Cover Image: My Mother, Munchausen's and Me

My Mother, Munchausen's and Me

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

It's difficult to know where to start with this one. It's obviously a personal account so it's hard to criticise - as who knows how you or anyone would react in the same situation?
Personally, I became a little frustrated with the repetitive nature of the story/narrative, the author's mother continued to act exactly the same throughout her life, as did the author which meant nothing really changed, so we just heard similar stories and reactions repeated.

The author's mother was obviously mentally ill and yet no one seemed to address that, one psychiatrist appointment was arranged and then moved on from, instead of addressing the issue of her mother's illness the author seemed to focus on how it was affecting her, which of course I understand but after the realisation she was actually really ill with a mental condition her outlook might have changed and stopped seeing it as so personal?

The author stopped seeing her mother and yet continued to obsess about her, I was starting to believe that there was hope as the author understood she was ill, but the obsession continued without any action to seemingly address it. So I found the whole read quite frustrating.
ESPECIALLY as after the mother had died the daughter called family members who all seemed to know what her problem was!? Why weren't these people contacted while the mother was still alive?

A very strange tale all in all, I'm not a fan of these 'misery memoirs' and don't really read them but was interested in this condition, however the book was only about how the daughter was reacting the mother's behaviour towards her, not really about the condition itself. Probably am wrong target market, but hope remaining family continue to heal.

Was this review helpful?

I really struggled to get into this book and I normally love memoirs. It is very sad what Helen went through and her mother was a narcissist. The odd diary bits added in from her mum seemed out of place and didn't give much to the story. I wish Helen and her family all the best.

Was this review helpful?

This book is Helen Naylor's account of growing up with a mother suffering from Munchausen's disease. It reads like very compelling narrative fiction but for Helen and her family this story is, unfortunately, all too real. The writing switches between Helen's memories of various events in her life where she suffers varying degrees of abuse and endless gaslighting at the hands of her mother and actual excerpts from her mother's diary. I found it so interesting to see these events from both perspectives and how disjointed her mom was from reality. This was a difficult read at times but I found myself unable to put it down.

Was this review helpful?

I was really excited to see that Thread Books approved my request to read this book! Thank you to Thread Books and NetGalley for this e-ARC!

I could really relate to Helen Naylor's experiences with her mum, Elinor. Growing up I went through similar experiences with my mother minus the Munchausen's. As Helen questioned whether it was her imagining all these things that her mother was saying or if Helen herself was the problem and not her mother. I really felt for her. I also question everything and my relationship with my mother. As Helen wrote, "I was being consumed, robbed of my own life and drawn into a world of labyrinthine darkness that my mother controlled -- one which was destroying me." It was tough for me to read parts of this book as this book related so much to thoughts that I've had in my relationship with my own mother. The sense of guilt that Helen felt is something that definitely consumes you and you can't snap out of because you think to yourself, well, she's my mom. I appreciated how open and honest Helen was. This was definitely a heartfelt read! If you have a narcissistic or toxic parent in your life, this book will be both relatable and eye-opening!

I will post my review on instagram @thrillersandcoffee

Was this review helpful?

I read this on Halloween weekend and though it was not intended as horror it was frightening. The fact that Helen Naylor came out of this extremely dysfunctional and toxic household with her brain intact is a credit to her strength. Just reading this memoir was exhausting at times. I really can't fathom how Mrs. Naylor was able to deal with her mother's extreme illness and still function day to day. A disturbing and in depth look at mental illness and also the very real problem in the medical field of unnecessary prescriptions and faulty diagnoses. The author did come off as self pitying at times but then again she was a child dealing with a very sick mother and disabled father, having some self pity is a small character flaw after what she endured.

Was this review helpful?

What a tragic story this is! But Helen’s father should have shelved some responsibility for the care of his daughter. He was there a lot of the time but seemed quite happy to go along with the way they lived. That was through choice, not a condition.

There is no doubt that Helen had a terrible childhood. She endured hardships, loneliness and dangerous conditions, but it was the system that let her down. Her mother had an illness, which had been constantly overlooked. Having Munchausen’s meant this was how she was going to behave.

The account is well written, and it must have been so frustrating for her when the authorities, doctors, family and friends wouldn’t listen to her. That is a huge burden to take on, and I can imagine the guilt of walking away.

I am glad that Helen included that her mother had been respected in her career, and her charity work before the illness took over her. I feel sorry that Helen missed a normal childhood and did not have a mother around for her. I wish her well.

I wish to thank the publisher and Net Galley for an e-copy of this book, which I have reviewed honestly.

Was this review helpful?

Difficult to read! Felt desperately sorry for everything this poor lady went through during her life. She is very brave to be able to look back and tell her story to others.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to read this book because I find Munchausen's and NPD so very interesting. I honestly think my own mother is borderline NPD and that's why this story fascinated me so much. Kudos to Helen Naylor for being brave enough to bare her soul and tell her personal story. I don't think I would have the guts to do that. This story felt personal because the author digs deep, she doesn't hold back and the writing style made it feel like she was speaking directly to me.

I devoured this book in a couple sittings as I was captivated right from the beginning...I and learned something as well...I am amazed when books can do all that. I also felt a lot of different things while reading this. I felt so bad for Helen, especially her younger self. BUT her mother too should have some empathy, mental health wasn't looked at the same back then and a lot of the time it was swept under the carpet so to speak. This is a gripping book that shows that Munchausen's affects everyone around the sufferer, but especially the ones closest to them...Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

The title of this book was the reason I really wanted to read it. It is written in a chronological manner and tracks the relationship of the author and her mother.

It is incredibly sad at points and you really feel for the author as her childhood wasn’t a ‘normal’ one.

One thing I would say is that I didn’t really see how the diary entries made any impact to the story, it didn’t seem that they had much of a relevance other than being written by her mother.

