Cover Image: True Crime Story

True Crime Story

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The presentation of this story is a perfect cross between Night Film and Daisy Jones and the Six, both books which I loved. The short snippets are easily digestible and completely compelling; the secrets and lies woven through every page are delicious and poisonous. Really enjoyed this.

Was this review helpful?

True Crime Story is written in a very unique way and is unlike anything I’ve read before. A few chapters in I found myself searching online for the case as I couldn’t work out if it was fictional or not! The inclusion of the author as a character, and of “publisher's notes” added to my confusion (it is fiction, to clarify!).

The start of the book was a bit slow moving, but it picked up pace towards the middle of the story and I was gripped, needing to know what could have happened. Due to the way the story is told (through interviews with those close to the victim), as the reader you are never quite sure who to trust and who may have an ulterior motive.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author via NetGalley and this is my honest and voluntary review.

Was this review helpful?

This is an original take on an unravelling disappearance story. Think 'found footage film' or 'Netflix true crime' series - told largely in transcripts by a number of unreliable witnesses, who's stories contradict each other and change constantly - everyone's a suspect - even the author himself!

This is so different and a refreshing change from usual crime genre and it's testament to Knox's writing that while all characters are a little loathsome at times and so many voices vie for attention each is clear and distinct so while the style of this book may be very different it's fast paced and keeps you hooked.

While the ending did leave me scratching my head in terms of it's plausibility it was such a fun ride to get there it's forgivable - I raced through this, changing my opinion of characters as the story unfolded, trying to second guess what would happen next - this is a great book!

Was this review helpful?

True Crime Story is a very addiction read. It feels somewhat chaotic at times, confusing, even misleading at points, but I thoroughly enjoyed the experience of the novel. (I should add that I did have to check several times that it was actually a novel that I was reading - the 'Publisher's Note' certainly threw me at first."

True Crime Story is an investigation into the mission person, Zoe Nolan, who was last seen in Manchester in 2011. It is formed through transcripts taken from interviews with Zoe's various associates. These interviews have been undertaken by author Evelyn Mitchell, who aims to solve the mysterious case and publish her transcripts and findings as a book. She entrusts her (fictional I assume) author friend Joseph Knox with her work, as shown by the emails between the two writers. When Evelyn is unable to completely the book herself, Knox takes it upon himself to see it through to its conclusion.

I must admit that it took me some time to get this case of characters straight in my head. At no point did that put me off this book though, in fact I just wanted to uncover more of the investigation! It felt a bit like some of the true crime podcasts I listen to - I just wanted more info!

Knox (as in the actual, real-life author) has worked this book masterfully. Each of his characters has its own distinct voice. He weaves details in such a way that I thought I'd figured out 'whodunnit' at least twice!

I actually now want to go back and reread it just so I can pick up on those details as missed - and ignore the red herrings along the way.

A very creative way of telling a story , and one that had me hooked!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishes and Net Galley for giving me a free e-copy of this book for an honest review.

I would class this book as a ' whodunnit' kind of book. We know from pretty early on that something bad has happened and I really couldn't wait to find out why and who.

The book follows two sisters after one of them seemingly disappears after a student party. The book is full of juicy secrets and unsavory characters,

The writing style reminds me very much of Daisy Jones & the Six , in the sense, it doesn't follow a conventional book but instead is made up of transcripts of interviews and newspaper stories throughout. Y are drip fed bits of story information as and when Evelyn - the writer - discovers it herself.

I actually had to google within the first couple of pages to see if this was really based on a true crime story, and I knew very early on, within less than 10 pages that I was instantly going to love the book and it did not disappoint!

The book had me gripped and I loved the writing style especially.
I really couldn't put it down, such a good story and it really did have me racing to the end to find out 'who did it'

Was this review helpful?

WOW WOW WOW
On Saturday 19th December 2011 in the early hours 19 year old Zoe Nolan a student at Manchester University walked out of a party at the shared accommodation where she'd lived for 3 months.
She was never seen again.
We are led through events leading to her disappearance by emails and accounts from her twin sister Kim,her parents and friends as well as the police covering the missing person case.
Everyone is a suspect I felt totally involved in the investigation and it gripped me from start to finish.
Excellency written I would highly recommend this book.
Thank you to Netgalley and Random House UK for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Imaginatively, Joseph Knox, in his fourth novel and his first standalone one, "True Crime Story," has seized upon our passion for true crime podcasts and the like. A Manchester girl goes missing without resolution, a podcast investigator conducts an investigation years later, and then an author (named Joseph Knox, of course) needs to mop up the interlaced stories and evidence to finally seek justice. Comprising interview snippets with all the various suspects and acquaintances, and memos between podcaster and Knox, the plot is a maze inviting the alert crime fiction reader to piece together the vital clues. Knox is an energetic, talented stylist who nails all the various characters and maintains high tension throughout. I greatly enjoyed the antics of True Crime Story until … until the race homeward in the final ten percent of the novel. The trouble was, such episodic narrative construction stymies genuine character identification; in particular, "author Joseph Knox" eluded this reader. All up, True Crime Story is a stylish hoot of an experiment that many genre readers will lap up, but its experimental limitations can leave one flat after the final revelatory climax.

