Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Do you ever read a book and feel an overwhelming wave of love for it - that fleeing tenderness -that makes you want to press the book tight to your chest and never let go? As you go through the story, you know - you just know - that you will come back to those pages to seek emotional comfort and hope in times of turbulence.

God, "Project Hail Mary" made me feel so much.

I wasn't prepared for tears of joy reading this book. I wasn't prepared to get so attached to the characters that I stayed up reading until 5am for two nights in a row because I didn't want to let them go. I wasn't prepared to experience the friendship so deep, so pure and sincere that I was reminded of how much my own friends mean to me and how dearly I appreciate their presence in my life.

If 2020 completely obliterated your faith in humanity, please pick up this book. "Project Hail Mary" is a story about a very strange climate disaster and a sequent deep-space mission that is meant to find a solution for it.
In this book, Andy Weir shows how humanity can deliver its best in the worst of times, and while collective cooperation is challenging, it is possible. Sometimes, it requires unethical decisions to be made. Sometimes, people need to be open-minded about unorthodox approaches if they guarantee the safety and survival of our species. And sometimes, whether we want it or not, we confront things that are much bigger than our own life and death.

As for the scientific aspect of this book, it is as brilliantly executed here as in "Martian". Because of the strange nature of the above-mentioned climate disaster, a lot of science here is fictional; however, it is well-explained and enjoyable to follow to the point of you getting super-excited when new discoveries are made. Due to the dense scientific explanations, I would recommend picking up either a physical copy or an e-book, as quite often I had to go back and re-read certain concepts to fully grasp them (which would be very hard to do with an audiobook).

Because this book has a bunch of fantastic themes and developments, I would leave a list of compatible recommendations to check out after reading this book, however, be careful - the very concept of those stories may be a spoiler for this book: To Be Taught If Fortunate (morality and humanity, microbiology, environmentalism), Arrival (linguistics and interspecies cooperation), Network Effect (deep friendship - pure, joyous, "I will die for you because I care so much for your survival"), Ad Astra (environmentalism, deep space investigation), Children of Time (spider-like aliens).

*An e-copy of this book was kindly provided to me by the publisher Ballantine Books via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.*

Was this review helpful?

If you loved The Martian, get this book right now. I have no words. Someone else mentioned a "book hangover" and I'm definitely feeling that. When this one also becomes a movie, I will be first in line to see that as well.

Thank you to #NetGalley for the ARC of #ProjectHailMary

Was this review helpful?

Project Hail Mary is a fun read that returns to much of the tense atmosphere that surrounded The Martian. It's an opportunity for a middle school science teacher to save the world by sciencing the **** out of things. We have aliens, high-speed travel, time dilation, Earth on the verge of collapse, unethical managers, and dangerous stunts in outer space, what's not to like?
Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Let me start by saying: this book gave me a book Hangover. It's been two days and I still cant stop thinking about that ending!! Took me totally by surprise and I might actually have to reread it soon!



This book follows Dr. Ryland Grace in a Dual Timeline. In the first he wakes up in a spaceship in a solar system that is not our own, with no memory of how he got there or even who he is. The second timeline is his slowly regained memories from before he left earth and the events leading up to his adventure into the Deep Dark. As the story unfolds Dr. Grace discovers he might not be quite as alone out there as he though.

As with The Martian, one of Andy Weirs other Novels (and probably Artemis as well, but I haven't gotten to that one yet), Project Hail Mary is very heavily science based. I was surprised then to realize with my limited science understanding, I was able to comprehend everything discussed in this book. For that I would like to give a hand to Weir as that is truly a remarkable feat. To take dense, advanced science and make it understandable to a neophyte I am in awe. I believe it did help that I read this at a slower rate then I normally do and would recommend doing the same if, like me, science is not your strong suit.

However, now we need to talk about the main character himself. Dr. Grace. I don't think I actually like him at all, and I get the feeling that's kind of the point. He came off, to me at any rate, as a PG, blasé Mark Watney, from The Martian, only instead of being a Botanist Dr Grace is a biologist. A lot of the times he is funny, and other times I can't tell if he's suppose to be funny or if he just likes stating the obvious.

