Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I didn't hate this, but there were a few poems that weren't exactly horror except for some "dark" descriptors. There were a a lot of them I did like, and that really stood out to me but really I've read better poetry this year and this was just not what I expected from the description.

It's not was "horror" as the description suggests but I did enjoy myself!

Thank you to NetGalley for letting me read this in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a beautiful collection that includes all women. So grateful to Net Galley for providing a copy. Beautiful prose through out, even if you are not currently a poetry fan I think this would appeal to a wide audience. Also, the cover is to die for.

Was this review helpful?

I was very excited for this one because I love the horror genre and am trying to find my niche in poetry.

Unfortunately, this was wasn't really for me. I did not enjoy the majority of these, as they felt a little flat. There were some stand-outs that I did really enjoy. However, I don't feel that I can give a collection a very high rating if I didn't enjoy most of the works.

This isn't something that I would call scary, perhaps unnerving is a slightly better descriptor? Most of the poems were gory, or had features of body horror. Some of works felt as though the author was going for shock value rather than fluidity. But, as I stated earlier, poetry is something I am just getting into.

Overall, even though this wasn't for me, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this to someone who enjoys poetry or horror anthologies.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC!

Was this review helpful?

I have been desperate to read more poetry in a broader variety of genres so when I saw this collection of horror poerty, I couldn't resist, especially since they were wriiten by women and focussed on women in general. I'm not a poerty expert but I don't necessarily think you need to be super into poetry to enjoy a collection like this. Almost every poem in this collection made me feel something and I think that's what's important. Whether it was disgust, distress, sadness, or anything else, each poem evoked some kind of emotional response from me. Having such a wide range of writers from different backgrounds really worked for me as it allowed for so many topics to be discussed and written about. From pregnancy, abortion, fertility, relationships, self worth, self image, there's something in her for everyone to relate to.

I really love the idea of this collection as a way to showcase women in horror writing and also to express the frustrations and themes of womanhood in a more gruesome, horrifying, and memorable way.

I think the collection is organised really well and each poem flowed well into the next. Nothing felt out of place, which I suspect can be quite difficult to do when working with such a broad collection of poets. The cover, of course, is stunning and realy represents what this collection is about.

Some of my favourite poems include;
'Untouched' by Marilyn Fabiola
'Words Unspoken' by Mary Rajotte
'To Bloom in Blood' by Sara Tantlinger
'These Men are all One Monster' by Cassondra Windwalker
'When Witches Come Out of Us' by Donna Lynch

I do think the first half of the book was stronger than the second half, however I did enjoy the majority of the poems. Often I found that the poems were covering the same ideas and themes using the same words and phrases which left parts of the book feeling repetitive.

Overall I really enjoyed this collection and would highly recommend it to anyone despite of their level of poetry knowledge.

Was this review helpful?

I thought I knew what to expect with this book. I didn't. Poetry is still new to me and so far it's been a blast. I don't think this will be for everyone, but I thoroughly enjoyed this.

Was this review helpful?

I don't read a lot of poetry so I didn't really know what to expect with this book. But I was so surprised by how much I liked it. I also wasn't expecting how literal the title was with the poems, there were definitely a few that creeped me out and that I didn't enjoy as much as the rest of them. but overall I think that if you love poetry especially poems by women you will love this book.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to Netgalley and the publisher/author for providing me with an e-copy in exchange for my honest review.

When I requested this I was just intrigued by the concept of it and I use to love writing poetry. If you love poetry and dark concepts, I would recommend this. I started reading this as soon as it was given to me on Netgalley and I loved it. There were some of the poems that were not my favorite but overall the entire book was very good.

I enjoyed it. Its a solid 3 stars for me.

Was this review helpful?

This was a dark, imaginative and engaging poetry collection, with a huge range of writers and themes explored. I'm pushing myself to try more poetry, and this collection really delivered! There are over 80 poems in total, so of course some stand out to me personally more than others, appealing to my personal tastes, and some poems really missing the mark for me, but that's the beauty of such a large collection; I get to discover many new poets/authors all within the horror genre. Some of these were particularly dark and descriptive, so I might be reluctant to recommend this to just anyone, but that's to be expected with horror! Plus, the foreward and introduction from the editors clearly established the themes and aims of the collection. Overall I think this was a well put together collection that I want to own physically when it comes out next April!

