Cover Image: The Four Winds

The Four Winds

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The Great Depression and the early days of migrant workers’ strikes make for a riveting read. This novel of poverty, terrifying climate events, and fortitude is a must read. The main character is so human, you feel as if you are her best friend. I can't wait to introduce this book to my friends and patrons.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! When you read a book
written by Kristin Hannah you know going into it, you will meet people who have strength, courage and true grit ! A book that will teach you, stay with you, and writing that pulls you into the story , and for the entire book you are there, with the characters, their families, their struggles and the triumphs.
Elsa is born into a rich family who doesn’t know her, and doesn’t love her. She has this desire to be loved. She wants a life where she can be judged on more than her appearance. When she meets Rafe she mistakes his lust for love and when she becomes pregnant and her family disowns her, it is Rafe’s family that takes her in, and Rafe marries her. Elsa grows to love Rafe but Rafe constantly wants a better life than being a farmer in Texas.
Rafes parents become the parents Elsa never had, hard-working farmers who fall on very hard times. The hard times become way too much for the couples youngest son, and he has to be taken out of the dust bowl that has become Texas, and they migrate to California hoping for a healthy and safer life. That is not what they get .
I love this family, this family went through so many hard times, so much pain and suffering, all they had was their love for each other.
This is a book about America and about migrant workers. This is a book about the farmers and the hard times that befell Americans in the 1930s, The Great Depression and the fallout from the stock market crash.
I loved Elsa, she had more grit and courage than she ever thought she had.
I am a huge fan of this author and I love that she writes of strong females and lives that don’t break them but make them stronger and mold the generations after them to be just as strong .
A huge 5 star “ don’t miss “ read!
A huge thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review .

Was this review helpful?

Oh my heart!! Kristin Hannah is my absolute favorite author and her latest does not disappoint. The Four Winds is a beautifully written book that is heartbreaking, inspiring, courageous and will leave you with every single feeling. Living in Texas, I know the history of the dust bowl, but reading the details and descriptions made it all so real. Absolutely loved this beautiful book. Thank you to netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It is 1930s Texas and the depression, drought and the Dust Bowl has led to desperation. Elsa Martinelli has to make a very difficult decision to move with her two children to California, with hopes of a much better life. Instead they are met with prejudice and issues like inflation. However, Elsa is indomitable, and her courage and strong will shines through time and again.

Elsa never had an easy life. As a teenager she nearly succumbed to serious illness, and this had a long-term effect on her life. Also, she never quite measured up to her sisters and never felt the strong arms of love from her parents. As Elsa became pregnant, she was forced to marry. Blessedly, her in-laws, Rose and Tony, welcomed her with open arms. However, as the years progressed, now the mother of two children, extreme conditions made life impossible in Texas. And, like many families, Elsa wanted something better for her children.

Elsa made the perfect protagonist. A strong woman who rose time and again, despite the incredible odds against her. Elsa felt so very real to me. I connected with her from the very beginning, whether as a woman living vicariously through the books she reads, as a daughter who couldn't measure up, as a wife who felt completely alone and as a mother who would move mountains for her children.

I only discovered Kristin Hannah this year, and have been chipping away at her backlist. Actually, I had planned to read The Great Alone last month, but time got away from me. At this point I have read The Nightingale, Summer Island, Winter Garden, Fly Away, Firefly Lane and True Colors. So, I have a lot more to read and greatly look forward to the opportunity. Kristin Hannah mixes amazing talent with extensive research, thus always producing incredible stories that manage to compel me from the very first page to the very last word.

This touching story broke me. To be frank, I bawled. Kristin Hannah never ceases to surprise me with the quality she puts into her writing. That time in history was incredibly tragic for many people, and this book did an excellent job at reflecting that time in America. This is in stark contrast to the life we live today with the pandemic. Uncertain times then. Uncertain times now.

Many thanks to St. Martin's Press and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah does it again. You root for Elsa from the beginning til the end. You feel her pain,love, anguish,and triumphs.i would love to see this book made into a movie

Was this review helpful?

