Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Oh my goodness, this book. I absolutely LOVED Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir! If readers enjoyed his novel The Martian, then I have no doubt that they will enjoy this one. This is a story about survival, friendship, space, new discoveries, and perseverance.

From the first page, we’re thrown into the story and discover things alongside our main character, Ryland Grace. Ryland felt similar yet very different to the MC of Martian. Which is good because I don’t want to read about the same character in a different situation unless I’m reading a series.

Unsurprisingly, Weir’s writing was on point and I loved the characters. Ryland, as we slowly find out, is a total science nerd, is a science teacher, and somehow ended up being a part of this mission. Which he only knows parts of the purpose is at first. Weir went the route of writing present moments and past moments, which I really enjoyed because I was learning everything as the same time that Ryland was … it made for quite the reading experience. It was also an interesting way to see the development of Ryland’s character.

Not being even the tiniest bit science-inclined, a lot of the science and other technical language went over my head. I also tended to just read those parts and not bother trying to understand. Doing this and having to read all of that without understanding did not diminish my reading experience at all.

While I have no idea if the main components of the plot is even plausible, it felt realistic or that it could easily be plausible. The story flowed really well, kept me on the edge of my seat without going overboard with the obstacles, which I appreciate. And that one big moment that happens? Somehow I did not see it coming and it was SO GOOD. Made the story all the better.

The ending was not quite what I was expecting, though it made it a lot of sense. Even if it felt a little bittersweet.

Was this review helpful?

First of all, thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for access to this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

When a small life form starts feeding on energy from the sun, humans on Earth must find a way to stop them quickly before they go into a mass extinction event. After finding a planet 12 light years away that's star hadn't dimmed, but had this life form, they send out an expedition to this star system to find out how this star is surviving. Once out there, the scientist discovers alien life.

This book was so heartwarming and fun. The relationship between Rocky and Dr. Grace is so cute and wholesome. The beginning instantly grabbed my attention and I was sucked into this story. Some of the middle bits were a little slow. It was a lot of scientific experiments as Ryland and Rocky were trying to figure out how this star was surviving. There wasn't as much action, and there was a lot of scientific explanation. However, by the ending, I was fully invested again. The end was completely unexpected, but I think was an incredibly fitting ending to this fun, cute story. This book has inspired me to read "The Martian" in the future, considering this is my first Weir book I've read.

I highly recommend this book to sci-fi and non-sci-fi readers everywhere. It's a story about space exploration, but also a story about friendship, discovery, and perseverance.

TW: alcohol, death, drugs, fire, kidnapping, needles, skeletons, poisoning

Was this review helpful?

I loved Ryland Grace and his endless optimistic search for creative solutions to life-threatening---for everyone on Earth--problems. But I fell in love with his companion, Rocky. The relationship grew in its warmth throughout the novel and made me that much more invested in the outcome!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much for NetGalley for this opportunity to read this book by Andy Weir.

I don't really love Science Fiction, But this was a fun book.. i'm nowhere near smart enough to understand all of the technical and scientific dialogue in this (i'm also too lazy to fact check and do any research on the concepts discussed), but that did not stop me from enjoying this.

I couldn’t put this book down. I just adore the snarky tone of his writing, Weir has an uncanny ability to make science understandable and interesting. As he did in The Martian, he draws you in immediately to an everyman type who is faced with a huge scientific problem. In this case, it's not only the survival of one human being, but of our entire planet...

Was this review helpful?

This story immediately pulled me in - a man wakes up in a spacecraft...and he remembers nothing. Not his name, not why he is there, and not where he is heading. His memories soon begin coming back, and he eventually remembers he is on a mission to save humanity. No pressure! You’re chugging along with Dr. Grace as he begins problems solving and learning about his new environment, doing experiments, and learning how to navigate in 0g. And then the story took a pretty weird turn. And I was not on board...until I suddenly was! Andy Weir charmed me with his characters and writing style so much that I was able to suspend my belief a little further than I normally would have. I found myself smiling while reading which is so corny but true!

The only somewhat negative thing about it for me, if you could call it negative, were the times when the scientific explanations got a little too in-depth, and my eyes started glazing over a bit. Though I do understand why all of that information was included, I may or may not have skipped over a couple of paragraphs.

I gave this book 5 stars because I truly enjoyed every page of it, and it left me thinking about it long after I finished reading, which is always a good sign in a book. I still haven’t started a new book because my mind keeps going back to it. I even shed a little tear at the end.

