassy personality. It was so much fun watching her try online dating and trying to navigate the busy city. Leena was also a lot of fun to follow. She did all the small town fairs and all the small things that come with small town living.

Honestly this book was a bit of a shock for me. Like I said, I was worried about one of the leading ladies being a grandmother but I want both characters as friends. They felt like friends! They felt like the type of people I want to know.

The narration for the audiobook was perfect in every way. They made the characters really come alive!

I haven't read the authors first book but I have just purchased it and I can't wait to read. I am very excited! I love her writing.

Was this review helpful?

I'm new to audiobooks and this one hooked me! I am sure I'd have loved this story reading it myself but the narrators put it over the top for me. I could have listened to them all day!

This story makes you laugh out loud (embarrassing for me as I'd listen to it while out walking) and will also give you a gut-punch of empathy and compassion for the characters as the story goes on.

I want Eileen to be my grandma, and I want to move to the small Yorkshire village where the majority of the story takes place.

This funny, witty story of a twenty-something granddaughter switching places with her 79yo spunky grandma is highly entertaining. Yes, you can see some of the plot twists coming, but the heartfelt way the characters are written (and the amazing job by the narrators) will make you feel you know these quirky characters. You'll feel you are literally there, hanging out with these fun people who all have their own baggage to deal with, and care about each of them.

I will definitely read this author's first book, The Flat Share. She is a fantastic, hilarious author! Thanks o much to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me a copy of this fun story.

Was this review helpful?

Such a sweet story of two women from the younger and older generation doing a life swap. I enjoyed the narration and was happy to cosy up with my hobby, relax and listen in the late afternoons. My thanks to Netgalley for the audiobook in exchange for review.

Was this review helpful?

The Switch was a lovely book about Leena, a stressed out young woman living in London experiencing panic attacks who was forced on a two month sabbatical from her work, and Eileen, her 79 year old grandmother looking for a second chance at love.

Eileen lived in a small villaage in Yorkshire and there was an extremely small pool of eligible seniors to date. Leena needed a rest in the countryside to get away from the pressures of her job.

The two switch their entire lives, including duties, phones, houses, apartments, and friends. Leena no longer has her smart phone and has to contend with a clunker old cell phone and computer. Eileen gets to swipe right and meet a multitude of eligible men if she wishes while sharing Leena’s apartment with the roommates.

Since Eileen is involved with all aspects of the small town including neighborhood watch and the upcoming May Day festival, Leena steps in and tries to fill Eileen’s shoes. Of course hilarity ensues in both scenarios. And maybe even love?

I listened to this story on audiobook with Alison Steadman and Daisy Edgar-Jones as performers (and both were wonderful!) While I was listening to this story, I could picture it in my head as a delightful rom-com movie. It’s a brilliant idea and I adored both Leena and Eileen. Even all of the side characters were absolutely adorable.

*Thank you so much to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the advance copy!*

Was this review helpful?

‘You only have a car in London if you want to practice road rage or high stress parallel parking’ - too relatable! I barely ever drive our car in London, but Ben LOVES driving in London (crazy kid!).

I’d seen this book all over Bookstagram and thought I’d check it out. I saw @l.auraslibrary review of the audiobook version of The Switch and I have to say I completely agree with her! I absolutely love Alison Steadman, but I found her chapters sometimes annoying to listen to, and I LOVE Alison Steadman. I think it would have been a really great book to read physically rather than listen to, particularly after how much I enjoyed The Flatshare, but the conversations between characters over text messages/dating sites etc. being read out by the narrator was sometimes a bit painful to listen to and very repetitive.

Despite this, I really enjoyed Daisy Edgar-Jones reading Leena’s chapters, I thought it was great casting for a VO. I think I was slower to click with this one due to the age between the characters - I often find it easier to read and therefore relate to characters my age. I did love the setting of this book - the politics in the local town were absolutely spot on! A lighthearted read, and just what I needed to get me through a busy work week - I could have it on in the background whilst I was sorting lots of paperwork!

I’ve also seen that Beth O’Leary has her new book The Road Trip ready to pre-order! I’m looking forward to checking that out when it’s out.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading the book and that's why I downloaded the ebook. What I have realized is that, it works better for me when listening to audio books, if there are is an entire cast performing the book with background music.

I couldn't keep up with the audio book because my mind wanders off. This is something specific to me so its not a review for the book or the author or the actors performing the book.

Thank you Netgalley and the publishers for approving my request for this audio book.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book so much. The characters seemed very real to me, and the dialogue was authentic and funny. I loved seeing how they dealt with grief and life changes and how both Eileen and Lena both carved new paths for themselves. The audiobook version was very well done. I highly recommend this as a book that seems lighthearted on the surface but has some real depth.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book!! It was a cute story!! First book I read by this author will read her other book!! Received this book from netgally!!

Was this review helpful?

Leena living in London was ordered to take a 2 month sabbatical after being overworked and overstressed that she could no longer function at her job.

Eileen who is about to turn eighty is looking for another chance at love but its slim picking in her Yorkshire village.

What a perfect suggestion to switch for two months for Leena to wind down and relax in the countryside, while Eileen enjoys her life in the city meeting some eligible gentlemen.

The story is told in their point of views and it was lovely to read about the city and village life neighbors, gossips, and matters of the heart. Beth O’Leary’s writing is easy to read, heartwarming, and funny, while also embracing how important friendship, family and the community we live in. Her characters are realistic and relatable, and despite challenges and difficulties, the writing is full of hope and positivity. I love that O’Leary gives me that tender fuzzy feeling when I read her books. 

After reading this book in March, I had to listen to this on audio, which was phenomenal! I loved the narration by #alisonsteadman and @daisyedgarjones that truly embodied the characters. I also enjoyed how the sound changes when the characters are speaking over the phone. It was a nice touch that I really appreciated!

I highly recommend this for a wonderful and fun escape read!

Was this review helpful?