Cover Image: Deer Season

Deer Season

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Small town rural America. A young girl goes missing. All eyes turn to “retarded” Hal, a farmhand, who seems to be hiding something about the very weekend the girl disappears. As the community start to ask questions, his carers also begin to wonder – could he be capable of something like this, this boy they have taken in and nurtured? A gripping and compelling novel about guilt and innocence, responsibility and loyalty, a tense psychological drama that kept me guessing to the end. Well-paced with an expertly handled gradual reveal of the back stories, convincing and nuanced characterisation and authentic dialogue, all narrated with insight and compassion, I thoroughly enjoyed the novel and recommend it highly as a really enjoyable read.
Was this review helpful?

Enjoyed this one a lot. Well written. Atmospheric setting. Intriguing plot. Slow moving, yet suspenseful. Interesting and well-developed characters. I maybe wanted a little more out of the ending, but overall this was a solid two thumbs up read! 

**ARC Via NetGalley**
Was this review helpful?
Deer Season is part mystery, part slice of life in small town America.  The mystery unfolds as it is told through two perspectives, Alma and Milo.  Of the two, I enjoyed being in Milo's head a lot more than Alma's.  I thought the story was beautifully written. The author did a great job with character development.  However, it was a bit slow for my taste.  There was a lot of mundane, day to day stuff that bogged down the story for me.   I did like the ending.  I think this book would be perfect for people who like slow burn, small town mysteries.  I would recommend it.
Was this review helpful?
In Deer Season Erin Flanagan writes characters that are witty, smart, and complicated. The characters are shaped by the place they live as much as they shape its farmland. It is a compelling whodunit, but it is more than that as you begin to feel deeply for the people and secrets in the town. The people in the town that are quick to judge are balanced with those striving toward more - toward something most of the characters don't know and haven't experienced beyond their own musings of what life outside a small town might be. Erin Flanagan picks a perfect time and place to set the novel - a farm town on the brink of massive technological advancements but not there yet. A couple years earlier or later the novel couldn't take place as it does. In a bigger city, it wouldn't fit. However, Erin perfectly allows the novel and the characters to spring forth from time and place.
Was this review helpful?
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for a copy in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Once I started Deer Season I didn't want to stop. When I had to take a break, I wanted to keep reading until I knew what happened. It's definitely a book of suspense wrapped around one question: what happened to the missing girl? This is a book about a disappearance, but it's not a crime story as I'm used to, and I think that worked for the story.

This isn't a crime procedural following some battle-hardened detective linking subtle clues together at the last minute to figure out whodunnit. The main characters are those normal, everyday people whose lives wrap around the missing girl's: her brother's, a local woman, a local man. They're not actively engaged in an investigation. It's like they're trying to survive it instead. It was more interesting to me reading those viewpoints than from the detective's. It seemed more focused on the missing girl as a person and as part of a community than crime stories usually get. 

The views offered on the local community were compelling. There was good and bad and a complicated mixture just like in real life. No character was a cardboard caricature. The main three characters especially felt very real. The bits of past that you get made them make sense, even as I saw the change from who they had been to who they were  in the story's present. 

This was a great viewpoint into how quickly we suspect those we see as different. As soon as the girl goes missing, everyone in town blames the guy with the intellectual disability. But, this guy also has committed violence in the past, whatever the reason. Their blame isn't wholly unfounded. Even the MC, who loves this man like a son, has a horrible inkling of suspicion, even though she never directly says or thinks it. 

The story progressed quickly enough to not get bogged down, but not so quickly as to feel like it was supposed to be a thriller. My only complaint was in how quickly the ending wrapped up. The crime was solved in what felt like a paragraph (even though there are clues throughout the story), and the reader is only told what happened. There's no real action or first hand account of this part. 

I'd recommend Deer Season to those who like reading about small town dynamics, the complexity of human nature, and to book clubs. There're a lot of great discussion points in Deer Season.
Was this review helpful?
This is a great story (contains some romance, mystery & suspense) that takes place in NE, & anyone who lives in the area (in SD/IA/NE) will recognize so much, will find so much to relate to......will be able to understand the locale, the mindset, the culture, the rural vs urban, the career choices. Flanagan really portrays this whole rural culture to such was fun to read & recognize so much, even though it deals with very serious issues.
This book is a part of a series called 'Flyover Fiction' in which stories are set on the Great Plains, in the center of the country.......& the plot lines follow something about life in that area. At the end of the book, it names other titles in this series.......& I'll definitely be looking some of these up. I'd definitely recommend this to anyone, whether in this heartland/tri state area.....or anywhere else!
I received an e-copy of this book from University of Nebraska Press via NetGalley for review purposes & these opinions are my own.
Was this review helpful?
Deer Season quietly crept up on me and I found myself engaged from beginning to end in this literary mystery set in a small Nebraska community in the 1980s. Character driven with characters, who while not always likable, feel real and will stay with me. Clyle and Alma Costagan are childless, and have become family for Hal, their intellectually challenged farmhand and they look out for him, even as he is approaching 30. They aren't happy when he goes on a deer hunting trip with a couple of locals and when he comes back early saying he shot a deer, and with a dented truck with bloodstains, they think the hardest thing to do will be to smooth over the issues with his hunting permit and help him clean up. Unfortunately a teenage girl, Peggy Ahern, is missing and soon the community is suspicious of Hal, and Alma and Clyle do their best to defend him while having their own thoughts and worries about what Hal is capable of. 

