Member Reviews
I think if I had read this book instead of listened to it, I probably would have enjoyed it a lot more. Some books just have too many details for me to see it in my mind without actually reading the words. The narrator is fantastic and the idea of the story is great, but I found it hard for me to remain focused. Once I found out this would be adapted, with quite a good cast, it helped keep my attention a bit more, but I still think there are too many details and I wish I had read it first instead. |
What a treat for film noir and lit noir fans! First off, I should say I am a big film noir fan and this is one of my very favorite old film noir movies. I first saw it at Noir City introduced by the Czar of Noir, Eddie Mueller (more on him in my next review!) and was blown away by the gritty plot in the carnival atmosphere. I recommend this old movie to fans of noir and camp. It’s kind of obscure though, so I was surprised and delighted to see this offering as an audiobook on NetGalley as I had never read the book. It did not disappoint! First of all, the narrator is great, bringing you back to the 50s without being overly kitschy or stylized. And the book itself is fantastic. I mean, this is a book about swindlers, carnies and murder in a carnival atmosphere. It also explains things how the “geek” who bites the heads of chickens in the freak show is born. If you like twisted fare and noir period pieces, this one is for you. If you aren’t into stuff that’s truly weird and dark, you should take a pass on this one. And by the way, Guillermo del Toro is remaking this movie with Bradley Cooper, Willem Dafoe and Cate Blanchett, so if you want to get a jump on this freaky story, this audiobook is a great place to start. Many thanks to Tantor Audio and NetGalkey for this awesome advance listen. |
I had absolutely no idea that this novel was first Publisher in 1946! I honestly feel great about the fact that I've just read a classic and felt as though it was a contemporary noir mystery. The story itself is clever, dark and eerie; starting is a freak show, the reader is transported to the world of Stan - an ambitious man who's utterly disappointed with where he's at with his career and life, doing pretty drastic things to change his situation. This was WEIRD! Nightmare Alley is definitely a unique choice for me, and although I wasn't sure whether I loved it or not, it was certainly an experience I was looking for to diversify my reading. My experience was definitely enhanced by the narration, so if you're interested in this title, I would definitely recommend the audiobook. It's a voice perfectly suited for this type of a dark novel, making it even more chilly - and highly engaging with each character being portrayed in a unique way. *Thank you to the Publisher for a free advance copy of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review. |
Everyone dreams of running away with the circus, or living the exciting life of a carny. Stan wanted more the the dream, he wanted the fame and fortune. Knowing a little magic leads Stan to becoming a mentalist, a seer. The art of telling the future is the oldest con in the book. It can be the perfect payout with the right mark. Stan just needs to find the right person, and play the long con. But how long can he live the lie until it consumes him? I wanted to read this book purely because I had heard that Guillermo del Toro is turning it into a film. And let's face it, del Toro is the master of dark film. So I thought I'd get the book read before I saw the film, brilliant planning with a head start. Listening to the audiobook I instantly felt like it needed to be a movie. The audiobook does not do the book justice. One narrator for several characters, who really only had a few voices in his capability, didn't work. Music to segway between chapters would be amazing. The story itself is good. I love stories of old circus or carnival acts. American Horror Story did it the best with Freak Show. I wanted this book to be like that. Its set in the right time, with a strong cast, but didn't grip me with anything thrilling. It was all about the con, the smoke and mirrors of the act. I wanted more, a darker story. I hope the movie makes that happen. |
So I debated on whether or not to request this book. It sounded intriguing and it was different from what I'd normally listen to. However, I just couldn't get into it. I'm not entirely convinced that was the book's fault since I hesitated to listen in the first place, so I'm giving it an average review to be fair. I prefer more fast-paced, suspense-driven audiobooks and this was too slow for me even though it started out promisingly enough. Thanks to the author, publisher, and Netgalley for a chance to listen to this audiobook in exchange for an honest review. |
I do not like giving bad reviews but this book and I didn't click. Maybe it is the way it was narrated? I had to restart a few times just to get into the story and then I would rewind and eventually I just gave up. It is probably just me. |
Sprawling. That is the word that describes how I felt listening to this book. The life of those trying to take advantage of the rubes shouldn’t be that. However, it was. |
Kathy P, Educator
Thanks to Netgalley for the opportunity to read this book. Noir style at its finest. Interesting and wee developed characters and a gritty, dark and descriptive location. |
Closer to a 3.5 star rating!!! I was super interesting in the book in the beginning with the description of the freak show, but the book started to lose my interest around halfway though. I enjoyed the main character and the carnival but the mystery fell really flat for me. The narrator for this audiobook did an amazing job! He changed his voice for every character and it never sounded weird or annoying and they were all different enough from each other that I was never confused. |








