Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Diana has all of her ducks in a row: She’s working at a job she finds personally (and financially) fulfilling, she’s expecting a proposal from her very serious (and very good looking) surgeon boyfriend, and things are going well in the New York fast life. And then COVID happens. And just like in real life, it blows everything upside down. This was the first fiction I’ve read that incorporated COVID and I think Picoult got a lot of things right. She’s an excellent writer, although parts of the book moved much slower than I would’ve liked. For that reason, I’m rating it a solid 3.

NOTE: Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here is a novel that chronicles how the world, our lives, can change between heartbeats.

While some may not be ready for a story that plunges directly into Covid-19's heart of darkness yet, especially since this one exposes our shared sense of fear, isolation, grief, and heartache when people first started dying and we went into global lockdown in 2020, I knew I couldn't stay away. I wanted to read something that would resonate. Something that would frame this unprecedented moment, this nightmare experience, in a context that might make it a little easier to process. To understand.

I think a part of me has been searching for a literary excuse to ruminate over all that's transpired over the last year-and-a-half for a while now. I've been looking despite knowing that, once I stopped, I'd be smacked with echoes of pain from the moment I opened that Pandora's Box.

Still, I was ready for this. I needed it.

Like the characters in this book, I have been touched by this pandemic, too. I've experienced the surreality. I know people who have fallen gravely ill, others who have died. I have a brother who is a doctor treating patients in the ICU. I also understand there are those out there who still believe this virus is "no worse than the flu" even though the science says otherwise. I have had to make changes in my own life. I've listened, I've learned. I've adapted in order to survive the New Normal.

We all have.

To say that we haven't would be a lie.

The beauty of this book then, at least for me, was how Picoult was able to give voice - real voice - to all the people who have been existing behind the vague face of the pandemic since it first began.

What I liked about that is how it did away with all the numbing statistics that track down our news screens every day and instead created a visible pulse that could be touched. Believed. Humanized. It provided readers with a specific personhood they could envision. They were allowed to meet, to get to know, a few people who were actively being affected by this virus in early 2020. They got to see and experience what was happening to them, almost vicariously.

The characters in this story were all real flesh and blood people who were trying to cope with the sudden, unexpected changes Covid-19 brought to their lives.

For Diana, an art specialist who thought she knew exactly what she wanted personally and professionally, that meant getting stranded in the beautiful Galápagos Islands during lockdown. Though alone there and unable to speak the language, she forms a connection with a local family and begins to reevaluate her identity. She also must work through issues she has with her mother, who is in a nursing home suffering from dementia.

While there, she's separated from her boyfriend, Finn, whom she plans to marry. He's a surgical resident who is confronting the horrors and PTSD involved in being on the frontlines, at home, in New York City. His emails to her record the overwhelming burden medical professionals face in the fight to treat sick Covid patients. They also detail how hospital resources are running thin or have been stretched to crisis level.

The insight he provides as a physician, as someone whose job it is to save lives, is stirring in a way that makes readers think but also leaves them bleeding with compassion.

There's a Sliding Doors element that pops up part way through this book as well, so be aware of that. However, to say any more would be to spoil the overall effect...which, when it hit, sent a shock across my chest like a defibrillator because it was so heartbreakingly good! So, so good! I never saw it coming.

This was one of my favorite works from Picoult so far.

Though not for the faint of heart, it's certainly a timely story that keeps readers plugged into the characters and hooked into their emotions from the beginning as they struggle to make sense of Covid, as they try try to tether themselves to something steady. It's a riveting tale of people who are orienting about all lost and adrift amid a new - and shocking - global reality.

A special thanks to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for the ARC in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I have read from this author in close to a decade and wasn't sure how to feel as I read it. I found that this is a book I have been waiting to read since the pandemic began. I think that this will resonate with so many people as a shared time, but I think the tie in works so well with this book. It did take me a while to get into this, but am so glad I kept reading. I felt so many things and appreciated so much of what was written although this was quite a departure for this author from past books I have read. I will definitely be recommending this to others. Thanks for the ARC, NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I was happy to receive an early copy of Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult as I enjoy her novels. This book did not disappoint. She took the very difficult topic of the pandemic and turned it into a very enjoyable story that I couldn’t put down. I have to say I didn’t not expect the twist at the end of the first part of the book. I’m going to recommend this book to my book group when it comes out. I’ll be happy to read it again, taking my time, and enjoy it all over again.