The story is told by partially by Alma, a hard woman to like and considered by most to be an outsider since Clyle brought her back from the city when his mother died. The other chapters are told by Milo Ahern, Peggy's 12-year-old brother, wise beyond his years, and my favorite character in the book. I enjoyed the 1985 Nebraska setting and the cast of small town characters that make up Gunthrum. The mystery is solid and slow and steady tension is built to the end, but it is the relationships and the the meaning of family and loyalty that are the standouts. One of my favorites for the year so far, Erin Flanagan is a talent, and I'm going to look up her short story collections to read more from her.
Was this review helpful?
Erin Flanagan’s Deer Season is a slow burn murder mystery that doesn’t let go.  By the end of the book, Flanagan had me second guessing every character for the murder.  Deer Season has impeccably crafted characters and Flanagan has brought to life their little nook of the world.  My favorite was Alma, a woman who left a life and job in Chicago to move with her husband back to his rural farm town.  Crusty and grumpy with a heart of gold.  Alma is so spot on, I feel as if I know her.  Deer Season is one of my favorite reads of 2021--I'm looking forward to reading more from Erin Flanagan!
Was this review helpful?
What happens when a small-town teenage girl disappears the same weekend an intellectually disabled man returns from a deer hunting trip with a bloody and dented truck and a story that doesn't make sense?

Deer Season is set in Gunthrum, Nebraska in 1985 and it explores small-town syndrome and the negative impact it can have on everyone involved. Alma Costagan moved from Chicago to Gunthrum with her husband Clyle 14 years ago to care for his sick mother, but after she passed away, the couple ended up not leaving the town. Throw in their inability to have a child and you get a city woman full of resentment towards the small town, its people and her husband because she is unable to make friends, she is often the butt of people's jokes and she feels like her husband isn't on her team anymore. At the same time, Clyle is keeping on as well as he can by avoiding Alma, but he also oscillates between feelings of love for her and guilt at all the mistakes he's done.

Even though they don't have their own children, their farmhand Hal Bullard is like a son to them. He became intellectually disabled at a young age due to his mother's neglect but Alma and Clyle are adamant he is a good person, capable of being independent and taking basic care of himself. Of course, not everyone believes that and Alma's long fight to protect Hal from accusations of murder begins.

The novel mostly focuses on interpersonal relationships and the relationship each person has with themselves. There is a lot of anger, sadness and regret in the mix and no single character is either completely likeable or completely unlikeable. While I appreciated the realism of people's inner thoughts and struggles, I felt like it became very repetitive and none of the character development past page 150 was unexpected. Despite it being written in a beautiful, imaginative way that easily pulls the reader in, my biggest gripe with the novel was that I, someone who almost never reads crime novels, felt like the story itself was not unique or extraordinary in any way.

Other than the writing style, I enjoyed the fact that events unfold from the perspectives of two people - Alma and Milo, the missing girl's younger brother. Milo was my favourite character because his arc was the strongest and the story was more interesting to observe through his eyes and mind.

Deer Season comes out on September 1st. Huge thank you to NetGalley, Erin Flanagan and University of Nebraska Press for the advanced reader copy.
Was this review helpful?
There are a couple of good characters in this novel--Milo, whose sister is missing, and Hal, a big handsome guy who is brain damaged. Good friends in this tiny Nebraska town turn against each other pretty quickly in a story that never quite takes off. It's a thoughtful story, but slow going. "Deer Season" is one of those books that, if you're in the right head space, will involve you. But if you're not there, it's just good, Erin Flanagan has a way with words and her career will be worth watching.
Was this review helpful?
Deer Season by Erin Flanagan is a very highly recommended character driven novel wrapped around a mystery. This is a beautifully written novel!

In Gunthrum, Nebraska, the 1985 deer season is opening and Alma and Clyle Costagan's intellectually disabled farmhand, Hal Bullard, 28 years-old, has been invited to join two other local men on their weekend hunt. Alma, a pessimist by nature, is concerned for him considering who invited him along. Instead of staying away the whole weekend, Hal returns Saturday night and is seen at the OK bar. When he shows up at the Costagan's Sunday he claims he shot his first deer and came home early. He also has a dent in his front fender, which he may have gotten hitting his garage again on Saturday night, and blood in the truck bed from the deer.

On the same weekend 12 year-old Milo Ahern is being confirmed in church that Sunday. When Milo goes to wake up his 16 year-old sister, Peggy, she's not in her room and later, when she can't be tracked down anywhere, she is reported missing. Gossip begins to swirl around Milo's early return and the condition of his truck. Residents of the small town quickly spread rumors and gossip that accused Hal of violence against Peggy, in spite of the lack of proof. It does not help matters that Hal has a crush on Peggy. Milo is much more observant and thoughtful than most of the adults around him.

