Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this fun book. The storyline and characters are equally absurd, but I found it hard to put down, and it certainly made me chuckle. I found the large number of characters difficult to keep track of (but not horrendously so) and my only real criticism is the spelling errors - e.g. Wedgewood. I would thoroughly recommend this as a light-hearted read.

Was this review helpful?

1930s Scotland.

The servants at Loch Down Abbey are dropping like flies from a mystery debilitating virus, but above stairs the family are more concerned with the lack of bathroom tissues and feral children (since Nanny has so inconveniently popped her clogs).

But then Lord Inverkillen is found dead in suspicious circumstances. The useless Inspector declares it an accident, but redoubtable housekeeper Mrs MacBain isn't so sure. Since the house is in lockdown, only someone on the inside can be the culprit. And with the family doing who knows what all day,. Mrs MacB (in the face of dwindling staff numbers and increasing workload) goes digging.

It's amazing what secrets are hidden....

Excellent :)

Was this review helpful?

In this quick and delightful read, Beth Cowan-Erskine takes elements of our current pandemic (the isolation, the quarantining), gives them a surprisingly playful spin and a 1930s setting, and introduces readers to the Ogilvy-Sinclair family, which is holed up at the family estate in rural Scotland, being attended to be their band of faithful (?) servants. With elements of Downtown Abbey, Gosford Park, and Clue, this novel takes the classics upstairs-downstairs trope and livens it up with details of family squabbles, pandemic, and murder most foul!

While I enjoyed most of this work, I do have to say that I had one major problem, especially early on - the large cast of characters. While a guide is provided at the beginning of the book (which, in hindsight, was also a warnings of sort of the large cast to come), keeping aristocratic titles and unusual names straight was a task. While it didn't put me off the task of reading Loch Down Abbey, mileage may vary by reader.

Was this review helpful?