I started this book. It was really hard for me to get into. The main character has a special ability that hasn't been seen in over a hundred years. I think the plot showed promise, but the execution was poor.

I really wanted to like this book, but it just wasn't for me. The writing and the message are good, but I just did not like Clara which made it a bit of a slog to get through.

I’m a sucker for a witchy story. This was a light fantasy with a cool magic system. I enjoyed the main character and felt her intentions were in the right place. I would read more from this author.

I thought i would love this book, witches, a witchy school whats not to love? Sadly it was a DNF for me :/

Absolutely loved this. It was like a breath of fresh air. The writing was great, the story wasn’t something we seen over and over and I really enjoyed the characters. I definitely have recommended this book and will continue to do so.

In the same vein I'd spoken in before, YA has been a little bit of a struggle for me. So maybe that's why I didn't LOVE this one.

With that said, there were many solid aspects to this story. My favorite? The main character, Clara. She's written well; she's interesting, she has growth throughout the story, and (most importantly) she doesn't annoy me to no end.

Even though I've been in a YA rut lately, because of my love for witchy stories, this one resonated with me and I'm glad to have read it.

I tried really hard to get into this story. I found the premise to be very interesting and unique, but hard to read. It did not hold my attention as I would have liked and was easy to forget about once I stopped reading and sat it aside. I was unable to finish this book at this time, but hope to revisit it in the future.

This was a lush, imaginative fantasy—a new take on what it means to be powerful, and I loved watching the protagonist grow on her journey as she figures out how to use her powers in a way that feels good to her.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a copy earlier.

A charming story about coming into your own power… even if it doesn’t always come naturally. I think many of us can relate to that. It was easy to get into the magic system of the book. I also remember the cover standing out… it’s beautiful!!

Hello yes I loved this. Magic, growth, climate change, the cutest little cat, love, yes to all of it. Clara was an absolute delight and her journey was wild and sad and wonderful and I loved her and she is my ever ever ever okay???

So precious, so easy to listen to and devour, I enjoyed the hell out of this.

I was not expecting to like this book as much as I did, one of my new favorite quotes is from this book. “ Be wary of those who will let you apologize for who you are”

I have gotten this book for my mom and my sister because I thought they would also love it

The Nature of Witches by Rachel Griffin has a beautiful cover and a very interesting blurb, which initially made me excited to read it. However, I felt a sense of disappointment right from the beginning. The issues lie in the worldbuilding, storyline, characters, and even the writing style. Although the story is set in Pennsylvania, the execution didn't give off the magical atmosphere that I was expecting from a magical academy setting.

Furthermore, the 'chosen one' trope is present, just like in any other book that deals with magic. It’s a trope that is just so overdone that when I see it I pretty much roll my eyes. Add in the fact that the 'chosen one' character in The Nature of Witches is quite annoying, and it took everything in me not to continue to read this book.

The writing style lacks depth and variation. Even during intense moments like a big storm, the writing failed to evoke any strong emotions or captivate my interest in the story.

The unique lore and magic system is quite interesting. It deviates from the typical portrayal of witches. It brings something new to the table of witch-themed books, but unfortunately, it's not enough to make this a great book.

The first thing that always captures me in Rachel Griffin’s book is her beautiful, prose-like writing. I write down so many quotes from her books and love looking back over them to read over and over again. I wish I had read this book before her others so that I could give a good comparison of her debut and the growth of her writing but I honestly kept forgetting this was her first book, it was that well-written. The atmosphere was amazing, all of the descriptions had me smelling and seeing everything as if it was in my own living room. Her magic system was one of the easiest I’ve ever read, not confusing at all and so well fleshed out. I loved the romance, even though it felt a little juvenile at times, it more than made up for it throughout the book. My favorite part of this entire book was the quotes at the beginning of every chapter and how they tied into something specific within that chapter. I also loved how the quotes tied up in a huge way at the end. I’m really sad this book is just a standalone, I need more from the two characters and I want to see more of Clara’s personal growth as an Ever witch.

If you’re looking for a book that will give you all the cozy, fall, witchy vibes this is definitely one to pick up. I will be thinking about this book and rereading this book for many years now.

Thank you to Sourcebooks Fire for the copy to review.

