Cover Image: Raven

Raven

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thank you to Netgalley and to the publisher for giving me this eARC to review.

The only thing I liked about this story was the art, the story wasn't engaging. I mainly skimmed the story because there was a lot of dialogue that was just boring to read. I give it a 1.5.

Was this review helpful?

This is a really entertaintment graphic novel, I have enjoyed the story and the character (the female characters were well written), and the art fits really well for both the story and the characters. Definitely a must read for any one who has been loving adventure and pirate stories such as Treasure Island.

Was this review helpful?

I had such high hopes for this read, but unfortunately the expectations weren’t reached for me. I did love the illustrations but the story as a whole was meh.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 Stars ( I received an e-arc from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review)

This graphic novel was...meh. The protagonist of the story is a drunken washed up pirate, who everyone is kind of tired of. Then we have a badass female pirate with her intense and creepy crew, hired to find a treasure located on a mysterious cursed island. At the same time a wealthy family travelling get thrown off course by a crazy storm and have been stranded for a while. Then everything collides and shit hits the fan. Curious to see what happens in the next volume.

Was this review helpful?

The art was good, the colours were ok, the story was middling,

the characters were not very memorable. The protagonist was like a pale imitation of Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow but without all the likeability. He was hardly even an anti-hero and I very much wasn't rooting for him.

The suggested ordering of rape of a captured girl by a female leader was very triggering and also, I felt, completely unnecessary. They'd already shown the female pirate leader to be a ruthless woman, now she's shown to be a despicable one too. So, if you can't root for her, and you can't root for the protagonist who's just looking to save his own skin, who can you root for here? And that is where the issue lies in this comic. The story can't benefit from characters who all seem to have the same selfish characteristics.

Of course, this was only the start of the story so maybe the story progresses in a better way. I'd say this wasn't so bad that I wouldn't be interested in reading more as there is potential for everything to turn around and improve greatly

•Character development- 3.5☆
• Story Plot- 3☆
• Side characters- 4☆
• Flow of the story- 3.5☆
• Overall - 3.5☆

Was this review helpful?

Raven book 1 is an entertaining adventure tale that has a sort of boisterous energy on every page. The action is brilliantly illustrated and the story itself has enough intrigue to keep you turning the page. There is a fair bit of violence and bloodshed so maybe not one for some younger readers that might be fans of The Pirates of the Caribbean franchise.

Unfortunately, the cast of characters are all a bit boilerplate. We have the stubborn nobleman Count de Montignac and his sweet daughter Anne. Kemba who is Raven’s wise and witty mentor. This is fine as there is enough nuance and smart dialogue to make you care about them (apart from Lady Darksee who as a villain is truly despicable).

For those that fancy a graphic novel full derring-do on the high seas or something a bit darker and violent than Pirates of the Caribbean, this is a real treat.

Was this review helpful?

'Raven, Vol. 1: Nemesis' with story and art by Mathieu Lauffray is a graphic novel about a fearless young pirate.

Raven has courage, but also is capable of great error. In this volume, he is searching for treasure and finds himself in the midst of cannibals, shipwrecked people and vengeful former crew. It appears hopeless, but Raven seems to stay one step ahead of the game.

I liked this swashbuckling story. Raven is an interesting character and I'd like to find out where this story goes. The art is also good too.

I received a review copy of this graphic novel from Europe Comics and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

This is a translation of a French comic about Raven the fearless pirate captain. The action scenes were great. The story begins with a sea battle so you are instantly thrown right into the action. Tons of action scenes throughout the book. The art is beautiful and the colors are vibrant. The tone is set with colors, darker shades are used in danger spots in the story. It doesn't matter if it is people or landscapes, everything is equally beautiful like each page is a piece of art just waiting to be hung on your wall.

Creative Team:
By Mathieu Lauffray
Translated by James Hogan
Letters Cromatik LTD
Originally published in French

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel reminded me a bit of the first season of Black Sails: besides the obvious similarity of pirates in the Caribbean, there's a great deal of setup for the rest of the series interspersed between the action sequences. It's a riveting book with gritty art, and I'm looking forward to the second volume.

Received via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I think this is a solid start for a first installment.

Are you a Pirates of the Caribbean fan? Then you'll definitely love this graphic novel.

The artwork is breathtaking. The color and the amount of detail are so pretty I stared at the pages for a long time.
The story starts in action as we are transported to a ship in the middle of a battle with another. Here, we are introduced to Raven. He is known to bring bad luck and is often misjudged by other pirates. Then we meet Darksee, who is on a quest for huge riches. She is a pirate captain and my favorite character from the graphic novel.

The story is pretty mainstream for a pirate plot, but I think that will change in the next installments.
I look forward to reading about Raven's adventures.

Was this review helpful?

