Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Diana is looking forward to a vacation to the Galapagos Islands with her boyfriend. Her life is right on track with a possible promotion at the art auction company and a future engagement after finding a ring at her boyfriend's home. The day before their trip, her boyfriend has to stay in New York when the number of Covid patients is rising. Yes this book takes place in March 2020. Diana, unaware of what the future holds, travels by herself and once she gets to her destination, the island just closes. Her hotel is closed, the internet is spotty and her luggage is lost. She forms relationships with the locals and her 2 week vacation extends to two months. This book has a very unexpected ending! I liked reading about artists through Diana's job and learning about the nature of the Galapagos Island. The only part I didn't like was the obvious story knock off of John Lennon and Yoko Ono. The author could have easily made up a famous celebrity.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book in exchange for an honest review.

To say I flew through this book is an understatement. I couldn't put it down. I honestly am tired of covid so a book about covid? I wasn't sure. But this is the covid book we all needed.

Diana and Finn have the perfect relationship. They are headed to the Galapagos where Diana knows she will get engaged at. Yay! But then covid hits 😞. Finn works at a hospital and he insists that Diana continue the trip. She goes but gets stuck there for months. Yikes! But while there she meets some amazing people who welcome her with open arms.

This book is something else. Plot twists, pandemics, romance, it has it all. Just read it.

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult once again examines the choices one makes and how circumstances can force retrospection and change. Diana and Finn are the perfect couple with shared goals that they are all on the way to achieving. Diana, who works for Sotheby's, is about to close on an amazing deal that is guaranteed to give her respect in the art community and a promotion. Finn is a resident at a NY City hospital and he is on his way to a successful career. But, Covid hits and their lives change. Finn is called to work on the Covid ward and Their upcoming plans to vacation in the Galapagos may need to be cancelled or Diana may need to vacation alone.
Picoult has excelled at providing a viewpoint from Frontline workers with her precise and heartbreaking accounts written to Diana from Finn. She explores the after effects of Covid patients and the often confusing and disturbing results of being placed on ventilators. The strength of this novel is in the medical details and accounts of survivors.
Recommended for Picoult fans. This is a story of resilience, choices, and taking chances.

Was this review helpful?

As someone who read Fever 1793 by Laurie Halse Anderson many times as a kid, I've spent most of the quarantine dreaming about the novels I'd read with main characters living through this pandemic. This wasn't at all what I thought I'd read.

No spoilers here, but this was exactly what I needed to read. It's lighthearted enough that it didn't make me feel sadder about the constant stream of Delta variant news and stories about hospitals running out of generators again. Don't get me wrong--this book was not a walk in the park to read. I cried so much while reading it, but it gave me a space to process my own COVID grief.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Jodi Picoult, and Ballantine Books for the advanced copy of Wish You Were Here. I was skeptical of this book during the first half of the book because writing about the pandemic and quarantine felt too raw and too soon, but I absolutely loved the second half of the book and the ending. Read it! #NetGalley #WishYouWereHere

Was this review helpful?

I quite enjoyed this title (as I always do for any Jodi Picoult novel). I was slightly wary of the fact that the premise dealt with the pandemic and wasn't sure how I would feel about "thoughts of the world infiltrating my time of escape", but I felt it was handled beautifully and I can see it resonating for years to come. I quite enjoyed this read and will recommend it to others during readers advisory in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This was a thoroughly absorbing and timely read, with quite a few surprises. 4.5 stars rounded up.

*Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing an e-galley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Random House Publishing for the eARC!

Jodi Picoult is one of my favorite authors and this book just reinforces that fact. Wish You Were Here is beautiful, heart wrenching, and immensely powerful all in one. Reading a story that was set during the lockdown of last year made me relive all of the emotions I felt last year. But, Jodi Picoult has a way with words. You will fall in love with the characters in this story and you will feel for them as well. This story made me cry and laugh and it also made me feel thankful as well. Also, that twist towards the end? Was not expecting that. However, I will say that if you lost someone to COVID-19 or had COVID, this story will definitely hit hard. There is also a warning for self-harm, it is talked about quite a bit. I would still recommend this book to everyone. It’s a beautiful story and I honestly fell in love with the main character by the end.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars - Intrigue set in as soon as I started reading. I wondered what it would’ve been like stranded in the Galapagos during the beginning of COVID. Unfortunately, I had a hard time liking the protagonist Diana. Then the second half of the book takes us back to NYC and the awfulness of COVID. I live in NYC so I didn’t need to read a book about what was going on here during that time.

