3/5 stars

I've read and really enjoyed Serle's previous books so I thought I'd give this one a try. I went into this book a bit skeptical after seeing so many mixed reviews. Now to read the Dinner List to see where it stacks up.

What I liked:
-the mother/daughter relationship
-the setting (it made me want to book a trip to Italy)
-the short and concise ending

What I didn't like:
-the very apparent infidelity
-unlikeable characters
-lots of jumping around.

Although I didn't love this book and it was just okay to me, I'm still glad I read it. and it made me grateful for my mom, our relationship and to savor time together.

There was a lot of hype surrounding this book which is the main reason I chose to read it. The highlight of this story was the Amalfi Coast's descriptions - the scenery, the food, and the people. However, the main character, Katy, treated those around her poorly, especially her husband. Even dealing with the horrendous depths of grief at losing her mother does not give Katy the right to dismiss everyone else that cares for her. I was unprepared for the odd twist that occurs not long after Katy arrives in Italy, and I found it bizarre. Unfortunately, I was disappointed with One Italian Summer.

It definitely took me a while to get into this one. It opened with the death of our main character's mother. This is where her journey begins, so it might seem like a good place to start, but it was so dark that I had to force myself to keep reading. And then we quickly learn that this is not your typical mother-daughter relationship. Katy and her mother have a fairly co-dependent relationship. Katy says she is in love with her mother. She wants to end her marriage after losing the real love of her life. Okay....

Finally, we get to Italy. Things lighten up a bit and we see a few rays of sunshine. I never really connected Katy. She isn't a particularly pleasant protagonist. She's grieving, but she's unfair to the people attempting to support her. I did, however, enjoy her travels. I even enjoyed some of her self-exploration and will admit to breathing a sigh of relief that some personal growth occurred. But mostly, I enjoyed following her around Positano and the Amalfi Coast -- trying new things, exploring new places, and eating alll the food.

So this one was kind of mixed bag for me. Overall, it was worth the read.

*Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the advanced readers copy.

One Italian Summer is a quick read,full of emotion. The mother/daughter dynamic was well written and the story in itself with well done. I loved, loved, loved this book! I highly recommend all mothers and daughters read this.

After losing her mother to cancer, Katy feels devastated. Her mother was her best friend, the one with all the answers. Losing her makes Katy doubt everything in her life. She is not sure she wants to remain married to her husband, Eric. She is lost in despair and grief.

Needing a change and a place to clear her head, she decides to take the trip to Italy she and her mother, Carol had planned. The Amalfi Coast was a place quite dear to her mother. Carol had spent time there before she was married.

When she arrives in Positano she makes a connection with a young man, Adam, and then she sees her mother, alive and well and young too. Katy doesn't understand it but she doesn't want to blink and realize it was all a dream.

Carol and Katy become fast friends and Katy will do anything to continue hanging out with this carefree version of her mother. She is getting to know a part of her she never saw but for how long can this be?

I won't lie, I was a little disappointed in One Italian Summer. I felt like Katy took all but never reciprocated. She was mean and disrespectful to her husband, Eric who seem like a nice friendly guy. She was also trying to force Carol into making the decision she wanted. It was all Me, Me, Me with her.

What I did like was seeing Positano again through the author's eyes. The Amalfi Coast is one of my favorite places. A few years ago, I spent two magnificent weeks there. I had the best time with family and the best food too. I miss it and I can't wait to go back and have another cheese tour, visit a lemon farm and do a limoncello and meloncello tasting, take the boat to Capri, and enjoyed quite memorable dishes and desserts.

Cliffhanger: No

3/5 Fangs

A complimentary copy was provided by Atria Books via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

At the start of the book we find Katy lost in her grief of losing her mom, her best friend, the greatest love of her life. She explains their relationship beautifully and also explains the devastating loss she now feels without her.

As Katy runs away to Italy, to the place she planned to go with her mom, Positano itself becomes a major presence in the book and I loved being transported there. I’ve been to Italy but not the Amalfi Coast so it was fun being able to explore it through this book. I felt like I’d just gone on an Italian summer and could practically feel the sun on my face.

I don’t want to give too much away but similar to In Five Years, Rebecca Serle bends and plays with the concept of time and the here & now in a truly interesting way.

