Cover Image: Beautiful Country

Beautiful Country

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Beautiful Country by Qian Julie Wang is a memoir told through the eyes of a child as her family struggles to survive in America. In China, Qian’s parents were well educated and respected professors. Qian’s parents do not agree with the Chinese political system and wishing for a better life come to America on visitor Visas. Overstaying their Visas, the family remain in America as undocumented Chinese living in constant fear. They remain in the shadows of NYC to avoid being discovered, arrested and deported back to China. Working menial low paying jobs for long hours and little pay, the family is barely able to exist. They live in inadequate housing sharing a bathroom and kitchen with other desperate families. There is little food and “shopping days” are their only means of acquiring clothing and everyday household items. The Wang family’s fears, stresses, struggles and desperation is a story of people trying to find a better world for themselves and their families and the means by which they are willing to go to achieve that life.

Was this review helpful?

Moving story of a young girl brought to the US from China at 5 years old. Her parents, college professors in China, wanted a better life and freedom to think. Her story was an eye opening look at the difficulties that immigrants, especially illegal immigrants face and how hard they work for little benefit. The ultimately happy ending for most characters was welcome, but it also made you think of how many were not as lucky.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I love to read and I love to learn and this book took care of both of these things. This book is a great teaching tool for all people. It follows Qian who is just a young girl when she arrives in America. It provides an understanding of exactly what people who immigrate to America go through. The constant struggles in many different areas as well as always being afraid that you will not be allowed to stay here. The experiences of school and "jobs" were very interesting. I do not know what kind of ideas I was harboring as to how immigrants acclimate to America but these were not them. Congratulations to her on a successful life and a great book.

Was this review helpful?

Intriguing and thought provoking. As I read Beautiful Country I was sad as I realized how much this” Beautiful Country has missed by ignoring the gifts immigrants bring to us. The creativity and talent we’ve overlooked. And how much more beautiful and what a better country we would be if we only could see that. This is the authors honest and brave retelling of her childhood. I commend her for a story well told.
We Often see immigration as a political issue. In this story it is a human issue. It Challenges us to do better. We can do so much better. I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

This review will be posted on August 27, 2021 to: https://instagram.com/amandas.bookshelf

This memoir was so powerful! @qianjuliewang writes with honesty, bravery, and eloquence about her five years in the USA as an undocumented person starting when she was seven. Her child's perspective on the poverty and hardship she and her parents experienced were intermixed with moments of joy, like getting lost in books after she taught herself English or making her first real friend. Wang's memoir serves to remind us - especially those of us privileged enough to not have our legal residency or citizenship questioned - that behind the inflammatory vocal bombs the culture warmongers levy about "the illegals" are real humans. Real people who are marginalized into silence and fear, while also vulnerable to xenophobic attacks, sexual assault, wage theft, malnutrition, poverty, and neverending worry and anxiety. Wang's commanding memoir needs to be read by all to start to understand what it really means to be undocumented. But, above all, she needs to commended for sharing her most painful childhood trauma with the world. Thank you, Qian Julie Wang. #BeautifulCountry Rating: 😊 / really liked it

This book is scheduled for publication on September 7, 2021. Thank you @doubledaybooks for providing me this digital ARC via @NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the advanced copy of this book.

Definitely 5 stars. Probably a top rear for this year.

Such a compelling story. Not just a story of an undocumented immigrant but that of a child. So many vivid details. Heartbreaking at times but a story of true perseverance. Not only to live it but to share it here. It wasn’t so much about her fears of being caught but rather her day to day suffering. From their meager existence. Living in substandard conditions. Working in sweatshops. “Shopping” days in the trash. Barely enough money for food. An illness that nearly kills her mother. So much trauma. But she bears it all. And in the end to see she not only finds the freedom she had sought but achieves the dream of becoming a lawyer where she can now champion for those like her. What a story. What a story to share.

I am grateful to have read it.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was a very interesting, well written and honest personal account of a Chinese child who grew up as an "illegal alien" (if that term is still used) in New York City. Besides reading about the various challenges that she and her parents encountered in terms of employment, housing and education, we get insight into the psyche of the writer - how her experiences affected her. I was only disappointed that the writer didn't give more details about a life-changing conversation she tells about at the end of the book.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful Country: A Memoir by Qian Julie Wang
Doubleday, 2021 (2021)
Hardcover, e-Book
* * * Reviewed by Barbara Lingens

Mei Guo (America in Mandarin) literally translates as 'beautiful country,' and this is the story of how an immigrant Chinese family experiences it. Seven-year-old Qian arrives with her Ma Ma to join Ba Ba, who had left two years earlier. When she sees him again, he looks different. And pretty soon Ma Ma will also look different. In China, Qian's parents were professionals and relatively well off. In New York, because they have no papers, Ma Ma has to work at a sweatshop and Ba Ba at a laundromat.

Qian is pretty precocious, and through her eyes we see how her family lives in their new China - Brooklyn. Their home is on the second floor in a single room next to a bedroom that hosts revolving families of immigrants. All share a bathroom. Dinner might be one slice of pizza for the three of them.

Fear and shaming quickly become part of their lives. Qian is told not to talk to anyone, not to trust anyone, and to stay away from police officers. She and Ma Ma are called chinks, and people pull at the corners of their eyes and make faces at them.