Was this review helpful?

As a scientist I LOVED this book!! It has everything I never knew I needed! Science, space, sarcasm, aliens, more science! I LOVED the Martian when I first read it, I enjoyed Artemis, but Project Hail Mary was the Martian level amazing-ness! Dr Ryland Grace was such a wonderful, smart, and funny narrator! I really enjoyed being inside his head and problem solving with him!

There is so much to this book; science (if you couldn't tell), humor, fight for your life, friendship (in many forms), action, and tearful moments. This story will keep you on the edge of your seat for the entire ride! I am so thankful for this copy!

Thank you thank you thank you!

I will be singing the praises of this book for years to come!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars!

Andy Weir has done it again! He’s made this reader who avoids most books related to math and science love another book that’s brimming with it. He has a talent for taking complex ideas and making them simple and even interesting for someone who generally zones out when anything scientific sounding is introduced. At this point, I think it’s safe to say Andy Weir is an auto-read author for me. While most readers who loved The Martian weren’t fond of his follow-up novel Artemis, I actually really enjoyed it. And for me, Project Hail Mary was the best of both of those novels.

This will be a novel that’s hard to discuss without spoilers since so many surprising things happen right from the opening. But I’ll do my best!

I challenge you to read the first five pages and NOT want to keep reading. What an opening! Ryland Grace wakes up alone with no clue where he is or how he got there. HIs body isn’t responding the way it should and he struggles with the fog that is keeping rational thoughts at bay. He slowly comes to the realization that he’s hurtling through space and his crew mates are dead. While that opening alone is enough to keep me turning pages, Weir infuses Ryland with his unique wit and humor that elevates the story beyond the run of the mill science fiction thriller.

As Ryland’s memory returns, he flashes back to the past and slowly reveals how he ended up as the sole-survivor of this last-chance mission to save Earth. And as things seem hopeless, he finds glimmers of hope in unexpected places. He also just might be the perfect person for the job.

This well-written novel is a mix of things: science fiction, mystery, fantasy, thriller. There’s a diverse cast as the entire planet comes together to save humanity. And I can only hope Hollywood takes notice once again.

Was this review helpful?

This book is absolutely amazing. I can honestly say it's my new all time favorite. Just like The Martian there is a lot of science that i tended to glaze over but the story is incredible. I could not put it down.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 5/5

ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY! ROCKY!

Can that be my entire review? No? Well, let me just say this. I am in love with this book!

This is my first book by Andy Weir and wow! I. Am. Just. Lost. For. Words.

The plot of Project Hail Mary is basically this. All of Earth is going to die and it's up to one man who can't remember anything, much less his name, to save it. This book also has some alien life in it but it was done in a super new and interesting way, that I personally have never seen done before!

I was a bit hesitant to read this because of a couple of reasons. 1) Andy Weir is a big name author and I was scared I wouldn't like his work, 2)this book uses the amnesia trope which isn't something I usually enjoy, but wow did I love it in the context it plays in this book, 3)claustrophobic spaces/stories that are set in only one small location are my jam, but 4)this book also has a duel timeline which is another trope I usually tend to dislike, but once again, I loved it in the context of this story! So yeah, you could say I was wrestling with some mixed feelings before jumping into this story, but luckily it paid off really well! And I don't want to jinx anything, but I think this might be a new favorite of the year!

I really don't know what else to say besides that I loved this book! I found it fascinating and fast-paced, I connected so deeply with the characters to the point that I laughed and almost cried my way through it entirely, and that ending! Perfection!

*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

In a last-ditch effort to save Earth from an extinction-level event, a group of astronauts is sent on a desperate mission in a cobbled-together spacecraft. But when Ryland Grace wakes up, he has no memory of his mission or why the rest of the crew is dead. The sole survivor, he must take on an impossible task with no margin for failure.

Andy Weir returns to many of the elements that made The Martian a best seller: a desperate space mission where a sarcastic protagonist MacGyver's his way through with science. Unfortunately, Project Hail Mary doesn't have the mass appeal of The Martian. Ryland Grace is an annoying version of Mark Watney, the mission was less realistic, and the science was overwhelming at times. I didn't connect with the story until over halfway through, and would only recommend this book to strong science fiction readers.

Was this review helpful?

I’ll be the first to admit that science fiction isn’t my go-to genre. But I read Andy Weir’s first book (The Martian) and loved it. So when I saw this one coming out, I figured it was time to try another sci-fi book.