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult was everything! I was so skeptical about reading my first book that deals with Covid, but I savored every word of this stunning novel. I think you should go into this one without reading too much about it beforehand. I was pleasantly surprised by all the feelings this story brought out in me and it’s has taken a spot as one of my favorite books of the year! Highly recommend!!

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for the opportunity to read this book for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

One of Jodi Picoult’s better novels, I was immersed into this novel from the very beginning as we follow Diana O’Toole’s journey through the COVID-19 pandemic. Like with previous novels, Picoult takes her readers on a journey with plot twists along the way that make for a beautiful story of resilience during a time of uncertainty. Cannot say more than this because I do not want to give away anything about the story. #wishyouwerehere @jodipicoult

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, this book was not for me. While I enjoyed the setting and it was a nice, immersive escape to an island, that’s where my enjoyment ended. I didn’t enjoy the main twist and felt it was for shock value. I think it’s probably too soon for me to be reading about COVID. Thank you to the publisher for my advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

Imagine--Diana, ready for a dream vacation to the Galapagos Islands with Finn, who she expects will propose to her there. But, it is March 2020. Finn is a surgical resident at a NYC hospital, and he has just been informed he will be needed for the expected number of COVID cases. Vacation plans are off for him, but when he tells her to just go without him, she does. Or, so the story begins.
The unfolding seemed a little different for Jodi Picoult, yet I was turning the pages quickly--and then the story surprised me in a way that I couldn't put it down.
The Finn character gives a great doctor's view of the COVID experience through medical eyes, while Diana takes us on a vacation that is far from the descriptions in her tour books.
Picoult has been my favorite author ever since I read My Sister's Keeper. She is a master of taking a social issue and seeing it in more than one light. She does not disappoint. Loved this read, right up to the last three sentences.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed Wish You Were Here, a Covid related story of a woman with Covid who dreams a whole different reality while she is under sedation and on a ventilator. Her dreams are a real reality to her and the people, places, conversations, and situations haunt her when she awakens and recovers. It is a curious notion to explore, that of a parallel life that feels real and elicits emotions.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I had a difficult time reading this book. It was not that it was bad it was actually very well written and quite good. I just struggled with the content. It is definitely worth the read.

Thank you to publisher and NetGalley for allowing me to read this book!

Was this review helpful?

Author Jodi Picoult is widely known for her #RealisticFiction on timely topics, but no title is more timely than #WishYouWereHere. Other reviewers may share more details, but I highly recommend this books for two reasons. The first is the shocking right-hand turn mid-novel. This turn served as the driving force to read the book in one sitting. The second reason to read this book is how deftly Picoult informs readers about something for which they have may no knowledge weaving it into the second half of the book seamlessly. November 30 cannot come soon enough for readers of her works and I highly recommend this to all readers who enjoy timely Realistic Fiction. Thank you #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This was incredible. I cried, got full body chills, I loved it. This book will sit with me for a long time. This is the first Covid novel I have read and it did not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

I have never been as viscerally affected by a book as I was by Wish You Were Here
After I overcame my annoyance at the use of a Yoko Ono/John Lennon allusion at the beginning, , the book started to hit home I became the book much like Diana.
As a native New Yorker who has experienced and is experiencing the Covid -19 Pandemic currently, I was a bit leery of tackling fiction that is my current events BUT I fell into the story head first and have yet to come out of it. It touched parts of me that I haven't been able to reach since this all began

Jodi Picoult is an amazing storyteller. As this is my first read of what I expect to be a long list in the Pandemic genre, I don't know if this reaction is due to the subject or the story. or the caliber of the writer.

But it is one story I shall never be able to let go of.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure if I could read this book during the pandemic but somehow it gave me strength and positivity for going forward.

Was this review helpful?

My social media review(s) will be on my Instagram account this week (week of 8/23 preview review; full review/pub date celebration Nov 30th).

Thank you for the chance to read such a thought provoking and moving book. I appreciate the ARC from Random House and NetGalley to read and review Jodi Picoult's new book Wish You Were Here. I took 48 hours to process what I wanted to say about this tremendously moving and thoughtful story and I simply want to say it stuck with me, sticks with me still days later, and I have already recommended it to many friends and on my Instagram stories.

