Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I have some mixed feelings about this book. I enjoyed the different povs. I feel like it lacked feeling with the chracters although the timelines were quite interesting. It took me awhie to get through this book because I lost interest. But I’m glad I stuck with it! There were some things I did not see coming. Also needs to have trigger warnings especially for YA.

Was this review helpful?

Tell Me When You Feel Something is a great starting book to get into YA mystery. The idea and plot was interesting enough for me to be engaged to the characters. Especially to Viv. Though I find it hard to differentiate among the three (Viv, Tim, and Davida). Even if the characters are lacking, I really want to see the ending and twists. One thing I like about is you can tell the author knows how to write a mystery, the suspense is there and it's great that you could guess the ending.

Content warnings of this book includes: drug abuse, grooming, pedophilia, self harm, rape, eating disorders.

Was this review helpful?

Tell Me When You Feel Something has a premise that is compelling. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the review copy! However, I didn't find the story as compelling as I would have liked. The voices of the three characters (Viv, Davida, and Tim) weren't as distinct as they could have been, making me have to stop and remind myself who was the narrator at any given time. It also seemed like there were too many subplots that didn't all get resolved.

On the other hand, I did enjoy the plotting of the mystery, and though I suspected the culprit, I wasn't sure prior to the reveal. Ultimately, I give this one three stars. It won't be one I booktalk often and will be a secondary purchase for us.

Was this review helpful?

Oh how I wanted to absolutely love this, but. Oh how I unfortunately did not.

This book had one hell of an interesting premise, and I was immediately intrigued by the synopsis. I could not wait to pick this one up, so sure that I was going to be absolutely blown away by the story. But sadly, despite a unique plot and a compelling opening chapter, the book ending up falling flat for me, and didn’t live up to the hype that I conjured in my mind.

This story had all the right ingredients: unique plot line, mystery, and drama, but for some reason they just didn’t quite blend together correctly.

Still, despite all that, I still found some aspects of this book good, and don’t regret reading it. I loved the creativity of the story, and the writing was very good. It was just missing that certain something that I can’t quite put my finger on.

I definitely feel that a lot of people will enjoy this book, so I would still recommend giving it a go, as the writer is definitely talented! Although this one didn’t work for me, I would still pick up another book from this author in the future.

Was this review helpful?

Were do I begin. This book was absolutely amazing! I could not stop reading it. I thought at first the style of the way it was written was going to be a bit bothersome but it actually was very creative and helped the story become more alive.
I love how this story does not get overly dramatic and presents its self in a real life situation. I felt for all the characters involved because of the way it was written. You get to feel for everyone and see different points of view through their eyes.
The story unfolds so nicely and comes together at the end with a couple twists in the plot then a surprise. I really enjoyed this book and plan to check out more by this author. I am so glad I got the chance to read this. So thank you for allowing me access to read this book before it is released and to review it. I thoroughly enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Penguin Teen for the arc in exchange for my honest review.
I really liked this book. A party leaves one girl in a coma and the others wondering what happened. I don't want to give much away until the book is published in June.

What I can say about this book is there is a lot going on. It keeps you engaged and the characters are well written. I do want to state that there is trigger warning with sexual assualt. Vicki Grant created relatable characters who the reader will connect with although at times you may hate them.

The sexual assult and the substance abuse is addressed in a classy and understanding way. Its always a thin line when authors tackle that subject. I've seen that it either is addressed too much or not enought. but in this book its just right.

The ending was a little messy, but that didn't take away from the story.

Was this review helpful?

Arc kindly received from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Tell me when you feel something is a young adult mystery novel that follows the lives of three teenagers who are involved in a simulated patients programme in a local medical school. Viv is left in a coma after a party, and we see the build up to this event from Viv’s perspective and the aftermath from the perspectives of Tim and Davida.

This book had the potential to be brilliant. The general plot line was great and I found the setting fascinating. I thought Viv was a complete and enthralling character, and I found enjoyed her parts much more than Tim’s and Davida’s.

However, I do think we found out her ‘secret’ far too early, it would have been nice to see her portrayed as this ‘perfect specimen’ a little longer before the illusion was shattered. I also wouldn’t have minded her being a little darker.

Then we get to Tim and Davida. I have to admit, I really didn’t find myself emotionally invested in either character. They felt very flat and one dimensional, and I honestly don’t think they bought anything to the story.

Parts of the story were far too slow (especially in the first half) and parts were far too rushed (especially the ending). I think more could have been made of the ‘twists’ and again I would have liked the ending to be a little darker, it was all too neatly wrapped up with a bow by the end.