Was this review helpful?

This book is pure genius. It is totally unlike anything I've read before and I love "true crime/crime thrillers". Using formats of emails/interviews/podcast hosting it is fast paced read and the inclusion of the author himself as a character was a masterstroke.
Delving into the disappearance of Zoe Nolan a student from Manchester University the book begins with the reader wondering of this is indeed a true story being covered by investigative journalists. As layers of Zoes life and her secret life are revealed the story becomes deeper and more complex.
I predict this book will be a hit!!

Was this review helpful?

This book had me googling whether it, not this was a true story.

This book follows the disappearance of a Manchester University student Zoe and the events after and surrounding this. The key players in this disappearance are revealed at the beginning, including her twin sister Kimberly. Told through a series of interviews that are cut together after the fact, you get a picture of Zoe's life and the complicated people surrounding her.

The strongest part of this book was probably the style, it was the thing that drew me to it in the first place. The book is told through a series of interviews that are cut together as well as emails between the author and the original author. The style was unique and did keep things interesting.

Despite this, I did have an issue with the pacing, while there were massive reveals and things that didn't make sense, I felt like at times these large things were brushed to the side in favour of snide comments other none interesting information. It made me want to put the book down quite a few times but I stuck through to see how it would end.

The characters themselves started off feeling a little bit like caricatures, there were also a few things said at the beginning regarding race that was a bit iffy and didn't come up later. It did make me want to stop.

You understand at the beginning that everyone has their personal version of events and thus everyone seems to be an unreliable narrator which I think was a massive pro for the story.

The ending left a lot of questions which would be fair if it were a true story but since this is fiction it made me pretty frustrated. There are a few elements that seem to have been completely dropped but then why bring these things up if they're going to be dropped.

Overall, despite what it may seem at times I was drawn into the story. I wasn't expecting the ending but I'm unsure about how I feel about it at the current time. This was solid especially love the style it was written in.

Was this review helpful?

I picked up True Crime Story purely because Jane Casey, whose opinion on crime fiction o I trust, recommended it on Twitter and I’m glad that I did. It’s an unsettling tightrope walk between fact and fiction, although admittedly I felt better once I’d had a search online and was reassured that the “true” crime of the story wasn’t so. It’s an interesting concept, and one which definitely held my attention until the very last reveal. However, some of the characterisation felt a little bit facile, like Liu Wai is shallow and pretentious, so she casually mentions that she eats supermarket premium sandwiches for lunch every day. But there’s lots to admire in Knox’s writing, and True Crime Story really does present the genre in a new way, so I would recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Very interesting, high concept book written in an unusual way. I really enjoyed this book and it is hard to believe this is NOT fiction. Very sad story and I thought it was handled sensitively.

I would definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. Just wow.
True Crime Story was so good I gave up a Saturday to read it all in one.
This is such an original book and cleverly constructed. I love the playing around with narratives. Bringing the actual author in as an author and character is genius.
I enjoyed the interview format with its revealing of biases, conflicting stories, and character.
I've been looking for something different and new in the crime genre. Here it is.

Was this review helpful?

Unusual and unique, this is a fictional account of an unsolved mystery of a Manchester University student’s disappearance written in the style of a true crime book. The account of the disappearance is told from multiple viewpoints presented as transcripts of interviews with those involved and framed by emails between the author, Joseph Knox, who is a character in his own novel and another writer, Evelyn Mitchell, who is investigating the story. It is clear from the start that many of the witnesses being interviewed are unreliable and have their own stories and motivations which may or may explain the reasons behind Zoe’s disappearance and what actually happened to her. The story is gripping and has many twists and turns to keep the reader guessing. With thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for the chance to read the book pre publication in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Excellent. High concept in the way the author is a character in the book. Doesn't completely come off but still a great read.

Was this review helpful?