Some of my favourites included:
'It Hurts When I Breathe' by Mercedes M Yardley,
'Harm' by Emily Ruth Verona,
'These Men Are All One Monster' by Cassondra Windwalker
'Outside In' by Dalena Storm
'When You' by Miriam H Harrison
'My Body, My Book' by Carina Bissett
'Queen' by Alyson Faye
'Better By Now' by N J Ember

Was this review helpful?

I was intrigued to read this collection of horror poems about women, but I didn't like it. I like the symbolism behind them, but I couldn't find one and say "I really like it". I felt like there was something missing about each poem and most of the time I felt like something was off about them.
This doesn't mean other readers won't like this collection, but personally I didn't find it that great.

Was this review helpful?

I think my expectations were a bit too high going into this poetry collection. Knowing what it intended to do, I expected to be blown away, horrified, perhaps disgusted, and that this content would provoke a lot of introspective thought on my part as a female reader. I anticipated something like the emotions I went through reading the short stories in "Her Body and Other Parties" by Carmen Maria Machado—visceral dread, trauma release and unease, heightened by the fact that the horror in those stories comes in large part from how they relate to existing in a female body. As it turned out, I counted only a handful of poems in "Under Her Skin" as having any such impact on me whatsoever, which is, in the end, a disappointment to me. Again: my expectations were perhaps a bit too high.

However, poetry and how it affects you is very subjective, and it is important to keep your biases in mind reading a collection such as this. Especially when it comes to poetry which springs from diverse voices where the poets' lived experiences may differ wildly from your own. For example, many of the poems had themes of pregnancy, womanhood as it pertains to fertility, and motherhood—themes which I just do not relate to at all. They are an important part of many people's lives, though, and I recognize that those works just weren't written for me—and that is okay! They might be perfect and feel very resonant to another reader.

Beyond that, though, other poems I regretfully had issues with because they were just too vague for me. I love symbolism, but it needs to be rooted in some sort of clear intent, and here, at times I struggled to understand what the writer was trying to convey, as though the direction was somehow "off".
Others felt too shallow to me; I wanted the poems to cut deeper into the themes they centered around, because there is so much potential in the concept of cis and trans women and non-binary folks expressing their own personal horror, but I felt like a great number of the poems didn't deliver on their promise. At times, they felt repetitive.
Some of the ones I enjoyed the least read to me like the writer had formulated their phrases from a list of words that they thought sounded cool or beautiful, and those poems ended up saying nothing but "look at these pretty words" to me, which left me feeling empty.

Now a superficial note: the cover art is absolutely gorgeous, but the small drawings inside felt a bit... rushed? They could have benefited from more work. And there could have been more drawings, for that matter—they seemed kind of unevenly scattered throughout the collection, and that made them feel a bit like they were just thrown in there at the last second. This is just my opinion, but I felt like the drawings would have worked better and felt more organic to the content if they had had a more purposeful placement; perhaps if the poems came in some kind of thematic order, and the drawings separated the different themes like subtle chapter markers. I don't know. Just... as they were, I might as well have done without them.

In essence, I think mileage will probably vary with this collection. It might well be a five star read to you, and that will depend on what experiences, biases and preferences in writing that you bring to your reading experience. I would say to anyone curious, give it a chance—you might love it. For me, though, while I am sad to give it two stars as I truly respect the intention of what it was going for, in the end it just didn't give me what I wanted from it.

Was this review helpful?

In the debut poetry showcase from Black Spot Books, this collection showcases a diverse cast of women from all backgrounds; cis, trans, non-binary, and brings them together to create something unique and compelling.

Using horror and haunting imagery to convey the real-life fears of women all over the world - getting truly under the skin of the unspoken horrors and ripping into some darkly uncomfortable subjects. From sexual liberation, violence, bodily autonomy, fertility, self-harm and body image, underneath the eerie metaphors there is something that every woman will be able to connect with on a deeper level.

Rather than obvious monsters, most of the poems in this collection are a subtle horror - the chill in your spine, the fear that something is lurking, an unrest deep in your bones which stays in your mind long after you've turned the page. With a range of styles and prose, from classic to contemporary, from winding and story-like to short and concise - you may not like every style but you're sure to find something to connect with.

Evocative, darkly alluring and able to reach in and touch the hearts of its readers, I can't wait for the next collection.

Was this review helpful?