3 stars
The thing I liked most about this graphic novel has to be the artwork. It was colorful, super detailed and very eye catching. The story was ok for me, felt like there were a couple holes in the story line and would have liked a bit more formation and back story. I loved the pirates, they have always been a draw from me when picking up books, having beautiful art pieces were great to help bring the story to life. I also really liked the badass female pirate, until one scene and then I hated her. Overall I liked it, it is definitely a good one for people just beginning to get into reading graphic novels and would recommend.
Trigger warnings: Cannibalism, fighting, attempted rape and blood
I received this ebook, via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Raven is a swashbuckling adventure comic, perfect for fans of Pirates of the Caribbean.

The reader is immediately thrown into the middle of an epic ship v ship battle at sea before being introduced to our MC. Raven is known as a bad omen among his fellow pirates and is underestimated by everyone he meets. He's an interesting enough MC with a lot more to him than meets the eye. After some eavesdropping he's introduced to Darksee and her quest for impossible riches. Darksee is a badass cutthroat and pirate captain who for me at least, steals the show. She's unreserved in her ruthlessness and wits, I can't wait to see what she does next.

The artwork is a real highlight of this comic. It works wonderfully to convey the tone of the story and is completely immersive; the details on the pirate ship's rigging is a particular favourite of mine. The formatting of the panels and dialogue bubbles really helps to keep the reader engaged and keeps up with the fast pace of the story. The way the elements are drawn and coloured really gives this comic it's character and naturally evokes the feeling of sailing the high seas and descending into the watery depths.

This story definitely has a lot more to offer and I wish some of the other characters were a bit more involved. Aside from Darksee's character there isn't a lot that's unique to this story - it's a pirate adventure in search of impossible riches, but that's about it. Raven definitely has potential to be one of the best pirate comics in decent years and hopefully in the next instalment we'll get to see some really exciting twists and action.

Was this review helpful?

An unlucky pirate, hidden treasure, and a femme fatale. What could possibly go wrong?

Raven: Némésis is Mathieu Lauffray’s first official comic book. Published in 2020, it’s the first in the Raven series. Lauffray is a well-known artist in the graphic novel world, most noticeably for Star Wars (Dark Horse) and Long John Silver.

This inaugural volume tells the story of Raven, a fearless pirate who seems to curse everyone around him. It has adventure, revenge, the high seas, the infamous island of Tortuga and a formidable lady pirate throughout.

--------------------

Summary
The comic follows a lone pirate during the 17th century when the British ruled the Caribbean Sea. Arrogant and impulsive, he quickly decides that the governor’s treasure is his for the taking. The governor, of course, doesn’t agree. Allying himself with Lady Darksee, a pirate in search of a royal pardon, both parties race to reach the island first. Battling liars and cheats, cannibalistic tribes, and an entire armada that’s out to get him, Raven does his best to find the treasure first. But will he succeed?

--------------------

Commentary
Raven: Némésis is a simple story with many hallmarks of the clichéed pirate genre.

Praise
- The illustrations are incredible. Lauffray fully captures the heyday of pirate life during the 1600s. The battles are artfully created, the islands realistic, and the characters are as filthy and scarred as pirates ought to be.
- Lady Darksee is a female pirate. Despite there being plenty of evidence to suggest that female pirates were almost as common as male pirates, they are rarely depicted in media. On top of that, she’s depicted as a talented woman and not an object or a scantily clad distraction.
- The main character is less of a hero and more of an anti-hero. Raven isn’t a good person and doesn’t try to be. In this comic, you’re meant to root for the bad guy, which is pleasantly refreshing from being one of the minorities who supports a story’s villain.

Critique
- This might as well be called Pirates of the Caribbean: Comic style. The main character Raven is near identical to Jack Sparrow. Both are constantly getting themselves into tricky situations, both somehow save themselves in comical and unlikely ways, and both prefer to work alone for their own gain. It’s unoriginal and not remotely unique.
- It’s not so much the first volume as it is the prologue. The story only just begins when the comic ends, and as a result, there’s not enough time to truly get into the story. It’s difficult to care about the characters or even begin to like them when the comic’s cut so short.
- There’s a reference to a sexual assault that does not even remotely affect the plot. There are only two female characters (goodbye Bechdel test) and thanks to our white straight middle-aged author, one of them plays the wicked woman while the other is the innocent maiden. Guess who orders whom to be raped? It’s disgusting and unnecessary and quite frankly, an absolute disgrace to read about in the 21st century.

--------------------

Recommendations
Overall, I’d give Mathieu Lauffray’s Raven: Némésis a two out of five. It’s a stereotypical pirate story full of painful clichés and pointless assault.

I’d recommend this novel only to Pirates of the Caribbean fans, and even then, that’s a big maybe. It’s a simple adventure story if you want a quick read, but other than that, it’s not worth much.

Was this review helpful?

