Cover Image: Nobody, Somebody, Anybody

Nobody, Somebody, Anybody

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Amy Hanley wants nobody, somebody, anybody to notice her! Working at a local yacht club as a chambermaid for the summer, Amy is counting down the weeks until she can take her EMT certification test. Amy is an isolated young woman, who has difficulty controlling her emotions in certain situations, occasionally leading to dangerous and disasters interactions with others. She hopes that following her true calling as an EMT will help shape her life for the better. Having failed the test twice before, Amy decides to give herself a placebo; a specialized plan that she hopes will not only boost her confidence, but will help pass her test and follow in the footsteps of her idol Florence Nightingale.

Even though this book is written from the point of view of a woman who has some anxiety and obsessive tendencies, I found this book to be calming. Author Kelly McClorey is an excellent writer. McClorey was able to expertly convey Amy's neurosis so that as a reader we could understand the stress and anxiety the character was feeling, but those same feelings weren't thrust upon us as the reader. I wasn't getting stressed and anxious reading about someone who was stressed and anxious, and I appreciated that about this book a lot. I found Amy to be a very three dimensional and well constructed character. I found myself rooting for her to succeed just as strongly as I was rooting for her to get help with her struggles. I was happy when she made friends with her landlord Gary, helping him to prepare for his Ukrainian fiancé's arrival; and I felt equally disturbed to read what had happened with between she and her college roommate that lead to her being expelled from the school. McClorey created a very multifaceted character who was entertaining and thought provoking to follow.

I also thought "Nobody, Somebody, Anybody" structurally flowed very well. Its an extremely well researched book. There is a lot of medical jargon and historical facts throughout the plot, but it never feels bogged down by detail or like you are reading a text book. It's executed very well and not only makes Amy's situation more realistic for herself, but for the reader as well.

Overall, I enjoyed "Nobody, Somebody, Anybody" and I would recommend it for readers who are looking to for a character driven book that has heart, drama and vulnerability. I want to thank Ecco and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

This read very existentialist.

This was probably one of the strangest books I've ever read. I feel like I still don't know the plot or is that the point? It's clear the main character has mental health issues and an obsessive personality. I had a hard time getting through his book. It was a struggle to finish. The writing itself is great but the actually storyline was just strange and had no clear plot. She's clearly delusional and just wants attention but then also isolates herself from her family? I was kind of confused throughout the book in general about the plot, main character's adventure, purpose of the book, etc? I finished it and I'm not sure what I was supposed to get out of it.

Was this review helpful?

Kelly McClorey’s Nobody, Somebody, Anybody is an unsettling read: not because it has any particularly graphic scenes, but because McClorey’s writing is almost visceral. Amy Harney’s inner turmoil, grief, and delusion spill over every page. I felt second-hand shame, loneliness, and anxiety because of Amy’s behaviour, and found myself checking and re-checking the way I made my bed, cleaned dishes, washed my hands. There isn’t a dramatic plot to follow; instead, McClorey drops subtle reveals throughout that better explain why Amy thinks and acts the way she does, and at the end, there is no closure.

Though this book is marketed as a humourous jaunt, likely because of its light-hearted, broken main character — I didn’t find it funny. Not laugh-out-loud funny, anyway; if it’s “funny”, it’s funny in the same way ‘dark humour as a coping mechanism’ is funny. I don’t think this book is for everyone — it certainly isn’t for me, hence the low review — but for those who enjoy an unlikable character, this is a good read. I’d also recommend this to fans of Otessa Moshfegh and Jenny Zhang; and if you appreciated Gail Honeyman’s Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine, this might be up your alley as well.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a great reminder that literary fiction can be crowd-pleasing. I really liked this book. The narrator was unique, the specificity of her voice was really incredible and pleasing. I loved this book. Thank you for the review copy!

Was this review helpful?

An intriguing look at mental illness and how it impacts the life of a young woman. Amy works as a chambermaid and describes herself as a “Lady of the Trash.” This is prescient of her story where she destroys relationships that she so heart wrenchingly needs. She tries to use various psychological notions to change her life—most notably the placebo effect, creating a placebo for passing her EMT exam. This disappointing effort includes false certifications, uniforms and announcement to her family that she is an EMT. But just as the reader thinks she may succeed, she gets entangled in a relationship with her landlord and skips the real EMT exam. And thus the story proceeds. Spurred onward by the words of Florence Nightingale, we see her meandering and self-destructive path, moving forward in her life with recollections of her past.