It would be easy to say some won't be ready for a book set in this recent past but... that is unfair to the actual beauty of this book and narrative and shortchanges what Ms. Picoult has done: she has captured the sense of what if we leave this time in our lives as different/changed people in unexpected ways, what and who will be will and who do we want to be, and even perhaps a subtle why did this happen feeling that has been a part of how many of us have reflected on this pandemic. Ms. Picoult also captures the nuances of the confusion and uncertainty of different stages of the pandemic and does so in a way that resonates and validates small and big moments.

There is also for me the standard well researched and examined points in this book, details and richness with art history, the natural world in Galapagos, specific experiences with COVID and I appreciate the care that Ms. Picoult shows her characters, the book's settings, and her readers with these details and depth. Once the true meaning of Ms. Picoult's story and Diana's story is unearthed, there is an emotional connection and awakening that truly resonated with me. I stayed up late to finish this book just because I wanted and needed to know where Diana's story would lead me.

Diana's story is one that is so relatable to me, having a path, following it, seeking out early and steadfast success and being willing to put in the hard work and effort to achieve goals; planning for a happy and stable life with a partner and envisioning a happy life together. And yet the sense of something else, the what if this isn't what she wants or ever wanted, what is there is something else to life? Placing these questions within the early weeks and months of the pandemic... that is what this book is about at its essence. Though Diana has her life set and organized, her story still feels like a coming of age story or perhaps more a finding a way to try to make sense of this pandemic life story if this can be the start of a specific sub genre.

It is hard to say more without taking away the experience readers should have with this book, I imagine many will feel as I did (moved, emotionally connected) and others will take away other meaning and connection to this story. I can't wait to hear how reading friends and my book clubs feel about this book.

Thank you again for this ARC, it is an outstanding book and probably my favorite from Jodi Picoult.

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult writes books about timely social issues, and none will be more controversial than her November 2021 book Wish You Were Here. In this book, she has combined three different story lines. There is a romance with great characters that will pull at your heart strings. There is her relationship with her mother which many people will find fascinating in that love/hate drama that only families or close friends ever achieve. Finally, she embraces the pandemic of 2020 by interviewing front line workers, survivors, and families that lost loved ones. She describes the shutdowns we all experienced and the fears we still harbor. She embraces what it means to be human and describes the love, resilience, bravery, and hope that we have experienced.

Some reviewers of this arc (I received an advanced copy from netgalley.com in exchange for a review) have expressed that they think she wrote about COVID too soon. I certainly learned more than I ever knew from the first responder accounts, the descriptions of the hospital settings, the truth about vents and how they affect patients, and how long it takes for those who come off vents to rehabilitate back to where they were before they got sick. Since they were in hospital wards with no visitors, we had no personal experience seeing how they were doing. Since Delta doesn’t seem to be slowing down, COVID is not behind us over a year later and the debates about the vaccinations and the masks and the political divisions of the country still haunt us.

In New York, the ambitious Diana O'Toole is almost thirty, and on the verge of achieving all that she wants professionally as an art specialist at Sotheby's, and personally, convinced that Finn Colson, a surgical resident at the Presbyterian hospital will propose on a trip to Galapagos to celebrate her 30th birthday. However, her carefully planned life is about to be change forever when Finn is unable to go with her as a medical emergency develops with the beginnings of the Covid-19 virus. Diana arrives on Galapagos as it is going into quarantine and lockdown, leaving her stranded, her luggage is lost, she cannot speak the language, and internet is patchy. She is isolated and lonely but finds herself connecting with a local family. Like so many people, Diana is to find herself re-evaluating her sense of identity and working out what really matters in life.

I learned that COVID patients who survive may have lingering symptoms that may or may not change like sense of smell or taste. I discovered there is such a thing as COVID psychosis and that survivors may have PTSD. And I learned more about therapists and how they deal with these problems than I previously knew. I had no idea there was what we call art therapy.

Meanwhile, her mother is coping with her memory loss in an assisted living home where she can have no visitors. And having more time since furloughed from her museum job, Diana reflects on the journey of their lives during the past thirty years.

Finally, Finn gives us a behind the scenes look at what is really happening in his hospital.

