Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Calling all fans of The Bachelor and One to Watch! @andimjulie If The Shoe Fits is a delightful, funny, and swoonworthy slow burn romance fairy tale retelling with a contemporary twist! In the wake of her dad's passing, Cindy, a recent fashion school graduate, heads home for the summer to nanny for her young triplet step-siblings while she figures our her next steps. Her step-mom is the executive producer of Before Midnight, the world's biggest dating reality show. When contestants drop out at the last minute, Cindy and her 2 step-sisters take their spots. What better way to showcase her shoe designs by getting national coverage and going on some dates with a handsome bachelor?! As the first plus size contestant on the show, she quickly realizes the spotlight is extra bright and that her feelings for Price Charming may actually be real. I flew through this book, felt all of the feels, and rooted for Cindy the whole time! I loved Cindy's commitment to herself despite public pressure. This is out August 3, so go pre-order your copy today! Thanks to @andimjulie @netgalley and @hyperionave for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Like anyone with a beating heart, I loved the Dumplin' series, devouring each book more quickly than the last. Julie Murphy creates characters that you just want to root for and hug at the same time. After finishing Pumpkin', I knew my next read had to be Murphy's adult romance debut, and "If the Shoe Fits" did not disappoint!

While the classic story of Cinderella and the modern guilty pleasure of The Bachelor are the inspirations for this book, Julie Murphy manages to succeed in making this story unique.

First and foremost, I loved the relationships between women in this book. While there is an "ugly stepsister" character, it is not Cindy's actual stepsisters. In fact Cindy, her stepmother, and two stepsisters, have a pretty good relationship. It's not without complications all together, but they love, care for, and respect one another. Murphy realistically portrays what the dynamic would be for Cindy, who has lost both parents and has only her step family (and much younger half sibling triplets) for family now. This was a refreshing take on the classic fairy tale.

I also loved the fat representation in this book. Cindy is comfortable in her skin, but is of course nervous about the reaction she will get on the show. I love that there are acknowledgements of this very real internal struggle while at the same time, the book is not all about her weight. She's just another girl on the show, and (most) of the women treat her as tough competition (which, spoiler alert, she definitely is) but also as a friend. The friendships she makes on the show, both with other contestants and her producers, were almost more interesting to me than the core relationship.

Finally, I loved that Cindy had a unique skill and big dreams. Her shoe designs were fun and quirky and sexy and I wish I could buy a pair of Cindy originals for myself.

My only complaint with this book was I was hoping there would be chapters from Henry's point of view. I just didn't feel like we knew him the way we knew Cindy, and I wanted to look at the situation through his eyes. Of course that would have spoiled several twists and turns but I ended up feeling less invested in the core relationship than I normally am when reading a romance.

Overall, this is a delightful, breezy, cute romance that gives a modern twist on a classic story. I also would like to start a petition for Before Midnight to become an actual show please.

Was this review helpful?

I loved everything about this book! The characters and the love that binds everyone, be it friendship or family, made for a wonderful ending.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Disney-Hyperion (Disney Books) and Netgalley for providing me with an early copy in exchange for my honest review.

I'm a sucker for a fairy tale retelling so I couldn't wait for the chance to read If the Shoe Fits, a retelling of Cinderella. Much like Cinderella, our heroine Cindy is an orphan but she has a good relationship with her stepmother and step-siblings. After she graduates from fashion school, Cindy returns to L.A. to be a nanny for her half siblings while she figures out her next step in life. Her stepmother is the producer for Before Midnight, a reality dating show (think The Bachelor). When a contestant backs out at the last minute, Cindy decides to join the show. It isn't like she'll actually find love on a dating show...right?

I've been an on-off viewer of The Bachelor/ette shows for years. Even when I don't watch I follow recaps so I loved seeing the Bachelor elements that were infused within the story. If the Shoe Fits very much fulfills the fairy tale retelling of Cinderella so you know exactly what you're going to get. It is a closed door romance so although there are no steamy scenes Cindy and the suitor have great chemistry together. The end of the book leaves it open for further stories within the Before Midnight universe and I'm here for it. I also liked the body positive messages within the story.

If the Shoe Fits is perfect for readers who love fairy tale retelling, enjoyed reading One to Watch by Kate Stayman-London and is a fan of Julie Murphy's previous works. If the Shoe Fits is available August 3rd, 2021.

Was this review helpful?

I love this so much. Julie Murphy has officially conquered all the age ranges, she's a triple threat baby! I adored Cindy as a character and the plot was fantastic, I love the fat girl on a reality show plot so much (see: One to Watch - another amazing book and a great comp title for this!). Henry was a fab love interest and I especially loved how, despite this being a reimagining of Cinderella, the stepmother and stepsisters were so nice! They had good relationships! That made me so happy.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of those books that just sucks you in and you can't put down. It's a great retake on Disney's version of Cinderella including young triplet siblings named Gus, Mary, and Jack. I loved picking up on all the nods to the movie throughout the book while completely appreciating the story Julie Murphy was telling herself. I will let own voices reviewers comment on the representation that is in this book and how well it was done, but for me it worked well.