The title tells the plot. At first she has nobody, then she has somebody (the landlord), and then she’ll take anybody (woman on the cruise ship). Searching for connection, I hope she finds somebody, anybody to care. I loved the interplay of psychology, EMT, Florence Nightingale and neurosis. A complicated look at one struggling soul. As Amy says, “still, not every obecalp can be successful, and not every prayer can be answered.” The story is one of desire, psychology and prayer unfulfilled.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced reader copy (ARC) of Nobody, Somebody, Anybody from NetGalley. It it set to release in July. It was my one meh read for this month.

This novel is about an anxious young woman who administers a “placebo” treatment to herself in a last-ditch effort to rebuild her life. In the end she doesn’t move forward much at all and I’m not sure if she has learned or received the help she needs in order to move her life forward. I ended up not caring a whole lot about Amy or her “placebo” treatment as she continued to make terrible choices and spiral out of control.

This novel attempts to explore a young women’s inner world of grief, delusion and self-loathing but doesn’t quite hit the mark.

Was this review helpful?

Amy Harney is desperately and profoundly lonely and lost.

Following a nervous breakdown after her mother's death, Amy leaves college, leaves her family, and begins working as a chambermaid (she prefers the connotation of chambermaid vs. housekeeper) where she spends her time cleaning up after wealthy guests. Not that she minds or that it's her end game. Amy wants to be an EMT. The problem is, no matter how hard she studies she just can't seem to pass the exam. To remedy her crippling exam anxiety, Amy decides to treat herself in a placebo-type program of her own making.

In truth, I'm still gathering my thoughts on this one so forgive me as I ramble about. Amy's deep sadness and loneliness and her desperate, slipping grip on her dreams and her life made my heart hurt for her. She seemed like someone who is always looking to something (her EMT dream) or someone (her landlord Gary) to fix her or make her whole. Like if she could just *get it* that she would finally really be living and be happy. Nobody, Somebody, Anybody is a wonderful, beautiful, nuanced character study, and even after finishing the book, I find myself thinking of Amy and wondering if she will ever be happy and okay.

If you read A Year of Rest and Relaxation and were among the reviewers who said that it was a book where not much happened, this won't be for you. At the heart of this novel is Amy, and her quest for nobody, somebody, anybody to see her.

Was this review helpful?

Nobody Somebody Anybody begins with Amy, who is working as a maid while studying to be an EMT. Amy is desperately lonely and has a checkered past she is trying to move on from. In her last-ditch effort for her EMT exam, she devises a Placebo to help her get over her nerves and achieve -what she sees- as her life’s goal.

Tonally I would compare this novel to works by Ottessa Moshfegh, and Amy reminded me of Keiko from Convenience Store Woman by Sayaka Murata. At times Amy’s determination felt one-dimensional, and the references to Florence Nightingale began to feel forced as the novel went on. From the description I expected a slightly darker story, but the story unfolded into a journey of self discovery. I think the ending wrapped up the story very nicely, and I would definitely recommend this book to others who like a nice character-driven story.

Was this review helpful?

This novel caught my eye because the narrator, Amy, seemed like broke Ottessa Moshfegh character. Strong start, I know.

Amy lives in Boston and works as a housekeeper for a yacht club while trying to pass the EMT exam. But after failing the final part of the test twice, she embarks on a self-administered placebo regimen to try and pass a final time.

Despite the straight forward premise, McClorey dives deep into the insidious power of anxiety and how it impacts our most basic need to connect. Amy is both relatable and utterly alien in her self-deception. The lengths to which she goes to try and manifest passing the exam are both creative and heartbreaking.

McClorey also nails the loneliness of being in a town without connections. With Amy’s father on the other side of the country, and her brother in the Peace Corps, she befriends various men as a solve to her loneliness. Each of them offer companionship, but no positive connection, while Amy vilifies the one woman who tries to help her. These relationships mirror Amy’s unresolved trauma; crystalizing her isolation despite her increasing need for help.

