Cover Image: The Roughest Draft

The Roughest Draft

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

One of Emily and Austin’s best. I loved their new venture into romance novels - this book is so real and raw and beautiful.

I struggled bit in the beginning - this is the type of romance book that relies on stunning dialogue and rich characterization. It starts heavy - with discord and hurt feelings and not a lot of typical playful banter and upbeat pacing.

It makes the story original and special BUT definitely a different take for this genre.

Nathan and Katrina felt so real to me - I absolutely loved their story.

A must read romance of 2022!

Was this review helpful?

The cover is what grabbed my attention and the title, i thought this was going to be such a fun read. but i struggled with just the first half.

Was this review helpful?

Love this vacation romance - the perfect beach read! Katrina and Nathan are cowriting partners who had a falling out. Now they need to put their feelings aside and complete the final book in their contract.

Was this review helpful?

This read a little like Beach Read to me, which I loved, so I'm here for it. More angsty, that's for sure, but I really enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

This is an intriguing book. The character dynamic is decently fun. I just think that it wasn't for me? I was looking for more of the parts especially in the middle but it didn't gave me that.

Was this review helpful?

This second-chance romance is not one I’d recommend. From the slime ball agent to the main characters who are emotionally-repressed and downright antagonistic and sometimes cruel to each other, there’s no time that I was rooting for them to reconnect. I don’t know anything about the authors, but couldn’t help feeling this was life imitating art…or vice versa…and that this is just a pretentious retelling of their own story.

Was this review helpful?

This was just the book that i needed right now. Great chemistry between the characters, with lots of intensity and unspoken angst. I loved the author sub-plot and the drive to communicate through their work.

Thanks Berkley, for the gifted advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, Berkley Publishing, for the gifted copy of the Roughest Draft {partner}

Genre: Romance
Trope: Second Chance
Format: 🎧📖
Pub Date: 1.25.2022
Star Rating: ☆

“...sometimes relationships don't die. They just don't grow. Kept from sunlight, from nourishment, they never flourish.”

While I think that the Roughest Draft started off strong and I was fell right into place with the story and the characters, it quickly dropped off for me. I couldn't get past the cheating element or Katrina's fiance being so cavalier about their relationship. It added such an upsetting element to the story that I ultimately decided to DNF as I couldn't find anything else to enjoy with the story.

As always, this is just one opinion and I know several people who loved this book, but it just wasn't for me! I recommend picking it up and giving it a try for yourself. I did try it out on audiobook and I enjoyed the narration so if that's for you, go for it!

Was this review helpful?

3 stars

I liked this one but wanted more backstory on the characters. The writing was elevated but the plot was very cerebral (in the characters heads) but I didn’t feel I understood the characters pasts or motivations well enough which left me feeling disconnected from the characters and bored by the plot. I did really enjoy the writing and premise but just wanted more from the delivery.

Was this review helpful?

“We've written the rough draft of our love together, the draft with loose ends, unfinished edges, mistakes every other page. But every writer knows there's magic in revision, where your work changes from a manuscript into a book. Where intentions, emotions, missed connections coalesce into something complete. It's where what you mean to say becomes what you have said. The characters deepen, the details shine, the prose sparkles. Suddenly, from nothing, you find your story.”

I just adore this book. It gave me similar vibes as beach read, so I think that would be the ideal reader for this book. I loved the fact that this book felt raw, it felt real, albeit a bit pretentious at times but that also somehow added to the charm? This book definitely is not you run of the mill cartoon romance book with smutty interior. Rather it is angsty without being too dramatic, and I overall just was so glad I went into it blind.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a lovely read! Despite having several books by these authors, this was the very first one I read by them. And it definitely did not disappoint. A solid story with great characters, and I found myself wanting to continue reading. Can highly recommend this!

Was this review helpful?

I had a blast reading this. It was pure entertainment! Great characters and tension. Easy in one sitting kinda read😆

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure how much I would enjoy this book, but I found it quite charming. Something about the writing process really makes people curious, and especially when it comes to tension between writing partners, this one was well done. I enjoyed the dynamics between these characters as well as the third wheel friend, so to speak, who was a breath of fresh air. I really enjoyed this one.

Was this review helpful?

as much as I wanted to love this, I just didn't, It seemed too much like a wannabe emily henry book and it just did not work for me unfortunately

Was this review helpful?

I did not read this book before the audiobook was archived. But I plan to read it soon and purchased the ebook when it became available.

Was this review helpful?

This book was sooo good except for one glaring detail - the both characters emotionally cheat on their partners.

I honestly loved almost everything about this book. I loved the banter, the premise, the way the characters dealt with hidden emotions and grief, and the way they grew. I also liked their chemistry and their attraction and angst was very real.

What made it hard for me was the fact that to too for them was to root for their other relationships to fail. For one of the characters this didn’t feel as challenging since their partner did not come off as a caring person, but for the other character their partner was a caring and loving person and they suffered because of everything. I will concede that this is a realistic story and that it happens all the time, it was just hard to root for them since I had the feeling that this was a second chance romance.

Was this review helpful?

I’d seen mixed reviews for this book prior to picking it up, but I’m quite glad my friend Rachel convinced me to do that sooner rather than later because it was really good! I’m looking forward to whatever adult fiction these authors have coming out next.

The cover gives off the vibe of a fluffy, rom-com read, which is quite misleading because this book is definitely *not* that. The book examines the complicated relationship between two co-authors who clearly have *something* between them. It is messy. Difficult to read at times, and that’s because of how raw the emotions feel (and not the writing, which is actually quite readable). Cathartic in ways, frustrating in others. But overall, this book was compelling and well-written, and very reminiscent of early Taylor Jenkins Reid and current Emily Henry.

Was this review helpful?

Wibbroka can do no wrong in my eyes. This is the fourth book I've read from them and it is the fourth five star read I've give them. I love when romances have dual POV and this one having a dual timeline as well? That made it even better. I can absolutely see why this one isn't a favorite with people considering a major plot of this story contains emotional cheating but the tension was so good!! I loved how they could only express their true thoughts and feelings within their writing. The slow burn was soooo good and had me wanting more. I will forever & always be reading more from this writing duo.

Was this review helpful?

I really thought this book would be a favorite! And I'm quite sad that it's not.

But I didn't know that the bulk of this book involves some light emotional cheating, and the characters *insist* that they aren't cheating repeatedly, even though they very much are. Also, I just didn't feel for the characters--the moment they finally got together, I didn't feel any excitement or relief or giddy or anything. I don't mind some miscommunication as a plot point, romance books thrive on it to create angst or longing, but this one was extremely exhausting for me! However, I read the book quickly and I'm intrigued by the next book that's coming out by this duo, so I'll probably give it a shot and see if it was just this particular book that didn't vibe with me.

2.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Although, as far as I am concerned, this book has no "redeeming" value, I absolutely loved it. I loved the tension (and the affection) between Katrina and Nathan. I loved the setting of the heat and humidity of Florida. I loved the background of the relationship and how it affected the couple today. AND the writing process as it was described was fascinating. Sometimes a good old love story is what is need...as you can tell I loved this book.

Was this review helpful?