Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you, NetGalley for the opportunity to review this title.

I did enjoy this title, but it does not offer an escape from our current circumstances. It is about the covid pandemic, lockdowns, glimpses into families who have suffered loss during this time and those working on the front lines of the pandemic.

Was this review helpful?

This was a perfect book about such a completely imperfect and messed up time. It seems impossible that someone could write a book achingly sad and beautifully uplifting at the same time. It’s a gorgeous book. It’s sad and smart and lovely and so so so great. I loved this one!

Was this review helpful?

This is a tough one to review. For about the first half of the book, I thought to myself: this doesn't fit the Picoult book formula AT ALL. But then... oh THEN.

I don't want to say too much and spoil the book, but I'll say this: I found the first half of the book pretty slow. I quickly flew through the second half, and have found myself thinking a lot about the book since I closed the cover for the final time a few days ago- and that, I think, says something. This book DID end up fitting the Picoult book formula of stirring up deep human emotions. Mission accomplished.

I think I land on 4.5 stars.

I received an electronic copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I am a long-time fan of Picoult's writing so was thrilled when I saw she had a new release. Heads up -this one is about living through COVID, a global pandemic, and addresses how the pandemic affected relationships and our outlook on life through the story of one couple.

Picoult delivers with a big twist about halfway through the novel that I didn't anticipate and that brought with it a lot of questions.

I wasn't sure about reading a thought-provoking story about living through COVID while we are still in it, but I also found it to be incredibly engaging. I sat down and read this cover to cover in one day. Picoult captured so much of the way life shifted when COVID emerged in Mach 2020 and this was an emotional read, especially when thinking of loved ones who worked in healthcare or were at risk due to age.

I'm still debating what the ending meant and have a few theories. I love how she left space for interpretation.

Was this review helpful?

I appreciated reading a book that was set in COVID! I didn't think those would be coming out for a few more years. This wasn't my favorite Jodi Picoult by a long shot but a meh Jodi Picoult is still a really great, thought-provoking book.

Was this review helpful?

I love Jodi Picoult. I’ve not read one book that she wrote that I did not like. I enjoyed this one just as much. It was hard at times for me to read because of the Alzheimer’s part because I can relate. I will buy this and I would share it with a friend.

Was this review helpful?

I swore off Jodi Picoult about 2-3 years ago after reading her latest book at the time and I vowed to never again read one of her books. I'm a bit sorry that I didn't stick to my guns. While this book started out seemingly innocuous, it took a turn and became another one of her books about "an issue." She always seems to pick an issue and just beat it to death. This one was Covid - you know, the LAST THING that people still living it want to read about!

The book initially had so much promise ... a woman stuck in the Galapagos at the start of the pandemic. She goes from having nothing to maybe finding a way to change her life. Such promise. Then, BAM! It's all over and you're taken on a completely different, much less interesting journey. It would have been much better without the (usual Picoult) social commentary.

This review was also published on Goodreads.

Was this review helpful?

4.5
Always thought provoking, Jodi Picoult’s books explore relatable and current issues. This was an interesting book - I don’t want to give any spoilers - but there are some unexpected shifts in this story. Picoult’s writing draws in the reader with vivid and realistic characters and scenes. This was a very apropos read, given how recent quarantine was for all of us, and for how much Covid is still a part of our lives today.

Was this review helpful?

I read this book on a recent flight, it had me engaged the entire time! Jodi provides a thought provoking book as usual. I will be recommending this to all patrons who walk in the door. I found myself rooting for Diana and Finn's story. So pleased with the ending!

Was this review helpful?

I was not sure how I would feel about this book since it was about Covid. This is my first book by Jodi Picoult and it is very well written on a very difficult subject. I think I would have enjoyed it more in a couple of years since we lost family members to covid last year.

That said, Wish You Were Here is a very moving book and it makes you think about life.

Thank you Netgalley and Ballantine Books for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

This is actually the first book I read by Picoult and I ended up loving it. I went into it not having read the synopsis, and judging from the cover of the book, it was not what I expected! COVID is reaching New York city and Diane's boyfriend announces he has to stay behind and work the front line. He encourages her to still head to the Galapagos without her. When she arrives, she ends up stranded on the island.

This ended up being a beautiful story and a reminder to always examine relationships, choices, and ensure you are doing things for you.

Was this review helpful?