For centuries, the witches have controlled the climate. They have kept the delicate balance between warm and cold, they have kept extreme weather at bay, but now things are changing. The climate is getting harder and harder to maintain, and witches are burning up...literally. With witches tied to the seasons, their hope relies on the next generation of witches coming through training to be better, stronger, and more dynamic than those who have come before. But their hope is relying on Clara most of all. The first Ever witch in a century. The only Ever witch of her generation. It is predicted that her power that links her to all four seasons will be the power to save them all. But Clara doesn't want such a power. Clara doesn't want any of it, because for her, all her power has brought is death and isolation. But when trainers arrive from a school across the country, she finds herself drawn to Sang, a guy with an affinity for plants, but with her power killing everyone she has ever loved, she is stuck between wanting Sang and her destiny.

I basically was hooked on this book from start to finish.

Clara annoyed me a little at the start because I hate whiny characters in books, but we quickly find that she's maybe warranted a bit to be whiny. She is pushed to the edge by her trainers, her family have died, her best friend has died, she lives isolated from the other students in her school and her destiny to save the planet and the witches lies heavy on her shoulders. She actually winds up being a great character as the book goes on and I loved watching her blooming relationship with Sang develop. There was no insta-love, which is a pain of mine, instead Clara actually isn't interested in love at all after her past experiences with her power. It seemingly happens quite organically which makes it all the more emotional.

I cannot wait to read more from this author and visit this world again.

Great writing. Very intruiguing. I might take a pause from so many witchy books for a bit. But this was a good one.

This book was amazing. I loved the epic magic and whimsical feel it gave me reading a romance. I loved how Clara changed with the seasons. This was such a cool fresh concept on the magic world. I highly recommend for anyone who loves witchy romances. This one is for you!

4.1 stars

Oh what a captivating and spellbinding story! A world where magic is tied to the very seasons themselves! Elemental magic, heartwarming romance, and a quest to save the world from chaos... what a charming combination!

Clara is an Everwitch with a rare and powerful magic that can harness the energy of every season. As the world's climate becomes increasingly unstable, Clara's magic becomes more crucial than ever.

This book takes you through the changing seasons, each filled with its own challenges and discoveries. From wild and untamed magic to the responsibility of wielding incredible power, Clara's journey will keep you on the edge of your seat.

Why you should read this book?

- Magical storytelling about the power of nature and the complexity of relationships
- Truly inspiring character ARC about self-discovery and courage.
- Refreshing take on magic, tied to the beauty and chaos of the natural world.
- Great pacing
- relevant topic of climate change.

For fans of elemental magic, romantic twists, and stories that explore deeper themes, "The Nature of Witches" is a must-read that will leave you enchanted and moved.
For fans of elemental magic, romantic twists, and stories that explore deeper themes, "The Nature of Witches" is a must-read that will leave you enchanted and moved.

The idea of witches with control over the elements is a perfect pairing, and it’s portrayed in such an interesting way in this novel that it was impossible not to get sucked in. The visuals, moments of tension and the love story are interwoven seamlessly, and after the first couple of chapters I found myself sailing through this book. I’m so looking forward to reading more of what Rachel Griffin has to offer!

This book had so much potential to be a story I really loved. Witches connected to seasonal magic is a really interesting concept and one that I absolutely love. But unfortunately a few things fell flat for me.

First of all...the characters. The main character was a bit whiney and annoying at times. I found myself getting frustrated with her quite often. She is very melodramatic. I didn't care much for any of the other characters either. I think Sang would have to be my favorite even though I wasn't a big fan of the romance development. He was very sweet but something about the two of them and the romance didn't sit well with me. Possibly could have been the pacing which is a big issue for this story in general.

It took way too long for anything to really happen at all. This is very slow paced, made worse by the writing style which felt very...monotone is the best word I can think of as another person said. It felt like nothing was happening the entire book and then when a couple of moments that were supposed to be big events were happening, it just didn't feel like it was that serious. I think we were supposed to feel that the stakes were high but I just didn't. I felt no intensity or anxiety about the things that were supposed to be big.

Another part I was super excited about was that this book points out the issues regarding climate change and how people are ruining the atmosphere and the effects of that, which is extremely relevant to today. I really wanted a bigger message behind this and for this book to make an impact in that direction but it seemed to take a back seat and was brushed over in favor of Clara's internal struggles instead.

It was a decent read and a pretty good one as far as debut novels go. Just didn't quite meet my expectations.

This was a unique take on the idea of magic and the message that it gave regarding modern issues (air pollution, climate change) really hit home. The idea of witches having a specific season that their magic is tied to gave a new feeling for magic. Having a few, like Clara, have magic all the time led to one of my favorite tropes, "The Chosen One." Her friendship with Paige and romantic relationship with Sang were very real and helped the story push forward.

I would recommend this book for anyone that loves a witchy story, especially one set in modern times.