Cover Image: The Bookseller's Secret

The Bookseller's Secret

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Title: The Bookseller's Secret
Author: Michelle Gable
Genre: Historical fiction
Rating: 4 out of 5

In 1942, London, Nancy Mitford is worried about more than air raids and German spies. Still recovering from a devastating loss, the once sparkling Bright Young Thing is estranged from her husband, her allowance has been cut, and she's given up her writing career. On top of this, her five beautiful but infamous sisters continue making headlines with their controversial politics.

Eager for distraction and desperate for income, Nancy jumps at the chance to manage the Heywood Hill bookshop while the owner is away at war. Between the shop's brisk business and the literary salons she hosts for her eccentric friends, Nancy's life seems on the upswing. But when a mysterious French officer insists that she has a story to tell, Nancy must decide if picking up the pen again and revealing all is worth the price she might be forced to pay.

Eighty years later, Heywood Hill is abuzz with the hunt for a lost wartime manuscript written by Nancy Mitford. For one woman desperately in need of a change, the search will reveal not only a new side to Nancy, but an even more surprising link between the past and present...

Nancy and her family were a bit of a dumpster fire. I really didn’t care for them. Nancy was very wishy-washy and I frankly just wanted her to grow a pair, make a decision, and follow through. I actually enjoyed Katie’s story in the present-day far, far more than Nancy’s, although she had her own set of issues (more of a campfire than a dumpster fire).

There were some parallels between the two women, with their writer’s block and indecisiveness, but it was fun to see Katie’s journey. The blurb makes this seem like everyone in London is talking about the possibility of a lost Mitford manuscript, but in reality it was basically three people, so there’s that.

Michelle Gable is a bestselling author. The Bookseller’s Secret is her newest novel.

(Galley courtesy of Harlequin/Graydon House in exchange for an honest review.)

(Blog link live 8/17.)

Was this review helpful?

The Bookseller's Secret by Michelle Gable is a book that tells the story of Nancy Mitford. The socialite turned novelist, who during World War II took over a London bookshop. She also became involved with a French resistance fighter. A story full of mystery and intrigue that pulls you in from the beginning.

Was this review helpful?

In 1942, London, Nancy Mitford is recovering from a devestating loss and with her husband away at war, she is in need of a project. She has given up on her writing career, but the French officer she has taken as a lover is trying to convince her to write her memoir. In the meantime, desperate for an income and means of distraction, she goes to work at the Heywood Hill bookshop. Eighty years later, Heywood Hills is abuzz with rumors of the supposed manuscript that was never published. Katie, a writer who is suffering severe writer's block of her own, goes on a search for the manuscript.
I really wanted to like this book, but it was a hard pass for me. I just could not get into it. The characters came across flat and unlikeable and I just couldn't get invested in their stories. The Mitford Women were terrible women - all of them, apparently - and it is hard to enjoy a book where you actively dislike the main character like that. Other people may enjoy this,, but it just wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

Read as too much of a history book and not a historical fiction novel. I can usually get behind a struggling female lead working to overcome something but I became very board with lead character quickly.
This was my first foray in the Mitford history, so I was kind of looking forward to it but found it just wasn't suited for me. At points it got too wordy in it's dialogue with some description thrown in to help building the environment.
The research was thorough and well plotted but after a while it felt overwhelming. The ending also was lackluster in it's resolution for Katie our struggling main character.
This book is for someone, and I do think it is a good book, it is just not for me.
Thank you to Graydon House and to NetGalley for this eARC for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Author Katie Cabot has a major case of writer's block and is recovering from a breakup. She leaves her home in Virginia to visit a friend in London for a change of scenery and hopes the trip will inspire her to write another book.

Katie meets the handsome Simon while visiting the Heywood Hill bookshop where Nancy Mitford worked during World War II. Simon is hunting for the manuscript of Nancy's lost memoir, which he believes is inside the book store. Katie teams up with Simon because they have a shared love of Nancy Mitford's works.

Simon and Katie's relationship is quick to smolder, but the secrets they keep from each other may derail their romance train before it leaves the station.

Recommended for readers intrigued by Nancy Mitford's life.

Was this review helpful?

The ubiquitous Mitford Sisters apparently still garner attention and interest - one a novelist, one a fascist, one a fascist cum nazi, one a communist, one uninteresting to the press, one a duchess, each a controversial figure. This book focuses on the eldest Nancy and her “on again off again” writing career.

Raised in the Cotswold by uninterested, titled upper class parents, the children, six girls and one boy, were sheltered from the outside world and their existence in hindsight appears insular almost inbred. Hats off for the exploration and analysis done but this book only extended my disaffection for the Mitford Clan.