It wasn’t my jam. I loved the premise. The sun is losing energy. Microorganisms are eating it up. If that doesn’t change, everything on the Earth will die in 30 years. Ryland is sent to another solar system to save humanity.

But, at about a third of the way thru, it just got too weird for me. I’m good with fantasy novels, but I just can’t get onboard with aliens. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Though it’s not for me. If you’re into space, science fiction and smart, interesting leading men, then give it a try. I can see how others would love it.

Was this review helpful?

Ryland Grace wakes up aboard a spaceship with two dead crewmembers beside him and no recollection of how or why he got there. Then slowly he begins to put the pieces together. He was placed in a medically-induced coma and he’s on a mission to save Earth from another Ice Age and mass extinction.

I really enjoyed this one. Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir is an absolute celebration of science and human ingenuity, filled with humor and heart.

It also places an interesting spin of the alien first contact trope. Instead of sentient, human-eating alien predators, humanity’s threat is tiny invasive space algae that are eating our sun’s energy. You can’t shoot them or ask them to leave, so now it’s up to Ryland to get creative and figure out how to get rid of them.

Lastly, I think it’s important to note that this is very much a hard science fiction novel. It’s got a lot of scientific exposition in it. If you’re a science nerd, you’ll probably geek out over this one, but for others, it may make the book more difficult to get into. I admit that it’s been a while since I took a physics class, so some of the science went over my head, but I just nodded along, like, yeah, that sounds about right.

All and all, I’d say this book is very tonally similar to Andy’s previous novel The Martian. It chooses scientific hope and optimism in the face of despair, and that I think is beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely LOVED "The Martian" by Andy Weir. I loved it because it read as science fiction that could ultimately be feasible in our current world. It bridged a gap from astrophysics to humanity in a way that, if I couldn't fully understand it, I could fully support and cheer for it.

"Project Hail Mary" was close to that. When I started it, I thought it was going to be the best science fiction book I had read in a while. It was exciting, mysterious, and I loved the use of flashback for supplying the history of the present situation that the main character found themself in.

And then the science came. And it was so much science, It was pages and pages of science. The science overwhelmed not just my brain, but the entire book. I think the story was sacrificed for the sake of the science, and it made what could have been a real page turner into a bit of a slog.

Ryland Grace wakes up to find himself in space, alone, on a mission that will make the difference between Erath surviving and not. But he can't seem to remember who he is or why he is here. He is the only soul alive to complete this task....or is he?

I don't know that I WON'T recommend this book to people, because I think others may absolutely love it. I am a bit hesitant to recommend it to anyone who isn't a die hard science fiction fan. Because with "The Martian," there was mostly fiction with a a bit of science. And this seems to be mostly science with a bit of fiction.

Was this review helpful?

My rating is more of a 3.5 but not up to 4 stars. There were just too many times when it all felt like it was going to morph into The Martian but was pulled back from the brink just in time. I loved The Martian, it actually had me breathless at times - not so with Hail Mary because I even put this one down for long stretches and felt no compulsion to dig back in. I even made a trip to the book description page on Amazon at one point to see if I might have chosen a middle grade book by mistake. Not impossible for Weir to want to do something like that but logical thinking said that the science would have been quite a few shades too tough. The Earth is in crisis and this ship is sent on a suicide mission to fix the problem or everyone on Earth dies. Maybe a little too far fetched to believe all of these problems can be solved by one human? Maybe the ending was expected? Maybe it was too predictable? Yes, yes and yes.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for an e-galley of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely LOVED The Martian so when I saw Andy Weir wrote another book about a dude stranded alone in space I knew I had to check it out. How can a guy write TWO books about guys stranded alone and trying to survive in space, and make them different but also awesome? Could it be done?! Reader, it CAN and he did it.

(Side note: my poor spouse watched the movie of The Martian with me after I'd read the book, and was subjected to my continual comments about how much more amazing the book is than the movie. Don't get me wrong, the movie is pretty great, but there's just SO MUCH in the book and his sort of internal monologue you just can't get in a movie with basically one character with nobody to talk to. So please read the book - and listen to the audiobook if you can, the narrator is AMAZING.)

