Skip to main content

Member Reviews

***Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.***

🌟🌟🌟🌟
4 – 4.5 stars

The Red Ribbon by Pepper Basham is the 8th installment in the “True Colors” series. This one is based on the Hillsville Courthouse Massacre of 1912. I loved the peek into Appalachian life (the good AND the bad), and would LOVE to have a Granny around like the one in the book. As always, looking forward to the next installment.

Was this review helpful?

Another book in the True Colors series of Barbour Books is The Red Ribbon by Pepper Basham. This series hasn’t let me down yet!

A digital copy of The Red Ribbon was provided complimentary by NetGalley and Barbour Books. This book will release on October 1, 2020.

Like the beginning of any book, it starts off with basically sharing about the characters and the setting. This is my least favorite part of books! However, getting a better understanding of all these key players is helpful as you read through this story since there are so many characters to get to know! Having the character descriptions at the beginning is a big help to put the pieces together as the plot thickens!

The setting of this story almost reminds me of where my grandmother lived with it being pretty remote and it taking a while just to get into the town, especially if you’re on foot. Everyone knows everyone and everyone’s business as well. It’s a pretty tight knit community even with the controversy between families that follows generations.

When people are found murdered or left for dead, you know there’s something up. Small town folk don’t intentionally create havoc. Something bigger must be brewing and it was just a matter of time before it all revealed itself. The Red Ribbon has a few hidden secrets that are uncovered just in the nick of time!

As the story reached the climax, I was so hooked I couldn’t stop reading until reached the end! Lots of unexpected twists and turns that took me by surprise! Are main characters supposed to make it to the end of a book?

In my honest opinion, this book is a five out of five tiaras because it kept me guessing and my guesses were so wrong! Haha, I love it when I can guess what will happen and I’m totally wrong!

Was this review helpful?

Another thrilling installment in the True Colors series. The Red Ribbon by Pepper Basham transports you to 1912 Appalachia. Ava and Jeremiah find themselves in the middle of a family feud, based on factual events, with a fictional, romantic and inspirational twist. The characters are engaging and captivated my attention from start to finish. I loved learning more about the Courthouse Massacre through this historical account. The details are vivid and so clearly capture the time period, setting and characters. The writing has easily bumped this one to one of my favorites in the series. I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley and all opinions expressed are my own and freely given.

Was this review helpful?

Wow!! Can I simply say that and leave the rest for you to discover? Okay. Probably not the best choice, so I'll attempt to do this amazing story justice.

It was so fun to learn about the corn shucking tradition related to the red ear of corn. Not only does this tradition act as a catalyst in the relationship between best friends Ava and Jeremiah, it also gave way to a stupid act that catapulted the community into a conflict that resulted in tragedy.

Ava and Jeremiah's relationship was sweet and oh so romantic! Jeremiah's love for her was shown in his patience and persistence and the way he encouraged her. And, the gifts! He was so thoughtful and kind. He rather made me think of my amazing husband.

Ava struggled with a fear that her mother's "bad blood" would reveal itself in her own life and would have her going mad. Though she had given her life to the Lord at an early age, the tragedies that had occurred since had caused her to take her eyes off Jesus and focus them on her fears. I loved the gentle ways He guided her back to trusting Him and helped her to see hope amid seemingly hopeless situations.

The Courthouse Massacre of 1913 is not fictional. And the cause is not the imagination of Pepper Basham, either. While it is unquestionably a tragedy and while the added fictional conflict with moonshiners, murderers, and mayhem that led to the massacre could easily become dark and frightening, light shone into the darkness and filled the story with an expectation of good triumphing.

I am so thankful I trusted my instincts (as well as the recommendations of others who have read this book!) and wasn't afraid to read The Red Ribbon. It is another amazing story by a favorite author of mine and I recommend it highly, even to readers who, like me, are not brave enough to read the others in the True Colors series!

Was this review helpful?

