Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This is the 'Inception' for all the thriller lovers like me.
How much do I love this book - AHH!
This was unique and brilliant.
I can't recommend this enough!!!

Was this review helpful?

by Sulari Gentill
Pub Date 07 June 2022
Publisher Poisoned Pen Press"The ornate reading room at the Boston Public Library is quiet, until the tranquility is shattered by a woman's terrified scream. Security guards take charge immediately, instructing everyone inside to stay put until the threat is identified and contained. While they wait for the all-clear, four strangers, who'd happened to sit at the same table, pass the time in conversation and friendships are struck. Each has his or her own reasons for being in the reading room that morning—it just happens that one is a murderer" ....

Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for this advanced copy
The plot? yes, well, it's complicated!
First up we have Hannah, a fictional Australian author writing a novel set in the city of Boston, USA. Hannah has a fan/beta reader by the name of Leo, he actually lives in Boston, they have not met as Hannah remains in Australia, they communicate solely by email
Next we have Freddie, who is the star of Hannah's novel, Freddie lives in Boston , there is also a Leo in Freddie's life.

Freddie seeks inspiration for her novel in the reading room of the Boston Public Library, she discreetly studies the four strangers at her table and, in the way of a fiction writer, creates new names and characters for each of them.
Little does she know that one blood curdling scream echoing through the library will connect these strangers to her and to each other in a most unusual fashion!

Meanwhile, back in Australia, Hannah continues to receive both compliments and faint criticism from Leo. Over time Leo's emails get somewhat demanding, he becomes annoyed when his advice and suggestions go unheeded, he also gets downright creepy.

In Boston Freddie is caught up in a series of events that will leave you turning those pages as fast as you can!

I really enjoyed this book except for the ending, it wrapped up a bit too quickly, I felt I was left hanging over the outcome of a certain character. Maybe it's just me and other more perceptive readers will have worked it out.

Now that I've discovered Sulari Gentill I will be looking out for her other works

Was this review helpful?

A thoroughly enjoyable read. Compelling mystery throughout. The whole concept of libraries, books, writers and plots is really engaging to a book lover. Combine that with murder and murderers, it leads you on a cat and mouse trail that means you just have to keep reading.
A great book, loved it

This review will be posted with Waterstones

Was this review helpful?

This book was sent to me for review electronically for review by Netgalley. "In every person's story, there is something to hide...the ornate reading room at the Boston Public Library is quiet..." Conversations with strangers...four meet and get to know each other. One is a murderer...which one? Is this story real? The concept of this novel...a story of murder written by a novelist in the book...while a real murderer reviews and gives advice...sound convoluted? It is...at times...I had to take a step back and ascertain what was real in the book and what was part of the in story of the novelist...the one in the book...not the person writing this novel. Sorry...that is the concept of this tale woven by an author that is ingenious. I have read other books similar but never one exactly like this one. I could not put it down...and don't even talk about the ending...no hints there. My suggestion is take this book...don't miss it...concentrate on reading it...don't overthink...just enjoy...Take your time...don't try to determine who did what...just be...I am eager to read other books by this novelist...

Was this review helpful?

4.5 rounded up. What a thrilling, suspense-filled mystery! We follow Hannah, a popular author, through her writing process as she crafts her new novel. Though we don’t know much about the author herself, we get a partial picture of who she is from her interactions with an obsessed fan, Leo, and her writing.

Hannah is composing a story about four strangers who meet by happenstance in the midst of a mysterious murder. Bound by the peculiar circumstances through which they meet, we begin to piece together what happens in Hannah’s novel. It’s a real puzzler and is sure to keep the reader guessing. It is hard not to get lost in the story and project what is happening in Hannah’s novel to what is happening in her reality.

The only real glimpses of Hannah’s life come from a crazed fan, Leo. Whom she is corresponding with as a (presumably) unasked for consultant. In addition, we have a few emails from law enforcement and lawyers.

This story was fascinating and mind-bending in more ways than one. I loved pulling all of the seemingly disparate pieces (real and imaginary) together to try to solve the mysteries presented.

Two things that I found mildly frustrating was the lack of more robust information about our author. It was just too vague for my liking. In addition, reality’s ending left a bit to be desired in my opinion. But I thought Hannah’s novel’s ending was fantastic.

This book was a real page-turner that I will be sure to recommend to friends and family.

Many thanks to Poisoned Pen Press and Netgalley for this title in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a book within a book. The protagonist is an Australian writer who is writing in the US. As she writes each chapter, she sends it to a colleague to review. We read the comments from the colleague. But that activity becomes a book within itself. So, in effect, we have three writers. The real author. The main character. And the author in the book being written by the author in the book. At times, it can become a bit difficult to process. But the overall affect is riveting.

The book is well-written. Some of the characters could have been a little more developed. But the dialogue was crisp and realistic. Overall, the technique made for a ripping good story.

Was this review helpful?

This book ticks all the boxes, even the ones you didn’t know you wanted ticked!

Think Inception meets Agatha Christie, set in Boston and intersecting Australian / American culture and that’s where The Girl in the Library starts. It’s an astonishingly intelligent, multilayered story within a story that will literally keep you turning the pages until the very end.

