
Member Reviews

4 stars
This is a true all-that-and-the-kitchen-sink kind of read, but it WORKS. While Moon is supposed to fall in love with the universe, readers cannot help but fall in love with her.
The titular Moon Fuentez is the m.c. of this expansive novel, and she has experienced well beyond her fair share of struggle in 17 (going on 18) years. Moon's twin, Star, lives up to her name as a Fotogram influencer known for her external beauty but also her effusive piousness. Don't trust that kind of thing? Good call. Right at the start of the novel, Star gets an opportunity to go on tour in this role, and because the twins' mother is rivaling Piper Laurie in the original _Carrie_ for mother of the year, Moon is somewhat relieved to be shipped off with Star as her resident photographer and the tour's merch girl. As savvy readers might expect, this literal journey presents the ideal format for the twins' rite of passage (especially Moon's) from young adulthood into adulthood.
There is so much to love about this novel. Moon is utterly endearing. She has been emotionally abused (among other things - I'll keep this relatively spoiler free) in such a severe manner, and this is apparent in her self-perception and struggle to accept love and care from others. It is both heartbreaking and empowering to watch her work through this. A central component of this journey has to do with Moon's relationship to her body, her sexuality, and her new potential romantic partner. The intertwining of these these themes is another strength for the character and the work overall. The treatments of mental health and suicide are honest if - at times - a bit surface level. An unexpected but beloved quality of the novel is Gilliland's use of magical realism and the supernatural. Moon is a true Earth Mother and master of nature, and the archetypal juxtaposition between this constant affirmation and others' interpretations of her behavior is powerful and relatable.
Because there are so many issues and plotlines flowing at all times, there are some areas that rely too heavily on convenient clean-ups and coincidences and others where I'd have loved to see more explanation and closure. That noted, I love this character and am fascinated by this world. I'm eager to read more from Gilliland and to recommend this work to students for years to come.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC!! Oh my god. 5/5 stars. Everyone, oh my god. THIS BOOK. It's beautiful. The cover? Beautiful. Moon and Santiago? Beautiful. Depictions of mental illness? Beautiful. Depictions of influencers? Amazing. Depictions of fat culture? My heart.
Seriously, I picked this up as an ARC because of the cover and the synopsis. I couldn't put it down. Moon is SUCH a relatable protagonist and the writing and style and easy to read and get into. I do think there needs to be TWs for abusive family relationships, toxicity, and purity/religious culture along with body image. I was expecting a fun, light read and while I got it....this book also delves into the result of purity culture and religion on people along with the influencer life style.
I also LOVED the ancestral latinx influence in this with nature and magic. It was a beautiful addition and made SO much sense with Moon's journey.
The portions with Santiago (okay, the whole book) just made my heart full, warm, and fuzzy. I want a man like that...and can a man cook for me like that? I absolutely need more of Moon and Santiago's journey.
Pick this book up. You won't be disappointed. It was SOOOO good. It made me laugh, cry, squeal, etc.

Moon Fuentez is an absolutely beautiful book and character. This was a nearly perfect read for me. Moon is hilarious, heartbreaking, and so relatable, even though her life might not seem like it at first glance. The exploration of all different kinds of relationships, from family to friends to romance to the relationship you have with yourself was *chef's kiss*. Gilliland's writing is superb and I know this is a book I'll reread again and again. I ordered multiple copies for my library and I can't wait until it's released so I can push it on everyone I know.

There are some books -- and they're almost never the same books for everybody -- that just reach into your heart and touch some leftover broken part of yourself that you didn't realize you were holding onto. Characters that feel so real to you, you wonder if their lives on the page are some reflection of an alternate universe version of yourself. Moon Fuentes was that kind of magic for me. I didn't always like her; there were choices she made, things she said, that my adult self disapproved of. But the adolescent me, she felt totally seen here.
Favorite parts:
- Moon's photography. I had never really thought about earth art as a media form in and of itself, and now I want the Moonflower Tarot IMMEDIATELY.
- The relationship between Star and Moon. I don't think Star was a nice person, and I don't think we got to see enough of her own complexity, but I still love that even though they kept hurting each other, in the end, they thought of each other as a vital part of their constellations.
- The romance with Santiago. Wooooooowee.
I wish we'd gotten to see more of some of the side characters, especially Belle and Tia. And I wish I had known going in how intense the emotional abuse would be. But it really is a beautiful book, and I am so grateful I had the chance to read it.

