Cover Image: The Return of the Pharaoh

The Return of the Pharaoh

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

An intriguing new tale of Sherlock Holmes.

I am an avid Sherlock Holmes fan and have read and listened to all of the stories, so it was so wonderful to have a new addition. This was my first of Meyer’s Holmes tales and I am definitely interested in reading more. As a Sherlock Holmes super fan, I mean my 3 start review as a compliment — I definitely thought I would end up disliking it, but I thoroughly enjoyed this read. I highly recommend for anyone interested in Holmes, and I think fellow fans will also find it a worthwhile read.

There were definitely moments where I found myself lost in the story as if Arthur Conan Doyle wrote it himself, but overall, it was clearly written though a modern lens. The story was quite Watson-heavy, which gave him a much more active role. Counter to that, Holmes was not his usual, perfect, all-knowing self; this made him seem like a much more real-life detective and I missed Holmes’ magic. The story itself was interesting, though it would have made for a stronger short story or novella in my opinion — and perhaps it would have been more concise  if Holmes were sharper. 

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NeGalley for the ARC!
Was this review helpful?
*received for free from netgalley for honest review* 4.5 really lied this book! i will be reading the other books in this series! one of the better sherlock spin offs, really love the way its written!
Was this review helpful?
I did not realize this was the 6th book in the author’s Sherlock and Watson series, but I loved this book and will go back to read the others! I am always interested in Egyptology, so Holmes and Watson on a case there was very appealing and Nicholas Meyer does a great job of taking the reader right there with them. Also love that the author is a fellow Iowa Hawkeye!
Was this review helpful?
Dr. Watson brings his second wife, Juliet, to Egypt to cure her tb. He runs into Sherlock, who is looking for a missing nobleman. They join forces. In Return of the Pharoah, the game is once again afoot!

This author does the best job of the many writers trying to replicate Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The prose reads exactly like the original novels. There are a lot of obscure words and setting the scene going on, which you may or may not enjoy. The thrill of seeing Sherlock’s enormous brain solve the puzzle by deductive reason is not really evident as the mystery’s solution was easy to unravel. However, the unusual setting still made Return of the Pharoah a 4-star read for me.

Thanks to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for a copy in exchange for my honest review.
Was this review helpful?
“Return” is a terrific addition to the Sherlock Holmes genre.  

Holmes and Watson travel to Egypt to discover some of the secrets of the pyramids.  With cameo appearances from some famous Egyptologists, including Howard Carter, the story was fast-moving, engaging, and true to the genre.  I hope Nicholas Meyer continues to “discover” more of Watson’s work!

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Was this review helpful?
My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher St. Martin's Press for an advanced copy.
 
 
From the blurb:
 
In 1910, Dr. John Watson travelled to Egypt with his wife Juliet. Her tuberculosis has returned and her doctor recommends a stay at a sanatorium in a dry climate. But while his wife undergoes treatment, Dr. Watson bumps into an old friend--Sherlock Holmes, in disguise and on a case. An English Duke with a penchant for Egyptology has disappeared, leading to enquiries from his wife and the Home Office.

Holmes has discovered that the missing duke has indeed vanished from his lavish rooms in Cairo and that he was on the trail of a previous undiscovered and unopened tomb. And that he's only the latest Egyptologist to die or disappear under odd circumstances. With the help of Howard Carter, Holmes and Watson are on the trail of something much bigger, more important, and more sinister than an errant lord.
 
My thoughts:
 
This is the author’s fifth Sherlock story (Note to self: Get the other 4!!) It is such beautifully written and the way Nicholas describes Egypt (from their way of life through a history lesson of the different Pharaohs up to an actual sand storm!). It’s very authentic of the Egypt of the 1900's. It's like you're actually there. It shows he has really done his research.
 
Also love the footnotes at the end of every chapter which explains references of his other stories, a welcome addition to first time readers.
 
As a long time Sherlock fan I’ve read a lot of great books but the way the author portrays the detective, it’s something hard to explain, differently to other writers. I shall edit the review when I find the right words!!.
Was this review helpful?
The Return of the Pharaoh: From the Reminiscences of John H. Watson, M.D. (Sherlock Holmes Pastiche by Nicholas Meyer #5) by Nicholas Meyer is a fun new Holmes story. Meyer usually always does a good job bringing Holmes and Watson to life and their world as well. I can't resist Holmes or ancient Egypt and this contains a cool combination with a good core mystery. I'm glad Nicholas Meyer got to spend the Covid-19 lockdown working on this new story at least.
Was this review helpful?
I have an entire bookshelf dedicated to the original stories,  retellings,  and new adventures of Sherlock Holmes. I just can't get enough of the character! My shelf, of course, has an old hardback copy of The Seven Percent Solution by this author. When I saw this new book by Meyer, I knew I had to read it. I enjoyed his 2019 book The Adventure of the Peculiar Protocols, and I enjoyed this new story too! 