Thank you NetGalley for an advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! At first I wondered if it was too soon to read about Covid- after all, it’s still here. But I found it so moving. I loved the story arc, the settings, the characters- all of it! Another smash hit by Jodi Picoult.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Wow.

It has been a while since I had that feeling. You turn the last page, and say "wow". And you feel hungover, and a little sad you are no longer in that world. And that ending - are you kidding me? I Loved it and I wanted to punch the author at the same time..

I've read many books by Jodi Picoult. I loved her earlier ones, and the recent ones, well, not so much. So when I received the opportunity for an ARC from #netgalley I went into it with high hopes, but low expectations. But I loved this book!

There is so much I want to say about this book, but I cannot. Because it will spoil so much. The surprises and twists are amazing, and the book is so much better if you don't realize what will happen.

I do want to give you a warning though. This takes place during the peak of Covid (before Delta) and there are some really sad, really stressful parts. If you had covid, had someone close who died from it, be aware that this could trigger you.

(Another warning - be careful of reviews - many people are giving some twists away)

Try this for yourself and enjoy!

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed Picoult's novel, Wish You Were Here. It reminded me that not every story needs to be a happy one. The harsh look at these children's lives open your eyes, and minds, to the reality that this is not a fantasy. There are children everywhere for whom lives like these are a reality. It was though provoking and well told.

Was this review helpful?

I am just blown away. This book is about the pandemic, it is intense, emotional, and very human. It is so well done. There was a mind blowing twist that just left me shook. This would be an excellent choice for a book club. It was well written and oh so relevant. Hands down my new favorite of Jodis!

Was this review helpful?

Just a fantastic book!!!!
I thought it was great that the "covid" issue was brought in to this in a truly realistic and medically correct aspect.
I have always believed that things happen for a reason and even when something bad happens to you , it happened to bring you to where you needed to be. When you look back years later you know why it happened..to teach you or to bring you to a better place.
I started this book yesterday,,,I finished it today...because i stayed up the ENTIRE night reading it, not wanting to put it down.
There wasn't any "slow" parts to this read what so ever.
One of the very best books I have read in a very long time.
Thank you for allowing me to read this.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars. I read this book in less than 48 hours. The subject matter is obviously very timely right now, and may not be the most ideal reading for some as it definitely invokes many feelings regarding the pandemic; but, the writing, medical details/knowledge, and character development are all excellent. The descriptions about the Galapagos and the "Yoko Ono" character were fascinating and clearly well-researched. Truthfully, I haven't loved many of Picoult's recent novels, but this one is a stand out and reminds me more of some of her earlier works. The twist was one that I never saw coming, which is generally the best kind. Thank you so much NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

While I typically LOVE everything that Jodi Piccoult writes, I had a hard time with this book.

It is VERY Covid/Pandemic heavy and maybe for me it was just too soon to read about something that we have all been living with.

I look forward to more book by this author, but for me this one didn't work.

Was this review helpful?

This was a tough one for me to get in to... maybe because I was reading while home with my children who were quarantined due to COVID - I wasn't in the best mind frame to read a book about it. I had not heard much about this book and went into it with a completely open mind, so I was taken by surprise by the first half as well as really shocked by the turn it took halfway through.

Diana has her life figured out - the perfect plan to follow and she's been checking off items left and right. Her boyfriend (and soon to be fiancé according to the ring she just found) is right there with her. They share a life plan and work together to achieve the goals they've created.
Diana and Finn (her surgical resident boyfriend) have a dream vacation planned to the Galápagos. They are set to leave town on March 13, 2020... right before the world shuts down. Finn can't leave due to his front line job, but he tells Diana to go on without him. Get away, stay safe, and come back when things have "Settled down."
Diana reluctantly agrees, but her vacation quickly goes off course and her plans fly out the window. The entire island is now under quarantine and she couldn't get back to NYC even if she tried.

As she deals with lost luggage, no wifi, zero contact with Finn, she begins to step out of her comfort zone. She meets a teenager in need of help and her father. She befriends a grandmother and other locals. And all the while, she wonders if the world is changing as much as she is. Everything she thought she knew has been questioned and she has to dig deep to find the answers that she's been too scared to look for.

