Skip to main content

Member Reviews

DeLillo's newest offering is short and thought provoking and as usual, prescient. Imagined before Covid-19 hit (but not so far ahead that they couldn't insert a quick reference), The Silence describes a sudden event where all digital connections have been severed and humanity is forced to interact in its old ways. Present is DeLillo's stunning writing. Not a word wasted and sentences beautiful in their simplicity and striking in their multiple and layered meanings.

The Silence is reminiscent of DeLillo's previous novel Zero K, in that many interesting and important questions are raised but few are actually answered. Like Zero K, these open questions are the novel's greatest strength. DeLillo has always respected his readers enough to require that they share in the heavy lifting and The Silence is no exception. Excellent for book clubs, thought exercises and for anyone who enjoys a contemplative reading experience.

Was this review helpful?

Don DeLillo’s work operates on the level of parable. Though brief, this book examines human life through event and dialogue in way that speaks hauntingly to the electronic connections of our time. The Silence is both relevant and prescient.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t think the chilling new novella from Don DeLillo, #The Silence, is meant to be reviewed. Rated - yes. Discussed - most certainly. But reviewed ? It’s so short and hyper-focused that just about anything I say would be a spoiler. The ramifications of today’s “ on the brink “ world inspired Mr. DeLillo to speak his mind. Like a tick that burrows it’s way under your skin, I believe #TheSilence will firmly find its way into your head and gnaw at your unconscious until it’s front and center in your thoughts until the silence is your only relief.

Was this review helpful?

February 2022. A retired physics professor and her husband are hosting a Super Bowl game watch party on the Upper East Side of New York. One of the guests, the professor's former student, has already arrived, while two others are flying home from Paris and hoping to land in time to see most of the game. But when a sudden power outage shuts down all electronic communication and causes chaos in the streets and in the air, each party guest will have to come to their own reckoning with the nature of modern life and their place in it.

DeLillo apparently finished "The Silence" weeks before the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic, so it is eerie how much the novella reflects our current situation. One character muses, "But remaining fresh in every memory, virus, plague, the march through airport terminals, the face masks, the city streets emptied out"--an image that is perhaps too fresh and current in our own memories. And another character voices my own recurring thought through each new and disturbing quarantine development: "Is this the casual embrace that marks the fall of world civilization?" This sharp resonance with our current situation increased my interest and admiration for "The Silence"--I appreciated the "Why not us? Why not now?" self-reckoning the characters go through. This might not be the case for all readers, and certainly if you are looking for an escape from Covid, this is not the book for you right now. But there is a strange beauty and comfort as well in DeLillo's words:

"Whatever is out there, we are still people, the human slivers of a civilization." He lets
the phrase linger. The human slivers.

Thank you to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for providing me with an ARC of this title in return for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is an interesting reading experience coming off of Leave the World Behind. It is less concrete and sparer. The world without a Super Bowl (or being able to view it)? Maybe it wouldn't be so bad. Titans and Seahawks? We'll see.

Was this review helpful?

DeLillo will never not be my favorite. This almost novella is pure, concentrated DeLillo, distilled down to the essentials: men in small rooms, crowds, planes, technology, quiet seeping panic, language, insurance adjusters... While I miss the length of his earlier novels, just being able to stay longer in his creation, the sentences are still perfection and the sentiments eerie in their predictive nature. (If you’ve not read DeLillo, people will say start with White Noise. I say start with The Names or Mao II.) Thanks to @scribnerbooks for the ARC!!

Was this review helpful?

I must admit, I was more entertained by the reviews for this novella than the work itself. Not much to add to the conversation here as I am not a star struck DeLilo fan nor a student of literature (read: bro books) This was short and choppy and, honestly didn’t really engage me. Perhaps the tangential relevance to the pandemic had publishers pushing for a finish. But, to me it felt like a draft of the beginning of an idea.

Was this review helpful?

In late 2018, DeLillo said to The Guardian about writing, “It’s what’s keeping me alive,” and so It’s our good fortune as readers that The Silence is the result. Like his recent novels, it’s spare and sharp—completely relevant to this moment in America and just shy of terrifying.

Was this review helpful?

(I read an ARC of this novel provided free by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Thanks, Netgalley!)

You might know that I have a long history with Mr. Don DeLillo. I wrote my master’s thesis on three of his (early) novels. I’ve read most of his books, though I don’t think I’ve been able to finish any since my thesis with the notable exception of a White Noise reread.

Here’s why: my main discovery was that DeLillo writes the same novel over and over. You can pick up any DeLillo novel (except this one – but I’ll get to that) and expect a plot along the lines of this: Dude (always male) is disenchanted with mass media, retreats from said media, eventually decides that he can’t really get away, and returns to media-driven society. Read any DeLillo novel, and that’s what you’ll get. Which, I guess, is fine. Murakami essentially writes the same novels over and over, too, and I love him as much.