Stayed at home and read this beautiful heart wrenching book. Elsa - just wow. Talk about a strong female main character. She was absolutely amazing throughout the entire book. I can’t believe I finished an almost 500 page book in 4 hours, but I could not put it down.

I loved seeing Lorenda come into her own and grow into the person she was meant to be. This book played on every emotion possible. You will want to get this book when it releases February 9, 2021.

Was this review helpful?

Historical fiction that will tranport you straight to Texas, 1934 and make your heart full.

This beautifully written novel tells the story of America in the 1930s, during the Great Depression. It takes place in Texas as millions of people lost their jobs to a recession while a severe drought diminished the crops. Our main character Elsa Martinelli doesn't just deal with the rough times, but also a tough family situation: she's not really accepted by her loved ones, and when she gets pregnant with her daughter Loreda, she is made to marry the father of her baby, Rafe. Due to the increasingly hopeless situation and growing poverty, Elsa is forced to make an impossible choice: whether to fight to save her family's land or go West to earn money like so many others had.

The Four Winds is a heartbreaking yet wonderful tale of a resilient woman in a difficult time. I don't usually reach for historical fiction, but Kristin Hannah has a way of winning me over. The writing is incredible, which made me even more attached to the characters and their world. I can't wait to read more novels from this author.

*Thank you to the Publisher for a free advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Incredibly compelling story and characters, another stellar offering from Kristin Hannah. Telling the story of the Depression and Dust Bowl from the perspective of one family of strong women, Hannah brings the era to life again, and educates readers to many issues that were glossed over in American history class. One can’t help but make comparisons to what’s occurring now, making the book even more timely and moving.

Was this review helpful?

The Four Winds is Kristin Hannah's best work yet. Set in The Great Depression and Dust Bowl Era. Elsa and her family learn what it is like to fight to survive. Set in the Panhandle of Texas, this book shows what it is like to live on a farm and live just on wheat and crops.

Rosa takes Elsa in as her own and teaches Elsa everything her own mother did not. Elsa fights to survive and is the glue that holds that family together. As Elsa and family set out West she will do what it takes, but at what cost?

One of the highlights of the book is Ms. Hannah's ability to research. I felt like I was there with Elsa, Rafe, Rosa and Tony.

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martins for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was told I would ugly cry, and I did. Told in her beautiful writing style, Kristin Hannah took me on a journey of life during the Great Depression, in the Dust Bowl, and in the shoes of the migrants from all over America. I felt I was with them in the mud, sickness and poverty that California held for them, in tent cities, picking cotton to feed their families. It was strangely related to what many are living through today.

Once again the heroine is a woman who doesn't beleive in herself, because she was taught not too. And once again we fall in love with a warrior who finds her power and strength, surrounded by love.

Beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

Very enjoyable reading. I've read Hannah's European books. This time she explore America during the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl. It's sad to see so many parallels to today. Elsa Martinelli is a strong woman raising strong children in extremely tough times.

Was this review helpful?

The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah. An interesting read that details the hardships of the Dust Bowl and Great Depression and the plights faced by the farm workers in California and farmers in Texas during that time. Elsa is a remarkable woman and an inspiration. Heartbreaking, depressing to read but the love of family and perseverance shines throughout. Wish the story hadn't ended so abruptly, felt there was more to Loreda's and Ant's story.

