Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Jodi Picoult’s upcoming novel Wish You Were Here takes place in March of 2020. Diana works in the art auction world and is on track to have the life she’s always dreamed of. She’s found love with her boyfriend Finn, a surgical resident in NYC, and feels so sure he’s going to propose on their upcoming trip to the Galápagos Islands. But when COVID-19 hits the US, it’s all hands on deck at the hospital, and Finn needs to stay in New York. He convinces Diana to go without him, but upon arrival with the islands shutting down, finds she’s made a mistake. Stranded until borders reopen, Diana has to learn to forge her own way, but will she be the same person when she returns?

I apologize in advance to the Jodi Picoult die-hards out there, but yikes… this was not it. Quite frankly, I found the main character Diana to be incredibly selfish and unfocused on anything but what she wants at any given moment. Finn was a saint for dealing with her, on top of already being exhausted from taking care of COVID patients everyday. In a world where this pandemic is still very much a part of our everyday lives, the lack of regard for anyone but herself made Diana absolutely insufferable to me. I enjoy books with unlikable characters, but they need to be self aware. Diana didn’t think she had done anything wrong, and it just made me hate her. There is a huge twist about 55% through that just frustrated and annoyed me, but I can’t say more without huge spoilers.

I definitely think this is a book you can skip, even if you love Jodi’s other books. Thanks to @netgalley and Ballantine Books for the eARC. Wish You Were Here will be published November 30, 2021.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for this ARC. I have been a big fan of Jodi Picoult, so I was very excited to receive this ebook. This is a very timely story given the state of the the world with Covid-19. That being said, it is a good story. It follows Diana, who is on track to have her life play out according to the plan she has in her head. A great career with Sotheby's, marriage to her soon to be fiance' and kids by the time she's 35. A romantic trip is planned where Diana knows her boyfriend Finn plans to propose. Then the world falls apart due to a virus. Finn, being a doctor, cannot go on the trip. He urges her to go and she does. This otherwise planned to be amazing trip, is anything but. The island ends up being quarantined, and thankfully Diana finds and befriends a family who lets her stay with them. As time passes, Diana begins to rethink the things she had planned for her life. I did like this book and it is well written, but it wasn't a favorite, but maybe that's because Picoult has so many incredible books! I do recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

I've never written a review before finishing a book. I am at 23% and I just had to stop. I've read Jodi Picoult books before (is there anyone who hasn't?) but this one is just . . . special. It's beautiful and heartbreaking and transcendent—any yet also relatable. I love Picoult's descriptions and prose. love the emails and letters that are mixed in with the storyline. I love learning about Diana's work with Sotheby's and her relationship with her parents and Finn's experience as a doctor in NYC during COVID.
I have a million things I should be doing right now but all I want to do is keep reading. I hope, though, that eventually I'll put this book aside. I don't want to gulp it down. I want it to last, to savor this story. But I had to pause for just a few minutes to share my thoughts, to gush a little bit here.
Thank you to JP for writing this amazing book, and for the person at Random House who sent me the link to download just yesterday. I started it because I was curious after reading the description and I'm so glad I did.

Was this review helpful?

Even though Jodi Picoult is one of my favorite authors, I wasn’t sure I could stay the course with this one because of the Covid theme. But I’m so glad I did!

Diana is in the Galapagos on a 2-week trip that she hoped would end in an engagement to her long-time boyfriend, Finn, a surgeon. But she’s there alone, and things are dire. The Covid-19 pandemic is in its earliest stages, and Finn is called in to work in the Covid ICU and can’t get the time off. And in the Galapagos, Diana’s hotel and most of the stores are closed, she can’t get a phone signal, she doesn’t speak the language, and her money is running out. If not for the initially reluctant assistance of the locals, she wouldn’t know how to cope. When she is able (only sporadically) to receive email, she reads Finn’s heartbreaking account of what his life at the hospital has become.

But gradually, as Diana makes some friends in this unfamiliar country, she begins to wonder if her carefully planned life is really what she wants. The story is brimming with musings about the art business vs. artistic expression and one particularly storied Toulouse Lautrec painting, as well as interactions with the indigenous wildlife for which the islands are known. Family dynamics are also movingly explored. And all of it is in Picoult’s luminous prose.