It is 1910. Dr. Watson heads to Egypt with his wife, who suffers from Tuberculosis. While his wife is resting and receiving treatment, Watson unexpectedly bumps into his old friend, Sherlock Holmes. Holmes is investigating a case....and Watson (of course) gets sucked into it with him. With the help of a soon-to-be-famous archeologist, the two old friends are on the case! 

Loved this book! Lots of descriptions of Egypt, archaelogy in the early 1900s, the political climate at the time....all wrapped up within a great Sherlock investigation! 

I'm definitely on-board to read more of these Watson's Journals/Sherlock mystery tales by Nicholas Meyer. They have the feel of the originals by Arthur Conan Doyle and always keep my attention from start to finish! And, the front cover is awesome!

**I voluntarily read a review copy of this book from St Martins Press. All opinions expressed are entirely my own.**
Was this review helpful?
The Return of the Pharaoh by Nicholas Meyer
David Robb, Narrator
Part of the Sherlock Holmes Pastiche Series.
Thanks to Netgalley for the book and the audiobook. So this is my opinion for both.
This was very enjoyable for me because I love Sherlock Holmes and also the Egyptian setting of 1910. The author is a film writer and director and the book does have a somewhat cinematic quality. 
The narration was good. The only thing I disliked about the audiobook was the addition of footnotes which were an annoying interruption to the story for me. They were mostly unneeded for anyone who is a student of the Holmes canon or has an interest in Egypt or the history of the era. In the book they can be ignored but not with the audio.
I plan to go back and read earlier books in this series but this book could certainly be read as a standalone.
Was this review helpful?
Watson and Holmes Meet in Egypt

It’s 1911. Watson is taking his wife Juliet to Cairo for treatment of her recent bout of tuberculosis. Watson is happy to support his wife, but her treatment regimen is very strict, and he’s hardly able to see her. He wanders around Cairo becoming bored until he goes into a bar and sees a fellow who he is sure is wearing his regimental tie. He can tell by the spot. 

Of course, the man turns out to be Holmes in disguise. He’s on the trail of the Duke of Uxbridge. He came Egypt to search for a missing tomb. His mistress hasn’t heard from him and believes that the circumstances of his disappearance are suspicious. Holmes has been tasked with the investigation and now that Watson has appeared he is a welcome addition to the team. 

It’s an interesting time in Cairo. Not only are numerous adventurers looking for hidden tombs, but the international situation comes into play. The British, French and the Egyptians themselves want to control the country, not to mention the importance of the Suez Canal. It’s ripe for a good Holmes adventure with overtones of international intrigue. 

Nicholas Meyer does a good job recreating the Holmes era. This book is reminiscent of his first novel, the Seven Percent Solution. I am not a fan of many recreations of the Holmes Watson partnership, but this is a good one. 

The story starts slowly with Watson’s travel to Egypt and getting Juliet settled, but it quickly picks up when Holmes comes on the scene. The pace accelerates to that of a thriller. The history is accurate and the glimpses of the Nile and Egyptian archaeology are well done. If you’re a fan of Sherlock, this is a good one. 

I received this book from St. Martin’s Press for this review.
Was this review helpful?
Nicholas Meyer's "The Return of the Pharaoh" takes place in 1910-1911.  Dr. John Watson, who did well financially from his published accounts of Sherlock Holmes's exploits, sails from London to Egypt with his wife, Juliet. Upon arrival, she checks into the Al-Wadi sanitarium, where she will be treated for tuberculosis.  Over a month later, Watson is touring Cairo when he unexpectedly runs into Holmes, who is in disguise and traveling under an assumed name. Soon, the two team up to locate Michael, Duke of Uxbridge, who had shown an interest in excavating Egyptian tombs for the gold that might be hidden within.  The duke's wife, Lizabetta, hired Holmes to find her husband, who vanished approximately three months earlier.  She had previously appealed in vain to Scotland Yard and London's Foreign Office for assistance in finding Michael.

