The synopsis had me intrigued. I went into the book excited to read it. Only to be let down, it was so slow from the beginning. I kept having to put it down. I will say the writing was great the atmosphere was another good thing of the book just the pacing and the characters weren't memorable at all.

Thank you PenguinTeen for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.

This is a paranormal thriller about a girl named Grey who comes back to her isolated hometown for the summer. Her best friend’s been missing for the last six months and she wants to find out what happened to her.

While Grey’s own magical powers are showing up for the first time, her other friends have had theirs for years. They can feel other peoples’ emotions, can hear conversations and can communicate with the dead. But all of their powers are not enough to find out what happened to Elora.

The mystery is intriguing and the writing is beautifully atmospheric. I do feel like the middle part dragged on. I loved the beginning, it kept me turning the pages, but once I got to the middle, and later the ending, I felt a little let down. The twists were predictable and I wasn’t happy about the love triangle that got established along the way.

There’s subtle hints of queer representation, but nothing really noteworthy.

I’ve read better and worse mystery books. I’d recommend it for the enchanting writing style, the very fitting, isolated setting and the found family between the friends, rather than for the disappointing revelations at the end.

content warnings: suicide, murder, violence, physical abuse, incest (step siblings)

This book is fantastic! Full of bayou charm and mystery. 10 children born in La Cachette that summer and only 7 are left. Elora has been missing and Grey is back in La Chachette this summer to find out what happened to her. But what she finds along the way is lies, betrayal, and that she never really knew any of the summer children. Perfectly twisty!

This one was not for me. I felt like the writing style was too juvenile for my taste and it felt like reading thru molasses to get through it.

I liked this book a lot.
The atmosphere in Louisiana is captured super great, the fantasy part is exciting and the characters were just cool.
There are a lot of plot twists and you guess surprisingly little, which I thought was great. What I also liked: It wasn't all easy, pretty and clean. Some of the characters were messy and made mistakes, as young people do. I thought that was really well captured for a Young Adult book.
If you're looking for a paranormal Young Adult thriller set in the sultry American South that has great characters and a bunch of twists and turns, then read this book 💙

From the beginning I could tell Ginny Myers Sain is a powerful story teller. Her words combine to paint a beautiful and haunting picture of the south, dripping with sweat and secrets.

I’m not one to love really dark things so I found enough in this to not be super freaked out (haha) but there were definite moments of the “creep” factor to satisfy.

Toward the end I will say there was perhaps too much left to the imagination for me when it came to “answers” but I did find I couldn’t put this down.

This book makes me think of The Raven Boys & the Diviner’s.

❗️Language and a few adult scenes. Underage drinking & smoking.

—-
Thanks to Bloomsbury for this gifted copy.

This is such a perfect book to read in crisp autumn weather with the leaves turning orange and the air making you feel some type of way! I just thoroughly enjoyed reading this in autumn and it was a great experience. It's a dark atmospheric book with so many amazing characters, like I love them. I just realized this is a debut book and I'm just blown away by the masterpiece this book is! I recommend highly!

Dark and Shallow Lies is a gothic mystery with a paranormal twist that is equally chilly and atmospheric. Thank you Penguin Teen for the e-arc!

I enjoyed this YA paranormal novel more than the adult paranormal story I've read in the recent past! Its eerie, dark and will keep you guessing or atleast checking in on your shoulders. The story progresses in a slow pace than I had expected, but the interesting happenings kept me totally invested.

I know many readers loved this, but gothic fiction is a hit or miss for me. So I kept my mind open and this book is a hit for me!! One of the great YA books I’ve read this year.

I didn't even know I was reading a debut novel but apparently, that is exactly what Dark and Shallow Lies by Ginny Myers Sain is! I have to hand it to her, this was a super gripping and well-written YA mystery/thriller, and I loved it. It is very atmospheric, and I really liked the way the audiobook is done with water sounds for the second viewpoint (which is quite small). Most of the story is told from the viewpoint of Grey, but the bayou also felt like a character in itself which is a major part of why the book felt so atmospheric. There is also a fantasy/supernatural aspect that I really enjoyed and the mystery of what happened to Elora among other things was very surprising and well done.