A very thought provoking book (as most Jodi Picoult novels are!) and one that had to keep reading. In some ways it hit too close to home with all of the pandemic stats and death tolls and sickness, but in other ways it offered hope for a time that seemed so dark. A reminder in these unexpected and unparalleled times, we can still find anchors to hold on to.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine, Ballantine Books for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult was a very moving and timely novel. I had read some advanced reviews about what this book was about but they were not able to prepare me for how reading Wish You Were Here was going to affect me. Jodi Picoult was able to capture all the underlying fears, warnings, precautions, attitudes, compliance and non-compliance to the threat of Covid-19 as it overtook and cast its ugly face upon the world. Her extensive research was masterful. She captured the essence of the bewilderment, terror, stress, pure exhaustion and the determination to not let the virus win that the members of the health care community faced. The challenges of living in quarantine, excessive hand washing, securing time slots for food delivery, the process of wiping down and washing everything that would be touched, gathering mail and delaying its opening, mask wearing, overcrowded hospitals and the exorbitant amount of patients put on ventilators only to die were all present throughout. All those things and more was what made this book so believable. Jodi Picoult captured those moments of crisis so many of us faced and also the resilience that so many exhibited to be able to navigate their way through the pandemic. Wish You Were Here was well written and so memorable.

Diana O’Toole was an almost thirty year old woman that was living her life according to her plan. She was an associate specialist at the well known and renowned Sotherby’s. Diana had high aspirations to climb the corporate ladder in the art field at Sotherby’s and secure a prominent position. Her private life was equally satisfying. Her long term boyfriend, Finn, was a surgical resident at a prominent New York hospital. Their futures were promising and together they contemplated an engagement and eventually marriage and a home in nearby Westchester County. Diana and Finn had saved for and meticulously planned a vacation to the Galapoaos Islands that would occur just before Diana’s thirty birthday. Diana even suspected that Finn would finally propose to her there and of course she would say yes. Just at that time, Covid-19 had made its way to New York City. Diana noticed how empty the streets were and how few people were out and about. As Diana traveled around the city by subway, the day before her and Finn’s vacation, she noticed how deserted the subway stations and cars were. When Diana got home, she was not prepared for what Finn was about to tell her. Finn’s role at the hospital had been redefined. All doctors, residents and medical staff were required to be available to treat the onslaught of patients that arrived at the hospital with symptoms of COVID-19. Finn would not be able to go to the Galápagos Islands but insisted that Diana go by herself. He wanted her to be out of the city and somewhere safe where she would not get the virus. Reluctantly, Diana finally gave in and traveled to Galapagos alone.

As soon as Diana arrived at the airport on Galapagos, she was greeted with the information that her luggage was lost. She decided to take the ferry to Isabela where she and Finn had booked a room at one of the hotels. Just as the ferry docked, Diana was given the choice to return to the mainland. Isabela was under quarantine and almost everything was shut down. For some unknown reason, Diana decided to stay. She was about to find out that the hotel where she had a reservation was shut down. Diana had no luggage and nowhere to stay. Abuela, one of the women that cleaned the hotel took pity on her. Through hand gestures and the little bit of Spanish Diana could muster, she asked Abuela if she knew anyplace where she could stay. Abuela took Diana under her wing and offered her a place to stay. It was also almost impossible to get a message to Finn. The Wi-Fi on the island was almost nonexistent. As time passed on the island, Diana discovered its hidden treasures and beauty and was trusted with Beatriz’s secret and the special bond she formed with Gabriel. Diana began to wonder if this was the life she was meant to live rather than the one that waited for her back home in New York.

Then suddenly, Diana woke up. She had been on a ventilator for the past five days. Diana had COVID-19 and had nearly died or had she? Diana believed she had been in Isabela with Abuela, Beatriz and Gabriel. Diana says, “ I think I was in two places at one time.” “In the hospital, on a ventilator. And in my head, somewhere completely different.” Was that even possible? Her road ahead of her was long and hard. Diana survived Covid-19 but had to learn how to get her body healthy again and how to navigate this pandemic. Had she ever gone to Galapagos? How could she have imagined everything though?

