Cover Image: The Newcomer

The Newcomer

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley for this early, uncorrected copy of The Newcomer by Mary Kay Andrews. I enjoyed this book and thought it pretty well thought out, In most books of this type believable outcomes and realities should be suspended and the reader should just enjoy the book for what it is a fast, fun read with likable characters. Real world would have halted this story right at the beginning but I am glad we got a chance to see the relationship between Letty and Joe play out.
Maya is delightful, albeit pretty easily distracted which I found not to be the case with my 4 year old! While I did enjoy this read I do think the author was less detailed with the character motives and more so with location description. Bad guy was a typical bad guy, good guy a typical good guy, old person a typical old person and so on which made it a tad cliched.
I loved the setting at a bygone era motel on the Florida Gulf Coast. The octogenarian cast of motel residents/guests were fun and added a bit of color to the book. The location itself was a scene stealer, digging your toes into the warm sand while watching sunsets sounds lovely.
This is the perfect book when you just want to be distracted, a good beach read!

Was this review helpful?

I'm not sure what I was expecting when I first started reading The Newcomer, but I was definitely pleasantly surprised when I got a suspenseful murder mystery with a dash of romance thrown in. The writing style and plotline remind me of an old-school Nora Roberts novel, and those were some of my favourites so I definitely enjoyed this.

The only hesitation I have for not giving this 5 stars is the lack of romance and some sort of twist at the end. I felt like the climax of the story came too early (around 70%) and resolved itself by 85% so I was left wondering what was going to happen in the last 15% of the book. The ending to the murder mystery was also neat and tidy and I wished for something a bit more complex and honestly expected the killer not to be the obvious choice. From a romance perspective, I wish there were more sizzling moments where I could feel the love they had for each other.

That said, the writing was superb and everything flowed really well. I would definitely not hesitate to pick up another Mary Kay Andrews book and would recommend this to all my friends.

Was this review helpful?

I have read a couple of this authors other books and enjoyed them. However, I DNF this book due to the bullying comments that were left by this author on another author’s social media. Times are hard enough without people trying to tear others down. I appreciate the publisher providing me with this ARC to read but I cannot condone bullying behavior.

Was this review helpful?

This wasn't the type of story that I am used to reading from this author, but it was entertaining and suspenseful. Letty finds her sister Tanya married, and takes her 4 year-old niece to escape to safety. Details of the murder and Tanya's past begins to be revealed as Letty finds a home at a beachside motel in Florida. A romantic interest enters the scene, but he is also a detective. The storyline was slightly predictable but suspenseful nonetheless. An enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

Letty Carnahan is a newcomer to Treasure Island, Florida’s shades of a 60’s postcard The Murmuring Surf Motel. She’s also a newcomer to parenting as she is raising her sister Tanya’s charming four year old daughter Maya. This has all happened because she found Tanya’s dead body in the New York City townhouse she had shared with Evan Winfield. Maya, cradling her stuffed elephant toy, was crying nearby. Letty knew that Tanya believed Evan would kill her and had shown her a getaway bag stuffed with cash, jewelry and a Murmuring Surf brochure. So of course, Letty grabs Maya and ends up at the motel the next day.

Letty convinces motel owner Ava DeCurtis to rent her an efficiency, even if has been used for storage and not cleaned in some time. Letty takes that on and soon volunteers to do other housekeeping chores. The problem is Ava’s son Joe, a local policeman. He’s attracted to Ava but he also knows what happened in New York. Then Evan Wingfield enters the picture, Tanya’s past catches up to Letty and she is forced to decide what really matters to her.

Mary Kay Andrews has really nailed the Florida snowbird scene! Chaise lounges by the pool “reserved” with towels, the early bird special at 4:30, and the arguments over whose turn it is to use pools and shuffleboard courts. You expect the best of the best beach read from her and in The Newcomer, you’ve got it! 5 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press and Mary Kay Andrews for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to read this ARC. I have been a long time fan of Mary Kay Andrew’s books and although I enjoyed this one I feel like I read it in the past. Was this a reworking of a past book?
This story had a bit of romance, some mystery and suspense, but the part I enjoyed most was the setting. The story mainly takes place at an old fashioned motel near St Pete beach Florida. Some of the characters staying in the motel were like caricatures of crotchety old people and the police officer romantic interest was disappointing to me in his blatant disregard of the law, but other than that I really enjoyed the story.