A classic pirate tale - sailing, battling, scheming and hunting for treasure.
The illustrations are beautiful and very stylized, making them seem rough and dark - that complements the gruesome story perfectly.
The writing and story are a bit hard to get into at first, they seem messy, but at the end of the book I was fully invested and wanted more. As this graphic novel is quite short, there wasn't enough time to really learn about main characters (their background, personality and such), so it was a bit hard to actually root for them.
I would gladly read the rest of this series.

Was this review helpful?

Raven has a promising description. I read about a clumsy pirate who couldn't do anything right, and I thought it was going to be a fun, quirky or even an endearing story about a pirate.

It was none of it. 

At first, I thought about not even finishing it, but since it was a short story I decided to force myself to read it. 

The story is messy, confusing, and it wasn't interesting. A pirate looking for a treasure? Classic and overused. It's a pirate who get beaten around 5 times, almost gets killed and still was able to climb trees, houses, and all kinds of stuff. He memorizes a map in 2 minutes from the roof of the house where the map is, and then travels around South America in a little boat with one single man. 

It was boring, and I wanted to skip many parts, when I felt that there was too much information at once or that the information was irrelevant.

I couldn't feel any kind of attraction towards any character. They all felt shallow and uninteresting, and I couldn't relate to their motivations. Raven is moved by spite, apparently, Darksee by gold, and the other characters who knows, they don't even have personalities.

Still, the art is great, the character design is amazing. I loved the design on Darksee and Raven, the two main pirates, and the backgrounds were  well done and beautiful. 

I finally decided to give it 1.5 stars, since I didn't enjoy it enough to go up to 2 stars.

Was this review helpful?

A swashbuckling pirate tale that's gritty and gruesome in both content and style. High stakes, charismatic characters, and awesome art abound in this first volume of Raven's exploits with the formidable Lady Darksee. It might be set in the Caribbean, but this is not Disney! It's a gripping read - you'll be itching to find out where the story goes next.

Was this review helpful?

Loved the artwork and design of this comic. It was beautifully done and I really was drawn into this world! I’ll have to keep an eye out for more of this in the future as I really enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun pirate story. It was nice to see a kickbutt lady pirate with her own crew, I would be interested in reading the rest of this story if it gets translated.

Was this review helpful?

I remember looking at this title in the read now section, but not actually requesting it. I was very surprised just now to find that it's in my "archived, not downloaded" section and wish I could rectify the situation and review it properly, but alas I cannot. If I end up finding an ebook copy to borrow through Libby some time I'll be sure to come back and give a proper review. I am aware that the "will not give feedback" option exists, but as my ratio currently needs all the help it can get and I feel that this book snuck into my shelves unnoticed and uninvited, I'm submitting this way. I am absolutely open to receiving a PDF for this book some other way with the understanding that I would come back and adjust this "review" accordingly.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this graphic novel in exchange for an honest review. It has been published in December 2020.

"Raven" by Mathieu Lauffray is the first instalment in an adventure saga about pirates, naval battles and treasure hunts.
All the tropes that a true genre aficionado could ask for are there: high sea warfare, brawling in Tortuga, a treasure map, shipwrecks, a cocky swashbuckler for a main character, a dangerous and ruthless pirate captain for an adversary...
The drawings and colouring are gorgeous and the pacing is just right, considering this graphic novel is only the first instalment in the series, basically just introducing the characters and locations.
It ends in a cliffhanger, which could put some off, but I personally didn't mind.
What I did mind was the second attempted rape scene (how do *two* attempted rapes even fit in such a short book?) where a *woman* orders another woman raped on the pretence of "freeing her from the shackles" of her virginity, which would put her at risk of an arranged convenience marriage. Yeah, sure, have someone raped today so that they don't get raped later on. Makes lots of sense. My guess is, the real reason why this scene was included is to prove how evil the villainess is (I admit I had been kind of rooting for her until that particular scene... she's just much more interesting than the main character) and also to show off the protagonist's chivalry, since for the second time in a handful of pages he's putting his life at stake to save a damsel in distress from a fate worse than death. Yeah, that's a tad too much sexism for my taste and kind of ruined the ending for me.
The larger-than-average panel where the second rape ALMOST happens is particularly disgusting. I get that sexual violence was common back then, especially among pirates, but seeing the half-naked girl pinned down by the brute right in front of her distraught father, who is powerless to help her, while the villainess looks on with a smug grin was simply too much.
It also made me notice that this supposed "nemesis" doesn't do any of her own dirty work: she orders people raped, she threatens the protagonist to "have him killed", but she's never actually seen using her weapons or joining the fight. This realization quickly deflated my excitement about the character.
Overall, this book does for an entertaining read (up until that disgusting panel), but it should come with a trigger warning for that graphic almost-rape scene.

Was this review helpful?