Skip to main content

Member Reviews

*This book was received as an Advanced Reviewer's Copy from NetGalley.

Anything about food and history will be a draw for me. I like learning the origin of dishes, the trends of the past, and well, it's way better than the history courses in school because I get to pick the subject. This book covers a few areas of food (with a sardonic tone throughout), taking a hard look at some of the past foibles and current watch-outs for food.

Ranging from breakfast cereals (hello Kellogg and Graham and your uh, interesting, ways and beliefs). Olive oil (what is it really), tomatoes (definitely not good to eat), vanilla (the most favorite ice cream flavor ever), and others make their histories known in this book. While a lot of times it focuses on odd beliefs and the potential or real adulteration of foods, it also offers some look at just how the food entered the human diet and how popular it is today.

Overall, the book is kind of melancholy. It really gets to the not so nice history of these foods in most cases and while interesting, can be a bit like living in a shadow while you're reading the book. And I'm a bit scared of my olive oil now, but not enough to stop using it. I did enjoy the book though and learned a few new facts, and I appreciated the author's grim sense of humor or interjections of issues that only vaguely related to the food at hand, but were still poignant.

Review by M. Reynard 2021

Was this review helpful?

Written in a lush conversational style, this is not a concise reference guide, and that's just fine with me. I like the "I'm telling you secrets" tone of the book. It feels like I'm relaxing with a brandy after dinner and listening to that one distant cousin, you know, the odd one, tell shocking stories just out of earshot of the more genteel relatives.

And I have to confess, the 'short' list of aphrodisiacs had me laughing until I cried. I found the chapter on corn to be astounding in its scope and detail. I learned shocking things about honey. And much, much more. I'll need to re-read this book a few more times, there's just so much to be learned.

If you are squeamish when it comes to candid talk about human body functions and secretions, notably those of the sexual variety, consider yourself warned. There's also creepy stories. But, history is often gross and creepy, and that's no fault of the author. I enjoy learning about attitudes, superstitions, medical practices and more from humanity's past.

File "The Secret History of Food" next to "Ripley's Believe it or Not" on your reference shelf. Your cookbooks might be intimidated by it.

My thanks to author Matt Siegel, NetGalley, and Ecco publishing for allowing me to read a digital advance review copy of this book. This review is my honest and unbiased opinion.

Was this review helpful?

What a fun and interesting read about something we all indulge in, food. I particularly liked hearing the backstories of things that we consume, sometimes often and other times not.
This book is written for all to enjoy whether you are a foodie or not.

Was this review helpful?

A riveting and humorous look inside the history of some of our most basic foods, like apple pie, cold cereals, and chilies. The book seems well researched, and will easily become one of those sources of “random trivia knowledge” about food and its background. I can’t wait for the day a dystopian novel about a society post-corn-extinction comes to fruition.

The setup of this book would lend itself nicely to a sequel, a “volume two” or similar, expanding to discuss more foods. I would definitely read it if the author chooses to write another! I enjoyed the book, missed out on many of the informative and interesting footnotes due to the tedious task of clicking on footnote links in netgalley’s ebooks app (side note: bought a new kindle halfway through the book and what a difference!), but overall had a great reading experience with it.

Trigger warning note: there was one very short paragraph toward the end of chapter 9 in which the author quotes Paul Bloom, and I found it to be quite triggering and insensitive (re: self-harm), but that’s my only gripe.

Was this review helpful?

What an interesting look at the food we all eat. Everything from corn and honey to McDonalds and of course the wild and crazy history of breakfast cereal.
Entertaining and informational.

Was this review helpful?

Thought provoking, entertaining and at times unexpected, The Secret History of Food is a delight to read. Not an exhaustive or authoritative exploration of all types of foods, the information is humorous and geared for enjoyment, not compiled like an index. Although some of the information is shocking and gasp-worthy, as a whole, this book is pure fun.

Was this review helpful?

So entertaining, while being so informative! I had to share snippets of what I read with friends and family! It was a pleasure to read (and very hard to put down when I had to...) Not a good idea to read over a meal, however. Gross out factor, for me , anyway, was too high. Still I pushed on and thoroughly enjoyed every page! So many eye openers! I'd recommend this book to foodies everywhere. Kudos Matt Siegal! You certainly did your homework here!

Was this review helpful?

Matt Siegel’s "The Secret History of Food" proved to be a delightful feast for the mind. Every single individual chapter was rich in facts that ran the gamut from fascinating, to eye-opening, and often to flat-out startling. Even for the topics that I thought myself quite familiar with (for example, the peculiar origins of breakfast cereals in America), Siegal was able to provide a surprising wealth of new detail alongside his own witty and thoughtful commentary. It was the kind of entertainingly educational read that despite all of the information that it packed, I was able to devour it in what felt like no time, almost to my dismay.

Here is to hoping that the author provides second helpings with another book in the near future.

Was this review helpful?

Well, I want pie. But I want American-Style pie, not the pie of old Europe. I am also now somewhat uncomforable eating bread in public - because now I know….

The Secret History of Food is just plain fun! In this brief history of food, the author takes us on a worldwide journey of eating! Some of it (seriously…I want pie) will thrill you. Some of it (can we say Vagina Bread?) will startle you. And some things (I’m looking at you, Fidel Castro!) will amuse you. But all of it is fascinating!

The author’s style is so readable – I felt like I was reading food gossip. Not only did I enjoy every bit of it, I kept stopping to share tidbits with others.

A wonderfully entertaining book!

*ARC Provided via Net Galley

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyed every page of this wonderful book about food.Entertaining informative every foodie every cook everyone who loves to eat will devour this book.I will be recommending and giving this book as a gift to friends.#netgalley#ecco

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this. It was such a fun journey through foods, I cannot wait to buy my husband a copy! Thank you to Netgalley for the arc ebook!

Was this review helpful?