The dual timeline employed served its purpose but the characters in the “here and now” were vapid, uninteresting and who cares?! The dialog from the time of Nancy Mitford could have been lifted entirely from an early black and white movie, staccato, fast moving, spoken abbreviations with the unstated understanding that you would just get every spoken word and connect the dots.

I respect the effort, not so much the book. Thank you NetGalley and Harlequin / Grayson House for a copy

Was this review helpful?

My historical fiction loving heart loved this new book!!!!!!!!!!!!!! As a huge Michele Gable fan this latest book was right up my alley!!!!!!!!! Every booklover will adore this one!!!!!!

Was this review helpful?

The Review

This was a remarkable story. The way the author balances the history and knowledge of the infamous author’s life and the war itself with the more modern-day characters who begin discovering things about Nancy as they search for her long-lost manuscript was so fascinating to see unfold. The setting of both time periods and the descriptive way the author writes really does a great job of painting a picture of the events of this narrative so perfectly.

It was the character growth in this book that really sold me on this narrative. The modern-day protagonist, Katie, really drew the reader in and kept the mystery and wonder of discovering more about Nancy’s life alive, while Nancy herself was engaging and mesmerizing as she balanced her work in the bookstore, her standing in social circles in the midst of her loss and the war, and of course her passionate affair with the French General who became the love of her life.

The Verdict

A beautiful, heartfelt, and creative approach to historical fiction narratives, author Michelle Gable’s “The Bookseller’s Secret” is a must-read novel of 2021. The perfect balance of dual-narratives with mystery and history blended in made this story shine brightly, and the setting really will engage history buffs while hitting the heartstrings in the process. If you haven’t yet, be sure to grab your copy today!

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley and am voluntarily posting a review. All opinions are my own.

I didn’t know much about the Mitford family prior to picking up The Bookseller’s Secret; I only knew that they were a bunch of aristocratic sisters in the mid-20th century, and some were writers. And while I lacked any true grasp of their contributions to history and literature beyond that, I still found myself invested in this book, even if at times I did question whether it would be better to put it down.

“Colorful” is perhaps one of the nicer adjectives I can apply to the Mitfords and their circle, which consists mostly of other shallow aristocrats. While it can be tiresome to read about some entirely unlikable people, I found it rather fascinating, especially when I really began to delve into the connections they had. I went through a Virginia Woolf phase, especially concerning her love affair with Vita Sackville-West, so to find out that Vita’s cousin, Eddy, who eventually inherited Vita’s beloved Knole (after his father), was one of Nancy’s contemporaries? And the fact that one of the other Mitford sisters, Deborah, married the eventual Duke of Devonshire, who only became Duke when his brother tragically died, and that brother was married to Kick Kennedy, who herself also died tragically? It was a fun “who knows who,” and having experienced stories highlighting the shallow nature of the aristocracy, I didn’t expect much less. I did appreciate getting a quick rundown of who everyone was at the beginning, as well as what each sister was known for, as that helped to navigate the story better.

I did find it fascinating how the sisters’ varying political beliefs and varying lifestyles played a role in their relationships with one another. A key one that comes to a head is Nancy’s opposition to Diana and her husband’s fascist politics, leading to Nancy reporting them to the government. That really resonated, especially as we are again living through politically contentious times, and having to make decisions about relationships with people with dangerous political beliefs.

I did feel like the book was promoted to have a more suspenseful tone, especially with the title, but ultimately, “secret” in question was more personal in nature, and while I wasn’t super let down, I did feel like it was misleading.

The present day storyline was all right, inasmuch as it tied in with the past one of writers losing confidence in themselves and lacking inspiration. It’s also fun to look at the ways in which writing and being an author changed since the 1940s to now, with jokes about overly critical book reviews getting a chuckle out of me. I also loved the name-drop of some other women-centric historical fiction writers, some of whom I’ve also read, such as Kate Quinn, Beatriz Williams, and Paula McLain.

I was comparatively less invested in the goings-on with Katie in general aside from that, however. I wasn’t really interested in her personal life or her budding romance. Nancy’s was the more fleshed out of the two POVs, if I had to make a comparison.

I did enjoy this book a lot, even if more for the content of the Mitford chapters. If you like women-centric historical fiction, and you don’t always have to feel sympathy for the characters, I recommend picking this up.

Was this review helpful?