I loved the way the audiobook was executed, but I wasn't too keen on the narrator which was Emma Ashton. I somehow listened to her twice in a row and at times I thought she was slightly better in this one, but still not my favorite narrator. Her pauses seemed really off to me which made the book feel choppier than it actually is. The element of the water sound was spot on though and I am glad I got to experience the book that way. Dark and Shallow Lies had me interested from the very first moment, and I could definitely see this being a reread of the physical book at some point. I couldn't believe how real the town of La Cachette felt to me and Sain really nailed the setting of this novel. If you like psychic and supernatural elements plus YA, then you definitely need to read Dark and Shallow Lies.

I received a complimentary digital copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

This book follows Grey, a teenager who grew up in a small town in Louisiana and now visits every summer to catch up with her old friends. When her best friend vanishes, she spends her summer digging into the mystery of what happened to discover the truth.

Here’s what I loved:
✨ The cast of characters were so interesting and each one had a distinct personality! One of my pet peeves is side characters that you can’t tell apart but these you could identify right away even before their name is mentioned.
✨ The setting and atmosphere were wonderfully creepy! I think this would make a brilliant movie almost for that alone
✨ The psychic/magic aspect was intriguing because each character has a different power and I wanted to learn more about all of the different abilities.
✨ The ending was a PERFECT way of wrapping the story up
✨ The cover is gorgeous and shiny 😍

If I could change one thing, it’s that it was extremely obvious that the red herrings were trying to lead you astray. I want to trick myself into believing the wrong thing, not have it bashed over my head. That being said - the actual twists were still shocking and I did not see them coming!!

After a bunch of YA thriller duds in a row, this was a great change of pace and I highly recommend adding it to your fall TBR!

Ginny Myers Sain’s debut, Dark and Shallow Lies, ended up not being the book for me. The story was very much character-driven, which is usually one of my favorite types of novels, but this book's pacing felt off to me.

Sain spends much of the novel describing her setting: La Cachette, Louisana. Through ​her storytelling, Sain brings Louisiana’s oppressive heat and tumultuous storms to the forefront so that readers can experience the dramatic setting right alongside Grey. Not only is Grey trying to solve the mystery of Elora's disappearance, but she must do so before an approaching hurricane hits the small town. Other readers may be immediately drawn in by Sain's eery descriptions of La Cachette, making Dark and Shallow Lies the perfect atmospheric read for Fall.

Many thanks to the TBR And Beyond Tours, NetGalley, and Penguin Teen for e-ARC. All opinions are my own.

Dark and Shallow Lies is a dark, mysterious and creative book. The cover is what drew me in, it’s gorgeous and creepy.


"How do you keep a secret in a town full of psychics?"

17 year old Grey returns to her place of birth, La Cachette for the Summer. A place in the bayou where she grew up with 10 other children all born in the same year. La Cachette is a small town deep in the bayou, known as the psychic capital of the world.
Grey’s best friend is missing, we follow the clues with her to try and find what happened to her.

I thought this was such a great novel. I love small town mysteries! I’ve always been fascinated by stories of the south, this had everything I love in a mystery.

The writing is beautiful yet creepy. I’m shocked that this is a debut. I look forward to reading her next book.

The story isn’t just a regular mystery, the touch of magical realism made it that much better.

I listened to the audiobook and I have to say it’s one of y favorites by far. I really loved what they did with Greys visions. The narrator Emma Ashton did a fantastic job with the Cajun accents.

I highly recommend this book if you love thrillers! Don’t let the YA genre stop you, it’s a great read.

Grey spends her summers in her hometown of La Cachette, Louisiana, the Psychic Capital of the World. This is the first time Grey has returned since her best friend, Elora, went missing earlier in the year. Grey and Elora were closer than friends. They shared a birthday and always felt like sisters. Grey’s goal for the summer was to find out the truth of what happened to Elora. However, she didn’t think she would discover the truths behind other mysterious disappearances and deaths, including the secrets her mother took to her grave.

This was a spooky, mystical story, perfect for the fall season. The town of La Cachette was full of psychics. All of the kids born in the same year as Grey had some kind of psychic ability. Grey didn’t think she had a gift until she started seeing visions of what happened to Elora in her final moments. The town itself was also spooky. It was quite isolated from the rest of the world. The town was the target of hurricanes, like New Orleans. It added to the spookiness and unpredictability of the town.

The ending was shocking and surprising. There was one character who I found suspicious from the beginning, and I thought they were the one responsible for Elora’s disappearance. This character was involved, but it was a complicated ending. There were some other revelations at the end that were quite disturbing and unexpected.

Dark and Shallow Lies is a creepy YA story.