How I love it when I find a book that does something different and exciting within the confines of its genre! This was twisty, fiendishly plotted, and beautifully written, with the "true" story and the transcripts adding a unique and interesting element. "True Crime Story" is not just the tale of Zoe Nolan, 19, who disappears from her student flat in Manchester, seemingly into thin air, but also of those she leaves behind, her grieving friends and family, and of how they learn to navigate a world without her in it. Told through transcripts curated by budding crime reporter Evelyn, we are essentially told the same story in several different ways, depending on who the 'narrator' is at any given moment. Each of them has their set of memories and recollections and their own set of prejudices and secrets, which makes each of them unreliable in their own way, and I loved that we found out more about each character through what others said about them than we did from their own accounts. There were clues throughout, but they were so subtly planted that I only realised at the very end how everything drew together, which is no mean feat given that I read a TON of thrillers/crime novels, and my brain is basically programmed now to look for breadcrumbs. I loved that we'll never the know the real story behind some of the 'reveals', and I feel like the novel ended perfectly, with questions left unanswered as well as some sense of resolution.

I will be recommending this one to everyone I know. Pacey, engaging, twisty, and clever - my only complaint is that the story had to end.

Thank you to NetGalley, and to the publisher, who granted me a free ARC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was such an interesting concept - a fictional true crime story. I really liked that the story was told through interview transcripts with the people involved in Zoe's life. Every one of them was unlikable at times (or all the time), which made for a great story. I had my suspicions on who the killer was, which changed at multiple times, but I was completely wrong!

Was this review helpful?

A solid convincing novel that will have you googling whether or not this is based on a true story. I think Knox has very cleverly taken the genre and given it a little shake up, so convinced that this was a true story.

I particularly liked the way it was constructed, interviews and transcripts, wading through the information as if I myself were trying to solve the disappearance of Zoe Nolan. And the emails between the writers is a great touch in upping the ante. I enjoyed the fact that all the characters were well developed and no one was above suspicion.

This will leave you scratching your head.

Thank you for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Having read Joseph Knox's other books I was really interested in reading this so thank you for the advanced copy.
Dark, destructive, addictive, dangerous all spring to mind. I would love to see this as a TV series or TV film please.
What an absolutely great read and one I will definitely read again in a few years; time.
Please keep writing and let me have more advanced copies - I love the way Joseph wrights and this is very highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

A #russelreads from just before my hospital visit (no connection --
@josephknox__ will not make you ill!) Was TRUE CRIME STORY (@DoubledayUK , 2021) -- a brilliantly twisted "true"* crime story compiled by a writer Knox knew and edited by Knox himself, its like nothing I've read before. Focussed on the vanishing of Zoe Nolan, a student at Manchester University, the story is told through the filter of a series of interviews with her friends and family as conducted by a writer friend of Knox's.

Interspersed with this are emails between Knox and his friend concerning whether there's really a story to tell in this fractured narrative. As the book continues, it becomes clear that the writing of this book may unlock darker truths that will come to haunt both Knox and his friend.

It's a trick, twisty narrative trick that relies on the blurring of lines between truth and reality, to the point where I was ready to get in touch with the real Knox to ask some very pointed questions before remembering that this was (probably) fiction.

The beauty of the book lies in this tightrope walk intended to utterly immerse you in its world. The messy nature of the central mystery is what convinces most: as in real life, the answers are both terrifyingly inevitable and messily disconnected; the ambiguity of people's perceptions allows Knox to introduce the right amount of uncertainty to the book's eventual conclusions and shiver-inducing finale.

It's an unusual book in its telling, but it's also brave, exciting, and like absolutely no other thriller out there right now. I have a feeling this one will divide some readers (but then any book with ambition and genuine talent will) but I bloody loved it. Knox was already a brilliant crime writer, but this book shows a talent and imagination like nothing else. It's the kind of book that makes you shiver with excitement when you realise what it's doing, and keeps you turning those pages, searching for the truth between the words until you reach what could be the terrifying truth.

TRUE CRIME STORY By @josephknox__ is out in June from @DoubledayUK. The copy I read was a digital galley from @NetGalley
.
.

*Fictional. Maybe.

Was this review helpful?

Firstly a huge thank you to the publishers for my copy to review on netgalley. I’m a huge fan of this authors books so was excited to see what he had written next.

I’ll be honest its very different both to what I expected and to his series . I am left pondering after reading did I enjoy it.. not in a bad way! It is a highly thought provoking and unsettling account of a true mystery surrounding a teenager girls disappearance. I’m a mum to a teenage girl who’s off to uni this year so perhaps this shifted the level of enjoyment for me personally.

However it is incredibly fresh and written in a easy to read and follow dialogue. I raced through as was compelled to know more and find the truth.

It’s a dark topic but you can see the grit ,determination and passion that was given in getting this story out there.

Cleverly written and in a unique original style that captures the reader straight away.

Published 17th June

Was this review helpful?