Cover Image: The Girls from Alexandria

The Girls from Alexandria

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Set in Alexandria, this is a dual-timeline book written about Nadia and her sister, Simone, as young girls and close sisters, and also decades later. Nadia is in a hospital and she doesn't know why except she does find she forgets words and situations and has dizzy spells causing her to fall. Her medical team is frustratingly very vague with her about her condition and her muddled forgetfulness sadly doesn't help. However, she has memories of her sister, some sharp, some hazy. Nadia knows Simone went missing ages ago also has postcards signed "S" but nurses don't believe she has a sister.

I like that we see snippets of lucidity and memories and I'm a fan of different timelines in books. The stories about the sisters (and other characters) are interesting. The innocence of children! The mystery element is good. Though not intended to be an an action-packed story, it is a bit slow in spots, sort of rambly. A few bits don't seem to blend in or add. Egypt history and culture are fascinating to read about. The premise of the story is brilliant yet I didn't connect as much as I had hoped to. It was engaging but sort of at arm's length.

However, if you would like to read a book with an interesting plot, knowing it's somewhat slow here and there, do pick this up. I understand how many readers would love it, especially those of Literary Fiction.

My sincere thank you to Agora Books and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this interesting book in exchange for an honest review. Much appreciated.

Was this review helpful?

Another quick advanced read thanks to Netgalley. While I enjoyed the characters and tale itself, I personally felt that it could have been pared way down to a novella or short story. I didn’t feel that there was much action or plot/climax. The ending rather drags on and, even after the truth about Simone comes out, I didn’t feel like I had closure as to her whereabouts or why she never returned to Egypt or attempted to find Nadia (as the wife of a prominent doctor it wouldn’t have been difficult). I felt that Nadia’s character deserved better than she got.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advance copy of, The Girls from Alexandria, by Carol Cooper. I really enjoyed this book. Most book out now are very cookie cutter, this is different. This book goes back and forth from childhood to present day. The characters are well drawn out.

Was this review helpful?

I was drawn by the stunning cover and premise of this novel but ultimately the book didn’t work for me. I found it overwritten, lacklustre and bleak.
There’s two narratives: in the present day we follow 70-year old Nadia who’s in an old person’s home and despite her forgetfulness determined to find Simone, who sister who went missing years ago; in the past narrative we follow a young, adolescent Nadia in her homeland, Alexandria, Egypt, where Simone went missing.
I found the writing style overly descriptive and flowery; there’s too much telling (explaining the Egyptian Muslim culture) rather than showing, and it felt like I was being lectured than reading a novel with plot. While evocative of place the author’s writing style just didn’t work for me and failed to hook me.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book. It is an interesting story about family and mystery. It is figuratively beautiful in context. I highly recommend reading it.

Was this review helpful?