I like Michelle Gables books. This one, however, did not grab me immediately. I have read about the Mitford sisters in various capacities. I found the modern parts of this novel to be more appealing than the ones from WWII. I failed to get a feel or a read on any of the characters. I liked the concept, I just never felt invested in the plot.

Was this review helpful?

Amusing historical fiction about author Nancy Mitford. A fun introduction to Mitford to those who are not familiar, and a tale full of Easter eggs for the Brit Lit connoisseur. The present-day storyline is a bit predictable, but the characters possess enough charm to overcome it.

Was this review helpful?

Nancy Mitford was one of six sisters and they couldn't have been any more different. For example, Nancy was a novelist, sister Pamela was a countrywoman, and Diana was a Fascist. Then there was Unity, a Hitler confidante and Jessica, the Communist, while Deborah was a Duchess. They also had a brother named Thomas. Indeed, all of the siblings were strikingly different.

Although this novel is based on the true-life story of Nancy Freeman-Mitford, an English novelist, it was not a biography, and was written as historical fiction. Nancy had a wonderful writing career, but after expericing a devastating loss, as well as being estranged from her husband, she gave up writing. Once known as the Bright Young Thing, it was her sisters who were continuing to make headlines.

Nancy is forced to find a way to earn an income, so she takes the opportunity to manage the Heywood Hill bookshop. One of her customers sees more for Nancy and this helps her to see that she just might write again. Meanwhile, in present time, Katie Cabot is searching for Nancy Mitford's unpublished manuscript. Katie's career needs a boost and unearthing said manuscript would definitely make waves. Then Katie meets Felix Assan, who is also searching for the manuscript and the two become allies. Slowly, the past and the present converge, especially as Katie and Felix dig deeper.

Whether the story takes place during the late 1940s or eighty years later, it is intriguing throughout. I love the extensive research this story proved. Although I had not heard of Nancy Mitford prior to reading this novel, I found her to be a very interesting person, and her trials made a deep impression on me. I also enjoyed how Katie's story developed as she searched for the manuscript, all while developing a kinship with Felix.

Many thanks to Graydon House and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this one without any real knowledge about it other than it involved a bookseller and a secret and was set in London during WWII. That alone made me think it would be a good match for my reading tastes (it wasn't quite the match I had hoped.). I had some preconceived idea that it would follow a similar plotline to “every other” WWII historical novel hitting the shelves in the last few years. I was wrong to make any assumptions as it centred more on the life of Nancy Mitford in the past timeline and an author’s interest in Nancy Mitford in the present timeline - I have never *gasp* read Nancy Mitford in my life and this novel didn't actually make me want to, unfortunately.

With the focus on exploring the struggles and social life of Nancy Mitford and her contemporaries during WWII, the novelization was less World War II-themed and more of a fictional biography. It wasn’t a quick read – not one of my sit down in a single session reads – it was heavy on detail but well written. The contemporary angle was more to my taste, but even then I wish it had been fleshed out a little more. There was a parallel between the past and present with a mystery manuscript to tie both timelines together.

I would recommend for fans of Nancy Mitford, those who have read or watched an adaptation of In The Pursuit of Love, or anyone who enjoys a glimpse into the often “sordid” life of Britain’s historical upper class.

Was this review helpful?

A dual timeline story set in London alternating between WWII and present day that fictionalizes the life of author Nancy Mitford. The first timeline focuses primarily on the years when Nancy worked in a bookshop during WWII while trying to come up with an idea for a new novel. In the present day timeline, Katie is an American author struggling with writer's block who is visiting a friend in London. While visiting a local bookshop in Mayfair, Katie is drawn into a man's search for a missing manuscript that Mitford may have written while working at the same bookshop.

Perhaps this book would have appealed to me more if I had already been a fan of Nancy Mitford as it's clear that the author has done a great deal of research into her life. I had trouble connecting to the characters in any meaningful way, however, and didn't enjoy the novel's heavy reliance on dialogue. The one thing that I did quite enjoy was reading about the Heywood Hill bookshop and discovering that it is an actual bookshop still operating in London. I will definitely make a point of visiting the bookshop the next time that I'm in London!

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with a digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to read this book as I'm a huge fan of Nancy Mitford, the reason that made me request this book is the weakest part of this book.
Nancy Mitford was a complex, clever and witty woman. The Mitford sisters were a fascinating group of woman and I don't think it's a easy to approach and write about a myth.
But the Nancy Mitford in this book is a selfish and quite shallow woman, it can be a point of view but she was quite complex and this was main issue.
The contemporary part is enjoyable but I think that the historical part is a problem. I read plenty of reviews talking about Nancy Mitford as an unlikeable character.
I can only say "please read her books".
Not my cup of tea.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine

Was this review helpful?