While it was a good read, the relationship between Katy and her husband wasn’t explored enough and there were parts of her mom’s backstory I didn’t love.

If you have recently or at any time lost your mom this may be a tough read.

⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 / 5
Takeaway: a love story between a mother and a daughter that is explored in unexpected ways on the Amalfi Coast.

Thank you Atria Books for providing me an arc.
This story was absolutely beautiful. Rebecca Serle has a way with her words and truly created an image of Italy and what Katy experienced. I personally have never had a connection for my mother and it was truly amazing to read about such a close relationship. I can not wait to see what Rebecca has next.

Reeling from loss, a woman takes the trip of a lifetime in One Italian Summer by bestselling author Rebecca Serle (In Five Years).

Thirty-year-old Katy Silver used to have it all: an adoring husband, a comfortable home near her family in Los Angeles and a rock-solid friendship with her mother, Carol. But her mother’s death turned everything upside down. Suddenly nothing makes sense or feels right for Katy, not even her marriage. After the funeral, she wonders, “If your mother is the love of your life, what does that make your husband?” Katy doesn’t have an answer, but she knows she needs change.

So Katy leaves all her commitments behind and travels to Positano, Italy—a place her mother spent the summer 30 years ago, and where Carol and Katy had dreamed of visiting together. There, Katy stays at the gorgeous (and very real) Hotel Poseidon, and she immerses herself in the Amalfi Coast.

That may sound capricious, but to Katy these choices are necessary, even if she can’t quite explain why. What Katy doesn’t count on is running into a woman who looks and sounds exactly like Carol would have at 30—and even shares both her mother’s name and profession. Without understanding how it’s possible, Katy gets to know a different side of her mother as a young woman, and One Italian Summer becomes a sumptuous and sensuous feast of a book.
Full review at BookPage.com

My feedback is much like some I read from others but hoped I could get over...this book is atmospheric about a lovely part of the world but it's just so difficult to get past this girl's unhealthily codependent attachment to her mother. Not her best friend, the LOVE OF HER LIFE? And she completely casts aside her husband and her dad, because she and her mom are soulmates - too bad, guys?? I mean, she's a full grown woman but that's all she talks about, especially in the introductory chapters. It colors her as such a stunted individual the rest of the book.

I love a book set in the idyllic and romantic location of Italy and this one was no different. The author uses such colorful and vibrant descriptions, I could picture just what she was describing even if I have only ever dreamt of visiting. Like other Serle novels, there was magical realism woven through the pages, which I didn't love, but also didn't hate. This story follows Katy on her journey of grieving the loss of identity through the death of her mother, an unfulfilling job, and a marriage that she is frustrated by when she travels to Italy on a trip she thought would look a lot different. I felt the subplot of her marriage was not fleshed out and was a bit rushed but overall enjoyed the perspective of how everyone grieves differently even if the mother/daughter relationship felt very codependent to me in a way that was hard to relate to.

I really enjoyed One Italian Summer, I’m a big fan of @rebecca_serle and this one didn’t disappoint

What I loved 🥰
🌅 the setting!! Take me to Italy please
🪄 I love a little magical realism
🍝🍕 the FOOD descriptions!!
💭 the overall messaging of the story
📖 I loved knowing that the places described in this book are really places! You can go to this hotel, and the cafes/restaurants mentioned in this book!

The only thing that didn’t work for me was Katy’s relationship with her mom, I just didn’t connect with it. Yes, it’s obviously the entirety of this story, but I think you can still enjoy this book without it.

I enjoyed the magical realism of characters meeting in time - the twist got me, but I'm not sure I enjoyed it as much as The Dinner List.

📖 Katy's mom dies & Katy can't cope with the loss. Carol wasn’t only her mom but also Katy's best friend & with her gone life has lost its meaning.

She decides to plan a visit to an Italian town her mother had once gone to as a summer escape from her mourning.

