Cover Image: The Secret Garden

The Secret Garden

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I was pleasantly surprised to find a graphic novel version of this story. Here are my pros and cons for The Secret Garden:

Pros
1.	This is a great introduction to The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett. The graphic novel format may appeal to children who aren’t interested in reading novels yet.
2.	The story is heavy on illustrations and light on words, which may be attractive to reluctant readers (see Con 3).
3.	There is a glossary at the end of the book!!

Cons
1.	The imagery is nice and appropriate for a graphic novel. However, I wish the faces had been illustrated more realistically. Single lines and dots were used to depict facial features and expressions and it made the characters feel cartoonish. I understand this is a graphic novel, but the rest of the imagery is so nice that the simplistic humans felt a bit distracting to me. Note, however, that the targeted age group probably won’t mind or even notice this.
2.	Since I have read the original novel, I feel like this graphic novel format loses a lot of the depth and detail of the original story. However, the general story is still there, and it is clear what is happening on a basic level. 
3.	There were surprisingly few words in this graphic novel, so occasionally the reader must pay attention to the illustrations to make interpretations about what is going on. This isn’t a bad thing in and of itself, but young readers may miss some detail if they aren’t paying attention.

Summary 
While I think this graphic novel version is missing the depth and detail you get from the original story, I do believe it is a good introduction of this classic to children, particularly reluctant readers. Hopefully it inspires them to read the full story, too.

I also think this would be a nice gift book for fans of the original story or for those who enjoy collecting multiple editions of favorite books.

Thank you NetGalley and Andrews McMeel Publishing for a free eARC of this book, which I have reviewed honestly and voluntarily.
Was this review helpful?
This is a charming retelling of the classic story, reworked into a graphic novel for the younger reader.  As the Secret Garden was a favourite of mine when I was little, I was eager to see the new format.

The bare bones of the story remain intact: Mary, a spoiled child is sent to Misselthwaite Manor to live with an distant, widower uncle after the death of her parents.  In her loneliness, she befriends the servants and explores the grounds, discovering both a secret garden and her hitherto unknown, hypochondriac cousin, Colin.  The children's tending of the garden heals their own emotional wounds, and that of Colin's father (Mary's uncle).

It is a charming story, with a depth to it I never noticed previously.  Younger readers will benefit from this introduction into the classic.  The illustrations were sweet and whimsical, with excellent use of colour to enhance the mood of the scenes

For myself, though, I found the graphic novel format lacking some of the magic that one would otherwise find when losing oneself in a regular novel.

**Many thanks to Netgalley and
Andrews McMeel Publishing for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review**
Was this review helpful?
Such a cute rendition of a classic, with beautiful illustrations all throughout the book. Thanks again to NetGalley and Andrews McMeel Publishing for allowing me to read this ARC in exchange for feedback. 

If you’ve read the classic story, you’ll enjoy reading this graphic novel version that follows Mary all the way to Misselthwaite Manor, where you’ll meet some new friends and a secret just outside the manor! The adapter of this book is also the same person that adapted the “Anne of Green Gables” graphic novel, and Mariah Marsden does a fantastic job (again)! I just recently read the original story earlier this year, so seeing this copy on NetGalley made me excited for there to be a graphic novel version, so you bet I’ll be adding this one to my forever collection (and it releases on June 15th) 😊
Was this review helpful?
An updated graphic novel version of Frances Hodgson Burnett’s classic novel. When I saw this on NetGalley, I couldn’t say no, as I loved this book when I was younger. This version stays true to the original story, for the most part, but I felt that lacked something. The magic maybe? The found the illustrations to be average at best, and, although, I read through it quickly, I was disappointed. Young readers may enjoy it.
Was this review helpful?
The Secret Garden was one of my favourite classics when I was child. I enjoyed the book and movie growing up, and so I was very happy to read the graphic novel adaptation by Mariah Marsden and Hannah Luechtefeld. Thank you Andrew McMeels Publishing for the e-galley via NetGalley.

The graphic novel follows the original class as it was though with some storytelling changes that the author explains in the author’s note at the end. Mary Lennox’s upbringing in India with her colonialist parents are not explicitly discussed or delved into. Instead, the graphic novel focuses on the magic of the garden and the power of nature to change things for the better. For an adaptation of the original classic, I think that this was the right decision as there are definitely racist elements of the classic novel that would need to be re-evaluated by today’s readers. This graphic novel was an enjoyable and nostalgic return to a childhood classic and I think will connect with young readers today.
Was this review helpful?
This was such a sweet adaptation of the original. I appreciated the author's note on why she left out certain aspects of the original book and loved the glossary in the back as well. I love the story of The Secret Garden and felt the illustrations did an amazing job of capturing the essence of the story.
Was this review helpful?
This Francis Hodgson Burnett classic has been adapted into a fun graphic novel with all the essence of the original. After her parents pass away, Mary is sent to live on her Uncle Craven's manor, Misselthwait. There she makes friends with the servant, Martha, and her brother Dickon. It is suggested she play outside and soon discovers a locked-up secret garden on the grounds. But why is it locked up? And who belongs the terrible cries she keeps hearing in the middle of the night? The book has a nice biography of Burnett at the end with information about the places in the novel and a glossary to build vocabulary. Mariah Marsden and Hanna Luechtefeld did a wonderful job on this enchanting retelling!
Was this review helpful?
This book is unique because it connects to history and also I love the artwork it's simple in terms of just about enough illustration, yet it carries the beauty which goes perfectly with the story. Also, the narration I give not too much so it's easy and quick to read. What I like about this story carries a wave of excitement and little mystery that keeps the readers engaged with the story. Overall I love this book I don't see any that need to be fixed.
Was this review helpful?
This was essentially a retelling of The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett without much of the India backstory that is in the original book. I thought it was a fun retelling though and I enjoyed reading it. I don’t think anything particular really stuck out to me in this book and since it was a pretty similar plot to the original, there wasn’t really anything new aside from it being in graphic novel format. The artwork was beautifully done though and the font was easy to read which was great! I think this would be a nice story to read to a child or even just a nice way to reminisce on favourite stories from your childhood. Reading this book made me want to rewatch the 1993 version of The Secret Garden. Oh and I also appreciated the authour’s note regarding Marsden’s choices on including or cutting out parts of the original story.
Was this review helpful?
It is a beautiful book and full of expression.
.
The story is adapted to fit the vignettes, but the essence of the story is found between the drawings and the use of different tones.
I liked how art served as a tool to express the different moments and feelings of history. As the flowers begin to bloom, the colors come alive and the book has that  look of the story that have with every word.
.
I think it is an ideal book for children although I enjoy it a lot as an adult, is a must have in all library
.
Thanks to Andrew McNeel Publishing, for give me this beautiful book in exchange for my honest review
Was this review helpful?
I absolutely adored this graphic novel adaptation of The Secret Garden. I loved the original book and story, and the gorgeous illustrations certainly add to it even more. That magical feeling of the garden was depicted beautifully.