ANYWAY, back to this book. I was so invested in this book, in the outcome and in Ryland's slowly returning memories, that I didn't want to put it down. The story is almost told in a dual timeline; there's the "now" of Ryland waking with no memory of who (or where) he is or what the heck he's doing there, and then slowly bits and pieces of memories start to come back to him, and interspersed with the "now" storyline we get the "past" story that led to Ryland waking on a spacecraft with no memory. Certain things Ryland does or needs seem to unlock key memories that help him move his mission (and this the story) forward, and it makes for a very compelling storytelling method. We learn about the mission right along with Ryland as he recovers his memories.

The only thing I didn't 110% love was the ending. It felt a little ... off, for me, but I can't quite pinpoint why. And I don't really want to say more because I don't want to spoil anything! And it wasn't off enough to make me rate this less than 5 stars, because it was an amazingly enjoyable ride the whole way through anyway. I'm definitely looking forward to seeing how Andy Weir manages to strand a man in space next and still make it new and interesting, haha!

Was this review helpful?

“Project Hail Mary” by Andy Weir. I really, really wanted to love this book. I really, really wanted to be blown away. I really, really read the scores of five-star reviews. So, after completing the novel last night, I sit here wondering what I missed. I enjoyed “The Martian” with its mixture of science and suspense. I believe Mr. Weir was striving for the same mixture but it has fallen flat. This story feels more for the Young Adult market beginning with the selection of a protagonist who teaches science to young people, and, oh yeah, on the side he is one of the foremost scientists in the world who happens to be chosen for an interstellar trip to save his home planet from extinction.
So if you like science this book is for you: I agree with another reviewer who wrote that “if you cut out all of the science exposition, you’d be left with a 70-page book.” Spot on! I like science titration...a small dose distributed over a long period of time. Please give me “The Foundation Trilogy (I know I am old school.” Some sound science mixed into a rippin’ good yarn.

Was this review helpful?

Easy 5 star read for me. I loved Michael Crichton as a younger reader and Project Hail Mary is reminiscent of his best work with added layers of character and humor. Any discussion of my favorite character would be a spoiler, so i'll say generally that the characters are the best part of this book. Other than that, you want to go in as blind as possible (as our protagonist is on the first few pages). This will be a hit with fans of The Martian. Its an incredibly fun thriller.

Was this review helpful?

Received an ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

This is my second Andy Weir novel, as I read (and LOVED) The Martian but never checked out Artemis.

I'm not going to go deep into the plot because I don't want to spoil a novel before it's even released. That said, I liked this a whole lot. The pacing was consistent, the plot was fun and interesting in a way that strongly reminded me of The Martian, and I loved all the characters.

Andy Weir has a real talent for taking scientific information that I am just barely smart enough to follow and making it readable. I also appreciate how based in science his books seem to be (because it's not like I'd actually be able to tell if he was full of s**t.

If you're in the mood for a funny, frankly kind of heartwarming and wholesome sci-fi that has not even a hint of a romantic subplot, do yourself a favor and check this out!

Was this review helpful?

Since publishing The Martian Andy Weir has been at the top of my science fiction favorite authors. He has another amazing work in Project Hail Mary. The author has an amazing talent for integrating science information in his novels and making them interesting. This book is no exception. For lovers of space flight, biological science, physics, and calculus this novel is a must-read. For the rest of us it a novel that teaches and entertains. Andy's books are realistic with great characters and plots that explore human and in this novel, inhuman nature.
The main character is a space traveler. He awakens in his spacecraft to find his fellow astronauts dead after their induced travel comas. He remembers his training but in bits and pieces, he puts together the past and how he got on the Hail Mary. Then he encounters another ship starting the adventure that exceeds his expectations and takes the reader on a journey exploring his efforts to save not just earth, but another planet.
Along with science, this book explores friendship and makes a statement about what is important in our lives. For fans of The Martian, I highly recommend this book. It has so many fascinating facets including life, science, space travel, and diversity that you will find yourself thinking about it long after you turn the last page. Andy Weir does it all right in #ProjectHailMary. Thanks to #ProjectHailMary#NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this excellent book. The publication date is May 4, 2021. Put it on your must-read list.

Was this review helpful?

I received a galley of this book from NetGalley prepublication.
The Martian felt to me like science fiction that actually happened, I started to believe that we had landed humans on Mars. Andy Weir’s second book Artemis was way different: fun and easy sci-fi that felt plausible but never real. This latest novel pushes the limits of plausibility but backs it with so much fun science and math. A grade school science teacher saves the world with good old STEM! From the discovery of alien microbes to actual alien intelligence this author does very little hand-waving in terms of explanations, relying instead on hard science. Excellent, thank you again Andy Weir.

Was this review helpful?