Cover Image: So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix

So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

So Many Beginnings, A Little Women Remix by Bethany C. Morrow is an eloquent tribute to both Louisa May Alcott and our neglected black history. Morrow has deftly built her own unique characters patterned after those in Little Women. I have never read such a well-written retelling of a classic, and especially not one that is so important in our times. Morrow excels at presenting a range of feelings and thoughts about what emancipation and freedom truly mean in the context of history that the majority of us have never learned about, while at the same time keeping the story engaging and the plot moving forward.

This is a great stand alone book, and would also be interesting to pair with the Alcott original for engaging and meaningful discussions. I will definitely be getting a copy for my classroom library and recommending it to students, teachers, and others a lot!

Thank you to Macmillan Children's Publishing Group, Feiwel & Friends, the author and Netgalley for early access to this wonderful story.

Was this review helpful?

A well-written remix of Little Women, featuring four Black March women post-Emancipation, loving each other and building community in the ill-fated Roanoke Island Freedmen's Colony. While each sister mirrors an essential characteristic of her Alcott counterpart, each is a unique creation set in a time and place that we all need to know more about. A fascinating story! Since good historical fiction often prompts readers to explore the history behind the fiction, a full bibliography of the sources she drew upon would've enhanced Bethany Morrow's endnotes. Also, I would've loved one flashback chapter that focused on how the March family achieved their high level of learning and accomplishment during their enslavement.

We'll certainly be purchasing this title for our high school Media Center and recommending it to our ELA and History faculty.

Was this review helpful?

I've not yet had a chance to read this book, but I'll be reviewing it for the Historical Novel Review and then on my website at a much later date (bibliostatic.com). However, I received the ARC through NetGalley, and I have to submit something by today since it will be archived today. I'm putting in an average of 3 stars because I can't submit this review without it.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much for an advanced copy of this book!

I enjoyed this book so much, and I think it is a great companion novel to the original Little Women story. I honestly think these would be great read back to book and then having a comparison study of the two books.

I think what I love most about this book is that the book completely reimagines the March family and provides historically accurate information. This book gives the March family new purpose and new skills, and I think this is the book's truth strength. This story could have easily just changed the skin color of the characters, but instead the author really dug into the story and made this story educational, informational, and engaging. I'm so glad I read it!

Was this review helpful?

i'm absolutely in love with this book. little women is the only classic that i've fully enjoyed so i was so excited to see it retold, but with a diverse cast and it did not disappoint. plus, i didn't think i'd finish it on time but i sped through this. 5 stars. full review to come soon ( probably tomorrow after school ). but yes, go read this book and the remixed classics series too ( i had the pleasure of reading an arc of a clash of steel, which i enjoyed and the others are such anticipated reads ).

*insert a lot of unnecessary information here because i need to reach the word count and i don’t have time to finish the full review rn.*

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and Macmillans Children’s for the ARC of this in exchange for my honest review.

I am hesitant when considering picking up Classics, because so many seem to be so boring or out of touch compared to more modern novels. I reread Little Women as an adult last year, knowing that it is well loved, and found it so slow and the characters so often moralizing in a way I couldn’t identify with, that I struggled through it. A retelling or remix, though, is something I can definitely get behind and this one sounded much more interesting than the original. I found it much better paced, enjoyed the characters more, and was pleasantly surprised at the ways in which the author managed to catch the vibe of the original while still feeling like a whole different story. I didn’t realize it was part of a series of remixes, and I’m definitely excited to pick up the rest of them!

Was this review helpful?

This just didn’t work. It should have. Maybe a modern day retelling would have been more effective. Some things are more interesting set in modern day and this was one of those things..

Was this review helpful?

So Many Beginnings, this historical fiction re-telling is firmly rooted in the power of the history and oppression of words. Packed with family and ambition, Morrow tells the story of four sisters with vastly different dreams. In many ways, So Many Beginnings feels like a slice of life. A moment of transition and change. New hopes and dreams, while still confronting the history and racism.

Was this review helpful?

A recent trend in fiction is to have a rewrite of classic books. Little Women has always been one of my favorite stories. I was overjoyed when I was approved to read So Many Beginnings, a reimagining of the age old story of four sisters. The March clan are living on Roanoke Island after being emancipated. I love how the author gave nods to Little Women, but reworked the story to create fresh new approaches and stories for each sister. I particularly enjoyed Jo and Beth’s versions the best. It’s a compelling read and a good investment for reading, four sister, bound by affection, however far their paths take them.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Fierce Reads for the ARC! (contest winner)

Another beautifully done adaptation of a classic novel!

I will admit that Little Women is one of the classic novels that I could never get into. I've tried multiple times to read the novel and it never held my interest. Morrow's version is so much better than the original! The novel focuses on the March sisters who are part of the Freedpeople Colony of Roanoke Island. The base of the story stays true to the original novel, while adding in new and complex layers. I found many of the conversations about the freedpeople and the Civil War to be moving and thought provoking, with many of the topics still relevant to black people in America today. "They're only ever speaking for us, and about us. Rarely with us."

I look forward to reading more of the Classic Remix novels!

Was this review helpful?