Overall I did love this book. I just couldn't put it down! I couldn't really sleep until I was finished with it and I'm positive I drove my co-workers utterly bananas talking about it. I could never predict what was about to happen and that ENDING. Wow! As I said, 4 stars. I can't wait to get my hands on a finished and as always, can't wait to see what Weir's going to come up with next!

Was this review helpful?

This was incredible! Weir did an excellent job with plot twists and last-minute rescues. A joy to read.

Was this review helpful?

If you liked The Martian, you're probably going to like this book. It's fast paced, it's got a great premise, and is full of action and even some laughs.

The book starts out with some HEAVY Martian vibes. Dr. Ryland Grace is stuck alone on a spaceship and has to use science and math to figure out how to save himself. The story almost felt TOO similar to The Martian.

Ryland's voice is very much Mark's Martian voice (which is, I suppose Weir's voice, too) and he's the only character. Don't get me wrong, most people love this voice and it's non-snooty approach to stuff that normally seems unapproachable (including me). However at first it felt so on the nose, I worried this was simply going to be "Project Hail Martian."

Thankfully, it is not. The book is very much it's own thing, mostly do to two key narrative choices. The first is a big, fat spoiler that I will not reveal here, except to say that I enjoyed it. (Suffice it to say, this is NOT a rehash of the Martian plot.)

The second was the fact that Ryland wakes up at the start of the book without his memories, knowing who he is, how he came to be on the mission, and what exactly that mission even IS. It's a smart artistic choice that gives the story a lot of momentum and keeps you guessing (the reader eventually starts, like Ryland, filling in some of the missing pieces of his memory, which aren't always correct.)

I admittedly am not into outer space, find science fascinating (but don't necessarily always get it) and downright loathe math. So, of course, that is the biggest hurdle for me in reading Weir's books. Weir loves to get technical....suuuuuuper technical. Thankfully his characters are Regular Joes that explain things in a way ordinary, non-sciencey/mathy folks can follow. However, it is still A LOT of science and math to follow. (When Ryland started calculating a bunch of stuff in the final pages of the book, I realized I was a little exhausted.)

My biggest beef with the book is that for being a regular guy (who is very smart and resourceful), Ryland is also suuuupper lucky. He makes a whole lotta, "just spitballing, and using basic logic here" leaps of faith and nearly ALWAYS lands on his feet. It became a little hard to buy after awhile. (Like I'm just spitballing, but I think this is how you fly a spaceship.")

Of course, the character also makes some mega mistakes in the story (because otherwise the plot would be boring), but as a whole, this mission's success relies on him being not only the smartest guy in the world, but the luckiest too. The book kinda explains the former (how a middle school science teacher found himself on this crazy mission with no memories), but not the later. I think we're supposed to love him so much and root for him so hard that we just roll with all these heroics. For the most part, I did...but not always.

I received an ARC of this book courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Strangely, I abandoned both The Martian and Artemis, but Project Hail Mary was a definite hit for me.

There is a lot of science/physics/math that I didn't understand, but made me think that solving problems with this knowledge could encourage young people into STEM courses. Even a "mathophobe" like me was intrigued and felt the excitement of problem solving.

Middle School science teacher, Ryland Grace wakes up from an induced coma far in space, with no memory of how he got there. His two crew mates didn't survive, and it takes him a while to remember even his name, but he gradually realizes that he has a great deal of knowledge about the ship and its functions. At first, his knowledge is a little surprising to him, but as his memory returns in fits and starts, and he experiences flashbacks of his previous life, he understands the mission of Project Hail Mary and its importance--a last ditch effort to save Earth and humanity.

He is alone in space...until he isn't. He finds an unexpected ally, and the two of them risk their lives over and over to make sure their missions are completed. Here, Weir excels at creating a dynamic between Ryland Grace and Rocky and moves beyond the typical space adventure into something more. The need for Grace and Rocky to communicate, to except each other's abilities and limitations, and to work together using their combination of skills in order to save their respective worlds is the crux of the book. Yes, it is a space adventure, but not in the usual sense--Project Hail Mary combines suspense and humor and "humanity" in the midst of some abstruse science and mathematics.

