Cover Image: House of Glass Hearts

House of Glass Hearts

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I’ve tried reading this book quite a few times and each time, I just cannot get into it. So for that I’m not going to be leaving a proper review..

Was this review helpful?

House of Glass Hearts delves into the intricate tale of Maera, a Pakistani-American teenager unraveling the enigmatic layers of her family's past. The narrative unfolds through dual timelines, alternating between Maera's contemporary quest to locate her missing brother and her grandfather's story set in pre-Independence India. The novel adeptly explores the often-overlooked tragedies of South Asia's recent history, delving into intergenerational trauma and the painful awareness of a family history marked by unspoken sorrows, particularly the lingering impact of Partition. The strength of the book lies in its portrayal of Maera's grandfather, offering poignant insights into interreligious tensions, the complexities of the Indian freedom struggle, and the enduring anguish of Partition, interwoven with elements of Indian folklore and magical realism. While the historical aspects shine, the present-day narrative featuring Maera and her friends feels comparatively weaker, lacking depth and cohesion. The frenetic pace, a sprawling cast of characters, and rushed writing at times impede the novel's potential. Despite these challenges, House of Glass Hearts stands out for its creativity and uniqueness, showcasing the promising debut of author Leila Siddiqui, leaving readers eager for her future releases.

Was this review helpful?

Leila Siddiqui's debut novel, "House of Glass Hearts," weaves a complex narrative that seamlessly blends history with myth, offering readers a poignant exploration of family secrets and the enduring impact of the past on the present. While the novel presents a compelling premise, it falls short of fully delivering on its ambitious storytelling.

The story revolves around Maera, a Pakistani-American teenager, whose family has buried the pain of the past deep within their hearts. The disappearance of her older brother, Asad, a decade ago remains an unspoken wound. When her grandfather passes away, a derelict greenhouse from her naana's house in Karachi mysteriously appears in Maera's backyard, unraveling the family's hidden traumas.

Siddiqui skillfully navigates between colonial India and present-day America, exploring the interconnected lives of characters as they grapple with the ghosts of history. The narrative is rich with cultural details, providing a vivid portrayal of South Asian heritage and the challenges faced by the diaspora.

However, the pacing of the story tends to be uneven, with moments of intensity giving way to slower, less engaging sections. The switches between timelines may leave readers occasionally disoriented, disrupting the flow of the narrative. Additionally, character development could have been more nuanced, as some individuals feel more like vessels for the overarching plot than fully realized personalities.

The novel's exploration of family secrets and the monsters within the grandfather's house of glass is intriguing, yet the resolution of these mysteries lacks the depth and emotional resonance that such a complex narrative demands. The potentially devastating secrets hinted at throughout the story are revealed in a somewhat hurried fashion, leaving some threads feeling unresolved.

In conclusion, "House of Glass Hearts" is a commendable debut that tackles significant themes of family, loss, and cultural identity. While the ambitious narrative and cultural exploration are notable, the uneven pacing and underdeveloped characters prevent the story from reaching its full potential. Despite its shortcomings, Siddiqui's novel offers a unique perspective on the lasting impact of history on the lives of South Asians across generations.

Was this review helpful?

The plot in this book is absolutely brilliant. But the writing fell a little flat and also the characters were just so underdeveloped
There are huge inconsistencies too.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this read. There were twists and turns and I was thoroughly entertained. I highly recommend… if you like that sort of thing. ;)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for giving me a free eARC of this book to read in exchange for my review!

Was this review helpful?

Leila Siddiqui's House of Glass Hearts presents a tale of family, loss, and an eerie greenhouse that mysteriously appears in Maera's backyard. As she grapples with the disappearance of her brother, Asad, and the death of her grandfather, the narrative takes the reader on a journey through two intertwined stories, one set in Maera's time and the other in her grandfather's childhood. While the story has its moments, it faces several challenges that impact its overall quality.

The narrative starts at a slow pace, which may test the reader's patience. It eventually picks up speed towards the conclusion, but the initial pace can be a deterrent. The storytelling itself appears somewhat flat but is not without its merits. It seems geared toward a younger YA audience while exploring some dark themes. The combination of history, magic, action, and the emphasis on family creates a decent foundation for the story. While not exceptional, it weaves an intricate narrative.

One issue that hinders the reader's experience is the inconsistent quality of the two alternating timelines. The more compelling historical timeline overshadows the present-day narrative. The historical passages dive into colonial India's struggles, the horrors of the Partition, and interreligious tensions. They evoke emotions and provide a deeper understanding of the characters' shared trauma. The present-day narrative, on the other hand, lacks character development and depth, which becomes evident as Maera's trauma appears downplayed.