The plot takes a stunning turn in the latter part of the book, which I won’t spoil because you NEED to read it for yourself.

My thanks to NetGalley and Random House/Ballantine Books for allowing me the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

When Covid first comes to New York City, Finn, a surgical resident, must stay behind, but encourages Diana to go on their long awaited trip to the Galapagos without him. As soon as she gets to the island, it shuts down with all tourists escaping back to the mainland. Diana decides to stay anyway. Through patchy cell service, Diana begins to learn the true extent of Finn's Covid reality, just as she is beginning to learn more about the island - and in turn herself.

Halfway through the book, you're thrown for a complete loop and this book becomes something completely different, something I'm not sure I was truly on board with. I liked where it was leading in the first 50% and am still unsure how I felt about it after. And because we're still in the midst of the pandemic, I'm not sure if I would've liked it better had I been further removed from it.

However, I loved the journey that Diana went on as she learned more about who she really is inside. I liked how realistic the Finn character felt being a frontline worker. And I loved the relationship between Diana and Beatriz, a teenager from the island. All in all, I'd recommend this one - maybe just when we're on the other side of Covid.

(This book will be reviewed on the 10/6/21 episode of Reading Through Life podcast.)

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult's writing is stellar in this emotional book. I highly recommend this book! You won't be disappointed!

Was this review helpful?

The first book I ever read by Jodi Picoult was The Pact. I made the mistake of reading that on vacation -- the mistake was that all I wanted to do was read. It was that engrossing. I read everything she's ever written up to 2020's The Book of Two Ways, which brought my streak to a screeching halt. It was so heavy and filled with ancient Egyptian history that I couldn't get through it. While I liked Wish You Were Here a little more, I didn't like it as much as other Jodi books.

The main character, Diana O'Toole, is positive that her boyfriend, Finn, will propose on their upcoming trip to the Galapagos. But as a surgical resident, Finn must cancel the trip because of "all hands on deck" at the hospital. At this point, no one knew exactly how bad Covid would get. Implausibly, he tells Diana she should still go, and she does. But, of course, she gets stranded and only has limited contact with Finn, who tells her that things are not going well. Since her hotel has closed, a local family puts her up, and she grows close with them.

A warning that the majority of Wish You Were Here is about the pandemic, so if you're not ready to read about that yet, you might want to steer clear. I think what I found most frustrating is that Diana in the Galapagos really seems like a completely different book than what Finn is going through in the States. The mesh wasn't seamless. All in all, I would put this toward the bottom of the list of Picoult books, but that's because she has so many other ones I liked better.

MY RATING - 3

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here is Jodi Picoult’s latest book. It starts out with Diana who works for an art auction dealer and she has planned a trip to the Galápagos Islands with her bf Finn, who is a surgeon in NYC. A pandemic hits NYC and Finn tells her to go ahead without him (personally I can’t imagine going across the world by myself like that but … ). As soon as she gets there, everyone and everything is in lockdown so she’s stuck there. Instead of just being a tourist now, she becomes friends with a family who has many secrets. The pandemic is front and center throughout the book. I wondered if it was “too early” for a book about Covid but she wrote a really touching novel here. It’s been a nightmare for so many people in 2020 and still going strong, unfortunately through 2021. There is a BIG TWIST a little more than 60% out and Holy cow!!!! What the heck happened???? You can tell ALOT of research went into this book and i really feel it’s one of her best books to date. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this early release in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I don't want to give any spoilers on this book. I was a bit hesitant to read it because I knew it was based on covid. I read the acknowledgements and author's note and felt connected to Jodi. She talked about struggling with asthma during covid and what it meant to her. I decided to give it a read as I felt I would be able to relate since I lived through covid with a chronic illness. This book can be a reminder of what we went through/still are going through with covid. But the way Diana changes and examines her life and how she is on the Galapagos is heart warming. I recommend this book to everyone. It will help you look inward.

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited for a new Jodi Picoult book but I was unsure about reading a book set during the pandemic while we are still in the pandemic. I am so glad that I read it now because it is just perfect. There is a whole ‘nother level of this book that I was not expecting and was super engaging. This was a great, quick read. Be sure to read the author’s note!