Was this review helpful?

Another wonderful page turner by Mary Kay Andrews.Perfect beach read combination of mystery and romance.I really enjoyed Letty and Maya and was sorry to finish the book.#neetgalley#st.martinspress

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the St. Martins and Netgalley for an ARC in return for my honest review. I would give this 3.5-4 stars.

First, I will outright admit that I am a Mary Kay Andrews fan from way back. I have read nearly all of her books. She has always been a go-to for a good read, and The Newcomer fits the bill as a fast-paced thriller/romance.

Letty and her niece Maya are on the run from Evan Wingfield, Maya’s father and the man suspected of killing Maya’s mom, Tanya. Letty promised her sister Tanya she’d take Maya and run if anything ever happened to her, and that’s exactly what Letty did. After her sister’s murder and following a clue she had left behind, Letty ends up in Florida at the Murmuring Surf, a quaint little hotel. There she meets the owner Ava, her daughter Isabelle and son/cop Joe along with the other visitors at the hotel. Everyone soon falls in love with Letty and Maya, which all plays into the tangled story that unfolds.

MKA is always good at building stories that are page-turning and full of twists. As she writes more books, though, she keeps moving further away from the Southern charm that oozed in her original books. She used to spend more time building quirky, lovable characters, but now, it feels like the mystery, suspense and twists are more important. I miss the Southern flair that made her books special and not just a mystery. I really miss the MKA books steeped in the South.

I still enjoyed reading The Newcomer and would recommend reading it if you want a quick read. Mary Kay Andrews remains a go-to author for good reads!

Was this review helpful?

Letty is on the run with her niece Maya after finding her sister murdered. She heads to the Murmuring Surf motel where she and Maya are embraced by the owner and her family.

Unfortunately, the crimes committed in Mew York have made headlines and Petty is considered a subject in the murder.

Lots of mystery and suspense in this story!

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The premise of the story is that Letty finds her sister dead and takes to heart her warning: that if anything happens to her, its her ex's doing and please take her 4 year old daughter and run. So that is what Letty does. I've read some of this author's books before and enjoyed them. While i don't this this is a 4-5 star read, it keeps you entertained. Its a bit predictable, but an entertaining beach read. It grabs you in the first chapter and even though you can guess a lot of what happens, it makes you want to keep reading. Recommend it and than you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced copy to review!

Was this review helpful?

This book has an interesting premise and blurb, and those are what drew me to it. It is categorized as a suspense, mystery, and romance, and the beginning definitely has the flavor of a mystery and suspense.

But as I read on, the story seemed to drag in many places, which diluted the suspense aspect, and there really wasn’t a mystery for me to ponder and try to solve since the identity of the murderer was pretty much presumed and established from the start.

Overall the story was fairly good—I liked the author’s writing style and enjoyed certain characters. The beach vibe was also nice. However, the execution of the storyline was okay. The pacing felt off. I wished for a better romance. And the mystery and suspense elements were rather disappointing.

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for an opportunity to read this story.

Was this review helpful?

Really big fam of Mary Kay Andrews going back to her Savannah stories with the character Weezie. So I was really looking forward to her new novel. A young woman escapes to Florida with her niece to protect her from her from her mother's killer. In a old fashioned motel, she meets a list of characters who involve her in their lives. I find the story dragging in spots, I was anxious to get to the end to see how all these characters fared. And of course, who the murderer was. I will recommend this to my friends .

Was this review helpful?

Letty Carnahan and her sister Tanya have had a troubled and emotional past. When Letty fears for her life and her daughter Maya, she makes Letty promise to take care of Maya. When Letty finds Tanya murdered she flees with the only clue she has: an advertisement for the Murmuring Surf Motel in Florida. So the story begins and you are charmed by little Maya. Letty finds work at the motel as she tried to help Maya heal and discover her sister’s past and murdered. Not to be left out is romance! The motel owner’s son is a cop. With twists and turns and heart warming scenes this book delivers suspense, love and much more.

