Skip to main content

Member Reviews

If I wouldn't have received an eArc, I wouldn't have picked this up...EVER. This was a difficult read and I guess because the pandemic is still highly triggering for me; this wasn't for me. Reading about it wasn't cathartic, in fact it was basically reliving the last two years in print.

I shockingly enjoyed the first half of the book versus the second half. I almost deemed it a DNF right before the big twist. I don't want to spoil it though. After the big twist I thought it was going to turn into a crazy plot twist (wishful thinking)..but it didn't. I don't think the main character had any real character development nor did the story. Everything she "developed" was already in her subconscious and was noted in the first half of the book before the trip. Also, there was a lot of art jargon that served no purpose other than to learn new facts - cool.

The only reason I am giving 3 stars is because of the message of the book - second chances. It is never too late to live your life to the fullest.

Was this review helpful?

I have read many Jodi Picoult books and they seemed to follow a pattern of legal themes with alternating viewpoints. This book is entirely different and one I devoured in two days. It’s the story of a young woman who seems to have her life in order, who decides to go on a Galapagos Island vacation alone when her doctor boyfriend has to stay in NYC battling Covid. As soon as she arrives on the island, everything shuts down and she is stranded there, unable to communicate with anyone. The story also touches on having a parent in memory care which hits close to home for me, as I had to deal with this during Covid. Then there’s a huge twist in the story which I can’t relate without spoiling it….. but let’s just say I couldn’t put this book down. It’s current and relevant, based on so much research both into facts about the Galapagos and treating Covid. I highly recommend this book which may now be my favorite Jodi Picoult book!

Was this review helpful?

From other reviews that I read prior to reading this story myself, it seemed like a lot of people didn’t enjoy it. I’m not of that mindset - I actually loved this book! In true Piccoult form, the reader is completely immersed in this world of Covid, art and consciousness. Without giving any spoilers, the ending left me wanting more but I think that was the point. There are even some elements of racism, privilege, how families function etc and somehow it is all tied together. Consciousness and reality were incredibly thought-provoking for the main character, Diana, and for me as a reader as well. I know it’s hard reading about Covid after the year we just had, but I found it a bit cathartic - it seems like we are finally on the upside of this thing. And Picoult has perfectly captured so much of what the world experienced while it was happening.

Big thanks to Net Galley and Random House Publishing for the ARC in exchange for my review! I will be sharing this to my Instagram blog (books_by_the_bottle) .

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book the sudden shift of story in the middle really bothered me and it was hard to be interested again. I was entertained but overall it was forgettable.

Was this review helpful?

I have read ALL of Picoult's books and have enjoyed them all... until this one! I was so upset when she did me dirty by having the first half of the book all be a fantasy/fever dream. It felt like such a cheap trick and also kind of lazy writing. Maybe it made me crabby because I was not ready to read a book about COVID while still living through this endless pandemic? I don't know. I'll still read her books in the future, probably, as long as there are no more Dallas plot lines.

Was this review helpful?

I think for me this book was too much given everything going on with the pandemic still.

I also lost my mother not long ago from COVID complications so this was definitely an extremely difficult read and not one I enjoyed.

Was this review helpful?

If you're ready to read a book that will take you back to the early days of the pandemic, Wish You Were Here, by Jodi Picoult, is a must read. If you are not, and some parts are difficult to read, I would recommend skipping for now.

While there are difficult and tragic moments this story reminds me of Picoult's earlier writing. Diana seemingly has all her goals checked: on track for a promotion in the highly competitive art world, nearly engaged by 30 to the love of her life and a trip to the Galapagos planned where an engagement is sure to occur. News reports of a virus start trickling in and soon its all hands on deck at the hospital where her boyfriend Finn is a surgical resident. Diana takes the trip alone, encouraged by Finn, and finds herself stranded on an island during lockdown. She befriends a local family as she explores the lands where Darwin formed his theory of evolution. Diana is forced to reconcile between her two worlds as they collide in dramatic fashion that is classic Picoult.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest feedback.

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult has done it again! In fact, this may be my favorite book of hers. Talk about timely - she really nailed the world we know during the covid pandemic. Wonderful heartfelt story that really brings to the surface all your emotions - isolation, grief, fear, and romance. I especially loved the author’s notes about her experience and how this book came tobe.

Was this review helpful?

Oh no! The twist didn’t work for this twist-lover!