This book was an interesting take on an old classic. I liked the translating of the March sisters from Little Women to this version. I did however find the writing was a little flat in some sections and I found myself skimming instead of reading.

Was this review helpful?

How much do I love this book? Let me count the ways: So Many Beginnings is arguably a better book than Little Women. Set in a freedperson's colony in Roanoke, the story follows the March sisters, who have begun building their home after their liberation from slavery. Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy face the troubles and changes of their lives with the help of their mother and their own strong sisterhood. Meg teaches other freed people to read, despite her own traumas and the patronizing attitude of white missionaries who are ostensibly there to help. Jo kept silent to keep from screaming, and as a writer navigates her own skill and the bigoted expectations of too many publishers. Beth is a talented seamstress with a perplexing illness. Amy loves to dance, and though she feels grown up, understands why her family want to let her be young as long as she can. These sisters face their trials with more grace, humor, and strength than the originals, and the look into the settlements of free Black people from their perspective is both fascinating and needed.
Spoilers:
Beth lives, Jo and Laurie stay together, and Amy becomes a successful dance teacher.

Was this review helpful?

This was unputdownable - in part because of nostalgia, and in part because of the incredible writing Bethany C. Morrow has done with this book. I meant to read a chapter or two of So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix and ended up reading the book in one sitting.
It has all the charm and family solidarity of the original but it is also an incredible dissection of life for a formerly enslaved family and it does not pull any punches. Morrow's adaptation shows how even after emancipation, the March family has to navigate how society puts more weight on white opinions than on the lived experiences and skills Black individuals have - Meg isn't allowed to teach with the missionary teachers, even though she's highly educated; Jo becomes a writer when none of the white reporters feel the need to interview anyone Black to draw their own conclusions; Beth's illness is one that white physicians decide is imaginary because they can't identify its cause. Readers of Little Women will find all the plot beats from the classic but through the eyes of the March family in the first few years of their freedom.
That this story follows the arc of an existing book so closely while also standing completely alone is an impressive feat of writing, and one that makes me incredibly excited for the rest of the Remixed Classics coming out in the next few years!

Was this review helpful?

In 'So Many Beginnings,' Bethany C. Morrow is returning to the classics. The book comes as part of Feiwel & Friends’ remixed classics series. So Many Beginnings remixes Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women. The year is 1863, in North Carolina. While the civil war carries on, the Freedpeople’s Colony of Roanoke Island begins to grow. It offers a haven for those recently freed from enslavement, offering Black people a community they create. Among them is the March family – Mammy and her four daughters Meg, Joanna (Jo), Bethlehem (Beth), and Amethyst (Amy). As they adjust to their new life, they finally have the chance to grow into their independence. Though they grapple with the echoes of the “old life,” they also experience love, heartbreak, health struggles, and fall into their new life together.

A quality I appreciated about Morrow’s writing is her decision to write as though this book is from the days of yore. Her writing style wholly embodies the trademark of many classics. This alone is enough to draw readers in. Her lyrical style creates an alluring type of yearning. Though she utilizes a similar style, she updates her language in a significant way; she replaces terms such as “slave,” “slave owner,” and “master” with “enslaved” and “enslaver.” She reminds readers of the humanity belonging to those who were enslaved. She reiterates the importance of shifting the language. Morrow also does a wonderful job moving through each sister’s life, and through time. Her technique is seamless. No transition is abrupt or unexpected. It feels like a true journey.

At the heart of 'So Many Beginnings' are the March sisters. Meg, the eldest, longs for a simple life. She wishes to be married and raise a family of her own. Jo excels at writing. Her words demand attention as she gives a voice to the voiceless. Beth is a gifted seamstress searching for her greater purpose. Amy, the youngest March, dances, a perfect fit for her energetic demeanor. Each of the sisters’ personalities shine. Morrow takes the time to paint a picture of each girl. They work as one unit but aren’t without their independence. Readers see how the sum of their parts forms a beautiful whole. The sisters deeply value their bond. Like any siblings, they face some level of conflict. Regardless, their sisterhood remains solid. Morrow provides it the attention and care it so rightly deserves.

Most notably, though, is how Morrow approaches the lasting impact of enslavement. Throughout, the family remembers their experience. However, she focuses more on emotional impact. Their experience doesn’t define them. But it prompts them to strive for a life they deserve. They carry on but never forget. More important still is that Morrow designs a safe reading experience. Readers don’t have to feel the brunt of the Marches’ trauma to recognize it exists. It doesn’t overwhelm the story in any capacity.

'So Many Beginnings' is an instant classic. It wraps readers into a warm, comforting hug. Readers will want to live in it forever. Fans of Little Women will find a new classic to adore with Morrow’s remix. It’s abundantly clear that she understands every facet of the story she recounts. The book also holds similar elements to the original while easily standing on its own. Characters such as Mammy and Lorie only add to the story. Morrow crafts a tender story, and sincerity inhabits every page. Despite the pain of their old life, the Marches’ story provides hope and joy. So Many Beginnings is nothing short of a celebration.

Was this review helpful?

This was amazing.
This book has beautifully drawn characters and repurposes the beloved story of Little Women to tell an entirely different story of the same time period, and in such a way that the reader clearly sees the work that still needs to be done in today’s world.