Was this review helpful?

I'm not usually a fan of the reality show set up in romances, but I do love a Cinderella re-telling. I also love to read stories of heroines who look like me. If the Shoe Fits starts off in surprising ways, like with Cindy having a wonderful relationship with her stepmother and stepsisters, and with how she ends up on the show in the first place (which seemed pretty unrealistic to me).

Overall, I really enjoyed the story. It was less of a direct re-telling of the Cinderella story and more a series of allusions to Cinderella, but I think that was for the better. I really enjoyed meeting the other women on the show and wished we had seen more interaction with Henry - both with the other women and with Cindy. I also thought Cindy's size was handled well. It was part of the story, but never used in a super malicious way like in other books.

It's difficult to read this book without thinking of One to Watch by Kate Stayman-London. I have to admit that I didn't love One to Watch as much as I had wanted to, so I was a little skeptical coming into If the Shoe Fits. However, I really enjoyed this book and am glad I gave it a chance. It's a nice, easy read for a quiet weekend.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great book, that fans of the reality TV show The Bachelor would enjoy. It was like reading the show instead of watching it and learning about how things really play out. Reality?!

The characters were well defined which helped me stay focused on the plot and not get side tracked trying to remember who did what. The plot had me hooked from the beginning. With the title and cover I knew it was going to be like a Cinderella meets Prince Charming kind of story with step sisters getting in the way but I liked that these step sisters were good and not evil.

There was just the right amount of suspense to keep me up late at night wanting to know what was going to happen next.

I would recommend this book to upper high school students, college students and adults who are fans of romance.

Was this review helpful?

I know this is billed as an adult book, but YA will love this as well. A mix of "UnREAL" and "Bachelor" with a strong fat woman as the lead, including a lot of humor and fashion. There's even a meet cute! Based on the Cinderella story, Murphy upends things by making Cindy actually friends with her stepsisters and a loved part of the family. That blend of familiar and twist made this a great summer read.

eARC provided by publisher via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

Well, this was an absolute delight to read.

If the Shoe Fits is a modernized Cinderella retelling that merges a fairy tale romance and a reality dating show perfectly to have the whirl wind and whimsy you'd expect, along with the drama and sexual tension you want. I love how Julie Murphy brought this story to life - giving a fat girl the chance to shine and find her prince charming, building a supportive and caring family around Cindy (who needs shrewd or cruel step family, when you can have a full cast of characters you genuinely enjoy), and the humor and personality in the dating show and the other contestants was fantastic. This story kept me completely entertained and I could not put it down - which is probably why I finished it in one sitting. If the Show Fits is a fast-paced, fashion-filled romp you won't want to miss.

I received an advanced copy of the book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Disney Publishing Worldwide Disney-Hyperion for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Cinderella meets the Bachelor!! SOLD.

This is a Cinderella retelling BUT AS A DATING SHOW. This was not your traditional retelling it was 100% orignal. I loved everything about this book. I loved that the main character was plus-sized. I am so excited that this is releasing on August 3rd in the summertime because this is the perfect summer rom-com read.

If you love reality TV then you will love this book. If you love subtle retellings then you will love this book. If you love a character who loves themselves and is unapologetically themselves then you will love this book. If you love rom-coms then you will love this book.

I want to avoid spoilers and I will not be adding many details about the story here.
I need the physical copy of this book on my shelf ASAP.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Disney-Hyperion for giving me an eARC copy of this book!

First of all, I *very* much appreciated reading about a plus-sized lead, ESPECIALLY in a traditionally published book with a company like Disney. So, that instantly elevated this book for me.

But even beyond the content, the book is well crafted and sucks you in immediately. I could not put this book down, and I ended up reading it within two sittings. I enjoyed the Cinderella retelling, drawing on the classic tale, but the author brought a ton of originality to the work as well.

I'm sooo excited to see what else Julie Murphy does in the future, and I'll definitely be following along with her career!

Was this review helpful?

Perfect summer read! Just perfect!
I loved this book from the beginning and I wasn't able to put it down, I've literally read it in one stand.
Julie Murphy definitely succeeded in creating an intriguing and funny story, with good and relatable characters.
If the Shoe Fits is "plus-size Cinderella-meets-The Bachelor-at Project Runway...and if you even liked just one of these shows, I promise you, you won't regret reading this book!

Was this review helpful?

Very fun and cute! I always love seeing plus-sized characters find love. As a plus-sized woman myself I think these stories are important!

Was this review helpful?

Omg, I could not stop reading this book. Fashion, true love, family, Hollywood glamor, reality TV, and a classic-with-a-twist Cinderella story. It is a delicious read.