Was this review helpful?

Personally, I'm a big Mary Kay Andrews fan, and love recommending her books. The Newcomer is one of my favorites. It is more like her earlier books, with better attention to plot and character. She's back in the "old school" Florida setting, which is very appealing. The Newcomer is a page-turner, with a couple of different mystery strands, which makes it hard to put down. Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

Mary Kay Andrews does it again! What appears to be a light read by the cover, is actually a story that has a lot of depth and emotion. I loved the cast of characters that Letty and Maya meet in Florida. A really good read that leaves you wanting to check into the Murmuring Surf.

Thank you to the publisher for an advanced copy of this book. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I really, really wanted to like this book but at the end of the book I was disappointed. Let's start with the title. It just does not seem to go with storyline of the book. Maybe at the beginning but as the book chugs along, it just does not seem to fit. I think she could have done something more creative with Murmuring Surf (motel name). Moving on to Vikki and Joe: I find that her descriptions of a FBI agent and police officer who appear to ignore basic law enforcement procedures appalling because she thinks it tells a better story. Why wouldn't Vikki be in more contact with her FBI team in regards to Evan? Why wasn't Joe ever seen discussing the situation with his commander at Treasure Island Police Department? Why did it seem he could leave his shift at any time Ava or Letty called him? I desperately want to discuss Tanya, Maya, Evan and Rooney but it would give away too many spoilers. After reflecting on the book for the past 24 hours, I have come to the conclusion that this is a glorified cozy mystery and not the chic lit storylines that I love from MKA. I feel like if she had a better editor or an editor who would stand up to her, they could help her fill out her 2D characters (Rooney, Zoey, Tanya, Sammi, Juju being just some examples) and plot line holes (Tanya and Letty's mother and grandmother/childhood). As a person who has a family winter house near the St Pete's area, I do enjoy her attention to detail to the area. She is a talented writer and the book is almost there but relies on too many coincidences (much like a cozy mystery).

Was this review helpful?

#TheNewcomer #NetGalley

Special thanks to NetGalley and St.Martin's press for providing me with ARC.

This is the first novel to me by Mary Andrews but i loved it.

I won this novel in NetGalley Giveaway and not regret it because it's a fun reading and i loved the relationship between Letty and her niece.

Was this review helpful?

I was a newcomer to Mary Kay Andrews with The Newcomer, but nothing about the book makes me want to stick around, or read any of her earlier books. This whole story was a hot mess, from a cliche storyline made even more cliche and cheesy by how it played out, to the multiple points of view at different time period - including briefly a cat, and the random interactions of the characters. Letty takes her niece Maya and flees New York to Florida after her sister Tanya is murdered. The suspect in question is of course her slimy ex. Then there's cranky cop Joe who's convinced Letty's up to no good but quickly falls in love with her. His mother Ava is the hotel owner who takes Letty in with open arms, aided by her daughter and her daughter's tech genius friend. And then because it's Florida in winter there's lots and lots of cranky old people bickering with each other. The story feels like it's about two hundred pages long as Evan the ex puts out a hit on Letty through (not surprisingly) an undercover FBI agent and everyone dithers over where and when they're going to trick Evan into something that can get him arrested and leave Letty and Maya living happily ever after. This was long, silly, boring and doesn't leave me inclined to read anything by Andrews again anytime soon.

Was this review helpful?

Another great book by MKA!!!

Letty is on the run from NY with her 4 year old niece. Her sister has been killed and she needs to hide until it all can be figured out. Her sister was involved with some pretty shady characters.

Letty ends up at a motel and is given shelter and a job by Ava. Ava’s son Joe is a cop and finds out that she is wanted for murdrer. Hey realized that Letty is not capable of that and works with her to figure it all out.

After some scary situations, Letty and Joe are married and Letty buys the motel from Ava.

I found the pacing of this book to be very good. Very vivid descriptions of the scenery . My one complaint would be of the portrayal of WV as I am from there.

Was this review helpful?

*ARC kindly provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Part chick-lit and part mystery this is the perfect book to toss in your beach bag next summer.
The characters are all really interesting and most are very engaging.
Overall entertaining novel.

Was this review helpful?