The author does a beautiful job in making us see how bewildering it all is for Qian to try to make sense of the world around her. She is a young girl in a strange and scary new world, with her parents confounded by their inability to master their new surroundings. At the same time she has her own difficulties: her constant hunger, trouble in school and her lack of friends or adults to whom she might turn for help and advice.

Finally though, Ma Ma gets on her feet, and they are on their way. For me, the memoir could have ended with Chapter 30. The next one fast forwards 10 years, and I miss the young Qian's take on her world - she has grown up. Also there is a great deal of information in this last chapter, and it seems a bit confusing. Nevertheless Beautiful Country provides valuable insight into what a young stranger can experience in a world we take for granted because we speak the language and we aren't poor.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful and engaging story. Cant stop reading it. Really recommend this to everyone about authors experiences as her family left china for a new life.
I highly recommend this book.

Thank you to Doubleday Books, and NetGalley for the ARC.


https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4112075798

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful story and sharing of suffering in a country meant to be beautiful for everyone. I’m not sure the book was as connected as it could be - stories aligned with thoughts and perceptions, but definitely full of heart. Wang was and is full of resiliency, which jumps from each page.

Was this review helpful?

A lovely memoir on immigration to the US. I really enjoyed the writing because she was able to capture her voice so well during the age she was going through these things. The word choices and way of explaining things as she understood the world at that time was amazing to read. It felt like you were reading the story in real time growing up with her and her family as they adjusted to such a new way of living for them. I am so grateful to have been able to read and review and ARC of this! Thank you so much NetGalley, Qian Julie Wang and Doubleday for allowing be the opportunity to read this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful Country is a memoir about an immigrant to the US. This is a beautifully written book that we should all read to understand different perspectives of immigrants. While this story may be slow moving at times, I think it is because it truly revels in the fear and trauma, and sometime it is hard to swallow that someone lives in this state.
The emotional drain of Qian's story is real. However, it is eye opening and highlights some of the challenges immigrants, undocumented and the underprivileged have experienced in our country.

Was this review helpful?

A beautifully written book about the authors experiences as she and her parents left china for a “better” life in Mei Guo, which translates to “beautiful Country”, the United States.
With high hopes yet fear of the unknown Qian and her family arrive in their new country, in stages. First the father went over and then later Qian and her mother go to meet him, in 1994, in NYC, she was 7 yrs old at the time..
Leaving your homeland is scary enough but arriving in a country where your hard work is not recognized is very hard. In China both of Qians parents were Professors , but once in the USA and Illegal, they must find what ever work they can, usually sweatshops or some factory to try and make ends meet, quite often hungry and living in horrible shared housing.
But the whole family are go getters and try their hardest to work their way to a better life.
Qian would sometimes help her mother in the sweatshops, but was able to go to
school, where she did well, she was very smart and loved to read and spent a lot of time going to the library where she learned to read in English.
This is a story of resilience, coming up from an invisible person, which Immigrant are quite often, to showing the world who you really are.
The book and story of Qian and her families from their trials and tribulations, to always envisioning a brighter future.
We have to be more aware of what people are going through as Immigrant and always offer a welcome.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful Country is an engaging personal account of the little-known or poorly understood life of American immigrants. It is exceptionally well written, and its vivid imagery depicts the journey's struggles on so many fronts: personal experience, how it plays out in the family, and the emmense swath of losses, from a sense of self and belonging, generational continuity, nurturing home-life, security, profession, joy, health and dignity. They are replaced with uncertainty of food and shelter, bigotry, intimidation, gut-wrenching impact of pernicious nationalism, injustice, threats and fear. It illuminates the shameful aspects of the America we thought we knew.

The book is about crushing injustice, love, personal resilience and true patriotism. I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Lovingly written memoir about the Chinese immigrant experience in New York City in the mid 1990s. And excellent choice for your next book club.

Was this review helpful?

I am in love with this awe-inspiring look into the author's childhood. It was raw yet full of heart. The moments of reflection were deep and thought provoking. An emotional read.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Doubleday Books and NetGalley, whom I deeply thanks. Opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A haunting book that is beautifully written - so much so that it leaves you feeling unsettled as you read about the traumatic experiences of the author's undocumented immigrant experience. While it is ultimately hopeful, there is a lot to process as you walk away from this.

Was this review helpful?

This memoir was incredible. The story of growing up undocumented was beautifully written. The words melted like butter. I would give this book 100 stars.

Was this review helpful?

This is a hard-hitting book, that is sometimes hard to read, but really beautiful. For anyone coming to America can be hard and this really shows the struggles that some end up going through.

Thanks NetGalley for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful Country
By Qian Julie Wang
Pub Date: 2021
Publisher: Doubleday/ Penguin Random House LLC

A memoir that covers the first few years author Qian Julia Wang spent in the United States. A first person, present tense, voice brings you into the mind of elementary aged Qian as she navigates life as an undocumented immigrant, and it was not an easy one. Adult fears and responsibility are mixed with the simple hopes of any child for popular toys and loyal friends. Because our writer is telling this from her childhood perspective she takes moments to pull back and reflect on what she understands as an adult. These new understandings help to emphasize how young our author is when she carries and outsized idea of responsibility for her parents and the overall well being of the family. What I loved was the funny honesty about her development as a kid, the phases of lying and scheming that all kids move through as they grow up reminded me of being a kid. A great read for adults and teens. I would suggest parents and teachers read this while guiding younger kids through a book like “Front Desk,” by Kelly Yang.

Was this review helpful?