But, it’s the book’s romanic ending which actually gave me hope that Amy might still be all right. In the final pages she breaks her previous patterns, hoping for a new outcome. In the end, all she can do is try something new.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this book was a bit like watching a car crash. Amy was a hot mess and there were many times that I struggled to get through this book, especially since I found it hard to find much to like about the main character. She had her occasional moments where she could come across charming and maybe even quirky, but that never seemed to match up with the character that we got to know, especially by delving so deep into her day to day thoughts.

I honestly found the people that she interacted with far more interesting and always looked forward to those moments, especially when she spent time with Gary. However, he ended up being pretty disappointing as well. The ending was also one that didn’t leave me feeling satisfied. I wish we could have gotten a bit more closure on her story and more of a resolution.

The description of this book also mentioned this book being “darkly comic” and “tender and laugh-out-loud funny” but I noticed very few of those things. I once laughed at a story her neighbor told but beyond that, it was more dark and depressing than anything else.

Was this review helpful?

I felt the strength of the writing in each passing sentence but the momentum of the story eluded me. The narrator is consistently marvelous in her observations but the pacing didn’t work for me.

Was this review helpful?

I found this book extremely smart and yet very bleak and hard to handle. I appreciated the main character’s humor, and yet it made me feel as though I was watching a car wreck in real time. The book is masterful and yet painful.

Was this review helpful?

This may be a sign of the times, but I wasn't drawn in by Amy. The settings and characters were perfectly described, I could easily picture all of them as I read. But, something about her story just wasn't compelling.

Was this review helpful?

A modern day Bell Jar. This book is heartbreakingly tender, and I found Amy’s experience to be extremely relatable. I loved this.

Was this review helpful?

Hilarious, enthralling and befuddling - loved every minute of "Nobody, Somebody, Anybody". A read that is so bizarre and interesting I couldn't put it down and cannot wait to read it again.

Similar to two of my 2020 faves that I read - "My Year of Rest and Relaxation" and "Convenience store woman"


Thanks to Netgalley and Ecco for the early ebook!

Was this review helpful?

There have been a lot of books about unconventional or women with mental illnesses in the last decade that I have enjoyed, like Where’d You Go Bernadette. This book tries to follow in a similar genre with our protagonist Amy. Unfortunately, I felt that we were left in the dark for too long about what happened to Amy, and I did not feel as if she had any redemption arc or quest for self improvement that made me want to root for her. Her continually disturbing choices were quite tragic but did not endear her to me as it wasn’t until the last three pages that it seemed like she had any desire to improve her life and even that was out of her control.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting debut novel about Amy Hanley desires to be an EMT but always has difficulty with taking exams despite being a well-read person. As a result, she decided to perform a placebo method on herself, making her and everyone believe she had passed the exam and now is a certified EMT though still working as a chambermaid in the summer, a job offered by her landlord. They eventually got to know each other, with him often asking her opinion on his cooking and relationship advice and things start go downhill from then. Amy's personality is definitely not lovable. She constantly wants to feel needed by everyone to the point that is a bit intrusive and often deludes herself into thinking that everything will be in her favor, that everyone will be forever grateful toward her if she centers her decision on that person she wants to be close to. Of course, things do not work that way but it is understandable if you know her relationship with her mother although some questionable actions of her still make me uncomfortable, not to mention her anger management is also one of the reason that lead to her downfall,
Overall, this is a great read with powerful message. I would definitely recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and Ecco for the early ebook. Amy Harney is a young woman obsessed with Florence Nightingale and sees her life as one for serving others. She’s a chambermaid for the summer, but will soon take an exam to become an EMT. After this sunny start, we find out that life is not as glorious as Amy makes it out to be. She constantly imagines that the rich clients, and her coworkers, are underestimating her, as she’s gone to an elite university herself. But soon we find out that she didn’t graduate from college and that Amy has no friends and sees unfairness and conspiracies against her from everyone she meets. Amy has never properly dealt with the recent death of her mother and this darkly comic novel makes you laugh out loud or hold your breath as Amy crashes into the various people she meets trying to define who she really wants to be. It’s a solid first novel.

Was this review helpful?