Thank you Penguin Random House Canada for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Older students who enjoy darker fiction and thrillers will eat this one up. I thought I had the mystery figured out, but I was completely wrong and never saw it coming. However, the best part about this book is the sense of place. The author does a great job making you feel like you are sweating through a hot summer night listening to the frogs sing.

Holy sh*t! This book scared me. And it reminded me why i do not like scary, creepy books like this.
But it had me hooked! I read it in about 5 hours, almost in one sitting because i just could not put it down! It was well written and it took me quite a while to figure out who did it. I did figure it out a little before Grey did though. The roamnce was sweet but a little bit unneccesary in my opinion.
Overall a really scary book.

Como vocês já sabem, essa resenha é em parceria com a Random House Internacional, de quem recebemos esse eARC (Advance reading copy: algo como “uma cópia de leitura avançada, ou seja, o livro ainda pode sofrer alterações antes de ser publicado). Também lembrando que essa resenha terá um formato diferente: por ser um ARC, não haverão quotes, já como os livros podem sofrer mudanças em seu texto antes de serem comercializados. Gostaríamos de agradecer profundamente a Editora pela oportunidade de parceria.

Precisei pensar sobre esse livro para tentar coordenar meus pensamentos sobre como me senti no final da trama e, pra ser, sincera, até aqui, ainda me sinto confusa. Por um lado, dou créditos ao clima do livro e sua construção magnífica como um thriller sobrenatural – porque sim, há poderes psíquicos na cidade, como diz a sinopse –, mas também encontro problemas de ritmo na decisão para que lado a trama iria pender e na construção dos relacionamentos que vão sendo mostrados ao longo da trama, muito provavelmente pela falta de aprofundamento no passado dos personagens.

Começando a trama, vemos Grey, uma garota de 17 anos que está destruída com o sumiço de sua melhor amiga, Elora. Grey não mora o ano inteiro na cidade de La Cachette, ela somente passa os verões lá com sua avó, Honey e mora durante o ano letivo com seu pai. Ela vai para a cidade, que na verdade é uma ilha e que fica em Louisiana, o estado mundialmente famoso pela grande rede fluvial que o corta, principalmente o rio Mississippi. Sem entrar em profundidade no assunto, “uma massa de água formada por antigos braços e meandros de rios” é o que forma um bayou, termo repetido diversas vezes durante a narrativa para sermos ambientados no clima da ilha, que está o tempo inteiro úmida, quente e cortada por água em todos caminhos. Essa ambientação, fugindo de grandes cidade, foi o principal ponto do livro para mim, principalmente pela influência da cultura francesa na trama, já como diversos personagens falam com o sotaque característico da região, que foi inicialmente colonizada pelos franceses. Sinto que preciso falar bastante disso porque é realmente um dos grandes pontos altos do livro – e ah, para quem está se questionando: não, o “sotaque” dos personagens, mesmo escrito, não influenciou nada na leitura. Foi algo muito mais divertido do que difícil de entender.

Voltando para a trama, Grey está sim, destruída pelo sumiço de Elora, sua melhor amiga, que sumiu enquanto ainda estava com seu pai, ou seja, Grey não estava na ilha quando Elora sumiu, e quando enfim chega para passar as férias de verão, a ambientação do sumiço já está estabelecida. Grey logo encontra seus amigos na cidade, que, juntos, formavam o grupo chamado de “Os Dez”: dez crianças nascidas na cidade em um verão, com diferença de meses entre eles. Mas, para surpresa do leitor, de cara entendemos que o grupo de dez na verdade não são dez: duas meninas desse grupo, gêmeas, foram mortas na cidade aos 4 anos de idade – Ember e Orli – e agora Elora está desaparecida. O grupo ainda tem os gêmeos Sera e Sander; o extrovertido Mackey; Case, o namorado de Elora; a caçula Evie e Hart, a paixão de infância de Grey e irmão de consideração de Elora (a mãe dele é casada com o pai de Elora), e enquanto vai conversando com todos eles, principalmente interrogando Hart sobre a noite do desaparecimento de Elora, a garota vai entendendo o poder dos segredos na cidade. Todos parecem estar escondendo algo, principalmente a própria Elora.