By way of synopsis… the story begins with Australian author Hannah Tigone conversing with a colleague in Boston about her upcoming novel. He is providing factual elements for her story, which is set in Boston and she is feeding him the story chapter by chapter. We also get to read the story, which is about four random people who happen to be in the reading room of the Boston Public Library when a murder is committed. From here the story unravels on two (or three) levels, intersecting, twisting and generally learning you a wide eyed reading maniac until the very last line.

A stellar read that I ignored my children for, I cannot WAIT to have a hardcopy of this book on my shelf in June.

Was this review helpful?

Freddie, an author from Australia, meets Cain, Whit and Marigold while writing at the Boston Public Library. She had been observing them all as possible characters when the silence in the library is shattered by a woman's scream. The scream and the ensuing lockdown allow the four to converse and become friends. When a woman's body is later found at the library, the four become interested and involved in trying to solve the murder. This book within a book is well written, with enough twists to hold a reader's attention throughout.

Was this review helpful?

**Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance copy in exchange for a fair and honest review**

This was a very ambitious book and the 'Inception' feel of a story within a story was intriguing. The mystery of the woman in the library was well plotted and, as it was unravelled, you came to know and care for each of the characters. The adiditonal storyline of the fictional author and their advisor / friend became much more complicated than I had expected and, to be honest, I'm not entirely sure I understood how it ended. The 2 characters named Leo was a bit too much for my tired brain, which one was it at the end? Had the 2 storylines merged?

Was this review helpful?

On the outer layer of this book are two characters: Hannah, a previously published and apparently successful series author in Australia, is writing a new novel about Winifred (“Freddie”), also an Australian novelist living in Boston on an academic fellowship. Leo, a struggling (and needy) writer acquaintance/fan of some kind, is corresponding with Hannah (we do not know her responses to his suggestions — Hannah is mostly a mystery). Leo is “assisting” by adding realistic Boston landscapes, correcting American idioms, and sending local photos of crime scenes to Hannah as he proofreads her manuscript chapter by chapter.

In the inner layer, Hannah’s main character, the fictional Winifred, is writing about the people she’s just met in the Boston Public Library — a group of three who came together after all heard a woman’s scream and later found out a murdered woman was discovered in the library. Freddie tells us upfront that one of these people is a murderer. Hannah has also inserted a fictional Leo, the one-sided narrator (name unchanged), into the story as Freddie’s neighbor.

The “real” Leo seems to think he can guess the murderer in Hannah’s novel, but if Hannah’s process mimics her protagonist Freddie’s method, it’s an ongoing “bus ride” with no definite destination (or killer) in mind. Because of Leo, we also know that Hannah’s novel is being created during the time of the Australian wildfires and the developing pandemic.

Is this a story about writing a mystery, a story about the writer character trying to solve a mystery, or a story, in the deepest layer, about the tale that the writer character is trying to compose?

One thing that always draws me into a novel is a twisty or unusual structure and Sulari Gentill’s “The Woman in the Library” definitely fits that description. I also love books about authors as main characters and a book about an author writing about another author is delightful. We almost never give thought to the author, but “The Woman in the Library” makes you hyper aware of who is writing what. Well plotted, smartly conceived and cleverly executed! 5 stars!

Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review!

Literary Pet Peeve Checklist:
Green Eyes (only 2% of the real world, yet it seems like 90% of all fictional females): YES Marigold has jewel green eyes, “sparkling in a frame of smoky kohl and mascara”.
Horticultural Faux Pas (plants out of season or growing zones, like daffodils in autumn or bougainvillea in Alaska): NO However, I loved the description of nana’s colorful garden like “a box of smarties.”

Was this review helpful?

A murder in a beautiful library - who wouldn't want to read this book?? The Woman in the Library is one of the BEST mystery novels I've read in quite a while. I love how Gentill is able to weave a story within a story. This provides the novel with the depth that readers crave and creates some breathtaking, unbelievable twists and turns. This book causes you to second guess the characters, the plot, and even yourself at some points because you're not even sure who could be guilty. The correspondence between the main character and her friend at the end of each chapter sets the ideal tone for a mystery novel like this one. I would highly recommend this book to anyone who likes Clue or your classic mysteries.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Poison Pen Press for an advanced copy of this book. I offer my review freely.

I would rather not talk about the plot of this book, because I'm scared of giving away too much. The way this book is written is so clever, it needs to be discovered and enjoyed first hand by the reader. Read the synopsis of you must, and then jump in with both feet!

I can say that it had my undivided attention! I loved the storyline, the pacing, the characters...

I almost took away one star, however, because the ending doesn't live up to the quality of everything that comes before. I'm still scratching my head about it. I feel like there should've been an epilogue... There's definitely something missing there.

Truthfully though, it doesn't tarnish my view of this book. It was excellent and deserves to be read!

Release date June 7, 2022.

Was this review helpful?

