Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This book is a lot of fun. It’s very similar to The Hunger Games, but with magic and a lot more morally grey characters.

The magic system in this book is easy to follow and I liked contemplating whether each character’s decisions were “right” or “wrong”. I think because they are all so morally grey, you really question what you’d do in their situation. I enjoyed doing those mental gymnastics with them.

The only thing I didn’t love was the pacing and how the book ended. It took me some time to get into the story because there was a ton of world building. By the time the action is starting, the book quickly ends.

I’d recommend going into this book knowing that you’ll be left hanging, but it seems like it should be worth it for book two.

I received an eARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I like the way it's written and the characters are interesting to follow. I like the inner thoughts displayed in italics, it always makes it more fun to listen to the character.

Was this review helpful?

YA Fantasy Suspense. There can only be one winner; who will survive the onslaught of spells to place their family on top?! This novel has the feel of a spell-casting Hunger Games -- one family member hopes to survive by utilizing cunning strategy, spell-casting skills, and historical perspective. Young adults who love fantasy will appreciate the storytelling and competitive nature of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

I loooved this book! It was like the hunger games but all participants are careers. The seven leading families are cursed to compete in a tournament every 20 years. They each select a champion to enter and it’s a fight to the death with the victors family having control of the high magic until the next tournament. It was brutal and shocking at times and while I did guess some things that happened there were plenty of times when I was shocked! The main characters are villains but there were times when I pitied them or warmed to them in some way, and one storyline touched my heart so much! If you liked the hunger games and game of thrones then snatch this up.
Thank you to netgalley and Macmillan tor for supplying the arc of this wonderful book

Was this review helpful?

I've been a fan of Amanda's since Ace of Shades and this dark and disturbing book gave me serious Maggie Stiefvater and Roshani Chokshi vibes.

I love books with multiple POVs and morally Grey characters. Add in unique magic and a murderous plot point and I was hooked. I'm looking forward to recommending it to my club closer to release.

Was this review helpful?

TW // grief, death, violence, gore, murder, blood, mentions of suicide and suicidal ideation

I heard ‘Hunger Games but with Magic’ and immediately I was intrigued. Next thing I know I hear it has queer rep and got even more excited! I was like, okay, cool so this is gonna be about a bunch of morally gray, murderous teenagers who are gay? Sign me up! After actually reading the ARC, though, All of Us Villains did not completely live up to my expectations.

To be fair, I didn’t know that there would be LGBT rep until I already started reading, so I didn’t even expect much in that department. However, from what I remember from my reading this book, there was only one openly LGBTQ character and his sexuality is only touched on very briefly. It’s easy to miss if you’re not paying close attention. If something went over my head, I apologize. He doesn’t really specify his sexuality, though I assume he’s either bi or pan. I do ship him with this one character but I don’t know if we’re supposed to ship them or if I’m just reading their dynamic wrong and seeing things that aren’t there.

Anyway I just wanted to touch on that and explain the LGBT rep situation a little bit. I will say that the main canon ship so far is m/f, so don’t go into this expecting the central ship to be gay.

Also, I felt this book was somewhat lacking in terms of world building. I understood that this was a fantasy setting, but it wasn’t clear to me if it took place in the modern world or a completely different fantasy world. I think the thing that tripped me up was the presence of cameras and the fact that there seemed to be some sort of high school. Those things kinda pointed towards a modern setting, but I’m just not 100% sure. Also, it mentions the government every so often but it wasn’t clear to me what kind of government they had? Maybe this will be clarified in the next book.

Another thing I didn’t like that much was how the characters weren’t as morally gray as I expected them to be. I blame the title for putting ideas into my head. Also, the pacing wasn’t the best in my opinion. In some places it felt like things were dragging on for too long, especially in the first half of the book until the tournament started. However when things picked up I got really invested.

This book was also just not that diverse from what I can recall, in terms of POC rep. In fact if there were any POC, they were probably so minor I can’t remember them. I feel like I read the words “fair skin” so much in this book when being introduced to new characters for the first time, it’s like, okay we get it!

As for what I liked about this book, I thought the magic system was unique. I don’t remember reading any other fantasy book that had a magical system quite like this one. Also, even though I do have a headcanon ship at the moment, I did enjoy reading about the main m/f relationship I mentioned before. Enemies to lovers back to enemies again? The angst, the betrayal… What else could I want in a ship?

That said, I believe that the four core characters were what carried this book for me, once I got past the ‘not as morally gray as I wanted them to be’ thing. The four core characters all were so interesting and had their own approaches to the tournament. To be honest though the stand out characters for me were Alistair Lowe and Gavin Grieve. They just seemed like the most developed out of the mc’s to me, but again, the other characters were interesting as well.