The Bookseller's Secret is an intriguing read told in dual time lines which I quite enjoyed.

There is Nancy Mitford and Kate Cabot, both are authors in different eras and both are having trouble writing their next book.

When Kate goes to London and discovers the book store that the famous Nancy Mitford worked at during the war, she is intrigued and just the thought of a missing manuscript has Kate more than interested.

There are secrets , mystery and romance as the pages fly by.

I enjoyed learning about the Mitford sisters , I knew of them but not much about them. The epilogue at the end was much appreciated.

Michelle Gable did a wonderful job with all the dialogue and I felt that I was right there in the bookshop. I am off to look up Michelle's other books.

Thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing (U.S. and Canada) Graydon House for a enjoyable and interesting read.

Was this review helpful?

I really struggled to get into this book. It all felt too stiff to me, and I was unable to connect with the characters. As a result, I really didn’t find any of the characters very likable. War was raging around them, but they seemed removed from it all.

It is a well-researched book and had a few interesting moments. I was fascinated by how very different the Mitford sisters were - a novelist, a countrywoman, a Fascist, a Hitler confidante, a Communist, and a duchess.

Thank you to Harlequin and Graydon House for an advance eARC of the book. The opinions expressed here are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This historical fiction novel made me look up what the Mitford sisters were really like. I enjoyed how this story went from the past to the future. I love stories that are based in a bookshop also. I really enjoyed how Katie figures out the best way for her to live her life and write her next book. This had some nice romance. This story made me want to look into some of the authors mentioned within. This has fun characters. I received a copy of this book from Harlequin for a fair and honest opinion that I gave of my own free will.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to love this one. I really loved another book about a London bookstore during World War II that I read earlier this year and I was excited about the present day POV and the literary search into the past. Unfortunately, I never connected with any of the characters or became invested in the past or present storyline.

Other then basic name recognition I'm not super familiar with the details of the Mitford sisters. After reading this I am a bit more curious about them and will probably do a bit of looking into them. While rather horrible I am curious about the ins and outs of their lives. However, that interest does not extend to wanting to read any of Nancy Mitford's works or finding any connection to her in this book. As well, while I did like some of the side characters in the present day storyline I disliked the main character, writer Katie, so much that it kind of soured my feelings about that part of the book. Katie comes off as whiney and aggressive to the point I could just not care about her.

The author does a wonderful job of setting the scene and really makes the locations come alive but unfortunately in the book that skill does not translate to the characters. When all is said and done, when it came to this book I found I just didn't care what happened to the characters or how the story evolved.

Was this review helpful?

Ok, What I knew about Nancy Mitford before reading this book: a) I knew she was a famous author from the 1940s, b) she came from a large family and had several siblings, c) she moved in the upper levels of high-London society, d) some of her sisters were also authors, and e) that one sister was a communist, one a fascist and one a Nazi. Now what I knew after reading this novel? Exactly the same thing I knew before. I am sorry but when I read a historical fiction novel I expect to learn a little something or at least to have what knowledge I already possess expounded upon. But alas, in this instance it was not to be.
This is a dual timeline novel about two women authors, Nancy Mitford and Katie Cabot, whose lives parallels each others. Katie (present day author) goes to London seeking inspiration to free her from writer's block. She, (and here comes the cliché') meets handsome stranger who is searching for a missing memoir written by Nancy Mitford who just so happens to be Katie's favorite author. She joins in the search, there is the expected trust/don't trust issue, what is he really up to suspicion and that's about it, it just falls flat from there. There is no connection to the characters in the present, for a dialogue driven novel Katie's dialogue, to me seemed extremely juvenile, not fitting the age her character was. Also the end of the book left the reader totally bereft, there is no plausible conclusion to be had to Katie's story.
In the past I expected Nancy Mitford's somewhat famous radical personality and bitingly sarcastic wit to shine through, I was very much disappointed. There was just no kick to the scenes at all. Nothing to really engage with or get excited about. I also fear if you go into reading this novel with complete lack of prior knowledge of the Mitfords or the myriad of secondary characters such as Evelyn Waugh, James Lees-Milne or Lady Helen Dashwood aka Hellbags, to only name a few, you will be totally lost and lose interest fast.
I can only give 2 stars for this book which saddens me, I had high expectations and wanted to love it as I had really enjoyed Michelle's earlier novel "A Paris Apartment".
Thank you to Harlequin Trade Publishing and Net Galley for the free ARC of this novel, I am leaving my honest review in return.

Was this review helpful?