As I mentioned, the science and math was beyond me, and yet I found the way Weir used it (or perhaps, overused it) made me see the solving of mathematical and scientific puzzles as exciting as solving a mystery in a police procedural. Never thought that could happen.

I was completely engaged from first to last with this novel. Rocky is the highlight and an unforgettable character--you really need to meet him!

Read in March; review scheduled for April 25.

NetGalley/Random House/Ballentine Science Fiction. May 4, 2021. Print length: 496 pages.

Was this review helpful?

Filled with lots of adventure, Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir brings back the science of of the Martian and wraps it into a fun story about a science teacher and an alien out to save their respective planets, humanity, and alien life.

Was this review helpful?

How has it come to this? The fate of humanity rests on one man, who woke from a coma with no memory of his own name, much less the reason why he is hurtling through space on a mission he can't remember.
Originally a crew of three, Ryland Grace is the only surviving crew member of the Hail Mary research mission. He needs to discover how to kill a parasite called Astrophage that is feeding off the energy from the sun, slowly killing it and potentially threatening all life on earth.
This book has a lot of science and technology that Weir has a magical way of explaining that makes it fascinating to this average reader. I'm left staring up at the stars, my brain overloaded with sciency information, wondering if we're really alone in the universe. This was such a great book and I can't wait for his next one!

Was this review helpful?

Well, this was a wild ride. Part mystery, part thriller, part comedy, more than part science, and that ending made Project Hail Mary a totally satisfying experience. Even when I didn't know what the heck main character Ryland Grace was talking about half the time, I thoroughly enjoyed him (think Mark Watney, but without the potatoes). Even though I can't tell you the best moments in the book because I would spoil it for you, I can share that they are lovely, touching, funny as hell. And even though a lot of readers will say, "Waaaait a minute, I saw this in a movie," which I would strongly agree with, it is still a delightful book that gives you pause. It gives you pause and makes you ask yourself, how far would I go to save the world?

So, that being said, I liked how Andy Weir unthreaded his last book, Project Hail Mary, by starting in the middle of the story with Dr. Ryland Grace waking up in a laboratory, in outer space, with tubes to every orifice, and he has no idea what is going on, much less his name. His memory concerning anything scientific or computer-related is intact and he is able to recognize certain things about his surroundings but he has no clue how he ended up there, so Weir fills in both the reader and Ryland through flashbacks. And boy, are there surprises in store for everyone. Lots of them.

There were certain parts when I had to suspend my disbelief, even more than most sci-fi/fantasy novels if you can believe it, and if an eye roll could be considered exercise my eyes were buff by the end. They sent this guy into outer space to save the world? Explain how one person is not only in charge of sending this guy into outer space, explain how is she is in charge of everything, and I mean, EVERYTHING. There were parts that made me laugh until tears rolled down my cheeks and there were parts that made me cry real tears. I was thoroughly engaged by Ryland Grace and his sweet, but snarky, personality and strange, but brilliant, mind and what drives him.

I wish I could share more as Ryland is only half the story but *spoilers* so just know I enjoyed it, I binge-read it and I am highly recommending it.

A huge thank you to Random House Publishing and Ballantine Books and Netgalley for providing me with an advance copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions concerning Project Hail Mary are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The premise was unique and interesting, and the plot was engaging. I liked the illuminating flashbacks as the narrator slowly regained his memory throughout the book. Ryland Grace got on my nerves sometimes (I think I expected him to swear a bit more), but his arc was good, and I even teared up at the end.