It might sound like I didn’t like this book from all the criticisms I presented here, but honestly despite any issues I had, this book was very entertaining and it was easy to get lost in these characters. It kept me engaged and honestly, that’s all I ask for from a book.

I want to be excited for the sequel but as I was looking at other reviews of All Of Us Villains, I found out something about one of the authors. To be clear I wasn’t aware of this going into this book, but apparently Christine Lynn Herman was called out for bullying authors of color. Do with this what you will. Because of this, I’m conflicted about the sequel to this book. I guess I’ll see how I feel at the time.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first instalment in the All of Us Villains series.

"You Fell In Love With The Victors of The Hunger Games.
Now Prepare To Meet The Villains of The Blood Veil."

Every twenty years the quiet town of Ilvernath becomes the setting for a tournament to the death. Seven individuals enter, representing seven families. Only one will walk out of the arena alive, leaving all others behind as corpses. The Champion's family become the guardians for high magick for the next two decades, meaning their life, their honour, and their abilities are all motivations to win.

The novel included a perspective from almost all the potential Champions competing in this year's tournament. The first entire quarter was spent introducing their various characters, as well as their personal motives and struggles. I appreciated this slow build-up as it aided in my understanding of the magick available in this contemporary setting and bonded me with the individuals vying for control of it. I had some I preferred over others, but every one was intriguing and engaging.

Once the tournament begun my early interest only sky-rocketed. Any fictional game involving the death of its competitors is going to be likened to The Hunger Games but I really felt like the brutality yet ingenuity of the former was also present here, yet presented in its own, original format. The focus on potential allies, the brewing mistrust, the ever-present fear, and the bloodshed all made this such a captivating read.

This might be a general concept I have read about before, but the actual bones of the novel were entirely unique and I couldn't stop reading until its twisted conclusion. This author duo have proved themselves as the perfect pairing and I can't wait to find out what transpires in the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

All of Us Villains is a is a wonderful and incredibly rich fantasy novel, so well built and fast paced that I wasn't able to put it down till I reached the end. I was absolutely captivated by the atmosphere, and the characters.

This novel submerges the reader in a landscape so imaginative and detailed that the information of the world building/plot never feels forced, and is never difficult to understand or picture in one's mind. I had an enjoyable time reading this and it held my attention the entire way through that I finished it within the day! I enjoyed every page and thought that the plot/story was very unique. Would recommend to anyone!

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting story to date. The multiple shifts of perspective took getting used to, but it gradually got easier to follow. I felt like this was a "Hunger Games" mixed with some "Harry Potter". A very interesting mix.

Was this review helpful?

Pitched as the Hunger Games with magic, this is going to have readers on the edge of their seats!
Super dark and gritty with morally grey characters you can't help but love?! This was one of my most anticipated reads of 2021 and it did not disappoint – I loved this book! Will 100% be picking up a physical copy where this book is released.

Was this review helpful?

I’m going to give it to you straight. If Hunger Games, Beautiful Creatures, and Red Rising had a magical love child it would be this book.

Brilliant. That’s the long and short of it. When the book started and suggested there would be seven characters vying it out in a magical Hunger Games-like battle, I was worried. Seven characters is a lot. Would there be enough character development. Would I be able to keep them all straight. Would I fall in love with one character and get bored with the others.

I had absolutely nothing to worry about. The authors took their time. They developed a great backstory while creating characters that I absolutely adored…even though they are all supposed to be villains.

Volunteer as tribute, cast a spell, give yourself over to the game or do whatever you have to do to add this book to your TBR list. You won’t be disappointed.

What I Liked
There was so much to like. Great character development, great setting, great backstory. This is book one in a series and I cannot wait to read book two. Better yet, to see this turned into a movie.

I like YA Fantasy but it’s not my first go to. It’s gotta be good to earn a nod from me. And just in case you can’t see it from where you are sitting, I’m practically a bobble head typing out this review.

For a story I couldn’t put down, an entire cast of characters I loved, and a satisfying yet intriguing ending, this book easily earns five stars.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishers and author for giving me the opportunity to read this book.
I really enjoyed this book!
I loved the Hunger Games vibes in it and if I'm being honest I found it even better then the Hunger games!
I definitely can't wait for the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

So good! I devoured this book in a day or so.

Light spoilers: all of the characters are unlikeable. But with a name like all of us villains what more are you to expect?