In Jodi Picoult’s author’s note, she conveyed the idea where she got the idea for writing this book. “Several months into the pandemic I stumbled across an article about a Japanese man who got stranded in Machu Picchu during COVID. He was trapped there due to travel restrictions and, out of necessity, stopped being a tourist and became a resident of the community. That was Jodi Picoult’s spring board for writing Wish You Were Here. In my opinion, I believe that this was one of her best novels to date if not her absolute best one. She gathered her research by interviewing medical professionals and survivors who had been on ventilators. Even though I lived through and am still living through the consequences, precautions and challenges of COVID-19 I was reminded of how this virus has changed our life as it was once was. Having two daughters and a son-in-law in the medical field, I was extremely cautious and still am as I always worried for their safety and health and mine. I devoured Wish You Were Here. The characters were so believable and memorable. I felt like I really knew them by the end of the book. It made me smile and even shed a few tears at parts of the story. I highly recommend this book. Publication is set for November 30, 2021.

Thank you to Random House Publishing Group-Ballantine for giving me the opportunity to read this advanced copy of Wish We Were Here by Jodi Picoult through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

Review posted to blog: https://books-are-a-girls-best-friend.com/

Cue the tears.

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult: A novel I thought I was prepared for.. and it kicked me in the gut anyways.

In ways I never imagined possible.

Covid. This novel centers around Covid and it’s as real as it gets. If this book is on your to-be-read shelf, prepare yourself...it’s gonna be a tough one. In addition, prepare yourself for the fact that it's also NOTHING like you think it’s going to be.

Emotional Heartbreak. Devastation. Shock and Awe. Self-Discovery. Introspection. Love.

When Covid strikes, Diana and her boyfriend Finn are preparing for a trip to the Galápagos. Finn is a physician at a hospital and given the situation, needs to stay. Not having any idea how bad it’s going to get, Finn urges Diana to go on her own, and so she does. It’s a world away. Lockdown and quarantine occur. Upon her arrival in the Galápagos, Diana is isolated, without internet and the ability to go anywhere, while Finn is facing Covid every day and trying to keep patients alive. He emails her often, and though she receives them, she is unable to reply due to spotty internet. His haunting portrayal of life, treating patients is heartbreaking and so very realistic. Tears filled my eyes and streamed down my face, knowing everything he was writing happened in real life all across the world and continues to do so. Diana, on the other hand, lives a very different life, on an island knowing hardly any Spanish, having access to very little, and meeting only a handful of people, some of whom have a major impact on her.

Diana and Finn’s lives couldn’t be more different and yet each one is compelling, moving, and stirring in their own right.

It is here that my heart was torn asunder in more ways than one. I have no words for it and cannot say more without giving away spoilers.

Shock, Bewilderment, Heartbreak.

This novel is raw, honest, heart-wrenching and so brilliantly done. Through many tears, I read this and at times felt wholly shattered and can only applaud Jodi Picoult for what she accomplished here.

This was a buddy read with Ms. Kaceey and it impacted both of us greatly. Kaceey - thank you for reading this with me. Let me just say that I know how hard this was for you to read. I can’t thank you enough for everything you do each day. You are my hero.

Thank you to NetGalley, Random House - Ballantine Publishing Group, and Jodi Picoult for this incredible read.

Published on Goodreads, Twitter, and Instagram.

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult is an auto-buy author for me. I was very fortunate to be given an e-ARC of this book from Netgalley, which I greatly appreciate.

I've read many of Picoult's books and other than The Book Of Lost Ways (which just didn't work for me), I have liked most of Picoult's other books.

This book is hard to talk about without spoilers, so I will just note that this is the first fiction book I've seen that addresses COVID-19. Given the wide spectrum of opinions on this global pandemic, I think many authors would consider it too risky a move to include this subject matter in their next novel, but not Picoult. I greatly respect her for this reason.

I liked the second half of this book more than the first. I liked most of the characters, but just couldn't find a positive connection to the protagonist.

I felt the book was a little long, but chalk that up to a lot of descriptors for different locations. Some people like this, so this a personal preference.

All in all, if I'm comparing this to the other books I've read by Jodi Picoult, I would put this one somewhere in the middle. Not my favorite, but I still liked it.

⭐⭐⭐

Was this review helpful?