The writing style tends to struggle, especially in the present-day narrative. It lacks smooth transitions, making the storytelling feel disjointed and rushed. The characters, who should be the anchors of the narrative, come across as underdeveloped, particularly in the present-day portion of the story. Maera's emotional journey, while central to the plot, doesn't receive the depth it deserves.

Despite these challenges, the story manages to offer a blend of historical and fantastical elements that can be intriguing. The tale incorporates Indian and Pakistani folklore, specifically the inclusion of a churail, which adds an enticing supernatural component. The historical insights provided are eye-opening and informative.

House of Glass Hearts is a book with potential, but it is ultimately hindered by uneven writing and character development. While it may engage a younger YA audience, it may not fully satisfy those seeking a more nuanced narrative.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for giving me a free advanced copy of this book to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

I liked it, although the implicit Indian/Pakistani history made it a little sombre at points. What I liked best about this novel was its mystical components and how it perfectly blends myth and reality. The finale and Maera's persona fell flat for me, but it was still a fantastic book.

Was this review helpful?

House of Glass Hearts is an enchanting tale that effortlessly weaves mystery and romance. With its easy-to-read prose and captivating characters, it keeps you hooked from the very first page. A genuine gem that takes you on a magical journey you won't want to end.

Was this review helpful?

I hate to leave a 3 star rating on this but i didn't love it. don't get me wrong, the blurb was so well written and the book had good foundation but it had so much more potential for growth. The flashbacks confused me but that isn't unusual for me as a reader. The incorporation of Pakistani culture made me so happy as a reader.

Was this review helpful?

House of Glass Hearts is a heartwarming story it’s about family, immigration, and history. I think it's so wonderful and long overdue to read own voices books like this and to diversify more the books being published every year, although I still think it’s just a dripping tap, when it needs to be a flood to represent the whole world. I highly recommend that you read this book, it’s intelligent, entertaining and just a great read


I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for giving me a free advanced copy of this book to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

I hate to leave such negative feedback but the only thing good was the cover. Sorry. This definitely wasn't for me. Or anyone.

Was this review helpful?

The cover was gorgeous, the blurb was really drew me in to start with. Unfortunately, it all went a little downhill for me from there. The writing and editing was a little flat and uninspired, though the premise of the book had a good foundation. It was ok, but definitely had room for growth.

Was this review helpful?

I really hoped to enjoy this one more than I did but it just fell flat. The plot was great but the writing didn't really draw me in.

Was this review helpful?

Not at all happy with the book. The cover was really pretty, the blurb was fantastic. If the editor / writer had put more effort, the book would have turned out better. But it didn’t. So so disappointing.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

House of Glass Hearts by Leila Siddiqui is a fantastic blend of Pakistani history and fantasy. The story revolves around Maera, whose older brother Asad disappeared ten years ago. But when her grandfather dies, the greenhouse from his house magically transports itself to America, where Maera's family lives now. When she opens the greenhouse, she will have to confront monsters - both literal and metaphorical - to find out what happened to her brother.

Here is a chilling excerpt from the opening chapter, which is a flashback:

"He stepped up to the door. "Who's in there?" he asked, his voice just above a whisper.
The greenhouse groaned in response, and then the door opened on its own...
Asad was immediately bathed in green light. He gasped, and the toys fell from his hands. As he crawled on the ground to pick them up, a long shadow fell upon him. He shaded his eyes from the light and blinked up at the figure standing before him."

Overall, House of Glass Hearts is a heartwarming story about family, generations, immigration, and touch topics. One highlight of this book is how it is an #ownvoices book. In the Afterword, the author talks about how she is the daughter of Pakistani immigrants, and how her grandparents were immigrants from India during Partition. I think it's so important to diversify the books being published every year, and I am so happy to support this author. I also learned a lot about Partition from reading this book. Content warning: physical and sexual assault. If you're intrigued by the excerpt above, or if you're a fan of fantasy books in general, I highly recommend that you check out this book, which is available now!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, this novel missed the mark for me and ended up being a DNF. The way the narrative was presented between the flashbacks and present-day ended up being done a little haphazardly and felt like the execution wasn't really there. I ended up getting bored and didn't really want to continue.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, I absolutely loved reading this twisty tale of love, loss and learning. This is definitely not the type of thing I would usually read but I thought I’d step out of my comfort zone with this one. And I was certainly not expecting this. House Of Glass Hearts is a fantastical thriller mostly set in Pakistan. What I loved most of all about this book, is the in-depth look at Pakistani culture..Thank you to the author

Was this review helpful?