Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Another epic from Kristin Hannah. Set in an era I really did not know much about. One woman’s struggle to keep her family alive during the Dust Bowl. A true survivor story!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Net Galley and St. Martin's Press for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
This was a compelling page turner, started out a little slow, but the story picked up and keep my interest from beginning to end. This is a part of history that I wasn't too familiar with, so I appreciated the ability to learn from this story. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone. Kristin Hannah has hit it out of the park with her last 3 books!

Was this review helpful?

An extraordinary albeit difficult story about a strong woman character during extremely challenging time in US history.

Unbeknown to most the Dust Bowl era was marked by the biggest American migration of people from the East ( Oklahoma, Texas, Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico all the way from Louisiana …. ) To California. These hard working American people went West trying to survive and got abused as slave laborers kept under the poverty level to pick, cotton, fruits and vegetables replacing the two millions Mexican laborers that had been deported by FDR Mexican Repatriation Act.

Yes, the account is dire, but the times were too. Regular women had to grow the courage, tenacity and survival skills during depressing, miserable circumstances, when death was looming around. I’m always gobsmacked that WWII stories are so popular but American history tales are judged as depressing … almost like … if it happened far away then it is romantic, if it happened here then it is dramatic.

Thankfully Kristin Hannah is a great writer who can entice the reader in a painful journey and still brings up the hope of betterment.

Allow yourself the space to read this book. Surely not a beach/pool novel but definitely worth your time (over a 100K 5 stars cannot be wrong ).

Thank you to the Publisher St Martin Press and Kristin Hannah for this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah's book, The Four Winds, is a very well researched historical depiction of a slice of time. She has once again created such vivid, authentic characters - flaws and all - who take the reader deep into the story. The Dust Bowl and Great Depression era come alive in these pages. Very well written and a must read for historical fiction fans!

Thank you to Kristin Hannah, St. Martin's Press, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this novel and share my thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

This book has a strong female lead like many of the author's other books of the author's other books.. It was not my favorite of hers but I'm excited for a future book. I felt like a dragon towards their trip to California.

Was this review helpful?

3 Stars

TW: Animal death & lots of it

If you are looking for an emotional book, Kristin Hannah is your go-to. I have found that most of her books tend to have me sobbing on the floor late at night. WhileThe Four Winds deals with heavy subjects, that wasn't the case for this book.

While I did enjoy the emotional aspects of The Four Winds, I struggled with it a bit. The first half of the book was hard to get through, I found it incredibly boring. It wasn't until the second half that the pace picked up. By then it kind of felt like it was too late. The pacing being slow for more than half the book kind of ruined it for me.

The problem with historical fiction for me is the amount of suffering an author puts their characters through. I understand this book was well researched but it felt like that overpowered the book. I know this book isn't meant to be an easy read, but so much suffering for one group of people? It was just a lot all at once. It didn't feel authentic, just carefully written sad plots tossed into one family.

While the ending did frustrate me, I think a lot of people will still like this one. It just wasn't for me this time around.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley for a electronic ARC of this book.

I'm usually a Kristen Hannah and eagerly await the release of her books. Unfortunately, I found The four Winds to be just....OK.
It's set in Texas during the Dust Bowl. Elsa's parents show her no love. She's made to marry someone she doesn't want to be with. Then, here comes the Great Depression and drought. Reading it felt like slogging through mud with a cloud hanging over my head. I know this was a harsh time in history and there wasn't much to be happy about, but a tiny pinpoint of lightness would have been appreciated. I thought she did a much better job developing characters dealing with troubles in The Great Alone. I'll revisit The Four Winds at some point and hopefully will find it a little brighter.

Was this review helpful?

None of my relatives are from the areas the Dust Bowl took place in. I have no first hand knowledge of it and have not had the privilege of hearing stories of this tragedy passed down from generation to generation so to gain knowledge of it I read fantastic and very highly researched books such as this one.
This book hits where it hurts, the heart. The characters are realistic and believable and you come to know them as though they are friends and they are in your corner.
These people could be your people, when they hurt you hurt as you become very invested in the character's lives both good and bad.
The Dust Bowl in the 1930's was a tragic time, many men were cowards and killed themselves or ran off to leave their women and children alone to fend for themselves.
The banks closed, everything did people didn't have the money to buy anything .
Dust covered everything, filling people's lungs ,killing off the livestock and making life an impossible hell!
Scraping together money for gas to make it to California they are in for a shock when they meet the land of broken dreams there.
Unfair wages for many hours of backbreaking work and having to live in tents where people carry diseases and total discrimination while trying to find and honest job are what they are met with.
The book was overall bleak but realistic for it's time period and I can't fault the book for that because I enjoy reading about realism.
There are pockets of sunshine and a renewed sense of hope along the way though.
I can't recommend this book enough!
This is my first book by this author but you better believe it won't be my last!

Pub Date 02 Feb 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I am always nervous when I see a book written about farming/agriculture because it is normally a misrepresentation. I am so glad to say Kristin Hannah really nailed it on this one.