Normally I don't enjoy graphic novels that have very little text, because I feel that part of the story is missing, but I didn't experience that here so much. It might be because I was familiar with the tale already of because I was pulled in by the beauty of the illustrations. I especially loved the pages that had all these little drawings to get a feel of the scene, so pretty! I could just pribt out these pages and hang them on my wall.

That being said, I do still recommend either reading the original book first or combining it with the graphic novel to experience the full impact of it.
Was this review helpful?
This is a great retelling for a child more interested in graphic novels than regular novels or even classics. This retelling sums up all the best parts of The Secret Garden in an easy yet still magical way to read. The way it told the story in pictures held my interest and was beautiful. The backgrounds had more details than the characters but there was no problem with it. Some of the details of the classic story were glazed over but I'm not complaining because the core of the story is still there. I would recommend this to children wanting something new to read.
Was this review helpful?
Years ago, I loved that story. Thanks to this comic book, I fell in love even more. It was wonderful to come back to this story years later in this version. While it wasn't 100% in the artist's style at first, in the end I think this style adds to the charm of the story.
Was this review helpful?
One of my favorite childhood stories and movies. I liked this as a graphic novel but it felt a slight short and lacking for me, otherwise good read.

I just reviewed The Secret Garden by Mariah Marsden, Hanna Luechtefeld. #TheSecretGarden #NetGalley 
[NetGalley URL]
Was this review helpful?
I think that this is a great graphic adaptation of this classic that would go great in any children's room. I loved the illustrations and the adaptation of the story. You can't really go wrong with this one!
Was this review helpful?
A very sweet adaptation of the beloved novel. I appreciate the artwork and detail included I wish something new was brought to this version, something new to help it stand out compared to other versions of this work. But overall, it is a very nice little read with very pretty artwork. However, if you’re already very familiar with The Secret Garden there may not be as much for you here.
Was this review helpful?
5 STARS 
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
*********
This was such a fun fast and beautiful read that I received as an ARC from NetGalley. 
It’s the book that makes you nostalgic because you’ve definitely seen the cartoon as a kid and waited the weekend to end to see a new episode every week, you fell in love with Dicken and appreciated Mary, you felt every time for Colin and your heart sprang up in joy when he took his first step into the garden.
Seeing all this in illustrations made me super emotional, especially that the illustrations were super beautiful and creative and well done.
The pace of this was super enjoyable, nothing super detailed for a graphic novel and not one important detail missed out on, it was super enjoyable and fun and well done.
I will definitely be purchasing this book and reading it to my kids.
Was this review helpful?
This adaptation was short and sweet. I was missing the meat of the core plot lines and story of Frances Hodgson Burnett’s classic. It was very fluffy and that wasn’t always a good thing. I did like how the colour palette changed as the story progressed. It was a great tell on the different characters as the pages went on. I just wanted more of the original story to be a part of this graphic novel. Overall, I would recommend it to someone who is interested in Victorian literature but would like to start in an easier place. 

I received a free arc from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
LOVE IT.
I SIMPLY LOVE IT.
AMAZING
The illustrations are good. The story MY GAWD. 
Sending love from Mexico.
Was this review helpful?
I received a free e-ARC from the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

This is a re-imagining of the book “The Secret Garden” by Frances Hodgson Burnett. For me, this was a short, easy read and I really enjoyed the drawing style of this graphic novel. This book follows the same story line as the classic, so this is perfect for anyone who has an aversion to reading classic literature. I personally have never read the original book, so I decided to give this graphic novel a try in order to at least know the basics of the story.

I commend the author for leaving out Mary’s time in India before returning to England because, as she writes in the afterword, it doesn’t “do justice to the history British oppression in colonial India.” I like that the author was conscientious of the fact that times change and classics don’t need to be adapted word for word. She chose to be mindful of those who would be offended by the misrepresentation of historical events. 

I believe that this book did a good job of telling the story in an accessible way. If you have never read “The Secret Garden” or are a fan of the original text, I think both parties will enjoy this adaptation.
Was this review helpful?