What’s different about DeLillo’s new book The Silence? Well, it’s not a novel, per se, even though it’s being marketed as one. It’s more the length of a long short story or a short novella. It’s also more like a couple of scenes from a longer novel or – better yet – a play (he’s written those, too) that isn’t finished. Maybe he had a deadline but didn’t feel like writing.

Another part of it (and, really, one of the reasons I generally can’t make it through his novels anymore) is that all of the characters sound exactly the same. That’s an issue with just about everything he writes, but in this tiny space, it’s magnified. If he doesn’t identify who’s talking, it’s easy to get characters mixed up.

Now for the plot part. This time, instead of some dude running away from the media, said media goes out. It just turns off. DeLillo isn’t clear if it’s just all media and communications or if all power is included. The whole situation is confusing. It’s mostly people in a room having conversations that are just parallel monologues or just standing up and talking. That’s it. Say that’s scene 2. Scene 1 is two of those characters on a plane that almost crashes because it loses communications and (maybe?) power. But it’s not an IED because cars still work to drive them from the airport to a clinic. And the clinic is still open. But stoplights and streetlights are out?

See what I mean? It doesn’t make much sense. There’s no story arc and no resolution. Instead of running away from media, the characters essentially become the media by reciting what the media would be saying. For instance, Max is hosting a football watch party when the media goes out. That includes TV, phones, etc, etc. So he stares at the TV and says what he imagines would be said including the commercials.

This “novel” is a big unfinished jumble. If you want to read DeLillo – seriously, it doesn’t sound like it here, but he’s one of America’s best living authors – read just about anything else he’s ever written. I suggest White Noise or Americana. I hear Underworld might be his best novel, but it’s huge and I haven’t made it through it. Maybe someday. Don’t waste your time here. I guess the publisher would accept anything DeLillo submitted just because of who he is. He’s 83 now, so maybe they’re worried about how many novels he has left in him?

I’ve read a lot of DeLillo, but this is the first time I’ve read something that’s objectively bad. And what’s weird is that it’s bad mainly because it’s not finished. It’s just a couple of scenes. DeLillo needs to suck it up and finish this novel or play and then submit it. Two scenes is only part of the story.

Was this review helpful?

4 stars

I cannot be reasonable when it comes to Don DeLillo. My graduate thesis, a few independent study courses, my sense of the world...all DeLillo. If he published a note on a Post-It, I'd probably consider it a sacred text. Starting this review any other way would be dishonest.

This work moves so fast, and I think that has more to do with the current state of ever present trauma we live in, even, than the brevity of the text. These characters are trying to make sense of the nonsensical, and readers are (1) along for the ride but also (2) living our own trauma in this moment.

DeLillo's access to an oracle-like sensibility has always scared and fascinated me. I don't know what's next. These characters don't. Somehow, he always does.

Fans of DeLillo's will, I think, appreciate the characteristically DeLillo aspects of this work and maybe not mark it among their top three. I expect folks who are new to DeLillo or do not possess the gene (that thing that connects you to him like he's the leader of your own personal cult when you even hear someone talk about their Toyota Celica from 20 years ago) will not connect as much with this work. I wanted more but accept that he always knows what's best.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Scribner and NetGalley for an ARC of this title.

I haven't read anything of Don DeLillo's since I read _White Noise_ in college, and this made me want to go back and read both that and more of his back catalog. This is probably more of a novella than a novel (since it's 128 very fast moving pages), and you can (and should) probably read it in a sitting. It's spare, and precise, and has a few beautifully clear moments that really hit home what it's going for.

A lot of the press around this is making a big deal out of it being finished a few weeks before COVID-19 hit, and there's a direct reference to it that I bet was added as part of final editing (since the book is set in 2022), but it's mostly about how we as humans respond to major catastrophic events, which has relevance.

Was this review helpful?

This is a brisk read, a look at a catastrophic event through the eyes of a small group of people. You might find yourself thinking that the stories of others -- first=responders, pilots, bodega owners and on. -- would offer more fruitful material than a small group of people who are trying to watch the Super Bowl in this dialogue-heavy, novella-length piece.

DeLillo is a giant and it'd be great to hear him discuss the choices he made in this story.

Was this review helpful?

This short writing "novella" I guess you would call it did not not speak to me much. It seems the reviewers who loved this book tended to speak in terms of high acedemia, of which I am not. I also wondered if maybe I missed something because I had not read the previous books of the authors in order to understand the writing better. From my standpoint the characters were very dry and boring. They spoke of little things going on and no real conversation or observing. When the plane started having troubles one even has to ask "are we afraid". I felt if we really are so reliant on technology as the world seems to be headed towards and then we suddenly lost it I would think people would be more panicked on what they would do and exist than the people in the story. I did not like how the story was narrated and could not get into the characters. I did like the feel of the story reminding somewhat of alfred hitchcock or an episode of the twilight zone but, i think maybe it went over my head or maybe I simply dont like a look into issues that is done this way. I can see by the reviews this is a big hit for some people so I say try it out. Read it. For me it is a miss for sure unless I can seem to make a deeper understanding of it.