I was unsure about this book, as I knew reading about the Covid-19 Pandemic, while still living in it, would not be easy. And I was correct, it was not easy to read, but I also thought it was incredibly well done.

Diana has a plan - married by 30, kids by 35, living in the suburbs of NYC and climbing the ladder in the art auction world. She is on track to hit all her goals, once her boyfriend, Finn, a resident, proposes on their trip to the Galapagos.

And then a virus hits that changes the world forever. Finn is required to stay at the hospital to help with the influx of patients. He tells her that she should go on this once in a lifetime vacation without him - and so she leaves NYC for the Galapagos. When she arrives on the Island, the borders shut down, isolating Diana until she connects with a local family and examining her life - career, relationship, and personal choices.

For obvious reasons, this book was incredibly relatable. Over the course of the past 20+ months we have all had time to reassess many aspects of our lives. Although we have all had different experiences - both good and bad - relating to the pandemic, it is something that we have all lived and can understand. Any fans of Jodi Picoult will like this book, however, it is definitely not an easy read!

Thank you netgalley for my advanced reader copy!

Was this review helpful?

I have been looking forward to Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult ever since I first read a description of it early 2021. Thanks so much to the publisher for providing me an advanced ecopy of the novel in exchange for an honest review.

Well, I wanted to read this fast before any spoilers got out because that is the one tip I tool away from early reviews: DON"T GET SPOILED. And I am glad I heeded the advice. Having a book with a big part of its impact dependent on readers not knowing much about the book makes it hard to write a review about, though. I am going to give it my best shot, though.

Diana is a millennial with a plan. Her career with Southeby's as an art buyer is on track to skyrocket as she has single-handedly landed one of the most sought after art pieces for auction. She has a solid relationship with surgical resident that may be heading toward marriage. Finally, she and her boyfriend actually have the same goals and dreams for their futures: where they want to live, how many kids they want to have, etc.

Diana and Finn have a dream vacation scheduled in the Galapagos Islands. This is where Diana knows Finn is going to propose to her and she is ready to say yes. But when rumors of Covid-19's potential impact on NYC, Finn is ordered to cancel any vacation plans in case there is a need for all hands on deck. He sends Diana on the trip without him as there is no need to lose all the money they already paid. She goes, and almost immediately upon arrival, the world goes on shutdown. For the first time in Diana's life, she is forced to make a way all on her own. There is very poor cell and internet service on Isabella Island. The hotel she has booked and paid for has closed its doors for the shutdown. She doesn't even speak the same language as locals as she had been depending on Finn to be the translator for her. Diana is forced to rely on the kindness of locals for food and shelter until she is cleared to travel back home to New York City.

It is during her time stranded she learns to live without a plan. She rediscovers her first passion: creating art, not just appreciating others' art. She develops a joy in exploring the unknown and a deeper appreciation for nature. The lack of communication between herself and Finn brings about some confusion about even that relationship she had been so confident in before: Why would he send her off on this trip if he genuinely thought the world was about to be in the chaos caused by a pandemic? Wouldn't he want her near him?

The theme of self-evaluation and self-discovery are strong in Wish You Were Here. I loved the idea to encourage us to reexamine life plans one sets before they even know what they are missing by going with those plans. Diana is a likeable, relatable character and the themes she is forced to explore during the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic, are themes that will resonate with all readers. Really good book.

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here Review by Jodi Picoult

This was the book I wanted In Five Years to be. I admittedly have been skeptical in the past of Jodi Picoult’s novels- I always think the premise look amazing, but the subject matter of many of them ended up being too upsetting for me.

Wish You Were Here also deserves a major content warning, because it’s set during the spring of 2020, so the major storyline centers around the pandemic. I have had no interest in reading any of the pandemic novels that have been released up until now because it felt too soon to read something we were living and most of them seemed really cheesy.

After reading the author’s note on Wish You Were Here, it makes sense Jodi wanted to write this book while it was all still fresh in her mind- and I suspect several decades from now someone would find this book to be a fascinating insight our lives during these years. All this to say I thought it was well done.

The premise of the story is that Diana and her boyfriend Finn have planned their dream vacation to visit the Galapagos Islands, but as the threat of a global pandemic looms over them, Finn stays behind to work at his NYC hospital, and Diana opts to go on their tropical vacation alone.

The pacing of the book was a little off, because the first half sort of meanders by and you find yourself wondering how things are going to work out. Then there is a shocking twist at about the 65% mark that I just did not see coming, and from there I had to finish it in one sitting.