Was this review helpful?

Too soon?
I think it is too soon for me to read this book. I liked the beginning, it is well written and engaging, but maybe too engaging for where I am at right now. It talks about a pair who got separated in the beginning of the pandemic - one working in NY hospital seeing horrors, the other locked down on a remote island where she does not speak the language and doesn't even have her luggage. I think I would love to finish the book when all this truly behind us, but it is just too painful and too vivid for right now.
I received a digital copy of the book from NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Wow! Another timely and relevant masterpiece with a classic Jodi Picoult twist! The protagonist of the story, Diana has her life planned out to include a career, marriage, a move to the suburbs and eventually children. And she is on target to achieve all these goals. She and her boyfriend, Finn, a surgical resident at a New York City hospital are ready to take a vacation to the Galapagos islands and Diana is certain that Finn will propose while they are there. However, the day before they are set to leave, Finn is ordered by his boss to stay in the city to help fight the new Covid 19 pandemic. Through a miscommunication, Finn insists that Diana go on the non refundable vacation without him even though he really wants her to stay in the city. Diana travels to Isabela Island in the Galapagos only to arrive and find out that the island is closed due to the pandemic. She has nothing but her backpack and with no place to stay, mostly nonexistent Internet access and no ATM or money, she has to rely on the island residents, most of whom do not speak English. During her several weeks of isolation, Diana explores the island with her new friends, Gabriel and Beatriz and her experiences change her life forever. Meanwhile, back in New York City, Finn is experiencing his own life changing events while treating Covid patients who are severely ill and dying. The author very cleverly incorporates Finn’s experiences into the story by use of very descriptive emails to Diana which come through randomly to the island via sketchy Internet service.
In the afterword of the book, Jodi Picoult explains her extensive research for the book done while she was spending a year in pandemic isolation. Her beautiful descriptions of Isabela island will make any reader want to put this destination on his or her bucket list. But it’s not all paradise on the island. The author also masterfully incorporates complex relationship issues, teenage angst and issues of single parenthood into the storyline of Diana’s time on the island.
Once Diana and Finn are reunited, they begin to struggle with their own values and relationship issues, mostly brought on by the impact of the pandemic. As a reader, I really appreciate the author’s tribute to healthcare workers who are risking their lives daily to take care of Covid patients. As a nurse, I especially appreciate Finn’s comment about nurses being the real heroes in this battle. Picoult’s research also enabled her to include very real and descriptive after effects developed by Covid long haulers. All of the issues around the COVID-19 pandemic should never be forgotten and Jodi Picoult is definitely ensuring that these concerns are brought to the forefront in this fantastic novel. Even though the characters are impacted forever as a result of this horrible pandemic, Picoult ends the story with hope for the future. This book is hard to put down. Definitely one to stay up all night to finish. My favorite Jodi Picoult novel to date!
Also worth mentioning, I love the way the author incorporates the wisdom of Kitomi Ito, AKA Yoko Ono into Diana’s transformation.

Was this review helpful?

Truthfully, this was the first Picoult book I've ever picked up. My supervisor has always recommended her, and when I saw this available as an ARC, she urged me to apply for it. So I did!

All in all, I really enjoyed this read. It started a bit slow, with a lot of art business jargon that resulted in me taking a break for a couple of days because I really couldn't get into it. But I forced myself to keep going, and I'm glad I did.

Picoult lives up to her legacy- she truly pours into her research and ensures that any time she gets technical, her information is spot on. While this is great, I did find that the parts where she shares her research to be dragging a bit, and I fervently hoped for those sections to go by a bit faster. However, they were still expertly written, and I appreciated that she credited her sources in the credit section at the end.

Her characters I found to be phenomenal. Each of them was unique, and I had no trouble at all distinguishing one character from the next. It was very refreshing to see a white female author being inclusive, and actually writing a fun gay character (even if that was most of his personality). Each of them was fully believable, and I enjoyed the Galapagos family that adopts Diana.