As the three stories build in the book, you will meet many unforgettable characters. Some have stayed with me since I completed the book. Certainly, the COVID facts and descriptions will linger. There are many, many twists and turns in the book which I cannot discuss in this review without ruining the story for future readers. Suffice it to say that just when you think you know what is what and who is who, you do not. I will continue to make my own decision about the last chapter in the book for a long time to come.

Is this book easy to read? The answer is possibly not but I will also tell you that I could not put it down and read late in the night to finish it in about a week. Even though it may be too soon to read about COVID, I could not stop turning the pages. I have read almost all of Jodi’s books. I loved the Egyptian book, and she has done her COVID research to write this one. I look forward to reading her next book. Be sure to read her comments at the end of the book which explain the research she conducted while writing. I loved reading this book. I hope you will too. Thank you to netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult is one of the best books I have ever read. I was do caught up in the story. The unexpected turn took me totally by surprise. What a way to remember 2020!

Was this review helpful?

I think there will be some mixed thoughts about this book which centers on the covid-19 pandemic. I'm sure there will be plenty of people who don't want to read about it, I'm also sure there will be plenty like me who will gobble it up. It is fascinating to read a story about an event that is still happening, and I appreciate the way this story offers multiple perspectives on living through the covid pandemic.

This story is about Diana, a woman trapped in the Galapagos Islands on a solo vacation when the world shuts down. Meanwhile her boyfriend Finn is working as an ER doctor in New York City, fighting daily to save the lives of the multitude of patients flowing into his hospital with covid every day.

We get to learn about both of their lives in these different places at the start of the pandemic, and then juxtaposition is striking. Of course, it led me to think about where I was just 18 months ago when covid started, and then to consider how much has changed (and how much is still the same!) since that moment. There's a lot of room for self-reflection as this story plays out in these character's lives.

Picoult has proven time and time again that she can tell a good story, and this book is no exception. I was pulled into this story from the beginning. And while I thought there were some moments when it dragged in the second half of the book, I still flew through this one so quickly! I definitely enjoyed it MUCH more than her last book (The Book of Two Ways).

Another thing Picoult is know for is using unique structure or a surprise plot twist to keep the reader on their toes. I sometimes complain that she does this so often, the supposed surprise ends up not being a surprise at all because we have learned to expect it. Well this book managed to pull off some unexpected moments for me! I want to avoid spoilers, so I won't go into details, but I really liked the way she wrote this book -- the structure, the ending. I thought it worked so well to tell the story!

If you are ready to dive into a story that centers on the covid pandemic, I recommend checking this one out when it is released in November!

Thanks to Netgalley and Ballantine Books for sending me an advance copy in exchange for my honest review. This one will be out on November 30, and it's available for preorder now.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this book but I had a hard time getting into it. I felt like the writing was ok and the characters never really kept my interest.

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult is the first book I've read that was written about the Covid pandemic during the pandemic. Picoult has become one of !my favorite authors in the last couple of years and this book did not in any way disappoint me even though she admits to writing it faster than her normal pace.

Diana works at Sotheby's and is on the verge of making several life goals come true. She's meeting with a client who is selling a piece of art Diana is sure will earn her a promotion. She and her fiance, Finn, are hours away from leaving on their dream vacation to the Galapagos, where she is confident Finn is going to propose. Dreams meet Covid. Finn is a resident at a local hospital and is told his vacation time is cancelled as they need all hands on deck. He tells Diana to go without him because the trip is nonrefundable and he won't be home much anyway.. Diana arrives just as the islands are shutting down because of Covid. She has no choice but to deal with it since there is no way home. She meets Gabriel, his mother, and his daughter Beatriz . There is little to no internet or cell service so she can barely even communicate with the outside world.

The rest of the book gives an amazingly detailed & researched version of a patient with Covid who was able to come off a ventilator and fight their way back to life as well as the healthcare workers doggedly hoping to save every patient. I have worked in health care before so I already have a huge amount of respect for the people who choose to take of people for a living but this book not only makes the respect I felt small in comparison to the sacrifices they make but really opened my eyes to not only the battle they've been fighting and the toll it takes to lose more than they saved but also for the survivors of this pandemic and how drastically this virus can change their bodies and their lives.

Most of the time I read as an escape.. This book had aspects that stayed true to that need as well as eye opening facts about this disease and how our world is changing because of it.

Was this review helpful?