Diana goes through an emotional arc I think many of us experienced during the last year, learning more about her true priorities and what really matters. I can’t say too much more without giving it away, but wow so good!

Trigger warnings: ICU, near-death experiences, dementia, death of loved ones, pandemic content

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult is about being apart from loved ones during the spring pandemic of 2020. The story follows Diana, a twenty-something associate at Sotheby’s auction house, so she is immersed in the art world. Her boyfriend, Finn, is a young doctor in NYC. It starts in early March 2020, with stay-at-home directives being put into place. Diana and Finn had planned a trip to the Galapagos Islands to start around that time. Finn encourages her to go, while he stays home, expecting his job will require a lot more of him in the coming days.

Diana arrives, but is quickly isolated and without cell service to contact home. She begins building relationships with a kind family that lives nearby. The story was a bit slow for my taste, so it took me a while to get through the book. Picoult well-described what the pandemic was like, people suffered in extremes and personal overwhelm. Diana is physically isolated with tons of down time while her boyfriend is overwhelmed and incredibly busy.

The second half really drew me in. I really liked the ruminations about determining what is truly important to us and what gives our lives meaning in precarious times. My favorite parts of the novel were the descriptions of Isabela Island in the Galapagos and the wildlife and the harrowing first-hand accounts from Finn battling COVID-19 in the height of the early pandemic. These accounts really drove home the seriousness of the disease and how exhausting it is to help patients when burnout is constant and supplies are limited. The book had me questioning my own priorities since, even though we're not through the pandemic, the grind of every day life often makes me blind to its beauties. Overall, a compelling and thought-provoking story.

Thank you Random House / Ballantine Books and NetGalley for providing this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I. Loved. This. Book.
I feel like this is old school Jodi Picoult writing and boy, did I miss it. This was definitely an emotional roller coaster with twists and turns that I never saw coming. It was tough to read about the height of the pandemic while still in a pandemic, to bring back those emotions and I had to put the book down for a few hours because it was so real; but I feel this is just a testament to her writing. I highly recommend this book to any one looking to read about the pandemic from the human/personal experience.

Was this review helpful?

Diana and her boyfriend, Finn, are planning a dream vacation to the Galapagos, but their plans are sidelined when COVID hits New York right before they leave. Finn, a surgical resident, has to stay, but he insists Diana take the trip. She makes it to the island just as the world shuts down. Stranded for months, she gets only spotty updates about the horrors Finn and others are facing as the virus ravages thousands. On the island, she forms a bond with a teen girl, her father, and her grandmother–one that has her rethinking the entire course of her life.

I’ve seen many readers say that it’s too soon for a COVID novel, but I think Picoult’s comes at just the right time. It’s not the story you think it is, and it succeeds in bringing close so many different aspects of this virus. It’s exactly the empathy-building book we need right now and I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

This book was charming, delightful, sweet, fun, sorrowful, sad, and gut wrenching all in one. The twist in the middle shocked me (which is HARD) to do and all the way to the end I was holding my breath. This was a quick read but held my attention from beginning to end. The first story I’ve really seen that captured the intensity, uncertainty, and mayhem that was the beginning of the pandemic. I wasn’t super familiar with Jodi’s work before this was kindly sent to me as an ARC through the publisher and NetGalley but WOW I will be checking out more of her books now.

Was this review helpful?

This was so, so heavy. I think if you're in a place where you haven't lost someone to COVID or if you're able to stay in a good mental health space and read about COVID, this would be an okay book for you to read. If, however, you're experiencing this pandemic the way so many of us are, it's just too heavy and not a great moment for this one. Jodi Picoult is obviously an outstanding writer, but I found that the story was dragging and then I found that I needed to skim just to process. I'm reading to step away from the world, so I'm not super interested right now in reading more about it.

Was this review helpful?

Diana and her boyfriend, Finn have planned their dream vacation to the Galapagos Islands, where she thinks he will propose. But when the Covid-19 virus is starting to peak in New York, Finn has to stay behind as he is a surgical resident, but he tells Diana she should still go. Her vacation starts out wrong with her luggage getting lost, no internet and the island shutting down due to the virus. Being stranded on the island she begins to meet the locals and starts to interact with a teenager that needs to open up to someone. While on the island she begins to examine her relationships, her job and the choices she has made. This is a very timely and thought provoking book.

Was this review helpful?