A cardre of children raised for a once-in-a-generation slaughter fest. The prize is more power for their families. The cost? Only one survives. It’s a generations old curse that they must participate in- if they the curse will pick someone at random.

All of them have different ways of dealing with it, and the results end up being truly mixed in success or failure.

I can’t wait for the second book in the series!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Tor Teen for the free copy in exchange for an honest review.
I absolutely devoured this book. It was described as Hunger Games with magic and I was already hooked. But the authors took that premise and made it their own. The writing was vivid and detailed so that it felt like you were with the characters during the action. Of and this book have it all. Magic. Alliance. Betrayal. Surprises and twists that keep you reading to the end and leave you wanting more. Each character shines on their own and each have their own unique perspective and agenda to fulfill.

Was this review helpful?

The moment you get to the end of the book…and you’re… Calvert confused. And then you realize that it’s only the end of book 1 and it’s a series. I never like that moment, but at least it made sense why I was super confused.
This book is being marketed as the next Hunger Games. I can see that and I’m there for it.
I’m enjoying getting to know the main characters and I’m intrigued to know more… when ever book 2 might come out.
I received this book from NetGalley and I’m very grateful for the opportunity to review.

Was this review helpful?

Give me book 2 and give it to me now!

A magical Hunger Games is already going to be a great sell for readers. But I do think this has more depth than Hunger Games. Is some of the pacing a bit slow as we have to get introduced to the characters, setting and story? Yes. Is it utterly predictable who will die? Yep. But there is something about the blurred lines of good and bad that make this truly captivating.

For Libraries: The hype of this book is going to be huge around publication time, so you are going to want this book. Plus, it's good!

Was this review helpful?

Every 20 years the seven “pure blood” families must send in a member of the family to fight to the death. They do so to maintain or gain control over high magick which is only available to the winning family. Otherwise, only raw magick is available which can be strong but when high magick is used it causes the spell’s power to double. I found the setup of the story and the environment to be fantastic. This book has four point of views which follows four of the chosen champions. POV stories can be hit or miss for me as when used poorly it makes reading through an unlikeable or boring character a churn. This book didn’t have this issue. The characters and their backstories are interesting. You fear for them as you start to like them but know this death tournament can only end in tears. Only one can be victorious — if more than one survive at the end of two months the curse kills them all and punishes the families to 20 years with no one having access to the high magick. This is a brutal world. No one can be trusted. No one is safe. If you’re ready for a Hunger Games type story with magick, some romance, and a ticking clock with betrayal and fear then definitely pick this up. I’m only sad now that I have to wait so long for the next book.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the magic system the authors created for this world! Diving into it, I thought it would be a standalone, and as the book was about to finish I realized how much bigger the world was! It definitely calls for a sequel, which I’m already looking forward to!

I ended up loving characters I hated in the beginning, and hating some I liked in the beginning. Each of the champions have a unique and interesting story underneath them that I can’t really choose a favorite.

Overall, it was a really fun, fast-paced book to read, and I feel like it has been a while since I’ve had so much fun reading a YA fantasy. It’s like… The Hunger Games with dark magic and all of them villains.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun blend of Hunger Games meets Harry Potter's pure blood families. I liked that the characters, as a whole, were multi dimensional. No one was truly a pure villain, but definitely no one was good, I hated that it ended with a cliffhanger of sorts, so I'll be over here impatiently waiting for the next book in the series.

Was this review helpful?

So I thought I had at least a few more pages to read. Turns out I was wrong. That is exactly where the book ended.

I was pulled into the story immediately. Each character is amazing to read. Sometimes I find the multi-POV approach a little lackluster and I end up not enjoying certain characters' chapters as much, but here I was completely immersed into the story no matter whose point of view I was reading. Each character's head was interesting to be in, and all of them had different goals and desires. Their backstories are all quite different too. I cannot wait to see what else might be revealed in the second book, because it is clear a lot of these characters still have many secrets! I'm also excited to see which characters why might get a bit more of eventually.

And can we please talk about that magic system?? I think it is so clever! It is complex and captivating all at once. I love how even though there is a straightforward way of casting spells and curses, they each have their own components and each character has their own strengths and weaknesses when it comes to magic. I like that the use of some of the magic also has a price that the caster has to pay. It's a really well-thought-out and unique magic system.

This book was incredibly captivating and now I have no idea what I'll do with myself while I wait for the second book. Amanda Foody and Christine Lynn Herman are true artists when it comes to storytelling and I would never hesitate to pick up their books.

Thank you so much to Netgalley and to Tor Teen for the eARC.

Was this review helpful?