Cover Image: Fallen Idols

Fallen Idols

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Alex von Tunzelmann’s examination of popular movements to remove statues is well worth a read for anyone needing context for recent removals of statues to slave traders, Confederate soldiers, or colonizers. It’s an easy and interesting read which connects the key fallacies of those who wish to leave statues in place with systematic oppression. Furthermore, Tunzelmann offers useful information in responding to those arguments. By looking at the removal of statues in different time periods, this book makes clear that despite some politicians’ claims, knocking over statues in protest is a time-honored tradition in the United States.

Was this review helpful?

Overall, a good introduction to the topic of historical statuary and when and why they come down. It's clearly aimed a general audience and doesn't make assumptions about what you do or don't know about history, which is important because not every historical person in the book is widely taught in your average curriculum. I think a lot people would find the chapters to be enjoyable bite-size sections, and for that reason I suspect the audiobook will be a popular version.

Unfortunately for von Tunzelmann, she is likely preaching to the choir. Those who would most benefit from considering a broader perspective of the history of statue removal are precisely those least likely to pick up the book. The choir will likely enjoy it anyway, and that's probably all any history author can hope for these days.

Was this review helpful?