Ready to relive the early days of COVID? The days of Tiger King, toilet paper, and trauma? Banging pots and pans, and cutting your own hair?

Well, check out this book, then, which is like going down a bad memory lane. Picoult talks about all of it. Zing zing, bingo! For minutes at a time, I’d drift off and think back to early 2020. There are a zillion Remember When’s. I actually didn’t mind going into life in the time of COVID—somehow it was a little cathartic—like, hey, we all went through this together. Some people might find it too depressing and traumatic, so be warned.

The main character’s live-in boyfriend is a doctor working in a New York City hospital when COVID first started. We hear the nitty-gritty of his harried life, and it’s not pretty. I haven’t read many COVID stories, and for sure none that show the effects of COVID on healthcare workers. It was eye-opening and powerful, depressing and scary, but very real.

Luckily, a big part of the book takes place on an island in the Galapagos, and hanging out there was relaxing and fascinating. That part of the story was especially brilliant. I loved the characters and was caught up in the intense relationships and the exotic scenery. I couldn’t put the book down when I was there on the island.

Okay, but here’s the deal. There’s a huge twist. There are those who loved the twist, but I am not one of them. And I’m all twisted up about it! It kills me not to explain why, but that would spoil the book for you. Okay, that’s Complaint Number 1, and it’s a biggie.

Picoult usually writes message books—not my favorite kind of fiction. The parts about the Galapagos didn’t seem like Picoult was trying to teach me anything, and I was loving it. And I was so happy to see that she could write plain old dramatic fiction. This book isn’t message-y, but in a big part of the book she does want to educate us about a phenomenon. I’m guessing that most people know nothing about it, so she was covering new ground, and for that she gets credit. Though learning about it was interesting, I wanted to go someplace else. Plus, the facts of it were hard to fathom. Picoult clearly researches the hell out of everything she talks about, and I do admire that—realism out the ying-yang. But I guess this lecturing business is Complaint Number 2.

My third whine: The relationship between the main character and her boyfriend was boring and a little too cutesy pie. It was Hallmark-y, and the portrayal seemed sort of cliched. Even the bantering between the two seemed familiar and ho-hum.

Damn, maybe I should have done a Complaint Board because suddenly I’m thinking of other things I didn’t like. A huge problem was that the parts related to COVID—which took up a big portion of the book—were often repetitive, which got tedious. Picoult really got into the phenomenon business, and I found myself antsy to get to something juicier and less abstract and strange.

Other complaints are smaller. For example, a main character in the Galapagos spoke English way too well. He used complicated sentence constructions, which just wasn’t believable. He also gave a diatribe on Darwin which seemed too intellectual and complicated given his background and the fact that English was his second language.

Another little nit (and I do mean little): the main character noticed there was a gap between a person’s teeth. Now wait a minute—they were in a hospital! The woman had to have had a mask on! No seeing tooth gaps possible! Masks were mentioned a lot; this was just a little writing slip-up.

There’s another sort of big complaint that has to do with letters sent to the Galapagos, but I can’t go into that. Sitting on my hands—Help! Just wanted to mention it for the record, lol, in case anyone who has read the book wants to discuss it.

Picoult’s writing is straightforward, and she clearly knows how to tell a story. Good pacing, decent language, with an occasional insight that made me stop for a moment.

What’s hard for me about Picoult is that she relies on research rather than imagination. Granted, the twist was imaginative, but that’s about it. Page-to-page it was all based on research. For me, that makes any story a little dry. Plus, lectures distract me; they pull me out of the story, which breaks my connection with the characters. I know realistic fiction isn’t known for its imagination, so I should cut Picoult a break there.

Bottom line: I loved a major part of this book but had big trouble with the twist. I’m the outlier on this one, I think; most reviewers gave the book 4 or 5 stars. Picoult fans will for sure love it.

Thanks to NetGalley for the advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

I was very late to the Jodi Picoult game. I didn't read my first of her novels until 2019; when I read a second of her books, this is what I had to say:
"Two things had put me off before that: the snobbish idea that good books cannot be written as fast as Picoult writes books and the idea that her books seem to always be about the latest "big" controversy. I still don't know that you could write the great American novel in a year but Picoult proved to me that you can write a book that will engross and entertain readers that quickly. And that if you can write well about whatever the latest big topic is, then it's good to write about those things in a way that will make people think about them."
Obviously, this is a book that has been written in a short amount of time and it is clearly about the latest "big" controversy (ok, one of them). And yet, not for one minute did I doubt that Picoult had had the time to write a thoughtful, well-researched novel.