We meet Cindy, a recent Parsons graduate who finds herself jobless after graduation because she pretty much broke down after her father's death. She ends up moving to California to live with her stepmother, two stepsisters, and the triplets. Now hold on, because you don't know where this is going. Cindy actually gets along really well with her stepsisters and is planning to nanny for her triplet step-siblings. Her stepmother, Erika, is pretty nice, too, and she happens to be the producer for a popular reality bachelor tv show, Before Midnight.

When her stepmom gets in a bind, Cindy and her stepsisters agree to be on Before Midnight which is how Cindy finds herself the first, and only, plus size contestant. We get to see a little of the "behind the scenes" of the reality show, as well as Cindy navigates through unchartered waters using the force of her personality and her love of fashion.

I appreciated how deftly Julie Murphy dealt with size and gender issues. Well, really, how she normalized these topics.

I cannot wait to recommend this to EVERYONE!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this softly romantic, modern retelling of Cinderella. I've never read a romance title where I identified so well with the main character! Cindy felt real in the way that so few romance heroines do - she talks about the ways that fashion industries exclude larger sizes from the elite fashion world, how body size is a part of who you are but you not only "Fat", and that finding love isn't always a fairy tale. What this romance lacks in steaminess it more than makes up for in humor, strong wit, and enjoyable characters. If you're looking for a perfect, feel-good, no strings attached read, than grab this book with both hands and don't let go!

Was this review helpful?

I feel like there are several disclaimers that I need to make before giving my opinions on this book. I do not typically read romance books. The only reason that I read this novel is because Julie Murphy’s writing is an absolute pleasure to read. The other disclaimer is that I have not nor do I think I will ever watch shows like The Bachelor or any of those other dating reality shows.

With that being said...this book was heavenly to read! I love how fleshed-out each of the characters are and the way they interacted in the story. I was also a big fan of the behind-the-scenes components of the reality show. Whether or not these things actually occur...I was still intrigued.

The romance part of it was definitely cute but (if I’m being honest) that’s not really what kept me interested in the story. This is a Cinderella retelling so we pretty much know how it all plays out. I’m not a big fan of romance novels anyway and I can say that this was done is a really great way. It was a central part of the story without being vomit-inducing over-the-top cheese.

I think this idea of Disney retellings for adults could work if it’s marketed correctly. However, I didn’t know this novel was intended for adults until looking into it a little more. The cover screams YA.

Overall, I can’t wait to see what the next retelling will be and, as always, I can’t wait for Julie Murphy’s next novel.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful Cinderella retelling featuring a plus sized shoe designer and a Bachelor spin. Cindy, a recent graduate from a design school, got an unexpected opportunity to join Before Midnight (Bachelor-esque show), and decided to take it for the opportunity to get some money and exposure to jump start her career, as a shoe designer. I loved the modern take on the retelling that included a supportive step family. There was so much drama in this book and I couldn’t put it down. I read it in one sitting and wish it never ended. The ending did feel a little abrupt and I wouldn’t have minded an extra 50ish pages. Amazing loved it would recommend to everyone!

I received this ARC from NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Are you looking for a grown-up re-imagining of Cinderella, complete with The Bachelor-inspired plot and shoe design? This is the book for you! Julie Murphy is a great writer, and this new work by her doesn't disappoint. There's a memorable and driven heroine, a diverse cast of characters, and a fated love story to boot.

I've read many fairy tale retellings, and this was a very good one. It had all the important tropes, but it also made the story just a lot more fun: the stepsisters are influencers, but they aren't evil. The stepmother works in reality television and is driven but genuinely cares for the Cinderella character. And in the end, the guy is the one putting his foot into a shoe.

This is a story I wouldn't have thought of to match the traditional fairy tale, but I'm so glad Julie Murphy did. Really enjoyed!

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this one! This was a nice spin on Cinderella and I loved the inclusivity! Like this book just made me want to be Julie Murphy's friend. There were a few issues I had though. The romance was insta-love galore even if it was super cute, the central conflict made no sense if you stopped for one second to think about it, we barely know the main love interest, and the ending was entirely too rushed. Despite all that, I really loved the cast of characters. Almost all the girls on the show were likeable and fun and I love the talk about family in the book. The "evil" part of the stepsisters is forgotten for a really adorable bond between Cindy and her stepsisters Drew and Anna.

This book is adult but it does read a lot like a YA. There's even censored cursing which I find a little odd. Overall, if I'm going to read Adult romance I do think personally I like it a bit steamier, as the most we got was a fade to black. There's nothing wrong with that at all, I just wish we had gotten like one step above that.

This book was just like...fun. It was a good time. Structurally and plot wise, there were definitely improvements that could've been made, but overall it was a fun beach read! I really liked Cindy and every time she spoke about her struggles as a plus size person it literally just like struck me in the chest because I've been through all of it. I'm excited for the next books in the series to come out!

Was this review helpful?