I am thoroughly enjoying this true crime fiction series and now Pepper Basham’s superb contribution has only made the series better. The love and appreciation that Basham has for the people of the Blue Ridge Mountain area permeates the entire story, which is one of the reasons I enjoyed this book so much. The terrific characters drew me into this mountain area, while the drama and adventure added excitement. Top all that off with one fabulous romance and you’ve got The Red Ribbon. At the heart of the matter, were lessons of faith dealing with fear and letting go of the past to be able to live in the present and look toward the future. Without a doubt a true crime fictional story that will touch the heart of readers. I was given a copy of this book by the publisher. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Ava Burcham wants to expose the people behind some moonshine runs, in part due to her past. Jeremiah Sutphin has been in love with her for a time, and most oftentimes winds up rescuing her from her own curiosity. We meet other people from the area, Sid and Floyd Allen along with their grown boys, Granny Burcham, Mr and Mrs Temple, Keen, Caspar, Ellis, Sheriff Webb, The Creed Family, and a few others. Ava and Jeremiah draw you right in to their story as we are introduced to other minor characters, some that have more of a role as the story builds. Set in Fancy Gap, Virginia mostly, we also venture into Hillsville for part of the story. Beautiful telling of this event In history, and be sure to read the author notes at the end too.
A complimentary copy was provided by Barbour Publishing via NetGalley. A review was not required and all thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This entire series has been fascinating and The Red Ribbon is no exception. The setting is the author's hometown of Carroll County, Virginia. That helps explain why she was able to so clearly bring the area to life. The novel is based upon "The Courthouse Massacre" of 1912.

Mountain venacular is part of what brings the setting to life with phrases such as "sparkin'" and "like a squirrel to tree hoppin'". The descriptions of meals, homes and occupations were equally well done to paint a clear picture of the time and area.

The slow building romance in the novel was sweet to be a part of. The disagreements between families was tangled in facts back in 1912 and that came through in the pages. The author's afterward was a wonderful complement to learn more about the events and citizens that were a part of this tragic event.

Was this review helpful?

This was another good book in this series. It starts before what was known as the courthouse massacre. It started a bit slow for me but it finally took off. There’s quite a few characters and at times I had a hard keeping who was bad straight.
I really enjoyed the book and definitely recommend this book and the whole series.
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the early copy

Was this review helpful?

Love, Suspense and Shoot-outs in the Mountains of Virginia

The Red Ribbon by Pepper Basham is a historical fiction based on the Courthouse Massacre of 1912 in Hillsville, Va. Ava Burcham is a spunky young lady who loves to write, but feels she will never be taken seriously since she is a woman. Her best friend is Jeremiah Sutphin, but he wants to be more than a friend. Both have lost family members to violence and find themselves in the middle of feuding clans although Jeremiah works for one of them. I loved the book and couldn’t put it down.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and NetGalley and was under no obligation to post a review.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

The crime in The Red Ribbon was, The Hillsville Courthouse Massacre, a local crime to a town in Virginia I hadn’t heard of before. And while I have enjoyed learning about these cases I haven’t heard of before, I found this one both interesting and frustrating, due to the complexity of the incident, with so many players involved. I understood the concept of the Allen family being antagonistic toward others in the town, but I did wish I had more prior knowledge to build on going in, and I wasn’t sure how much I should look up about it in order to keep an element of surprise.

There was a fairly good development of suspense and foreboding in the prose. While not scary, there’s a definite sense that something is not right, and the dark topic was handled with delicacy and sensitivity.

The lead characters, Ava and Jeremiah, were..okay, but as I found they really stuck out in the story, and I feel this is one of the continued side effects of it also being Christian Fiction, so there has to be an element of humanity and goodness, instead of fully centering the much more interesting direct players in the crime. They had a sweet romance, but it was pretty underwhelming, especially since I have heard from other disappointed readers that this does not compare to Basham’s other work.

This was not my favorite of the series I’ve read so far, but I expected that would be the case, with multiple authors contributing. I do feel that someone with greater familiarity with the crime might enjoy it more.

Was this review helpful?

If you’re going to change the world around you, make sure you’re not the one changing to fit - Jeremiah

Don’t expect to put this one aside until you find out who or what is behind all the danger and killing that leads up to the Courthouse Massacre of 1912. The Appalachian hills hold a certain amount of mystery to all those who have not lived or visited there. It seems hard to believe that there would be such enmity between two families or clans that the feud would last for generations. Such was the situation in Caroll County, Virginia. The Thomas and Allen clans had been at odds for years and it finally came to a head in that courthouse. Could a simple kiss set the scene for murder??