There is a little bit of an echo of The Book of Two Ways, with Diana struggling to decide between two men, one who she initially disliked but came to have feelings for and the other who was left behind and who seemed perfect. As with The Book of Two Ways, I've tired of the narrative of the cranky man who turns out to be wonderful and I'm growing tired of stories of the heart torn between two men. And here I felt like Picoult had to work a bit to make Diana's choice seem right. That might have meant that the book wouldn't work for me.

But this book is so much more than the story of a love triangle. It is a book about family, about survival, about our dreams, about adapting to changes, and about forgiveness. And all of those themes, they worked for me. I was mesmerized by Finn's accounts of treating CoVid patients and watching them die and I felt his anguish. I was frustrated for Diana as she came across one obstacle after another and as she dealt with her relationship with a mother who she felt had essentially abandoned her but who now needed Diana to care for her. And, dang, I did not at all see the twist coming in this one!

I am bad about reading the author's notes at the ends of books. When I finish the story, I tend to want to move on; there are so many books waiting for me. This time I glanced at the author's notes just long enough to realize that I probably wanted to read further, to understand how Picoult's experience with CoVid 19 had inspired this book.

In reading that, I understood why this book didn't feel rushed and how it happened that Picoult could know so much about both this disease and the Galapagos. And, as it happens when you have all the time in the world, you have plenty of time to talk to people who have both treated CoVid patients and to the people who have survived it. Those stories lent a real feeling of credibility to the story, the kind of credibility that allowed the book to pack an emotional punch. That emotional punch resonated in this book. It's not a book without flaws, but it's a book that made me forgive those flaws.

Was this review helpful?

Wish you were here

Thank you to @randomhouse publishers for sending me a eARC of "Wish you were here" via @netgalley All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Synopsis: Imagine a check list but for life. A check list that contains some of the most major thigns you would like to achive in life. Diana O'Toole had every item on this cheklist already checked off. Graduate? Check. Get a job? Check. Get a signifigant other? Check. To any outisder Diana's life seems perfect and it seems perfect to Diana too. Diana likes to stick to her checklists and play by the book. Her entire future is planned out and it seem's like everything is going just the way its supposed to. Until a deadly virus hits New York and all her plans go down the trash. Diana and her boyfriend planned to go on a trip to the Galapagos but her boyfriend Finns job as a doctor won’t allow them to leave. Diana and Finn decide that instead of wasting the money they spent on their trip Diana would just go without him. Little did they know this descion would impact them for the rest of there lives. As Diana reaches the Galapagos the entire island is shut down and Diana is forced to find hostage with a random family. Not knowing the language spoken or knowing how to naviagte around the island. Diana wants nothing more than to go home. But as Diana becomes closer with Galapagos inhbaitants she begins to create new relationships and with romance in the air Diana feels like maybe her trip hasn’t completely gone to waste.

✨A literary classic. 2 words I can use to describe this book. This book was written like poetry and every word felt like a line that could be quoted. I loved the writing style of this book and for my first Jodi Picoult novel I really enjoyed it. The modern COVID 19 twist was really enjoyable and made the book even more relatable. I was really intrigued in some parts of the story and could tell that this book was incredibly plot driven and I liked that. One of my favorite parts about this book was the ending and how open ended it was.The ending told the readers that not everything end’s perfectly and sometimes perfect isn’t what a human needs. I will say there were some parts in book that progressed a little slowly and was not hooking at all. It's definetly a slower paced read so be prepared for that. I would recommend reading this at a time in your life when things are settled down and relaxed because it can soemtimes feel like an info dump espesially because of the different times information is given to the reader. I can totally predict that this book will be a classic one day and if you wanna stay ahead of the game I would pick up this wonderful novel.

Author: Jodi Picoult
Genre: Contemporary
Age rating: 15+
Trigger warnings: COVID 19 and death.
Stars:⭐️⭐️⭐️.5/5
Date published: 30 November, 2021
Page number: 336

Was this review helpful?

Ms. Picoult was able to take a heart breaking pandemic and incorporate it into a beautiful story about how lives change and evolve due to events. I went through a range of emotions while reading this. She remains one of my favorite authors.
Many thanks to Random House Publishing and to NetGalley for providing me with a galley in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I did not finish this book. I found it still being a rampant time in the pandemic, it being very hard to read this story. Maybe if it were ten years from now I’d be able to, but too triggering at this time.

