Member Reviews
Mandi S, Reviewer
Scott Tracey’s Moonset is a captivating start to a series that combines witchcraft, family drama, and high-stakes danger in a way that’s both fresh and compelling. The story centers on Justin and his siblings, the orphaned children of a notorious coven responsible for widespread destruction. As they’re relocated to a new town under constant suspicion and scrutiny, they must grapple with the legacy of their infamous parents while navigating their own magical abilities—and a sinister threat lurking in the shadows.
The strongest aspect of Moonset is the complex sibling dynamic. Tracey does an excellent job of portraying the messy, imperfect love between Justin and his brothers and sisters. Their shared trauma and differing personalities create plenty of tension, but also moments of genuine connection that make you care deeply about their fate. Justin, as the narrator, is easy to root for, balancing snarky humor with vulnerability as he tries to keep his fractured family together.
The world-building is another highlight. The rules of magic and the shadowy political structure of the witching world feel fully realized, with plenty of room for expansion in future books. Tracey introduces just enough lore to intrigue without overwhelming, keeping the focus on the characters and the immediate mystery.
The plot moves at a brisk pace, with plenty of twists and turns to keep things interesting. However, some moments feel a little rushed, especially when it comes to explaining the backstory of Moonset, the infamous coven. I wanted a deeper dive into their history and the fallout of their actions, which felt like it could have added even more depth to the story.
Despite a few minor pacing issues, Moonset is a dark, gripping YA fantasy with plenty of heart. If you enjoy books with magic, mystery, and a side of sibling drama, this is one you’ll want to check out. I’m excited to see where the series goes next!