I also couldn’t understand why she kept on contacting her mother even though it stressed her out to such an extent, maybe someone who hasn’t experienced this would never understand.

Many thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for gifting me this arc in exchange for an honest, unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting memoir of life with an abusive, narcissistic mother. Ultimately optimistic, as the author is able to move on from her disordered childhood and build a healthy childhood.

Thanks to NetGalley for providing an ARC copy for my review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for approving me for this
ARC!

This book was extraordinary, I didn’t think I could be so heartbroken for someone I’ve never met just by reading a book. The immature and childish actions and ways that Helen’s mother acted are just beyond me.

I cannot believe that someone would want to be perceived as ill, this is something I will never comprehend as I am ill myself I would never want to pretend as it is so hard to get the care as it is.

My heart fully goes out to Helen, what a heartbreaking story

Was this review helpful?

A very personal story of what it feels like to be the child of someone with Munchausens syndrome.

As a child you trust implicitly those meant to care for you but what if that narrative was based on a lie? How do you ever come to terms with being cheated out of your past when as an adult you realise that all the time you were being manipulated?

This story delves into these questions and is heart breaking in places, the little girl who wants to be loved, the teenager who needs advice and support and the new mum desperate for her own mother to live her grandchildren. Caught inside her own sickness she can’t see how much better her life could be if she chose live over illness.

Was this review helpful?

I was super excited about this book from the title alone. I love being a voyeur into someone's personality disorder, the more obscure the better. Unfortunately, this book didn't rise to the level of excitement that I was hoping for. At no point was I dying to know what her mother was going to do next. This is a memoir of Helen, a woman whose mother was constantly ill and taking to her bed and seemed to revel in any attention her fragility garnered. I didn't understand really the significance of the excerpts from her mother's diaries, until the end of the book where Helen explains each entry. We hear about Helen's life from childhood to adulthood and it was just too burdened with small details that made it seem to drag on. Perhaps my issue was with the Helen herself, she put up with much more than I would have under the banner of "being a good daughter" and "she's my mom" especially when pieces of the puzzle began to fall into place.
I listened to the audio version of this book and the author narrated her own memoir and I thought did a very good job.

Many thanks to #NetGalley and ThreadBooks for allowing me to review an advanced copy of #MyMotherMunchausensandMe.

Was this review helpful?

There is no need for me to retell the storyline as that is done better by the professionals but it is not giving anything away to say that you will come into an increasingly emotional roller coaster ride as this book continues. I can well believe that this type of life actually happened, especially the early chapters. However I did get a bit fed up of the same sort of stories in repeat (I'm sure it was like that but ...) and feel that the book would have benifitted from editing to about 80% of its final length.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an electronic copy to read and review as well as an audio copy for review.

I don't know where to begin with this book. The story is so compelling and sucks the reader right in. It sounds like fiction and reads like it, but incredibly it is non-fiction. Helen (the author and a fantastic narrator) tells us of growing up as the daughter of two disabled parents. As she grows and becomes more aware of her mother's behaviours and illnesses, Helen discovers that her mother actually likes being sick - she craves the attention. The entire book is gripping; and when you really think about it, terrifying. The toll that her mother's lies had on Helen are immeasurable. I can't even imagine the strength that Helen must posses to overcome her past. This book will stick with you long after you are finished.

Was this review helpful?

Deeply buried familial secrets and mother-and-daughter accounts have spawned many novels and memoirs over the years, so I was interested in this latest account. I think I should point out at this stage, however, that this memoir, in its overarching attempt to shine a spotlight on a dysfunctional childhood, is not an easy read. Helen Naylor’s father is introduced to us as a barfly who develops a serious heart complaint, whereas her mother suffers from often-diagnosed but insufficiently explored chronic fatigue syndrome. Helen’s earliest childhood memories revolve around being quiet, so as not to disturb her mother, whilst missing out on all the fun and much of the unconditional love and parental attention that all children need to thrive. Little by little, us readers become convinced that Helen’s mother is simply narcissistic and that she fabricates many of the medical symptoms that we are introduced over the many following pages.
Whilst an emotional read, this book is light on backstories and outside perspectives and therefore lacks the depth that readers like me would have appreciated. What exactly happened in the childhoods of Helen’s parents that made them the insufficient parents that they were? What neighbours/friends/other relatives got involved and what were their perspectives? Turning over the final page of what is a gripping, harrowing account of a messed-up childhood, I could not stop thinking about what those fresh perspectives would have added to the narrative. My thanks go to the publishers and NetGalley for the free ARC provided in return for this honest and unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

This beautifully written and brutally honest memoir tells the deeply disturbing tale of a young girls childhood sadly destroyed by her mothers mental illness. At times hard to read, yet hard to put down.

Was this review helpful?

What a dark and disturbingly sad story of how the authors childhood was destroyed by the lies and mental illness of her mother over the years and how even as an adult with children of her own her mother cast a huge shadow on her life. This is a fascinating read the only issue is the cover photo my mum is convinced is one of hers so wanted to know why it was on a book

Was this review helpful?

Helen tells the fascinating story of living with parent with a mental illness. I liked how she used entries from her moms’s diaries to show what her mother was thinking. Great read, that I highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

I really really enjoyed this. A compelling account of the effects of childhood trauma and the lies and manipulation of a parent.

Helen has a gift with writing. Often non-fiction can feel more cold and distanced than that of fiction, but the personal style of her writing really allowed it to feel as though I was reading a piece of fiction. I applaud her for her courage in sharing her story - something which is never easy - let alone with the entire world to see.

An enlightening read, one that id really recommend providing you listen to the trigger warnings of abuse etc.

thanks to netgalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my unbiased review <3

Was this review helpful?