Imagine Katy’s surprise when she encounters Carol—alive & well & not the mother she remembers her as but as the young women she was BEFORE she met Katy’s dad & got pregnant. Katy now has the whole summer to get reacquainted with her mom in ways she never knew possible…

⭐️⭐️⭐️

📝 So… I cried. Bawled really. My mother had me at a very young age so her & I, in a way, kind of “grew up” together. She is my best friend in the whole world so I can relate to Katy when she says “My mother, you see, is the great love of my life. She is the great love of my life, and I have lost her.” I felt the pain of Katy’s loss to the my very core!

I loved that the loving relationship behind this novel wasn’t a romantic one but one of a mother & daughter which is infinitely more intimate in my humble opinion. I felt like the author did a phenomenal job with portraying grief & I also loved the description of the sun-soaked, beautiful Italian coast & the cuisine. (It brought me back to me & my hubby’s honeymoon that we took in Italy)

My only complaint is that I felt that the magical realism/time travel aspect of the novel was not explained as well as it could be. And I hated how Katy treated her husband. I also think there was some serious co-dependency issues she needed to figure out. But All in all though, I really enjoyed this book & would recommend to anyone who is obsessed with their mama like I am! 🥰

katy and her mother had a wonderful relationship as mother and daughter. carol silvers has died before they take their long awaited trip to see italy—a place where carile had spent a magical summer. katy leaves everything behind to make that trip alone. what she finds will change her forever.

I want to be in Italy.
Eating all the pasta.
Exploring all the breathtaking views.
Immersing myself in a simpler life.
I want to explore a new city.
Get lost in the streets.
Chat with locals.
Soak up the sun, the sand and the crystal blue sea.

Rebecca Serle has a way in her writing of capturing reflection during big life changing moments. Be those moments grief, love, loss, or searching for a sense of purpose her writing allows you, as the reader, to be reflecting right along with the characters. One Italian Summer felt the same.

I felt loss and grief with Katy. I felt the sense of exploration and being brought back to life and awe in the discovery of a new place. I felt the flurry of excitement for something new. Along with the realization things aren’t quite what you always thought they were.

One Italian Summer felt like a love letter to yourself. About searching for who you are meant to be, only to realize you knew all along.

Thank you to Atria and Netgalley for this eARC copy to read and review.

I truly and fully enjoyed this book - I wasn't the biggest fan of In Five Years but I LOVED this one. I found the time loop to be written wonderfully and thoughtfully. Katy thought she knew her mother but how can you really know someone who lived a whole life before you were born? She got to experience how her mother was younger first hand. She was lost and found her way.

I absolutely NEED to visit Positano, this book absolutely transports you to Italy and it sounds beautiful. I won't forget this one.

I love Rebecca Serle’s writing and was so excited to go to Italy via this book. I was there for it for about the first half, but it fell so flat. The best part of this was the description of Italy and the food.

Katy and her mom planned a trip to Positano together, where Carol visited before she met her husband and had Katy. Before they can go on this trip, Carol succumbs to her cancer, and Katy decides to go on this trip alone.

I didn’t love Katy, her personality and whole identity were tied to her mother. With Carol gone, Katy didn’t know who she was at the beginning of the novel, and I’m not 100% sure she found herself. I think Serle wrote Positano well - I could picture everything she was describing, almost to the point of being able to smell the salty air and taste the food.

The grief was real in this, and I felt so moved by it. Serle did a fantastic job of describing the process of grieving that moved me to tears in some places.

I am such a fan of Rebecca Serle. She hooked me with The Dinner List, fell in love with In Five Years, and One Italian Summer did not disappoint.

Katy’s mother has died and with her death Katy lost her identity. In the time of being with her mother for her final time on earth, Katy became unhappy with her life and marriage. So when the time came to take the trip to Italy that was booked for her mother’s birthday, she took the opportunity to go and figure out what she wanted out of the remainder of her life.

The spirit of Katy’s mother was everywhere on the Amalfi Coast, and Katy began to see her mother in all the places they were going to go. It was almost like a timewarp as Katy learned about her mother’s past.

This was such a lovely story and beautifully written.

4 stars

Thank you to @netgalley and @atriabooks for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Noone writes a sweeping story about love without it actually being a romance like Rebecca Serle does. Instead, she writes about grief, connections self-love, and the love stories that we surround ourselves with that aren't about romance at all. And she does it quite well.

One Italian Summer will have you planning a trip to the Amalfi Coast and calling your mother all in one sitting.