At this point most people know the general story line of this one and I feel like the most common criticism of the book is that it is "too sad". The thing is the Great depression and Dust Bowl was not a sunshine and glitter time period and while it was sad, this is what life in farming is like even today. The realities described in this book are still effecting farmers today and dismissing them as unrealistic just shows how removed most people are from the realities of farming not only in the US but the world.

If I could I would give this book 10 stars simply because it is the first book I have ever read where I feel seen in.

Was this review helpful?

This was heartbreaking, beautiful, and so sad. Loved it, another great one from this author. 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

This was a beautifully written book with strong historical content. I loved learning more about this era, and was drawn into her characters.

Another lovely book by Kristin Hannah!

Was this review helpful?

Wow what a story! The book begins with in the pre-Dust Bowl of North Texas and sets the stage with a ton of character and setting development. Because the author is so thorough, it feels like the book is a slow starter. However, every detail is in the book for a purpose and Hannah weaves all of them to create a deep and engaging story that is full of emotion. I cried the last 50 pages!

Was this review helpful?

Kristen Hannah's popular new book The Four Winds is a richly detailed Historical fiction set in Texas during the Dust Bowl, the story has elements for everyone to enjoy.

Was this review helpful?

The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah is a beautifully written book, but is one of the most depressing books I have ever read. Was very disappointed at the ending.

Was this review helpful?

Growing up, Elsa thought her life wouldn't amount to anything. Her family stifled her, she didn't have the nerve to stand up to anyone, and her health wasn't strong. After meeting a man and becoming pregnant, both of their future plans unravel as they are forced into a marriage that starts out loving, but becomes one sided as the ravages of the Dust Bowl take away their livelihood. Elsa, now parenting 2 children on her own, is encouraged by her in laws to depart for California. On their way they face hardship after hardship. It was difficult to read, as such stories are. If you're pining for a narrative of the Dust Bowl and migration to California, Grapes of Wrath is another classic to consider. Weaving into the story are themes of parent/child relationship, family ties between natural and formed relations, and the role of government in crises. The ending was both a satisfactory ending while still being realistic to the circumstances Elsa had found herself in.

Was this review helpful?

I am so glad that I read this book! I have had mixed experiences with Kristin Hannah's books in the past, and while I did love The Nightingale, Historical Fiction isn't always my favorite genre and I just wasn't sure I cared all that much about the dust bowl. I was wrong. This story was phenomenal. It had it all. Amazingly strong female characters -- I LOVE Loreda, and hope my daughters are just like her. Tear-jerking story lines -- I cried no less than 4 separate times. Fast-moving story -- I was intimidated by the long book, but since it spans a few years, there was always something happening to make me want to pick the book back up and see what happens. I ended up reading this switching between print and audio and both were excellent.

Was this review helpful?

Like many American students, I read The Grapes of Wrath in high school, and loved it. It was my favorite book for years and I had such a strong emotional reaction to reading it at that time that I've been hesitant to reread it and possibly upend that powerful connection I had.

And then along comes this book...

It's The Grapes of Wrath for women. Hannah's The Four Winds takes all the power of The Grapes of Wrath and places a warrior of a woman at it's center. You're along for the ride as she grows and develops into that warrior and when she yells "No more" you will feel it in your soul.

Hannah's strength is writing the kinds of woman to woman relationships we all want. She's crafted several interesting characters and builds strong, loving, and uplifting relationships between them. It's worth reading just for that.

The audiobook is exceptional. Julia Whelan does such a marvelous job with voices and accents. Each character has a distinct voice.

Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Four Winds is the newest novel by Kristin Hannah, the author of the Nightingale and Firefly Lane. This one is historical fiction set during the Great Depression in the dust bowl. Elsinore Wolcott survived rheumatic fever when she was fourteen. Unfortunately her family never let her move on and we find her at 25, unloved and unmarriageable. So it is no wonder that when she meets Rafe Martinelli, a young Italian farmer, she falls for his charms. Unsurprisingly she finds herself pregnant and disowned by her wealthy family. The Martinellis reluctantly take her in and Elsa finds love, for her unborn child, her new family and the land they care for. It turns out that Elsa has a knack for farming. The saga sweeps through the Texas dust bowl and throuh the Great Depression as Elsa must decide whether to stay and fight for her family and her land, or pack it in like so many others and head west to California to scratch out a better life.

Like Hannah's other novels, Four Winds is rich in detail - you can almost feel the dust in the air as you read. This would be an excellent selection for book clubs. Anyone who enjoys Hannah and exceptional historical fiction will find this one hard to put down. I recommend Four Winds to anyone who wants well-crafted, engrossing read. Many thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

How would we. / do we treat people who are experiencing the worst of what life can offer. Great book that I hope encourages readers to think about how they treat fellow humans.

Was this review helpful?

Wow!! Unbelievably captivating! I enjoyed Elsa and her journey, not only was this book a fabulous read, but also educational. I learned so much about our history. This was worth the over 400 pages!
Elsa is a warrior, fighter, lover, strong af woman!! I learned a lot from this book in so many ways, I am not a historical fiction fan but this was one to go down in my list of top ten books of all times.

Was this review helpful?