I read a lot of YA novels, and this is the first one that has made me feel to old for the genre. It just felt a little simple, and there wasn’t enough build up of all of the main characters. I did wonder if my age was the reason I didn’t enjoy it, but then I look at authors such as Alice Oseman, Mary H.K. Joy, Holly Jackson and ML Rio, and I realised it’s not me, it’s the you (well, the book).

I wanted to love this book. I had so much potential, it could have been amazing. But for me, it just fell very flat.

2.5/5

Was this review helpful?

Disclaimer: I got this ARC in exchange for an honest review from @NetGalley.

There were no trigger warnings mentioned, but here are some important ones: sexual assault and grooming.

This is perfect for fans of Diana Urban's All Your Twisted Secrets and Karen MacManus. An ideal after-school job turns out to be perilous when a charismatic student named Viv ends up in a coma. The other kids don't think that it was an accidental overdose. Something weird happened at this program and they want to find out what before their next. This book kept me up all night in the best way possible and I highly recommend this thriller! I'll be posting an official review closer to the date on pop-culturalist.com

Was this review helpful?

This book was FASCINATING! I loved it. What a weird, wonderful, dark, beautifully written. The "simulated patient" concept in and of itself is what drew me to this book! I thought it had just the right amount of twists and the reveals all felt satisfying. Will absolutely give this to my teens interested in thrillers and add to a booklist on sexual violence.

Was this review helpful?

~ I received an ARC for this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review! ~

** TRIGGER WARNINGS: sexual assault, grooming, alcohol & drug use.

This book is a solid three for me.

Davida, Viv and Tim are Simulated Patients (SP) for med school students to practice on as a part-time med school program. However, this Summer job suddenly turns deadly after Viv falls into a coma after taking pills at a party. Davida is trying to piece together what happened to her friend at a party. She doesn't drink or take drugs--so how did she overdose? Leading up to the party, Viv's life is in shambles and she's just trying to hold it together one day at a time. What really happened that night?

Alternating between multiple viewpoints and incorporating police reports, Tell Me When You Feel Something keeps you guessing and throwing grisly twists at you. We start off with few days before the party exploring the leading events to the situation that exists today and it's very well structured.
Police reports, though it kept me intrigued, I had difficulty piecing each piece of evidence together and had to keep looking back to see what I had already finished. Multiple POV was definitely a risky move but it was played well, so no complaints there. It started off slow, had its moments in the middle and blew it out of the park in the end.

Diversity severely lacked here. The characters were real and flawed. Although not everyone was as fleshed out but they had me at the edge of my seat. Viv's POV was the clear winner for me, and through her storyline, the author explores some pretty intense topics: sexual assault, rape, consent, teen alcoholism, illicit drug use, toxic relationships, and mental health, to name only a few.

Many parts of the book were exhausting. But, I was also incredibly uncomfortable at how much this touched on real-life situations many teens/young adults face today. These uncomfortable conversations are something we need to have. We need more art that dwells on topics like abuse, addiction unhealthy coping mechanisms and forming strong support systems.

Although I pretty much guessed the ending midway it was a thrill ride nonetheless. I've always felt that an author is doing something right if they can make you hate someone who doesn't actually exist, and it definitely happened while reading this.

bottom line, if you love thriller/mystery and are not triggered by the above warnings, I would happily recommend this book!!

Was this review helpful?

Tell me when you feel something by Vicki Grant is a YA contemporary mystery. We start off learning Viv, had dropped into a coma after supposedly taking a few pills at a party. Viv's best friend Davida states that Viv would never take drugs. We follow through a mystery based on what exactly happened.
The writing followed through nicely and flowed smoothly. It's understandable and simple. Though it's good it's somewhat part of the 4-star reasoning because it was too basic and simple-- there could've, been more thrill you know? We were narrated through a couple of different perspectives and styles of writing that included police interviews. During the start, we read about the after of Viv being in a coma and during the middle we read about the before, leaving us at the end with the after again. Continuing with the writing, parts felt cringeworthy. Specifically when some talk of pedophilia was involved. One thing about this book, there were NO trigger warnings (I included them at the end of the review). While still being a fun YA book, there should've stilled been a page for that in the beginning.
I loved the concept of the setting, I found it original and intriguing. Tell me when you feel something took place at a medical school. Where Viv and Davida were both Stimulated Patients SP, in a program. I loved how that was included because I had gotten to learn much more about being an SP what happens at programs like that.