Was this review helpful?

I’m too practical to give this book 5 stars - I was very mad at Diana for making the decisions she did about Finn and her mother. But I did really enjoy it and found it relatable, as I was also trapped in a foreign country at the start of the pandemic when borders closed. This was very well written and I didn’t see the twist coming at all. I’m glad this author has turned things around from The Book of Two Ways - I look forward to more of her work!

Was this review helpful?

A timely and interesting read about a woman, her boyfriend, and Covid. The novel takes place in New York City and the Galápagos Islands. It’s almost like two different novels, the first covers the pandemic and individual experiences, and then we get a huge twist that I for one did not see coming. It was fascinating. Then we find out what happens after the twist. The pacing for each seemed deliberate and set the tone for each the before and after. I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

4.5⭐ - wow, this was so well done!! A little emotional at times because covid, but I loved the way it was presented/handled and it will definitely stick with me!

Was this review helpful?

“You cannot trust perception. Falling, at first, feels like flying.”
.
I mean - wow! What a book....! This is my first Jodi Picoult and I am honestly blown away. Maybe it's that Wish You Were Here was super emotional and resonated, maybe it was the insane twist that I am still reeling from, or maybe it was the many thought-provoking lines and directions the author took - but I really enjoyed this story and it may be one of my favorites of the year. And I highly encourage you to go in blind, as I did, because I truly feel like that enhanced the read for me.
.
That being said, I don't want to give a lot away. This book delves deeply into 2020 and the beginning of the Covid-19 Pandemic. It gave me more respect for those early lives lost, what healthcare workers and doctors endured (and still endure today), and ultimately respect for a virus that we still do not know that much about - that isn't just another 'flu' or 'cold' - that living with caution is not the same as "living in fear".
.
100 percent will be giving this to all of my friends and family to read.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a wild ride! I've seen a handful of reviews on this one, it seems like people have either really connected with it- or not at all. I suspect the amount of COVID-related pages might've been behind the reviews that weren't glowing.

As much as I'm *also* sick of talking/thinking about covid, (like most people in the world right now, I'd imagine,) I found that I didn't mind reading about it. It was interesting to think about, and get insight into, how this experience has gone for people in vastly different situations than me. I appreciated the weight of the ongoing doctor observations, too. I like the concept of having a book that immortalized this bizarre time we're living in, also. Jodi Picoult did a great job putting our current situation onto pages, her info was accurate and succinct. I think this will be a fascinating time-capsule read for future generations.

NOW... That twist was insane! I loved reading the first 59% of the story, and I was admittedly sad about the change in directions. It was necessary and it did elevate the impact of the book, though. I knew it was coming (bookstagram spoilers strike again!) but it was still pretty shocking.

The only negative takeaway for me, was the pacing of the backend of the story, from the twist on. While the first 60% flew by for me, I struggled to get through the end. I was honestly pretty sick of reading about Diana's shock and refusal to accept the reality she found herself in, eventually. While I completely felt for her and understood the necessity of showing how deeply her experience had unnerved and changed her, I do think that point was hammered home too frequently in the final sprint to the end.

I really enjoyed this book overall, and I'm glad I read it. I would absolutely recommend it to fellow readers (*with a caveat about covid content for those who might not be able to rehash the events of 2020 yet.)

Thank you to #RandomHousePublishing #Ballantine and #Netgalley for the compliment ARC of #WishYouWereHere in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult has had me hooked since Small Great Things and My Sister's Keeper. Her storylines are not predictable and they plumb the depth of human emotions and interaction. This book is very timely to what people are experiencing today. The isolation that is not self-imposed, loneliness because people now have to sit with their own pain instead of running from it, unexpected loss and grief, disconnected from others. As these characters deal with that in more, Jodi manages to give us glimmers of hope and healing. I highly recommend this book as well as the two I mentioned earlier.
--USA TODAY Bestselling Author, Naleighna Kai

Was this review helpful?

I have a been a big fan of Jodi Picoult! Every time a new one is published, I jump at the opportunity to read it. She has a way of bringing together story lines and making her books easy to fall into. Honestly, I wasn't sure I was ready to read a COVID related novel, but the story did not feel like a pandemic story, it felt like a story of the human condition: finding our way when life can be unexpected and being able to be resilient when we are faced with uncertainty. Another great book by Jodi Picoult!

Was this review helpful?