It does read like a science textbook at times, but even with my brain blurring out the bits that went way above my head, I was still able to enjoy the story. I think I would have paid more attention in high school if my textbooks read like this :)

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars
4.5 stars
This was a mind blowing cosmic science fiction adventure, I enjoyed every minute in this world that Andy Weir has created. It was so suspenseful and heart racing. The real science applications used in this made up story were so believable, that this world with such advanced technology seemed so real.
This story focuses on Ryland Grace, who wakes up not knowing where he is or why but it does not take him long to start working out that he is not even close to home and on an epic journey to save millions of lives. Grace was such a great character, he was so likable and the humor would take you by surprise and was a bit juvenile, but bursts of laughter would just pop out as I was reading. Grace was also a flawed character but that just added to his likability as well as appropriate with the situations he was dealing with. I was also shocked by some of the events and actions people took in this story and it really added to the desperation trying to be conveyed, it just added another layer of depth to this epic story. This story was also very thought provoking about the measures people will take in desperate situations. Just be aware going into this story it is very science and math heavy. For the ending, I was just a little disappointed there was one thing that was not wrapped up for me and there was a bit of a lull in the middle of the story, which why this was not a five stars, but I really loved it and it’s completely amazing how he came up with such a space journey. I would highly recommend checking out this story if you are looking for an amazing, space defying mission to save humanity check this out!
Trigger warning: death, explostions, and suicide
I received this advanced ebook, via Netgalley, This review is my own honest opinion .

Was this review helpful?

I was thrilled when I saw my wish was granted by the publisher to get an arc of this book. Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for granting me an egalley to read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own, and they are built off an advanced copy of the novel, meaning some things might change before release.

I'm not new to Andy Weir's novels and style of sci-fi, having read The Martian, so I was excited to jump into some more 'scientific' sci-fi. Weir did not disappoint on this aspect, and honestly I was glad I recently took a physics course because otherwise a lot of this would've gone right over my head. I felt smart reading this, and I kind of enjoyed the feeling this book gave me. I mean I obviously can't guarantee every piece of science used in this book is 100% accurate, but this book still contains a level of detail that not all do, and while it feels like you have to stretch your brain around some of the content, I enjoyed that aspect of the story. It does make parts of the story feel slow moving, but it causes you to focus on the small discoveries as a reader, like Grace does in the story.

My favorite part of this book is what sets it apart from The Martian. In the latter, the main character is largely isolated, with only blips of contact with Earth. While Grace is still isolated from Earth, a secondary character does come in about halfway into the story, and the interactions between Grace and this character made the story so much more enjoyable for me. There was just something in the excitement that ran through most of their discussions, and their strong desires to save their home worlds, that was the final touch on this story for me. It would've been interesting without this character, but nowhere near as enjoyable.

However, there were two things I really didn't like about the story, and what hurt an otherwise 5 star read. I really didn't like the big 'twist' that the past and present storytelling was leading up to (though I did like the way this type of storytelling was otherwise utilized), as I felt like it undermined the character too much. Grace no longer feel genuine but instead hypocritical. It also just didn't seem to fully match the characters motivations in both the past and the present, and just overall frustrated me. I also didn't care for the ending, as it felt way under-planned and under-explained vs. the rest of the over-explained book. It was a jarring change and it in turn made it feel miraculous compared to the rest of the book. There were also just some odd statements and quirks that, while trying to explain the possibility of the ending, I really could've done without. Honestly, I felt the book would've been stronger if it ended without the epilogue/final chapter.

Overall though, I really enjoyed my time with this book, even if the final chapters frustrated me a bit. I still can't wait to see what Weir writes next, and still need to read his sophomore novel too!

Was this review helpful?

What a treat! Andy Weir's “Hail Mary” is one of the most original and creative novels I’ve read in a long time.

Ryland Grace wakes up completely alone. He can barely see or hear. Worse, he cannot remember who he is or what has happened to him. Worse still, once he finally regains his senses he discovers he’s on a space craft and that his two apparent crew mates died so long ago that they’re corpses are now desiccated. Slowly, as his memory returns, he realizes he’s on a one-way mission to save mankind from destruction by an extra-terrestrial threat it has no idea how to combat. It’s up to him, and him alone—or so he thinks—to figure out how to save humanity and then accomplish it without any help from anyone on Earth all the way across the galaxy.