TRIGGER WARNINGS: Sexual Assult, Pedophilia, Alcohol, & Drugs.

Thank you to Netgalley and Penguin Teen for letting me read an eARC of this book. I voluntarily left an honest review.
eARC provided by Netgalley & Publisher
EXPECTED RELEASE DATE: June 15, 2021
REVIEWED: 3/3/2021

Was this review helpful?

Chilling and gives me the vibe I am expecting so this one delivered the goods.

If you're looking for a riveting read, then this is for you. Read with caution.

Was this review helpful?

I'm torn on how I feel about this book. Overall, the book was all right as in mediocre or just okay. The book is told from multiple viewpoints of teenagers involved in a medical trial. Something happened to one of the teenagers and she wound up in a coma and the book basically leads up to finding out what happened to her. The characters other than the teenager in a coma all fell a bit flat and they're writing was all right. I wouldn't say I hated this book but I wouldn't say it was my favorite. Thank you to netgalley and the publishers for an arc in exchange for unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

The book uses multiple POVs (including the one of the victim) and multiple time periods that jump back and forth to create the total picture for the reader to discover the truth. Sounds intriguing, but the execution is a total chaos. The book also tried to deal with too many problems, and none of them were discussed in depth. Some (or most?) of the characters really have temper issues, it's okay to read one chapter of them arguing but exploding through the whole book? That just makes the whole explosions boring. They were probably all firecrackers but in my eyes they are just sparklers. Fun to play but not to watch/read.
In summary: a group of teenagers that have issues mess up their lives and the time of the reader.

Was this review helpful?

I both loved and hated this book. It was really intriguing in palces, other places it was predictable. There's very little diversity in this book which disappointed me since there most certainly could be.

Was this review helpful?

After taking pills at a party, Vivienne lays in a coma. Her friends and boyfriend are adamant that she doesn’t drink or do drugs but some thing caused her to act uncharacteristically that night
The story lead you through the moments before the party and after. There should be some warnings due to subject matter. Thank you NetGalley ad the publisher for an arc in exchange for a honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book, though the prose could be a bit simplistic. It also felt very flat with regards to diversity — I thought Steve and Davida's father were together for a good portion of the book, but that turned out not to be the case, and I envisioned Davida as black and Tim as Middle Eastern, but I don't know if that came from anything grounded in the text or not. Tim also read as very autistic to me, which I liked, but I am unsure if that was the author's intention. The stimulated patient program was really interesting, and I loved the title, but I did see the twist coming about a mile away. It was enjoyable, and what happened to Viv and why she took the pill, as well as what she told Tim kept me engaged, but I probably wouldn't reread it.

Was this review helpful?

Tell Me When You Feel Something by Vicki Grant tells the story of the events leading up to a teenager, Viv, lying in a coma after taking a pill at a party. The story is told from the alternating perspectives of Viv, Davida, and Tim, high school students who had been working as simulated patients at the medical school. The story twists and turns through the events from the month leaving up to the party and the subsequent investigation into the events.

I really enjoyed this book, and it was written with a pace that kept me turning the pages. It read very quickly for me. I appreciated the alternating perspectives interspersed with the police interviews as I felt that it kept me guessing as to what had really happened. I enjoyed the med school and simulated patient aspect of the story as I feel that it is a more unique aspect of the book. I thought that the plot was engaging and I didn't fully guess the ending until I was there. This book deals with some heavy content including assault, drug/alcohol use, and mental illness and may benefit from trigger warnings particularly as it is aimed toward a young adult audience. I would highly recommend this book for fans of YA thrillers.

I received an e-ARC of this title from Penguin Teen via NetGalley which did not affect the contents of my voluntary review. All opinions are honest and my own.

Was this review helpful?

i was provided an earc via netgalley in exchange for an honest review! //

anybody else feel like viv was the only character with any personality at all? how are you going to write a book from four different perspectives but only flesh out one of the characters? everyone aside from viv felt like they were just tropes- mentally ill mom, dorky best friend, weird quiet girl...it was hard to connect to any of them.

additionally, i would have loved to see more of katie and more of eva. i feel like eva’s story had a lot of potential, but the author kind of threw in a paragraph long summary at the very end of the book and called it a day.

all in all, not a terrible book, but i’m not going to lie in bed thinking about it. it’s a solid three.

as is often the case with “tough” ya contemporaries, i would seriously have liked to see some trigger warnings in some sort of a “before you read” page.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this book but I just couldn’t make it through. Just too slow for my tastes. DNF’d at 25%

Was this review helpful?