Ava Burcham had seen her share of sorrow, losing her father and brother in violent deaths. Her job at the Temples Alteration Shop Allowed her to make a living with something she enjoyed - especially the beautiful ribbons. Never would she have guessed how important those red ribbons would become.

I thoroughly enjoyed the slow romance that the author entwined into this story of illegal stills, danger and death. It showed the resiliency of the human spirit, especially when one puts their trust in God, knowing He will be there all the time - regardless of what you are going through.

This ARC was received through Barbour Publishing and NetGalley. All comments and impressions are my own and were in no way solicited.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 STARS!!!

Liquor soothed a lot of restless Appalachian men in winter. Some bore it better than others. Some loved their drink so much, they killed for it.

That’s a pretty chilling thought. Tensions run deep ‘in them thar hills’. Basham has written a compelling narrative based on a true story. The Red Ribbon is a mystery with a dash of suspense, making it a quick and intriguing read. The author captures a disturbing essence of Appalachia back in the bootlegging days with such reality that the reader can’t help but be drawn into the family feuds and rivalries. The old saying, “Oh what a tangled web we weave when first we practice to deceive” came to mind as I was immersed in the complexity of multiple murders, both past and present.

Ava is traditional in many ways and yet quite avant-garde in others. She has a tenacity about her that gets her in some troublesome spots but Jeremiah is often present to rescue her. Their relationship is one built on friendship that turned to love and it is a sweet thing to behold. While Basham is known for her kissing scenes, the beautiful thing about each one in this book is that you know right off Ava and Jeremiah have a deep history and it is going somewhere…marriage. Not once is there anything lustful or inappropriate described and I appreciated that.

One of my favorite characters is Granny Burcham. She reminds me of a woman I knew named Liza when I was growing up deep in Appalachia in my formative years. Wise words do not necessarily come from education but from experience and Granny has a lot of it.

I highly recommend The Red Ribbon to those who like to learn facts encased in great fiction. The author also includes fascinating notes in the back of the book about the real people involved in The Hillsville Courthouse Massacre of 1912.

I received a copy of the book from the publisher and author. My opinion is my own. No compensation received.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fascinating historical fiction story. It centers around the Carroll County (Va.) Courthouse Massacre of 1912, events which touched my youngest daughter's paternal ancestors in Virginia and North Carolina.
Along with the historical events, which are accurately represented, there is a fictional couple who are the main characters and who give us a realistic look into mountain culture in the area. I was drawn into their story quickly and soon became just as interested in it as with the historical portion.
At the beginning of each chapter, there is a quote of "mountain wisdom" which I also enjoyed reading. Some of them had me laughing out loud, but all of them offer food for thought.
Once the story ends, there is a short epilogue that tells how each of the real people in the book fared after the shoot out at the courthouse.
There is a slight Christian slant to the storytelling, but it is not overwhelming, and it fits with the culture of the characters.
I highly recommend this to all fans of history and/or historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

A story filled with history, family, danger and the possibility of love. From the setting to the characters to the story line, this is a great read. I received a complimentary copy of the book. No review was required.

Was this review helpful?

Red ribbon-you will have to read the book to see how this goes in to the plot!

This book left me on the edge of my seat and staying up way too late to find out how everything would end! I really enjoyed the wise quotes at the beginning of each chapter. The characters of Jeremiah, Ava and granny Burcham were particularly endearing!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.

Was this review helpful?

"I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review."
The Red Ribbon by Pepper Basham was a difficult book to read. The myriad of characters was slightly confusing even though a guide to each person or family is printed at the beginning of the story. I didn't like repeatedly going back to the list to figure out who was who. There was no introduction to the characters as they appeared in the story. I felt as if I had missed the first book in a series. Now, having thrown my reader's fit, I have to admit The Red Ribbon is an excellent story. Not only because it is based on a true incident but the author captured the phrasing and dialect of the region. I am from the Appalachian mountains so I can say this with confidence. Basham beautifully describes the area of Fancy Gap and Hillsville Virginia. It is a gorgeous part of Virginia steeped in history and traditions. The author states that many of the descendants of the story still live there. Without going into detail of the Hillsville Courthouse Massacre, I can honestly say the writing puts you inside the courthouse on that bloody day. I thoroughly enjoyed the love story between Ava and Jeremiah. Mountain traditions and family loyalty are strong themes in The Red Ribbon and Basham tells a story steeped with both. While the story is sometimes dark, the beautiful way she ties faith into the story brings light to a tragic time in the area"s history

Was this review helpful?