Beautiful, but..... mid-book all that talking about sex annoyed me.
And that's really a pity because the story is beautiful, intricated, it glues you to the pages.
Moon's character is simply wonderful, all characters are.
The focus on sex wasn't that necessary, in my opinion...It takes it away from all the wonderful things that are happening: Moon's growth, Star's secrets, Santiago opening up...
I give this book 4 stars because it's beautifully written.

This book is devastatingly beautiful in its prose and execution and I absolutely loved Moon.
The story touches on so many relevant things like art, religion, forgiveness, consent and it’s all wrapped up in poetic language. This is so much more than a romance and really is a story of Moon’s self discovery and coming of age.
I know that there are girls out there who will relate to Moon and I hope that her story gives them confidence too.
The aspect of the story that felt least believable to me was the relationship at the end with the twins. There was so much trauma that they each and collectively experienced, and it felt like a bit of a jump for them to seem that connected to each other.

I really loved Moon and how much she grew throughout this story and really became herself. It can be so hard to see the good in yourself with others around you exuberate and gain more attention. I was glad to see Moon find her path and really see herself as more than just the ugly wallflower sister.
A really beautiful book!
Thank you NetGalley for this ARC!

Goodreads review:
Thank you to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing for an ARC of this book!
Moon Fuentez is easily one of the most likeable protagonists I have ever had the joy of reading about. She was never perfect, which made me like her even more. We see her insecurities and emotional scars interspersed with her passions.
And don't even get me started on Santiago and how much I adored every detail of his character development.
This book has been described by other reviewers as beautiful, and that is the absolute perfect word for it. The imagery, character development and relationships readers peer into are all simply beautiful.
I highly recommend How Moon Fuentez Fell in Love with the Universe for young adult readers and new adult readers alike. I believe this book would make an excellent addition to any fiction collection developed for a young adult audience.

3.5⭐️/5 rounded up to 4!
I first want to point out how scarily on the nose Moon’s life is to my own––I’m Latina, I have a twin sister, my mom was abusive, and my dad committed suicide… like WHAT.
I ended up reading this aloud with my twin sister. Here are three things we liked and three things we did not.
We really liked Moon’s humor. She had some good quips and (even though it was a self-defense mechanism) comebacks for her sister. The banter between her and Santiago, when he wasn’t grunting, was really fun to read too. I busted out laughing when she told him his bra size was triple F.
The conclusion of this novel was refreshing. A lot of young adult novels with bad or abusive parents feature redemption arcs for these shitty parents or even some sort of final reconciliation between the protagonist and their parent(s). I REALLY liked that this did not happen. Love is thicker than blood as this novel so beautifully shows.
We also really enjoyed the flashback scenes between Moon and her father.
Because I am a twin, I have to mention that this twin relationship was horrible. I know not everyone gets along with their siblings, but I personally think this felt like a relationship between a sister and another sister who are not twins. I felt this way especially when Star made fun of Moon’s fear of bridges (and just about every other time Star was mean to Moon tbh.) I hope this makes sense, but the relationship I have with my twin is so different from the relationship I have with my other sisters, and Moon and Star’s relationship resembled the kind of bond (or lack thereof in comparison I guess) that I have with my twin.
We both agreed that Santiago felt more like a silhouette of a person rather than an actual person. I think part of this is because he is so reserved that his personality isn’t really shown a lot. The other part might be that most of what makes him a person is his body because so much of Moon’s perception of him is by way of his muscles, height, etc.
This is also a really long book lol. I felt some scenes didn’t really add much (Moon’s date with the boy from the library, for example.)

If I could use one word to describe Moon it would be irreverent, which makes for some hilarious scenes since her twin sister, Star, is a hyper religious purity influencer on social media. I love Moon’s character because she is someone who you just really want to succeed throughout the book as she comes to realize that she has been emotionally and physically abused her entire life. Her view of herself and her body has been tainted by that abuse, and she transforms into a young woman her knows her beauty and worth. I also really enjoyed the romantic relationship between Moon and Santiago and the discussions about his disability as an amputee.