Deer Season is an exquisitely written literary novel. While the plot follows the reaction of the citizens of the town during the search for Peggy, the focus of the novel is an honest and compassionate character study full of attentive, intelligent observations. The characters are fully realized, complex individuals with faults, shortcomings and emotional damages, but also with honest knowledge and awareness of the small community around them and their faults. There are heartbreaking revelations and thoughts shared by both Milo and Alma and they will have your total empathy.

Alma and Milo are the primary narrators in the novel and the plot unfolds through their points-of-view and their observations of the events surrounding Peggy's disappearance. While the mystery of Peggy's disappearance gives shape and purpose to the plot, the rich characterizations give the novel a depth and sensitivity that propels it to a standout mystery novel. Underlying themes include the contemplation of what it means to be a family and a question of how far would you go to protect those you love.

With the complex characters and the satisfying and surprising conclusion, Flanagan has written a stunning, extraordinary debut novel. Deer Season would be a wonderful choice for book clubs that like to discuss literary fiction.

Disclosure: My review copy was courtesy of the University of Nebraska Press for TLC Book Tours.  (8/30/21)
The review will be published on Edelweiss, Barnes & Noble, Google Books, and Amazon.
Was this review helpful?
I enjoyed this one. It's a classic small town who-dunnit. If you enjoy books set in small towns (like I do) then you'll probably like this one. With that being said, this isn't necessarily a book I would rave about. There's nothing wrong about it, but it's just good-not great. It's probably not a book I'd recommend to everyone, but if you do Come across it, it's worth trying out.
Was this review helpful?
Deer Season was a compelling, suspenseful read.  I was pulled in immediately to the characters and the richness of smalltown life on the Plains. As someone with a rural Nebraska background, I was impressed with how Flanagan resisted stereotypes.  This is a fabulous debut novel--there were surprises that felt true, and I became invested in all of the characters who were fleshed out so fully.  HIGHLY recommend!
Was this review helpful?
Loved the book! Really great character development, especially Milo. The story felt real and I connected with both Milo and Alma.
Was this review helpful?
I was raised on a KS farm so there were so many things mentioned in this book that brought back memories….one finger farmer waves, Dorothy Lynch dressing and how people know all about you in small towns, good and bad. So that part of the story felt so familiar. Great job of including so many details from that and the 80s time period. 

I also love Dateline and the story felt like it could be a Dateline episode with each chapter told by different characters. 

A really entertaining read. Loved it!  Thanks to NetGalley for allowing me the opportunity to read this interesting book.
Was this review helpful?
I am weirdly indifferent about this book. It has some very complex characters/relationships. It also weirdly sounds like something that could have easily taken place in my small hometown. I felt like some of Milo' s storyline were long and drawn out to fill space. There were a lot of details that I could have done without. Maybe it would have been a nice touch to add Peggy's point of view.
Was this review helpful?
Well developed characters.  Good story telling. Quick, easy read.  Tha ks to Netgalley for the opportunity to read this book.
Was this review helpful?
Erin Flanagan has done it again! Though prior to this, Flanagan has focused on short story collections, with this book, she's cemented herself as one of my favorite novel writers. Just like with her short fiction, Flanagan focuses on the authenticity of her characters and setting, giving us a genuine look at small town life in the Midwest. And her characters! How quirky, unique, and yet completely relatable! A complex, multilayered novel that kept me turning the pages. Well done!
Was this review helpful?
It’s hunting season, and Alma and her husband Clyle live on his family’s farm in a small town called Gunthrum, Nebraska. Alma and Clyle’s farm hand Hal, a 28-year-old man that suffered brain damage as a child, comes back from opening weekend with blood in his truck and a huge dent in the passenger side door, and is clearly hiding what exactly happened. It just so happened that same weekend, a girl from down the street goes missing. The same girl Hal is known around town to have feelings for. How far will Alma and Clyle go to clear Hal’s name, even when they themselves aren’t sure if Hal is telling the truth?  

I really enjoyed this book! I’ll chalk it up to being a southern belle myself, knowing how it is to be born and raised in a small town where everyone knows everything about everyone. I grew to love the characters, especially Milo and Hal. The storytelling was interesting as well, and helped add to the suspense. We would go from Alma’s point of view in one chapter, and then we would go across the street to Milo’s point of view in the next. Doing it this way ensured that there was no shortage of small-town gossip, and I loved every bit of it!  

The major critique I have, and the reason I gave 4.5 stars, is the slow-as-molasses pace. I felt that the author could have accomplished everything in closer to 225 pages, if it weren’t for the intricate detail and inner monologues of some of the characters. Overall, this book was a quick read and was entertaining from start to finish. I gasped a couple of times and laughed out loud at Alma’s “take no bullshit” attitude. Deer Season is definitely worth the read!

Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review! This book is set to be published on September 1st, 2021.
Was this review helpful?
This was a quick read…nothing really new or unique here. Despite that, the author created a couple of characters I couldn’t help rooting for. Overall, an enjoyable average story.
Was this review helpful?