I have read other titles in the True Color series, but I enjoyed this one less than the others. In 1912 Carroll County, VA, Ava is a budding writer with a penchant for trouble and a romantic interest in Jeremiah. They both get caught up in group dynamics that lead to a very nasty outcome for many people. The descriptions of the characters and times were interesting, but the plot just did not grab me and hold my interest. Thanks to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc. for providing an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Another novel in the True Color series – this one tackles The Hillsville Courthouse Massacre of 1912. Pepper Basham sets readers right into the historical setting through her attention to the scenery, customs, and dialect of the times. The true crimes story spills all of the details about some feuding families in an Appalachian mountain town. A seemingly innocent kiss at a corn-shucking contests leads to a bloody massacre, with outlaws on the run and a small town thrown into the spotlight. Ava Burcham and Jeremiah Sutphin find all kinds of dangerous situations as they fall in love during tumultuous and strange times. Not everyone can be trusted, and the pair become eye-witnesses to a deadly shootout just days before their wedding.

I’ll admit that this story wasn’t my usual non-stop action and suspense kind of read. A lot of romance fans will love this one. But I did enjoy this story. The author has an amazing writing style that captures the essence of the time period. I’m a fan of the whole series, which takes little know crime stories in the history of the United States and brings them to life in the pages of a fiction novel. The Red Ribbon let me imagine the chaos of the scene of these feuding families who seem to take the law into their own hands at times. The real-life crime still isn’t resolved as it seems unclear as to who started the whole thing and whether or not some innocent people were held accountable for the crimes.

Definitely check out The Red Ribbon if you are a fan of historical fiction, true crimes, or romance novels when it releases.

Overall Rating:
4 stars (I liked it a lot and would definitely recommend)
Suspense Rating:
3 stars (some suspenseful moments)

I received an ebook review copy of this book through NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own

Was this review helpful?

I've really enjoyed this True Colors series which are accounts of true crimes around the country, usually told from the perspective of fictional people - and most of which I'd not heard of prior to the reading of the book. This one was no different. This book covers the Courthouse Massacre that took place in Carroll County, Virginia in 1912. The event is set up through the tale of fictional characters Ava Burcham and Jeremiah Sutphin, whose friends-to-more story is sweet and romantic. Ms. Basham really sets the stage with the historical details and the beautiful backdrop of the Appalachian mountains. I enjoyed the setting and timeframe and getting to know the characters - both the real ones and the fictional ones. This book had something for everyone. A sweet romance, likable characters, small town drama, mysterious happenings and a serious shootout! Tensions run high amidst the mountain-folk and family feuds begin over a misplaced kiss at a "corn shuckin'". Things aren't always as they seem though, and there is a more sinister thread underlying all of the happenings of Fancy Gap and Hillsville. When things go sideways, Ava and Jeremiah find themselves in the midst of all of the action. I enjoyed reading their tale as much as the historical details of the events. I appreciated that the author put in the note at the end which characters were fictional and which ones were real and what the fates were of the real-life characters. It made it that much more interesting. I would strongly recommend this one to fans of historical romance, true crime stories and even historical mysteries. Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to write a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Red Ribbon by Pepper Basham is a fictional story based on historical facts that occurred in the mountains around Fancy Gap and Hillsville VA in the early 1900’s during prohibition. Ava Burcham is an aspiring writer and wants to investigate crimes in the area, mainly bootleggers. She enlists some assistance from her childhood friend Jeremiah Sutphin. What happens when they get too close to the truth that many does not want to be exposed? Will they find a connection to each other beyond friendship and fighting against crime?
WOW! This book drew me right into the story and I couldn’t put it down. I had to know what would happen next and if the criminals would ever be caught. I got so caught up in the story I almost forgot it was based on facts till the end. It is a chilling and thrilling read. I give it 5 of 5 stars. An excellent addition to the True Colors series.
I received an advance copy of this book through Netgalley in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?