This book is OUTSTANDING. The characterizations are top notch, and it is such a complex, multi-layered novel in the guise of a YA love story. It is LGBTQIA+, Latinx, and contains sex and body positivity, mental health, abuse among others-- all very important topics that teens (and the not-so-teens) need. Will definitely have this in our collection. Easily 5 stars.

This book covers so much. Let me just make a quick list!
*self-worth
*body shaming
*religion/purity culture
*disability
*mental health
*toxic families (mental and physical abuse)
*bullying
*suicide
*Mexican culture
*acceptance
*self-love
These characters have depth in a way that I did not expect. I really started this book anticipating typical enemies to lovers YA romance and I go SO MUCH MORE than that. This book is beautiful. The descriptions of Moon's art, the background with her Aunt (Tía), and the emphasis on nature and the cultural aspects that tied into it. Amazing. Each of the characters, even the one that I grew to seriously dislike, were stunningly REAL in a way that is hard to accomplish through words alone.
This is not just a romance, this is Moon's journey to becoming comfortable in her own skin, accepting that she and her art are worthy, and learning to set boundaries with everyone in her life--especially family--for her own sake.

*Review will be posted on my blog on 7/29/21*
Likes:
*I am in LOVE with this book. Where do I begin? First the title intrigued me, and the character’s name being Moon. Because I love all moon things. Then the cover with a curvy girl, the moon above her and all that pink and purple tones. That’s where my love for it starts – but then the story takes me on an emotional journey and that’s when I fell hard.
*Moon Fuentez is so relatable. She’s an artist and calls to the artist in me. I want to follow her Fotogram account, I want to buy her tarot cards, I wanted to know this girl and we definitely get to know her in this story. Her twin is Star Fuentez and her opposite from their body size and beliefs about lifestyle. Moon honors the old ways, honoring the Earth, delving in the mystical – and Star is a religious model (I didn’t even know those existed!). Moon has a lot of family secrets that are revealed little by little as she gets to know Santiago, a boy on the tour. I love how Moon grows on this tour. She’s there to basically be her sister’s assistant but she learns that she has a light around her too and embraces it in the end.
*Speaking of Moon and Santiago – theirs is an enemies to lovers romance which so much spark. They are enemies, then sort of friends, which was fun to watch because Santiago really is such a grump and likes to anger Moon haha, and Moon makes him laugh. I mean, Santiago already had me with his kitchen skills. They are the cutest couple.
*This story takes sensitive issues that Moon is dealing with and weaves them into the mystical and natural fabric of our world and universe. I thought it was beautifully done. I felt embraced in Moon’s experiences with La Raiz. I love how Moon learned divination with her Tia, the only person who has shown her real love (besides her dad). It’s a heartbreaking story at its core, a girl just wanting the love of a parent. But Moon is strong in the end to make decisions that are healthier for her heart, soul and mind, even if it hurts a lot.
Random Notes:
Triggers: suicide, child abuse, depression
*This story is sex positive but Moon struggles with her mom’s views on sex and body image. It reminded me of my own Catholic upbringing but obviously Moon’s mom took it to the next level by slut shaming her, blaming her – her own child, for how miserable she felt inside. Her mother needed help and never got it but it conditioned Star and Moon from childhood that sex was an evil act. Moon has other people in her life explain to her why it wasn’t how her mom portrayed it to be, which is great.
*Depression is mentioned because some characters in the book go through it. Moon has her own coping mechanisms, ones that she realizes she has to work through.
Final Thoughts:
Is Moon Fuentez real? Because I want her to be – I want to buy her beautiful tarot cards and pick flowers with her. I want to check out her artwork in a museum, I want to see the images she captured on her beloved camera. I fell in love with Moon and Moon with Santiago and this whole story about nature’s magic, how even in this amazing, big universe, we are all connected, even in our pain. This is a book I connected with wholeheartedly, it really touched my heart, and I can’t wait to have it in my hands as a physical book.

Ugh, I loved this. I related to Moon's story and journey so much and really felt connected to her and her relationships to her family and friends. If you like character driven stories about journeys and self-love, pick this up.
Thank you for the e-arc.