Thank you to the publisher, author, and NetGalley for the opportunity to preview the book.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Kristin Hannah's books. When I read one of her books it's like a friend is sitting on my sofa and says, "Let me tell you a great story." Another wonderful book.
The Four Winds is rich in American history. The story starts during the Roaring Twenties. When the economy was booming. Farmers had wheat in the fields. Women cut their hair and won the right to vote. A decade later came drought, The Great Depression and the Dust Bowl. Families lost everything. For many the only choice they had was to move west to California. The land of milk and honey. What they faced was discrimination and terrible working conditions. They languished in poverty.
The bigger story is the main character, Elsa Martinelli. She is a dauntless character. Faced with so much in her life she is courage, strong and determined, no matter what is throw at her. You can not help but cheer her on.
But mainly the story is about the family, love, survival and home.
Thank you NetGalley, St. Martin Publication and author Kristin Hannah the opportunity to read and give and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah
Book starts out with a listing of the author's other works, dedication and prologue where we learn about the penny that has hope for one's new life in US.
1921 and we start out in TX and Elsa has been raised to be very poor in health so the parents keep her safe at home.
Her sisters are beautiful and are married and out in the world. Elsa wants to be more like them so she does a few things to her hair and dress and spends the night at a speakeasy where she meets a boy.
She meets him more over time and before you know it she's with child. What I hated to read was that her father dropped her off at the boys house for them to take care of the daughter and child.
She was from a very well to do banker family and knows nothing of preparing meals and doing chores. She is thankful to learn how to do everything.
Rafe is tired of TX life and the droughts cause him to just up and leave to head to CA. They don't hear from him and the youngest boy needs to be relocated for his health so she packs up the kids and heads west also, leaving the grandparents behind.
Terrifying hearing of the nights spent on the road and passing through the desert. When they reach CA things are not what they expected and Elsa is NOT afraid to work. She meets a wonderful woman in camp who gives her information about how to survive.
She did scrub a woman's house from top to bottom til 6pm one day and got 40 cents. She puts the kids in school and while searching for work she tries to also find Rafe.
Fell in love with this side of CA during the depression reading about it from John Steinbecks stories so to me this is an added plus to continue on with the story coming from a different irrespective.
Hard times hits them front and center and just when you think they are getting ahead you realize they are not. They realize it also and the daughter goes to do something about it.
So many emotions and I love hearing of the travels and the places they went through on their way to follow their dreams.
Tragic times and love hearing about how they survived through it all. Love hearing of the strikes during the time as the land owners were in control and could set the price of a picker for the day...
Never saw the ending happening as it did but was so glad Ledora gets to bring it all full circle and move on with her life as she gets older.
Received this review copy from St. Martin's Press via publicist via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
#TheFourWinds #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for this ARC from one of my favorite authors.

As always, the story is beautifully written and I was quickly sucked in. The characters are complex, and it feels at times like the hardships they endure are never ending. This is an emotionally heavy story, and feels very real. I have a feeling these characters and events will stay with me for a long time

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC digital copy of Kristin Hannah’s The Four Winds directly from St. Martin’s Press and am delighted to offer my unbiased review. My thanks to Erica Martirano and DJ DeSmyter of St. Martins Press, NetGalley, and to Kristin Hannah.

Having read The Nightingale and The Great Alone, I was familiar with Ms. Hannah’s ability to portray strong female characters. She writes with fastidious attention to detail; she does her research well. In several reviews, I have seen comparisons, even as criticism, that this book is much like John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath. It has been far too many years since I’ve read that epic Pulitzer Prize winning novel so I can’t do a detailed comparison. However, Hannah’s story, like Steinbeck’s, chronicles a family’s struggles during the Dust Bowl and Depression. Both reveal the search for a better life and also the fight for unions, better work conditions, and higher pay.

Elsinore “Elsa” Martinelli shows us what true grit really is. She is the product of a family that does not really love her or accept her for who she is, nor do they accept others whom they consider to be beneath them. When Elsa becomes pregnant unexpectedly, she is forced to marry a man many years her junior. While she grows to love him, times are tough. With the love and support of her in-laws, Rose and Tony, Elsa evolves from a frail, book-loving town girl to a hard-working, competent mother and farm wife. Yet she never considers herself strong or brave. When the tough conversations need to happen, she tends fall back on her old habits by withdrawing into herself.