And that TWIST! When she woke up and found herself in the hospital, I started flipping back and forth between the last page and the start of the new chapter because I was so confused about what was going on. As I kept reading, I started to understand, but I thought it was interesting how she chose one of the stranger effects of Covid for the premise of her book. Though this felt a little weird, I feel that she very effectively conveyed the severity of Covid- even if she used a lot of technical terms that sort of alienated the virus and made it that much more intimidating. I felt just as confused as Diana when she resurfaced, and felt her anger as everyone tried to convince her that it was nothing but a result of drugs, the vent, and her lack of oxygen. Picoult did her research on the hallucination stories, though- I found several of them online after I finished her book.

I did have a few issues, one of which being Beatriz. It may be from personal experience, but when white women force their way into the lives of suicidal teens and try to "fix" them, I just get really irked. I think that their interactions were believable, and Diana was decently competent at talking her through her problems, but it was still pretty annoying that she was basically inviting herself into this family and their issues. I mean I guess it was okay- she was basically in a dream state so if her relationships flowed perfectly, it's no surprise.

When Finn proposed and she declined, I will say I was a little surprised. Her reasoning felt weird, and I didn't entirely believe that their relationship was truly in shambles. Yes, Finn was perhaps a bit too overprotective and constrictive when she left rehab, but I didn't fully grasp how their relationship could have fallen apart so quickly. Maybe I just wasn't paying attention, but it just wasn't really believable for me.

Other than those little things, I enjoyed the book. I liked the relationships between characters, I liked the heart-wrenching moments Diana shared with her mother, I liked the twist that left Diana fumbling for an answer and confused about whether she wanted back her life in the Galapagos or her life with Finn. Picoult's writing was also very good, and I think her plot and characters were well done. Although at first it seems that she is just going to be tackling Covid and how Diana is torn between returning to Finn and staying in the Galapagos, there are so many other touchy issues present that she tackles head-on.

All in all, this was a good read with a twist that leaves your head spinning with a well-written story and characters. My only wish is that she had written a little more for that ending!

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't too sure about reading a book set during the pandemic. Ultimately, I enjoyed reading Wish You Were Here and following Diana O'Toole on her adventure to the Galapagos Islands where she faces many challenges as the world is on lockdown. Diana leaves behind her boyfriend Finn, a New York City physician in the trenches with Covid patients to go on the vacation they had planned to take together. Her life takes a series of turns as she navigates life during a lockdown on the other side of the world from home. Without giving any spoilers, I can say I was shocked at the ending of the book and the twist that it took. Jodi Picoult is an expert at capturing emotion and humanity in her writing. She never disappoints! Thank you to Net Galley and Ballantine Books for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

It’s taken me a couple days to be ready to write a review for @jodipicoult newest novel “Wish You Were Here”. If anyone can write a book about the COVID 19 pandemic, and write it beautifully…it’s Jodi. ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
-
-Diana had her life perfectly planned out, and so far, it was perfectly on track!! She and her boyfriend were headed on a trip to Galápagos Islands where (hopefully) he’d be proposing. But Finn is a doctor in NYC, and this book takes place in Spring 2020. So, he encourages her to go on the trip, while he stays. But when she gets to the island, the quarantine goes into effect and she can’t leave.
-
-
-While this is a fiction novel, Finn’s experiences of working with Covid-19 patients, is absolutely true. And there were times I had tears in my eyes and times I had to stop. But wow, I loved this book!

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult is a long-time favorite of mine. I've read nearly all of her books (except for only 2) and I have to say that this one is right at the top of the list of the best books she's ever written. I didn't know how I would feel reading about the pandemic while we are still very much dealing with it, but she nailed it.

I was transported right back to the day when our country started to shut down and felt every emotion again that I did at the beginning of the pandemic. This is so much more than a story about a person during the pandemic, but a story of hope, resiliency, strength, and love.

Absolutely beautiful. 5 stars all around.

Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for the digital ARC in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This book is set during the covid pandemic. This may be too soon for some, but I was okay with it. Diana is living a great life in NY, working in Art Auction. Her fiance Finn is a surgical resident at the hospital. They are set to go on a two week vacation to the Galapagos and she thinks Finn is going to propose.