Holmes and Watson consult Egyptologist Howard Carter (who would later achieve worldwide fame for discovering King Tut's tomb).  Along the way, an informant is murdered, Holmes and Watson take a harrowing train ride to Luxor, and both nearly lose their lives in a grisly manner.  Meyer vividly describes the sights and sounds of Egypt, and he deftly incorporates the theme of stolen treasures into his narrative.  Over many years, unscrupulous fortune-hunters have looted ancient Egyptian tombs of their precious artifacts.

"The Return of the Pharaoh" is not as exciting or intellectually stimulating as Meyer's earlier novels.  The first half is particularly talky and slow-moving.  Fortunately, when Holmes and Watson are close to reaching their goal, the plot picks up somewhat. One of the liveliest scenes takes place during a khamsin, a violent sandstorm, and the concluding confrontation pits Holmes and his associates against a band of merciless killers.  Overall, however, this mundane mystery adds little of interest to the Holmes canon.
Was this review helpful?
I received a complimentary ARC copy of The Return of the Pharaoh, From the Reminiscences of John H. Watson, M.D. by Nicholas Meyer from NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press/Minotaur Books in order to read and give an honest review.

” …I found it an interesting and intriguing read that I would definitely recommend …”

I have always been a fan of author Arthur Conan Doyle and have always loved stories that bring the brilliant duo of Sherlock Holmes and John Watson back to life. I previously reviewed The Adventure of the Peculiar Protocols by Nicholas Meyer and thoroughly enjoyed it and I am glad to say that The Return of the Pharaoh did not disappoint. Studying Egyptology, I am always drawn to fiction that pays homage to the topic I love. The author did brilliantly, intertwining ancient Egyptian history with a well written complex mystery true to the Sherlock Holmes legacy.

Nicholas Meyer’s The Return of the Pharaoh takes Sherlock to Egypt in 1911, hired by a Duchess to find her missing husband the Duke of Uxbridge who was hunting down the undiscovered tomb of Thutmose V. While not immediately on the case Dr. John Watson also happens to be in Egypt with his wife while she is receiving treatment for her damaged lungs. Watson joins Sherlock on the case and as always, the game is afoot. The story is full of twists, turns and double crosses as the plot builds at a slow (albeit at times too slow) rate but with a brilliant pulse-pounding ending. Meyer gives the readers a dynamic cast of characters one of which is the infamous Egyptologist, Howard Carter who becomes a central character in the book and Holmes is rendered a more “human” and multifaceted character than we’ve seen him before.

I have to say, although as I mentioned it was slow to get into at first, I enjoyed it and found it an interesting and intriguing read that I would definitely recommend!
Was this review helpful?
1910 November Due to the illness of his wife Juliet, she and Dr Watson arrange to stay in Cairo for her treatment. Several months later Dr Watson discovers Holmes, disguised as a Colonel Arbuthnot, on a case. That of the missing Duke of Uxbridge. And so the adventure begins.
An entertaining and well-written historical mystery, with its cast of likeable and varied characters. Another good addition to the series which can easily be read as a standalone story.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
The Return of the Pharaoh by Nicholas Meyer is possibly the last published work of fictional character, Dr. John H Watson, assistant to the great Sherlock Holmes. Although they end up being in Egypt for different reasons, Watson is once again at Holmes side has he looks for a missing man. Watson is there with his second wife, Juliet, who is suffering from tuberculosis and is in Egypt seeking dry air and a curative retreat. Watson is only able to see his wife for small periods of time and so is thankful for Holmes' appearance. Holmes is being shadowed by his quarry's wife, which is an inconvenience, to be sure. There is a huge divide between the English in Egypt and the native population and their Turkish overlords. Holmes is, however, hot on his trail. 

Meyer is able to write pretty much as Watson would have: very formally. He has an imagination much like that of Conan Doyle and leads all readers on a merry chase. The ins and outs of the case, and the interesting characters are simply a portion of what makes this work fascinating. Maybe is foreignness? May be exotic characters, foreign or otherwise? Whatever the reason, the journey is compelling and certainly exemplifies the interest the world had in Egypt and its treasure at this time. It is a true journey into the past. 

