Cover Image: Where It All Lands

Where It All Lands

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Remember that movie called Sliding Doors with Gwyneth Paltrow? This young adult novel reminds me of that flick — where there are dual universes in which life, love and heartbreak can unfold.

Stevie Rosenstein is always the new girl thanks to her father’s job as a pro football coach. While she has usually will find a friend anywhere she goes, the friendship always fizzles out after she moves. And love? Forget about it.

So when Stevie meets best friends Drew and Shane, she feels like she’s found a new friend, and a new love. But a simple coin toss changes the course of their year in profound and unexpected ways.

While I enjoyed reading this book, I just didn’t love it. The concept is cool, but it felt like a lot, especially half-way through.

Thank you to Net Galley and Wednesday Books for providing an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
Was this review helpful?
Full review on good reads. Sadly, this one fell short for me. Good premise, but inconsistencies in characters and story line, what seemed to be very inexperienced writing, and poor character development to name a few things.
Was this review helpful?
Such a good read. I was hooked at the beginning and stayed engrossed to the end. The dual timelines weren't intermingled. It was one then the other. The ending(s) smacked me in the gut.
Was this review helpful?
This book’s love triangle had me in knots—in the best way! I loved them all and wanted everyone to get that HEA. If you liked Sliding Doors or Kara McDowell’s “One Way or Another”, you’re sure to enjoy this alternative timeline romance.
Was this review helpful?
Shane and Drew have been best friends since they were little and spend most of their waking hours together. Stevie Is the new girl at school but she is used to it because her father moved them around so much. When Drew and Shane both notice her and want to ask her out they do what they always do when they have a disagreement: they toss a coin. This story is about the choices we make and the how small decisions can change the trajectory of our lives. 

I enjoyed this book. It’s a typical new girl in town where everyone falls in love with her story but the differing storylines and timelines really made it different. The book is told alternating between the three main characters and also between whether the coin flip was heads or tails so you get a lot of different perspectives. 

There are two very different outcomes to each of stories and timelines which was difficult for me to come to terms with. Also Stevie seems to know things in one timeline that she doesn’t in the other which was odd to me. Overall though I would recommend this to my high school students who enjoy a thoughtful romance.
Was this review helpful?
Where it All Lands is akin to a YA “Sliding Doors”. This is a cute trope and the writing is fairly well-done, but basically this is a book about three rich white kids in a love triangle. The reader is told right off the bat that one of the boys in the story dies, but not which one. This is one of the reasons I kept reading this book.
Where it All Lands doesn’t feel repetitive, which is nice. Sometimes in this trope, the “alternate” story can feel like just a reworded version of the original, but the author does a good job of glossing over repeat storylines and focusing more on details that were skipped the first time around. For me, where I struggled was with the characters. 

A quick summary: 
Drew: cool kid, rich kid, super attractive, other kids like him because his dad is a music producer and they’re hoping Drew will hook them up with concert tickets, likes Ray Bradbury and singing. Drew’s parents are splitting up and he is very angry about that. Drew’s mom doesn’t seem to have a job.
Shane: not very cool for reasons not thoroughly explained, rich kid, talented drummer, intelligent. Shane’s dad died a few years ago. Shane’s mom seems to be a teacher.
Stevie: new girl in town, so pretty that she knows it and everyone knows it, rich kid. Her dad is an NFL coach. Her mom doesn’t seem to have a job, but she paints or does some sort of art in her spare time.

In one version of events, “Heads”, Drew “wins” the coin toss and he asks Stevie out and they begin dating right away. Immediately her dad hates him and they sneak around trying to be together. 
In the other version of events, “Tails”, Shane “wins” the coin toss and hangs out with Stevie. They become friends and eventually develop feelings for each other.

Two stories=two endings. While I wasn’t entirely happy with the ending, I felt like the book was overall an ok YA read. I would recommend to students who like this trope and who frequent the Romance section.
Was this review helpful?
I really enjoyed this book, and I found the storytelling really compelling and delightful. The story follows two best friends, Drew and Shane, who flip a coin over Stevie who is the intriguing new girl in town. Stevie's father is an NFL quarterback coach and she harbours a lot of resentment due to having to move around constantly to follow his job. I loved how strongly music played a role in this book, it felt seamless and fluid and I loved seeing how it blended throughout the story to further imbue it with meaning. 

The story is told in alternating points of view on a dual timeline, which really added to how much I loved it. We as readers have an even stronger "outside looking in" perspective than usual, which is at times as heartbreaking as it is hopeful. This book is exactly what I think a lot of us picture when we think of good YA, it's beautifully and elegantly told while never talking down to the reader, always holding space for us to fall more in love with these characters and their stories.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for this ebook in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Was this review helpful?
I gave this YA title to my 14yo daughter to read...she loved it but said it "wrecked" her which I'm guessing is a good thing?  :)   We heard all about it over dinner last night so thank you for the advance ebook.
Was this review helpful?
I received this book in exchange for an honest review for NetGalley. This was a cute YA read - I got through it in a day. While I enjoyed the parallel timelines and the "what-if" explorations, I didn't love the ending - I guess I was expecting it to go a different way and was left a little puzzled. I did love all the characters - while they were each flawed, the beauty of being young is that it's easier for me to forgive any mistakes the characters make as growing opportunities. This is a solid recommendation for YA fans.
Was this review helpful?
This good was a great read!  I very much enjoy stories that show alternate timelines, and the author here executed on that beautifully.