In a nutshell, that’s the premise of the novel. I don’t want to go into any more detail because I don’t want to spoil any of the surprises Weir has in store. And there are plenty of those—all involving a main character whose exceedingly wry personality and wit make him a pleasure to spend time with. That plus the high stakes, the many “Apollo 13” type dangers Grace faces, and the slow revelation of how he came to be on this mission, make this a wonderful read.

One word of caution. There’s a lot of science, engineering, and technology in this novel. Physics, chemistry, biology, astronomy, computer science—Weir intertwines all of them, and more, into his plot. If you’re not a math/science person (and I’m not), some of it can be heavy going. Not college-level-science heavy going, but maybe HS-science heavy going. Still, once Weir finishes describing the science, he is careful to explain it in layman’s terms so that all readers can understand what just happened and how and why it’s important to the story.

My thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for making an ARC of “Hail Mary” available to me; in exchange for which no promises were made concerning this independent review.

Was this review helpful?

Oooh, baby was I excited to get my hands on this book! Project Hail Mary goes back to the same feel as The Martian but with a whole new spin. What should be a rather depressing premise (the end of the world as we know it) becomes an exciting, fascinating study of what it means to be a reluctant hero. The main character isn't trying to survive the catastrophe. He knows he's on a one way trip and won't ever make it back home. What he doesn't expect is to find a whole new purpose within his original mandate.

The scientific jargon and explanations are still over my head, as with the Martian, but somehow it works to add to the authenticity and general atmosphere of desperation and inspiration. I can honestly say this is my favorite book so far this year and really kept my attention. I cared about the characters. I was invested in the plot and couldn't wait to read more about the "unexpected friend." When will the movie come out, because this will be another home run! Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir
Publisher: Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine
Genre: Mystery & Thrillers | Sci Fi & Fantasy
Release Date: May 4, 2021

Of all of the books I've read this year, Project Hail Mary has been my favorite! I don't even know where to start! It's captivating, exciting, and filled with so much great stuff! This is one of those books that you can't put down once your start reading it!!!

I loved how the book bounces between the present and the past and slowly fills you in on how Dr. Grace got to where he is! I loved Rocky, he is my absolute favorite character!

This book has it all! Suspense, adventure, heart, science, space, self-discovery and most of all, hope!

I will be reading this book again (& listening to the audiobook) because it brought me such joy! This book will win awards!!!! I highly recommend this one! Don't miss out on what could be the best book of 2021!

I'm so grateful to Andy Weir, Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine, and NetGalley for providing me with a free copy of this ARC ebook in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Lovers of Science Fiction will rejoice to hear Andy Weir, author of The Martian has written another space masterpiece!

Project Hail Mary is a suspenseful story about an unconventional scientist Ryland Grace who is on a mission to save planet Earth from a mysterious organism that is eating the Sun.
This book is a WILD ride! I watch space movies with my stomach in knots and perilously gripping the seat in an anxious mess, typically exclaiming how much I hope never to go to space. This book was like watching a thriller, teetering on the edge of your seat, nail-biting adventure, complete with hilarious dialogue and unexpected deep connection to the characters.

I throughly enjoyed this novel. I am positive it will be a classic for Science Fiction enthusiasts everywhere, I’m also positive even those that often don’t gravitate towards this genre will find deep satisfaction in joining in on Rylands race to save the species.

Rating: 4.5 STARS

Big thank you to Net Galley and Random House for this ARC

Was this review helpful?

First off, thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC of this book.

Ryland Grace makes for a fascinating main character - when you start the book, you know as much about him as he does. Because he doesn't know who he is, where he is, or how he got there, for that matter. Much of the backstory is filled in via flashbacks as he slowly regains bits of his memory.

And that's why this review is difficult to write, because half of the fun is in letting the story unfold!

But I will tell you this much - I loved this book because of:

- the clever, inventive MC with a wry wit.
- a really inventive plot premise
- all the crazy science and math that Weir somehow makes accessible (and if it's not entirely accurate, who cares, he made me feel smart in that I generally understood what was going on)
- fascinating secondary characters. I mean, REALLY intriguing, maddening, and/inventive secondary characters. Rocky absolutely stole my heart.