I was invited to read a free e-ARC of The Return of the Pharaoh by Minotaur Books, through Netgalley. All thought and opinions are mine. #netgalley #minotaur #nicholasmeyer #thereturnofthepharaoh
Was this review helpful?
What a treat, a new Holmes and Watson from the pen of Nicholas Meyer. Watson and his wife, Juliet have traveled to Egypt in 1910 because of her TB and a warm dry climate is advised. This is the time of Howard Carter, King Tut, tombs and pharaohs. Watson is delighted to discover that Holmes is on a case and while Juliet rests, Watson joins in the investigation.
Holmes is trying to find the 11th Duke of Uxbridge, an amateur Egyptologist on his annual dig. His wife hasn't heard anything from him for several months and she has hired Holmes. The Duke was on the hunt for an undiscovered tomb in the Valley of the Kings. As Howard Carter found King Tut, the Duke wants one of his own. Has he run afoul of others on the same quest? Another adventure for Holmes and Watson takes the reader on a wonderful tour of Cairo, tombs, pyramids with many surprises on the way.
Many authors have written the further cases of Holmes and Watson - some better than others - but Nicholas Meyer is, to this reader, top notch. I enjoyed every page and will eagerly read the next book.
My thanks to the publisher Minotaur and to NetGalley for giving me an advance copy in exchange for my honest review.
Was this review helpful?
After the death of his first wife, Dr. Watson married Juliet, who was later diagnosed with tuberculosis.  With a recommendation from her doctor, Watson takes her to a sanitarium in Cairo for treatment.  As Juliet works with the doctors Watson sets out to explore the city.  At one bar he meets Colonel Arbuthnot.  Watson recognizes his regimental tie, which he had left behind on Baker Street.  Sherlock Holmes is once again in disguise as he searches for the Duke of Uxbridge, who disappeared while looking for the tomb of Thutmose.  The Duke is not the first egyptologist to disappear and Sherlock has been hired by his wife to find him.  She is arriving shortly in Cairo and demanding a quick resolution.  Juliet is not happy that Watson has joined Sherlock in his search, but he promises that he is not getting involved in anything dangerous.  Some promises, however, are impossible to keep.

Sherlock discovers that the duke was involved with an exotic dancer named Fatima, who has also disappeared.  With the help of Howard Carter, Sherlock and Watson trace the duke to the Valley of the Kings.  Joined by Carter and his client, Sherlock and Watson depart by train for Karnak.  Their arrival is delayed when the train is stopped by a khamsin, a tornado of sand that leaves several passengers dead and Watson injured.  The duke was searching for a previously undiscovered tomb and the possible treasures to be found but the question remains whether he found a treasure and disappeared or did he become a victim like the other egyptologists?

Nicholas Meyer has brought back the Sherlock Holmes that fans love.  His deductions and disguises continue to amaze Watson.  While Watson tries to shield Juliet from some of the dangers they encounter, he underestimates her awareness.  She knows that working with Sherlock comes with peril and insists that he be honest with her and proceed with caution.  Meyer’s story also raises the problem of cultural items that are taken from the country of origin for display in foreign museums or for private collections.  From the back alleys of Cairo to the grand pyramids this is a story that will please Sherlockians.  I would like to thank NetGalley and St. Martin Press/Minotaur for providing this book fo my review.
Was this review helpful?
Another fine entry in the pastiche of Arthur Conan Doyle. Watson is Eygpt bound in 1910 seeking warmer, dryer air in hopes of curing his wife of tuberculosis. While Juliet is undergoing treatment Watson bumps into Holmes undercover on a case seeking a missing Egyptologist. Finding that their clients husband isn’t the first Egyptologist to go missing or be killed Holmes and Watson find themselves drawn into an intriguing case. Given ARC copies of the audio book and ebook from the publisher through Netgalley I found myself returning to the audio book more than the ebook. David Robb with occasional footnotes from author Nicholas Meyer nails Watson’s voice.
Was this review helpful?
I really enjoy Nicholas Meyer novels and this was no exception. Lots of twists and turns, leaving you guessing throughout. The plot was complex until the end. Great read. Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the advance read copy!
Was this review helpful?
Nicholas Meyer's The Return of the Pharaoh is an adventure set in the later years of the illustrious detective and his faithful friend that takes them to Egypt in 1911 to track down the missing Duke of Uxbridge, who was on a treasure hunt of a never-opened pharaonic tomb. Nicholas Meyer, of course, is a celebrated author and director who has penned his own unique Sherlock Holmes mysteries and has helped Captain Kirk navigate through equally turbulent voyages. 