Then covid hits the city and Finn is not able to go on the trip because he must stay to help at the hospital, but tells Diana she should go on this trip without him, so they don't let all their money go to waste. She reluctantly decides to go.

After she's there, everyone goes into lockdown, and she is unable to leave the island, but finds an apartment to stay in. She feels alone and nervous about her circumstances. She ends up meeting a local family, and then things will really pull you in at this point. I do not want to give any more details about this story as to not spoil anything.

This was very emotional, and I love how she took this book in a direction I was not expecting. Picoult definitely put a lot of research into this one and I was completely captivated while reading!

Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the gifted copy! All opinions are my own!

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure that I was ready to read a novel with covid as a main thread but I am so glad I did.

Jodi Picoult has done it again. I have actually just re-read this book because once was not enough. The descriptions of the Galapagos Islands brought the reader far from covid but then you jumped back to New York and felt the pandemic all over again. Then back to beauty and the exploration of character.

The character development was amazing. The writing was amazing. One of my most favorite books in a very long time.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This book gave me all of the emotion.

Suspense, shock, life and love. If you are looking for a book to really keep you guessing, this is one of them. Set in the year 2020, Diana O’Toole, an associate specialist at Sotheby’s, (one of the largest brokers of art collectibles), and Finn Colson, (a surgical resident at a New York hospital), were going to Galapagos. Things changed when Finn was told he could not leave New York in early March for their trip to be prepared for the wave of COVID-19.

Diana heads to the Galapagos without Finn and as you can imagine, the island goes into lockdown. Diana meets a few residents on the island and a former tour guide Gabriel who helps her through. Jodi's writing made me feel like I was actually there set with vivid views of the oceans, turtles and volcanoes.

This book is one I couldn't put down. You really do come to love the characters and want to continue to learn more about them. In each of these twists and turns, you'll feel and remember the times of isolation we had in the Spring of 2020. Reflecting on this book, it's one where I couldn't put it down but I'm still shocked by the vivid images of the last year and how the entire world was impacted by COVID-19. It's a heavy reminder but one with a unique and almost reflective perspective.

One note from me:
For those who had harrowing side effects of COVID-19, be prepared that this book is set in the year 2020. If you were affected by COVID-19, this will affect you. Meaning, everyone will most likely be affected by this book.

“Wish You Were Here” is set to publish on November 30, 2021

I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher, Ballantine Books, through NetGalley. Thanks for #Netgalley for the advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

Five Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult is an amazing book that I will not soon forget. I read this over a week ago, and the story is still stuck in my head, with no signs it will leave soon. This is a book about COVID, and some say it’s too soon, but I say, it’s just in time, and we need more books like this that illustrate the dire circumstances we are in with the pandemic.

Diane O’Toole has almost everything she wants. She has the job she’s always wanted and a loving boyfriend named Finn who she’s sure is about to propose marriage on their upcoming vacation to the Galapagos Islands. Her job as an art consultant at Sotheby's is her dream job since her college days and she’s expecting a big promotion very soon. Her boyfriend Finn is a surgical resident in a NYC hospital.

Just before they are set to depart for the Galapagos Islands, the virus, known as COVID-19 starts to hit New York City. The day prior to when they are set to leave for the airport, Finn tells Diane that he can’t go on vacation because his superiors at the hospital have told everyone to stay in the city because they expect the virus to get much worse. After some discussion, Diane leaves for the vacation on her own.

This is one of those books where spoilers will really spoil the story, so I won’t say much more about the story, except it was gripping, intense, educational, and very emotional. As COVID is the main subject of the book, I would think some people who have really suffered during this pandemic and lost close friends and family, might find this book is out a bit too soon. I do think that it validates many of the feelings I’ve had during the pandemic, and the book definitely describes many of the horrors we’ve suffered, but it's also an optimistic book. I was afraid that when I read it would be depressing. I will admit that the author describes many of the horrors of the pandemic, but also weaves a terrific emotional story around all the losses and difficulties of the pandemic.

Wish You Were Here will bring out all your emotions as you read it. Only a very talented author can write about such a devastating subject and turn it into such an uplifting story. And Jodi Picoult has proved what a talented author she is with this book. I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?