I didn’t love Elsa at first. It took a while for her to grow on me. But grow on me she did. The Four Winds is a story that requires patience because reading about the day in, day out hardships of what was to be called “the Dust Bowl” is painful. There are days and weeks and months without rain. Supplies are dwindling. Friends, neighbors, and families are packing up and leaving for “the land of milk and honey” – California.

Rafe is restless. And he fills their daughter Loreda’s head with dreams, too. This causes friction in the family, but as always, Rose is her pillar of strength and wisdom. My heart broke for this family, and I couldn’t help pulling for them. So much of what happens is predictable, although some of it is not. Some of the events are remarkably good; others are terribly depressing. All of it seems realistic, especially the descriptions of life on the farm in the encampment. Then there is the discrimination, the hatred, the back-breaking work the migrants did for hours for so little pay. The characters felt like real people to me. If I have one complaint, it is that the ending happens so quickly.

Despite the despair and hardship, there is also hope. There is hope that Loreda and little brother Anthony – called Ant (love that!) will go to college and have a bright future. There is love, so much love, despite the fights and the struggles. As Elsa tells Loreda, “It’s durable. It lasts.”

4.5 rounded to 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

So let me get this straight. A book that supports and pushes COMMUNISM as the answer to struggles in America? What the heck is the world coming to when authors write things like this? Was it a good story? Yes. Well written? Yes. But the hidden agenda and blatant glorification of communism is a huge problem for me. I won’t be reading any more from this author. If you don’t like this country and our form of government, it’s time for you to move. Go live in a communist country and come back and tell me how great it is. Go for it.

Was this review helpful?

BRAVO to the author, this is her best work yet. This was so thoroughly researched and well written I LOVED it. IT showed the strength, the bravery, the hesitancy, the will of the people during the Great Depression. It was so moving, so vivid, I could feel the dust in my teeth, the coughing from the dust, and the insects coming out of hiding.
I loved the characters. Especially the relationship between Rosa and Elsa. I can't stress enough how timely this book is and how thought provoking it truly is.
Everyone should read this book. This is the new American classic.

THank you to Netgalley, the Publisher, and the author for letting me read this extraordinary book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley, St. Martin's Press and Kristin Hannah for an early ready copy!

I absolutely loved this book! I didn't know much about it when I started it, as I will read anything by Kristin Hannah, but this book is exceptional.

Elsa Martinelli is a young woman whose life has been defined by her parents; after a childhood illness, she is considered not strong, not healthy, not pretty and a lifelong spinster. A chance meeting with a young man changes her life in a most unexpected way. As she leaves her parents to become part of another family, she learns what family can and should be, and just how strong and capable she is. But after years of living on a farm, in the midst of the Great Depression when things can't get any worse, they do. The winds scour Texas as they do the Great Plains, killing crops, drying up water, and leaving people with nothing to eat and nowhere to go. Like many others Elsa heads west to start a new life, but this time with her two children.

In California, Else learns that things are not as they have been advertised. Caught up in the endless cycle of abusive employers, lack of money, hatred and discrimination by the locals, like many newcomers Elsa feels trapped. But an unexpected encounter leads her to recognize the internal strength she has always had and helps her to become the leader she has always been inside.

The Four Winds is tells story of the migrants from the Midwest in the story of Elsa. This is historical fiction at it's best: compelling, compassionate, enraging and courageous. I will definitely read this book again!

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah writes such gripping and captivating stories and this one is no different. The Four Winds follows Elsa Martinelli and her family as they live during the Great Depression and Dust Bowl in Texas. Elsa, the main character, was someone you were rooting for during the entire book. You wanted her to realize her courageous spirit that was simmering below the surface. You wanted her to find her happiness. And as a mother, you felt her struggle to hold it all together in a time when everything was falling apart. This book was a journey in her self-realization.

Kristin Hannah wrote an amazing group of characters and really embodied what the world was like during this time in our history. You felt all the emotions the characters were feeling. You felt the desperation and the determination. The story is heartbreaking and inspiring. This book is a great read with all the feels. If you have liked any of Kristin Hannah’s other books, you will love this one.

Was this review helpful?