Grey e Elora nasceram no mesmo dia e são chamadas de “irmãs de alma” (em tradução livre), compartilhando uma afinidade e aproximação que todos respeitavam e admiravam. Sempre juntas quando Grey estava na cidade, a garota sempre deixava claro que assim que fizesse 18 anos gostaria de voltar a morar na cidade, enquanto Elora queria sair de lá. Nas últimas férias de verão que Grey passou na cidade, Elora estava distante, falando que queria espaço da melhor amiga, a afastando tanto que chegou ao ponto de terem uma briga tão forte que terminou com esta socando Grey na boca. A tensão entre elas era grande, e agora com Elora desaparecida, Grey se questiona o motivo real porque tudo aquilo estava acontecendo e, principalmente, o que ela não estava sabendo sobre a melhor amiga que sabia tudo sobre ela. Mas, da forma mais dolorosa possível, ela vai descobrir que não sabia tudo sobre Elora.

A chegada de um estranho chamado Zale que tem a mesma faixa de idade de Grey e seus amigos parece natural, mas, por um mistério que parece complicado demais no início, ninguém o conhecia – só Elora. Claro que Grey começa a desconfiar do rapaz, que tem um passado também bastante ligado à cidade e que vamos descobrindo durante a trama.

Desde o primeiro momento é estabelecido que a grande parte dos personagens se conhecem, e você, leitor, deve aceitar que eles se conhecem muito bem e é isto. Como eu já falei, o ponto fraco do livro é justamente estabelecer a certeza no leitor que Elora amava Grey da mesma forma como Grey amava Elora. É difícil entender a dinâmica do grupo dos Dez (que são sete durante a maior parte do livro) porque não temos ponto de vistas e temos de aceitar as afirmações de Grey, único ponto de vista do livro. Mas, como vocês podem imaginar, ela não sabe tudo sobre aquelas pessoas, não sabe tudo sobre sua avó e não sabe tudo sobre sua mãe, e o leitor é levado junto com a personagem nas descobertas que ela vai fazendo.

E, como se tudo isso não bastasse, enquanto todos ao seu redor possuem seus poderes psíquicos, Grey ainda não os tinha, mas, com toda essa explosão de sentimentos, ela começa a ter flashes e ver o que pode ter acontecido com sua melhor, tudo como se fosse sonhos. O livro é bastante inteligente nesse aspecto, colocando as visões de Grey como citações no começo de cada livo e isto foi algo que também me agradou bastante porque há um mistério nessas citações que você vai descobrindo no decorrer da trama.

Eu também me perguntei bastante foi se “Dark and Shallow Lies” é um livro de fantasia ou um livro de suspense, porque a narrativa sempre fica entre os dois. Não vi, sinceramente, qualquer diferença nos poderes psíquicos que todos personagens tinham e não teve grande impacto em mim. Entendo que os gêneros literários possam brincar com os outros, se misturando e criando livros que são bastante deliciosos de se lerem, mas confesso que não senti isso com o livro.

Fora isso, o livro entrega um livro que fala muito, muito bem sobre o poder dos segredos entre famílias e amigos. Nesse aspecto, eu também bato palmas para a trama, que se fosse um pouco mais trabalhada e tivesse mais profundidade em seus personagens, eu definitivamente teria me apegado bastante. Agora vamos torcer para o livro venha para o Brasil também e todos possam ler e possamos discutir a opinião de vocês sobre o impacto que mentiras são capazes de fazer em nossas vidas.

Thanks for the free book, Penguin Random House International.

T his was incredibly atmospheric. I really enjoyed the time I spent in La Cachette. Despite all the, ya know, murder. And I thought the way this explored grief through the different characters was really well done.

The beginning was definitely the strongest piece of this but it hit a plateau at about 40% and never really picked back up. I started being able to guess the twists, as the hints were way too glaringly obvious, and because there were so few characters it was not really difficult to figure out the whodunnit. I’d have preferred if there had been more characters, made the book a little bit longer to throw off the scent of the murderer. 3.5 rounded up.

Spooky vibes = Autumn? Count me in! This book met all the criteria necessary for a great Fall read and I couldn't get enough of it. Especially of the mystery that we had to solve with Grey. I highly recommend this book if you love a witchy, spooky and well written mystery novel. Definitely read it on Halloween and you will feel even more spooked.

Dark, creepy, creative, lyrical, and so beautiful! One of my top 5 favorites of the year. I don't think I've read a YA that's had me addicted like this in awhile. Loved it.

This was so fun to read! I loved how dark it got and the supernatural elements added such great atmosphere to the book. It had me guessing and going back and forth over who might've killed our main character's best friend especially as secrets about their small town and community surface in her quest to find the killer. There were great twists and that ending was shocking! It was truly a climax!