This book rockets along (pun intended) even with the MC not knowing a lot of anything to start. He has to piece together where he is and moreso what he's meant to be doing, which is a clever way to let the story unfold and keeps the intensity on. When we first meet Rocky, his ally in space, the pace changes, but it's important to the development of their relationship. I love Rocky - he may be my favorite part of the story.

Yes, Ryland Grace is a character very much reminiscent of Weir's Mark Watney in THE MARTIAN, However, Grace has no hesitation showing/sharing that he doesn't fit in with the people he's working with or the job he's tasked to do, and it humanizes him all the more to me.

There is a lot of science and math in this book, but Weir makes it understandable(ish). Fine, I definitely the premise and my brain didn't explode in the process, so it's a win.

This book is funny, fascinating, fast-paced, and the ending was a true surprise.

Was this review helpful?

Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir is a very, very highly recommended saving-the-world science fiction story. I love, love, love this novel and, in turn, Andy Weir for writing Project Hail Mary (and The Martian, and Artemis, which I enjoyed). After I read The Martian, I personally told everyone to buy it and read it, and I will do the same for Project Hail Mary. This will definitely be on my list of best books of 2021. I may even, gulp, love it more than The Martian, which is still way-up-there on my best books ever list.

Ryland Grace wakes up on a spaceship not knowing where he is, who he is, or what he is supposed to be doing while a computer is asking him what is 2+2. It becomes clear, after some time, that he is the sole survivor, and the task set before him is impossible. His task is to solve a mystery in order to save the Earth from an extinction-level event. Slowly Grace remembers that he was a junior high school science teacher. He also remembers that astrophage, a microscopic alien organism, is somehow eating the energy from the sun, causing it to dim, which will eventually lead to a new ice age on Earth in a few decades. Scientists have determined that all the other stars nearby seem to be suffering with the same affliction with the exception of Tau Ceti. The ship, named Hail Mary, has the task of identifying why Tau Ceti is immune and hopefully saving the Earth. Before he taught junior high, he was a molecular biologist, but why would he, out of so many better candidates, be chosen to be on the task force studying the astrophage and then chosen be on this mission, which is a suicide mission with no way to return to Earth?

The un-put-downable, extraordinary, riveting narrative alternates between chapters following Grace in the present day on the Hail Mary with chapters of Grace remembering what happened before he woke up on the ship. Information about his past and the present is carefully disclosed and new facts are discovered as the plot unfolds. There is humor in the narrative; I experienced several laugh-out-loud moments while reading. Ryland Grace is an imminently likeable character. He is channeling McGyver, although not quite as much as Mark Watney did, as he figures out what to do. It becomes even more interesting when he discovers an alien spaceship near his ship that is on the same mission he is.

Naturally there is plenty of science and scientific speculation in Project Hail Mary. Yes, this is an outstanding science fiction survival tale, but it is also a story about friendship. Expect several plot twists, nail-biting suspense, jaw dropping moments, relentless tension, emotional reactions, and heart-stopping events in this perfectly paced novel. The final denouement is perfect, absolutely, positively perfect. It needs to be said again that I love Project Hail Mary. It is a phenomenal, remarkable science fiction novel that is sure to become a classic.

Disclosure: My review copy was courtesy of Penguin Random House in exchange for my honest opinion.
The review will be submitted for publication on Amazon, Google Books, and Barnes & Noble

Was this review helpful?

I am not a sci-fi lover by any means but I loved The Martian SO much that I had to give Andy Weir's newest novel a chance and I am so glad that I did!

This book gets a bit dry due to the extended parts of science stuff. As you can tell from the previous sentence, I am not into the science stuff. I think those that are smarter than me will probably really enjoy all the science nerding out but I basically skimmed over this section since I didn't understand any of it.

Even without understanding most of the science this book is SO enjoyable. I loved, loved, loved Rocky and would happily read more stories about him! The friendship he has with Dr. Grace is the best. I really had no idea how things would wind up and this novel kept me turning the page wondering where it would go next.

Overall I think this is going to be a smash hit when released. SO enjoyable and it was a great escape when recovering from the second dose of the coronavirus vaccine.

Was this review helpful?