Ordinarily, I’d be disappointed to see certain things about the original story changed, but I can’t even be mad. A beloved character of mine is not present, but the direction the story makes me not even care.

An excellent read!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this retelling so much. The original was a bit bland in my opinion but this book made the sisters a lot more likable and reasonable in their personal conflicts. I really appreciated the Antebellum era political conversations in the book that grounded the story and added a wealth of meaning and history to what I considered was a rather vapid original text. Amazing stuff!

Was this review helpful?

It took me a while to get into So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix, but ultimately I really enjoyed it. I think, if I hadn't compared it so much to the original story or the cast of characters, I would've liked it a lot more. I found So Many Beginnings to be compelling, and heartwarming, while being incredibly important and potent. While the Meg, Jo, Beth and Amy are all fascinating characters in So Many Beginnings, I was quite hung up on the differences between them and the original story. I also felt like So Many Beginnings was very, very short, and would've loved to see more from the sisters. Because of the short length, I also felt all romantic relationships felt very underdeveloped. That being said, I ultimately really did enjoy So Many Beginnings in its remixed form, and believe it's a must read for any and all Little Women fans!

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC via NetGalley and am voluntarily posting a review. All opinions are my own.

So Many Beginnings is part of a series of “Remixed Classics” the publisher, Feiwel and Friends is doing to provide new, culturally diverse lenses to classic stories. And while the starting point for a retelling is typically reverence for the source material, I appreciate Bethany C. Morrow’s frankness about the fact that she didn’t have that personal connection to the story, but took advantage of others’ attachment to it “to trojan horse in a story and history you weren’t checking for otherwise,” even as she faced racist reviews accusing her of “cultural appropriation.”

Because, aside from some of the basic setup with them being four sisters with the same names, the familial relationships at the heart of the story, and somewhat similar (to varying degrees) personalities, and the fact that it’s set during the Civil War, the story is different and more nuanced, so it’s not just taking the original and racebending the cast, as has become the new trend in Hollywood. She sets her story in the Roanoke Island Freedmen’s Colony, something I had not heard of, something she also admits to in her author’s note, attributing it to the culture in the US of protecting the legacies of the people majority-white Americans view as heroes: enslavers and colonizers.

I really liked seeing the subtle ways in which the characters were adapted. Just like in the original, Jo is my favorite, and perhaps the best written of the four. I liked how she writes nonfiction about the Black experience in America, and enjoyed seeing how her ups and downs with that, including a questionable publishing opportunity, parallel the experiences of the original. I also really liked her relationship with Lorie, and their intense, close friendship. Given the intense conversations around whether the original Jo/Laurie should have ended up together, I appreciated how this was done, still allowing Jo to be her own person and exploring the fact that she doesn’t want anything physical with him, but values his companionship.

I also really liked the way Beth’s character was written, with her mysterious illness and the questions around that. I loved how layered it is, what with both the general misunderstanding of chronic illness, plus the way white medical professionals mistreat Black patients with these conditions and accuse them of lying, and then there’s the historical lens where the understanding of medicine was more limited to begin with. I appreciate how it does give her a chance for a happier outcome, as she’s given an opportunity to live her life and pursue opportunities, even if they do lead to her parting from her beloved family.

I had mixed feelings about Meg. I liked the general direction for her at first, as her character has always been the most “traditional,” wanting to marry and have a family. But I was a bit bummed by how this came to pass. She’s interested in someone early on, and it seems they might have a long distance thing, but it doesn’t work out. Then, almost out of nowhere she’s marrying someone else? I did like how some aspects of this relationship paid tribute to the Meg/John relationship of the original, including Jo’s skepticism, but I just wasn’t wild about who she ended up with.

And the reasoning for that romance fizzling out was setup for him to be Amy’s love interest…does Amy ever get a man of her own, or is every version of her destined for a former flame of one of her sisters? I mean, I get it, the guy is wealthy, so it works out for her, and it leaves the new Jo/Lorie arc unaffected. And I do appreciate that Amy makes her terms for their relationship clear, making him prove he wants her, and not just one of the March sisters, which feels like a direct response to some of the criticisms of the original Amy/Laurie pairing, where it seemed like he only chose her because she was Jo’s sister.

This is a beautiful book, containing the heart of what is so beloved in the original, the importance of sisterhood and family, while also excavating and interrogating history through the lens of nostalgia. Whether you’ve read Little Women or not, this is definitely a must-read.

Was this review helpful?

I love reading different interpretations of the stories I love, so I knew I needed to read this one. It didn't disappoint. So Many Beginnings taught me about things in history I knew nothing about (like the Freedmen's colony). I love that the author kept the hearts and souls of these characters the same while changing their experiences to something completely different than what we see in Alcott's version. The prose is beautiful as well. I would have liked to have seen more situations from the original novel adapted into this one (particularly surrounding Amy and her growth), but I can understand why they were left out.

Was this review helpful?

An innovative, fresh take on the classic Little Women. Morrow perfectly executes the potentially-risky task of making this novel its own while staying true to the original.

Was this review helpful?