In The Return of the Pharaoh, Meyer’s writing is top notch. His style is completely immersive not only of the period but also of the location. And man, is it terribly boring. 

While Dr. Watson finds himself in Egypt with his wife, he learns that Sherlock Holmes is also there on a case helping a Duchess tracking down her missing husband. Instead of finding the duke, the pair find a trail of corpses leading them to the sealed tomb of pharaoh Tuthmose V. 

The plot could have been loaded with enough snares and traps to make Indiana Jones jealous of Holmes’ remarkable intelligence as each is thwarted. The long Star of Egypt train ride the heroes embark upon could have thick with an Agatha Christie mystery. Alas, other than a rather exciting sandstorm they become trapped in, neither of those instances occur. Holmes sips tea and postulates. Watson complains and stays loyal. The story is overall entertaining but well short of magnificence. 

Perhaps modern-day fans are too comfortable with Robert Downey, Jr’s pugilist Holmes, or Benedict Cumberbatch’s Sherlock with the hip scarves and Siri-like recall. And both, by the way, are fantastic adaptations. The Return of the Pharaoh is akin to seeing movie action heroes well past their prime trying to perform in one last escapade. Like Eastwood, Sutherland, and Garner in Space Cowboys. The memory of their tales are broad and snappy and, when needed, menacing. Unfortunately, time dulls any such danger. And a Sherlock Holmes mystery should be anything but dull. 


Many thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for an advanced copy of this new mystery. I remain a steadfast fan of Nic Meyer.
Was this review helpful?
Holmes and Watson in Egypt – what a treat…

Nicholas Meyer has been “editing” the posthumous memoirs of John H Watson, MD, for decades, albeit rather sporadically, starting with The Seven-Per-Cent Solution, which came out in 1974, and won a Gold Dagger Award.   Now he’s come out with a fifth rip-roaring Holmes and Watson tale, The Return of the Pharaoh, which, as you might guess, is set in Egypt in the early part of the 1900s.  And although I was a little nervous about whether this most recent book could keep up with my fond memories of Meyer’s earlier ones, I needn’t have worried.    The Return of the Pharaoh grabbed me at (almost) the beginning and kept me amused and intrigued to the very end.  

As the case opens, Watson is travelling with his wife, Juliet, to Cairo, where they hope the regimen at the Al Wadi sanitarium will help her overcome her recent bout of tuberculosis.  But Juliet’s treatment schedule is quite strict, so Watson finds himself somewhat at loose ends.   Until, of course, he runs into Sherlock Holmes, who is (gasp! horror!)  wearing Watson’s old regimental tie as part of a disguise.    It seems that Holmes has been retained to look for yet another English aristocrat, the Duke of Uxbridge, who apparently was bitten by the mania for Egyptology (or perhaps just the mania for gold), before disappearing in suspicious circumstances.    

But there may be more to the tale.  As Meyer points out (via Mycroft Holmes), Cairo at the time was a hotbed of international intrigue:  although the Khedive nominally owed allegiance to the Ottoman Sultan in Istanbul, England wielded vast influence, rendering Egypt practically a colony.  And all the while the Egyptians quite understandably wanted their country for themselves.   In addition, there was still a big French presence from Napoleon’s days, and of course, everybody wanted control of the Suez Canal.   Whew!  Against this backdrop, was Uxbridge really the bumbler he appeared to be, or something more?   And what about his mysterious mistress, who appears to have disappeared along with the Duke?    I followed along with pleasure as Holmes and Watson tracked down clues, visited archaeological sites, headed up the Nile, and finally figured it all out.

I had only one minor issue with The Return of the Pharoah, which was that the introduction detailing the present-day history of Watson’s journals seemed a bit labored to me.  But I forgot all about it as soon as the case got going, and thus it wasn’t a big deal.   And one bit of advice - don’t forget to read the brief footnotes as you go.  These range from merely informative to downright funny, but shouldn’t be skipped – even if you normally hate footnotes!

All-in-all, The Return of the Pharaoh is well worthy of Watson and Holmes, and gets five-stars from me.    And finally, two disclosures.  First, I received an advance review copy from the publisher, Minotaur Books, and from NetGalley.   My thanks to them.  And second, I myself am a fan of Egypt and Egyptian history, and thus probably predisposed to like The Return of Pharaoh, just for its setting and historical background alone.   But I think Meyer does a great job making sure all readers have the background they need, and the book will appeal to Egyptophiles and non-Egyptophiles alike.
Was this review helpful?