Right from the start you know this is going to be a great mystery! A story about an author writing a book about an author writing a book about a murder, who thinks of something like that! The main story is the mystery that the first author is writing, at least that’s the one that is the focus. The use of this layering adds so much to the book. All the action in “fictional” mystery is interspersed with letters between the “ real” Australian author and her research assistant/fan who is back in the US. The way Gentill so subtly raises the issues of the pandemic and race in America in these letters is genius. What a fun ride! Highly recommend.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

This was another one of my most anticipated books of 2022! I love a New England set thriller and this book seemed like a fun take on one of my favorite tropes: locked-room mysteries.

Four strangers form a friendship in the Boston Public Library after they hear a loud scream, followed by reports of a murder in the library. Together they go down the rabbit hole to solve the murder.

Mind you, this isn’t your typical mystery tale. This is essentially a book within a book. Hannah is an Australian crime writer drafting this tale of four strangers meeting in the library. The book bounces between drafts of her book chapters (each struggling to nail down American slang) and correspondence with Leo, an aspiring writer living in Boston who offers her notes on her depiction of Boston. Is Leo simply a helpful fan, or are his intentions more sinister?

I loved this book! It was giving a bit of Hitchcock meets Misery. The book within a book and subplot did feel a little confusing at first, but I promise it’s worth the read. If you’re into a good ‘ol fashioned who-done-it this is definitely worth adding to your list!

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely fantastic! I could not put down this book once the mystery hooked me. I was fully invested in the four main characters of the story. I could not figure out who was who, and the mystery kept me guessing until the end.

However, I really did not love the random emails between the author and her pen pal. I couldn’t understand the reasoning to include this story within the main story, except to cause confusion or even perhaps the fear? I personally didn’t care for it.

The fast pace made that for a quick read, and for that I would read this authors work again.

Was this review helpful?

The book-within-a-book convention is an either/or convention - either it works or it doesn’t. Fortunately, Sulari Gentill makes it work in this intriguing if occasionally frustrating mystery novel.

The stories for both “books” are good, but not equally so. I developed a more solid connection with the characters in the book inside the book written by Hannah. They seemed real to me, although quite transparent. I pretty much pegged the killer by the second meeting of the four characters.

This book takes some concentration to read because there are a lot of plot strings to keep sorted. I think the book-inside-a-book thing will frustrate some readers. Those who stick with it, though, will come out on the other side knowing they’ve read a clever, well-planned story.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley, Poisoned Pen Press, and the author for an ARC in exchange for an honest review of the book.

This book ticked all the boxes for me. The intriguing start with a murder in the Boston Public Library that launches the friendships of 4 characters, the character building that then takes place, the larger Boston setting--and of course, the innovative set up of a book within a story within a book. I loved the main characters and couldn't wait to get back to their stories. I found myself constantly shifting my predictions of who the bad guy would be. Overall, a fun, addicting read.

The only reason I didn't go to 5 stars on this is that there were a few jagged corners that I would have loved to see smoothed out. I really liked the interludes between chapters where we watched uber-fan Leo slowly reveal himself. However, I felt like that relationship was never fleshed out enough--I wanted to know from the first chapter what his and Freddie's relationship was and how their correspondence began. I felt like there was more to be learned about Freddie's little sister. And while I liked the meta-nature of this whole thing, including the very end, I found that I still had some niggling questions for which I was hoping for more resolution. But . . . these are minor quirks, probably all mine. I highly recommend this one to mystery lovers and book lovers.

Was this review helpful?

Had trouble getting into this one, though it could have been the mood I was in while reading it. I found it hard to care about the characters and the mystery surrounding them. I felt that I didn’t care where the story went.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, this book just didn't work for me. The plot revolves around Hannah, an author who is writing a novel about a scream overheard by a group of strangers at the Boston Public library. Each chapter in the book is a chapter of Hannah's manuscript that she sends to a devoted but strange fan named Leo. The end of each chapter includes a letter that Leo writes to Hannah with his feedback about the chapter and his general musings in life. This unique plot structure sets up dual mysteries - who murdered Caroline (the scream at the library) and what is the deal with Leo?

I had issues connecting to the characters from the very beginning. I didn't dislike any of them but I didn't really enjoy them either. I couldn't understand how quickly they became completely intertwined in each other's lives and why it wasn't strange? If Marigold starting popping by my apartment every day because I didn't text back. I would be concerned. The story also had some small romantic plotlines which I never care for, especially in thrillers.

I think my biggest issue was that the secondary plot - Leo's letters to Hannah - drops a MASSIVE bomb about halfway through the book which made the primary plot even less exciting. I only cared about Leo from that point on. I already felt the story with Freddie, Marigold, Whit and Cain was dragging along but this made it even worse.

I almost bumped my rating to 3 stars because I really enjoyed the unique, double plot structure. Unfortunately, it didn't go far enough for me. They two stories never overlapped or mirrored each other like I was expecting. The ending, at least for one of the plotlines, was very anti-climatic and settled within two pages.

Ultimately, I think there is a lot to like in this book but it wasn't for me! Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I'm not sure what was fact or fiction in this book, what was plot and what was contrived. So unfortunately this was a dnf for me.
Thanks for the digital review copy.

Was this review helpful?