This tells the story of Drew and Shane who have been best friends since they were little and have seen each other through many difficult times, including the death of Shane's dad and Drew's father leaving their family.  When Stevie Rosenstein moves to town, Drew and Shane are both immediately drawn to her.  They decide to flip a coin, their usual means for resolving disputes when they arise, to decide who will ask her out.  And the books tells the story of what happens with both outcomes.

All three of the main characters are compelling, and the author does an excellent job of letting us see different perspectives on them and their choices through the two timelines.  

Highly recommended!
Was this review helpful?
I was intrigued by the parallel storyline and following how one small change could drastically alter someone’s life. I truly enjoyed following along in both scenarios and seeing the course of the three main characters lives play out. I was hoping for more of a concrete ending -  a “what’s meant to be, will be” situation but overall am very happy with this book.
Was this review helpful?
I really enjoyed this book but the one thing I did not enjoy was the end since we do not get to know where the coin really landed. I was skeptical about the two timelines scared it would make the book feel repetitive but that was not the case and I enjoyed shanes timeline even more than drew's but overall I liked this book a lot!
Was this review helpful?
Heart-wrenching in a good way, 'Where It All Lands' follows Drew, Shane, and Stevie through both potential results of the coin toss used to determine who would get to ask out the new girl. Thankfully, the majority of this book follows one of the boys' coin toss win, and then the other boys' coin toss win; it is only in the ending chapters where the 2 alternative time lines are spliced together, revealing a little at a time and switching back and forth quite often. Recommended to anyone who enjoys exploring what-if's and alternative time lines.
Was this review helpful?
I enjoy YA novels as a break from some of the heavier genres that I mostly read. The easy dialogue, the intense emotions, the overall lightness provides a welcome respite. This novel, however, fell short. The idea was unique; I liked the switch in perspectives halfway through the novel but the friendships and the interactions seemed too contrived and over the top. For example, an insecure new girl wouldn’t so quickly lock onto a guy and alienate female friends in the process.
Was this review helpful?
This was heartbreakingly beautiful. I loved the way it was told in alternating timelines, giving us a really nice full picture of the story that was happening. All three main characters have different relationships with their fathers, making that something they can bond about. I loved Shane, I wanted to hug Drew and Stevie grew to be an amazing young woman she develops into. I hate that Shane has such sad outcomes in both storylines. I did love this book so much and I do believe that Stevie and Shane belong together. I absolutely loved the Jewish rep and Stevie's internal monologue about wearing her star of david.
Was this review helpful?
Beautifully written novel where three characters are intertwined in each other's lives after meeting.   The novel is told from the different character's perspectives that reveals the story behind what is going on.  Stevie moves into town and has to start life over.  She gains new friends and has to determine if they are friends with her because they like her or they want something from her.    She finds two new friends, Drew and Shane.  She soon discovers their motives for being her friend.  The trials and angst a teenager goes through is compounded by so many different elements throughout the story.
Was this review helpful?
This one stunned me! A YA romance that begins with two best friends flipping a coin to see which one is allowed to ask out the cool new girl, Stevie, who has just come to town. The characters are all likable and have realistic insecurities that make your heart go out to them. Without giving too much away, this book has a unique narrative style that explores both sides of the coin and shows how one second or one choice can change everything. I also loved how it showed that there isn’t always one right choice in a situation- sometimes there is more than one way to be happy- and I think that’s a great message for teen readers. And the ending.... so perfect.
Was this review helpful?

Well that was utterly moving and heartwarming. What an emotional read. What a journey. In a lot of ways, this felt like a mystery to me, the way these three lives were intertwined and how just a simple coin flip could change the journey. My heart. Oh my heart. 

I truly fell for this trio. 

If you’re a fan of chances and the exploration of the family dynamic in teens, this book is going to score big for you as a reader. 

I thoroughly enjoyed it and recommend it to all YA lovers. It’s a treat! A true gem. 

Thank you netgalley for the advance reader copy.
Was this review helpful?
What a wonderful story. My heart is so full after this novel. I didn't know which way I wanted the coin to land and the end had me begging for more pages. Every teenager who's ever had a best friend or a first love should read this immediately
Was this review helpful?
The premise of this book sounded very interesting with the two best friends flipping a coin about their love life however I found it far-fetched at times and did not love the dual timeline. I can see how teens would like it. I received this novel as an advanced reader copy and exchange for an unbiased review.
Was this review helpful?