Cover Image: When You Were Mine

When You Were Mine

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Beth is a single mother with a seven year old son who has behavioral problems.
She is struggling to cope and after complaints from worried neighbours her son Dylan is taken into care and put in a foster home.
The foster mother does her best with Dylan but is getting little help from her family.
Beth was someone who was hard to like. She was dismissive of advice and critical of others who tried to steer her in the right direction to get her son back.
I had mixed emotions with this book and found some of it hard to read.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for my e-copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and Bookouture for allowing me to read this Arc.
A beautiful and heart rending story about a mother's love for her child. Some parts are bitter sweet. But it tells of the truth, love and sacrifices often felt in most families.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 5/5
Genre: Domestic Fiction
Plot: 
“Dylan…” I croak, but my little boy doesn’t even look at me. “Dylan,” I say again, my voice breaking now, and the social worker gives me a reproving look. I’m not helping, but I don’t care. “Dylan!” My voice is louder now, and my gaze stays locked with my son’s as she pulls away from the curb and drives away, taking my very life with her.
Single mother Beth loves her seven-year-old son Dylan with all her heart. He’s her world. But life with Dylan isn’t easy—and his emotional issues push Beth to her very limit. When a misunderstanding leads Dylan to be taken into foster care, she is determined to do whatever she can to get him back.
Mother of two, Ally has always dreamed of fostering—it feels like her chance to give back when she has been so lucky in life. But when Dylan joins their family, Ally finds herself struggling to balance his needs with those of her own children and husband—something Beth can’t help but witness when she visits.
Beth wants nothing more than to find a way to bring her beloved child home. But where is the right home for Dylan? Is it with the mother he was born to? Or is a new mother the greatest gift Beth could give her son?
My verdict: Firstly thank you to Netgalley for letting me read this prior release and I must say with this heartwarming and at times heart wrenching drama Katie is hot on the heels of the likes of Jodi Picoult and Kelly Rimmer. Not only does this book deals with a child with special educational needs but how stretched the American Foster system is and the social workers advocating for these children and in some cases the parents.
I have to say, I found that I wanted to shake Beth and scream that helicopter parenting doesn’t work but once we slowly discovered her backstory I sympathised a lot with anxieties.
I did like how in Ally’s POV with her children it shows that not all family’s are perfect behind closed doors - it made me like her more.
The novel also shows this from Ally’s perspective that even though your children may be grown-up and have left home it’s still important to maintain an emotional connection with them them and caring for Dylan makes All realise it’s importance and that honour roll and Ivy League colleges don’t matter. On the other hand, it is a relief when Beth realises that she’s projecting her anxiety on her son and especially once she comes to the conclusion that perhaps her and Dylan’s relationship is too intense and maybe setting boundaries and letting go of anxiety is a good thing. When you combine both women’s good points and bad points they create a fantastic support system for Dylan. In this books case it wasn’t a case of good parenting/ bad parenting but a mixture of both on either side, both sides showed me how competitive parenting is even when it’s done subtly and how self doubt is leathal.
Finally, This novel deals with many issues such as abandonment, mental health, drugs, childhood trauma and domestic abuse, the fall out of high parental expectations, educational stress, the lack of support in CFD. In conclusion, how there’s no such thing as a perfect parent and that some parents need some more help and support than others but, that doesn’t necessarily mean your a bad parent.
Overall Kate’s writing is emotive, when the scenes don’t translate the emotion to you, the inner a monologues of the characters certainly do with plenty of metaphors and similes. A fantastic addition to my bookshelf. Katie Hewitt is one to watch with her passionate and terjerking narratives and could easily give Diane Chamberlaine and Jill Childs a run for their money.

Click the image to be taken to Amazon so you may buy your copy

Was this review helpful?

To say this story is a five-star read is an understatement. There are not enough stars in the world to show how much this book has touched me. It is sad, thrilling, gripping and completely pulls on your heart strings. Beautifully written.

Was this review helpful?

Such a sweet heartfelt book. The story drew me in and had my heart breaking. Beautifully written.


Thanks to the author, the publisher and Net Galley for an early release of this book.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful heart rending read that will tug at your heartstrings long after you have read it!
The power and intensity of a mothers love for her son, so well meaning but so stifling, the process of losing your only child and having to prove yourself worthy of getting him back through undertaking counselling, courses and being observed whilst he lives with another family, that seemingly on the outside look to be respectable, upstanding and suitable to foster but behind closed doors things are far from perfect!
The sacrifices and love shown by a parent to prove themselves are humbling and heartbreaking at the same time, a really emotional read that I would highly recommend.
Thank you net galley for this early read.

Was this review helpful?

eceived an ARC of this book from the publisher in exchange for as honest review.

I have to admit, I did not have high hopes for this book. I couldn’t figure out how this could be the “heart warming” story that it was promised to be. It turns out that it was a beautiful story of love and sacrifice.

Was this review helpful?