Was this review helpful?

The reader should be alerted that this isn't a full-fledged DeLillo novel--yet, despite that--the author mines his rich theme of what it means to be human in a mysterious, abbreviated tale of characters drawn together by a disruptive event. Not DeLillo's finest work--but a thoughtful and intriguing read nonetheless.

Was this review helpful?

I was really looking forward to this because I enjoyed Zero K by this author previously. However this book was not really a complete, just more of a short (and boring) story. A mass malfunction occurs for electronics and causes "silence." People do not know what to do. Thank goodness this was only 128 pages but nothing really happens and the dialogue is bland.

Just a no, skip this even though it is short.

THanks tp Netgalley, Don Delillo, Scrbner for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Available: 10/20/20

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Net Galley for the free ARC. I would call this a short story rather than a novel. A sudden event shuts down all electronic communication. I wanted more.

Was this review helpful?

Any new DeLillo novel is an event, so I was over the moon when I got an advance copy of this one. It's marketed as a coronavirus novel, but it doesn't take long to realize it's not. It's barely even a novel... kind of a novella or just a long short story. DeLillo's novellas don't get a lot of respect. He's a writer with big ideas that are hard to compress into a short space. The Body Artist didn't stay with me nearly as much as Underworld or even Zero K. But the novellas are almost like seeing a stand-up work out new material on stage. They're rough and fragmentary, but there are gems buried there.

This is a story about a mass shut-down of communication and power systems. In a way, it's DeLillo at his most apocalyptic, envisioning the silence of all the communication and technology systems he's written so perceptively about for decades. In another way, it may be DeLillo confronting his own death. If he will not be here to write about these communication and technological systems, will they still exist in the same way? Certainly not for him. Zero K was about the struggle against death, but in this death is accepted for what it is--a silence, albeit a silence in which other life still persists. It's a bittersweet little book.

Was this review helpful?

Although I have read all of Don DeLillo's books, those that I read prior to joining goodreads don't show up on my feed. He's one of those writers I've followed for over 30 years, no matter what prior reviewers think. His style is distinctive. His viewpoint specific. I'll repeat from a prior review since it applies here as well: "In the years since publishing Underworld, DeLillo has written novels of spare prose, sharp and focussed that leave the reader disquieted and thoughtful. There is not an extraneous word or action. Underworld, still one of my favorite books of all time, is a string of interlocking stories using an iconic baseball as the Mcguffin ... He still writes at a distance, while getting inside the essence of the situation. He proves a writer doesn't have to use a lot of words to drive home his point."

This is another example of existential dread, a "... casual embrace that marks the fall of world civilization...". The collapse of the Internet on Superbowl Sunday 2022 as personified by five distinct individuals is believable, particularly in this uncertain word of Covid-19, which is referenced within. If you like him, you'll appreciate his contribution to the zeitgeist.

Was this review helpful?

I am a fan of "modern" DeLillo...loved Zero K, Point Omega. I don't mind shorter formats; every books doesn't have to be Underworld. However, the nuggets of brilliance in The Silence are float in a sea of, well, dullness. There were passages where I nodded my head and passages where I shivered to think how accurately he portrayed/predicted covid, but mostly there were passages where I shrugged and went "meh."

Was this review helpful?

Jim Kripps and his wife Tessa Berens confront their own mortality in-flight returning to NY from Rome. Their friends Diane Lucas, Max Stenner , and Martin Dekker await them in a Manhattan living room, big-screen TV, snacks, drinks at the ready to celebrate Super Bowl LVI in the year 2022, never knowing what oddities may prevent their doing so. Outside, Manhattan is full of disabled cell phones and blank screens, a disastrous hell-scape that requires person-to-person contact and actual conversation. Jim and Tessa have sex in a public bathroom in a very private, non-oral statement about their own survival and connection. I like the way this tableau is mirrored in a way by another less in-tune couple, I like how all five individuals maintain their own individual last names despite the convention of marriage, and I especially like the Albert Einsteinisms throughout this story although I kind of wish the one didn't open the book as I felt it diminished some of the statement's considerable thunder. I love the courageous way DeLillo calls out America, "We've seen it happening repeatedly, this country and elsewhere, storms and wildfires and evacuations, typhoons, tornadoes, drought, dense fog, foul air. Landslides, tsunamis, disappearing rivers, houses collapsing, entire buildings crumbling, skies blotted out by pollution." I even liked the sci-fi lines of questioning, have our minds been digitally remastered? Are we an experiment that happens to be falling apart, a scheme set in motion by forces outside our reckoning? DeLillo is the master at subtle subterfuge, and this quick read packs a wallop.

Was this review helpful?