I can not express enough about the plot. The plot is so interesting that you will find yourself gasping everytime you find something new. Thank you so much netgalley providing an arc!
I really like the worldbuilding, and how the author can create a world that has the capability of making us vicariously live through it. I feel like the introduction was a bit too slow-paced for me. The characters are fairly interesting.
Henceforth, it was quite a good read.

Was this review helpful?

Under Her Skin is a poetry collection written by cis, trans and enby femme authors bringing to light, women, using body horror to expose the way society and life has shaped the way women live, feel, love and die. A beautiful collection of harrowing narrations that left me breathless each time, each one a reminder that there is a power inside every women not afraid to come out under any injustice. I felt some were repetitive due to the main theme picked out among contenders, but nonetheless important, true, and brutal.

This was a great, jaw-dropping, important collection that belongs in the hands of those old enough to read it and understand the grief, power and beauty of the human soul with or without duress. Absolutely breathtaking.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks so much to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC in exchange for an honest review!

I’m glad I requested Under Her Skin. The poems within these pages are not always horror, but we all know that horror can take on many different forms, especially for women. It’s also quite beautiful to see the diversity in these writers. I think representation is insanely vital for many reasons, so it’s nice to see these doors open for more women. Let’s not forget about the awesome cover art, too! Holy wow, is it ever beautiful!

There were only a few poems that missed the mark for me, but that just means they are probably going to be perfect for someone else.

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyed this, the poems were interesting, but unfortunately did not find the book overly relatable, which is something I feel is necessary to enjoy poetry personally. But that is nothing against it, because others WILL be able to relate to it.

Was this review helpful?

3/5 stars
Poetry isn’t necessarily a genre I would consider my favourite, but sometimes I find a bundle of poems that I do really enjoy. It’s really a hit or miss for me.
This one, I’m not sure. Some of poems are good, one I liked a lot was Beautiful by L. Marie Wood. I can’t say I enjoyed all of the poems, only the minority of them.
Some/most of these poems tackled body issues, which I can closely relate to. A poem that hit a bit too close to home was Something That Needs Destroyed by Linda M. Crate.
Overall, I would not recommend this bundle. I had a hard time finishing it because most poems were not good. There sure are some good ones, but they are rare.

Was this review helpful?

A horror poetry collection that is so perfect for this time of year! It gives off all those spooky/creepy vibes that October and Halloween is all about.

I had such a great time reading this collection and I do have say most of the poems I really loved reading. For me poetry can be hit or miss and it can be hard to try and read poetry and take some of the information in, but with this collection I had a brilliant time.

Was this review helpful?

First of all, the cover art for this book is absolutely stunning, truly incredible!

This was a very interesting read, as it is not often that we are able to explore the many different experiences that women have which are exclusive to their womanhood and their complex relationships with their body, their identity, and their role in a patriarchy in a format such as poetry, much less in the horror genre.

Before reading this collection, I thought the theme was very fitting — the lives of women living under the patriarchy are not exactly short of horrific and haunting experiences. And so I expected to see an in-depth exploration of what it means to be a woman in a world that is not made for you, using the horror genre —which has always been known for its social commentary— as a medium. What I found, however, were poems that related very loosely to the genre, if they did at all. Most of the ones that one could argue pertain to the horror genre seemed to lean more into body horror, following a very similar formula, merely using “gory” adjectives to paint a gruesome picture in the mind, without necessarily exploring the profound fears that can bring women to see certain acts as a mutilation of the body or a butchering of their being.

That being said, if you look past the fact that the book is supposed to be a horror collection, there are many outstanding works in these pages that create realistic and haunting images through which they narrate the fears and worries and aches that come with being a woman. Without a doubt, the diversity of the team of writers is an absolute benefit, as not two women ever have the same experience, and we can see that in the book.

All in all, I do think that fans of poetry will enjoy this book, but you must be aware that the poems do not lean much into the horror theme.

Was this review helpful?

This cover is absolutely stunning, and should be framed in a museum! One of the most beautiful covers on any book that I’ve ever seen.

This was a very different type of poetry collections than what I’m used to reading. These pieces are so introspective and at times haunting. It is a different kind of horror that is written about in what one would expect in most horror work. This is very much focused on the horrors to women’s bodies that we face in our lives. Very profound and moving. I certainly would recommend this to my friends.

I would like to thank the many poets who wrote these works, editors Lindy Ryan & Toni Miller as well as Black Spot Books and Netgalley for the chance to read this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This collection of body horror themed poetry is unique.

These poems rip into the skin of women and pull out the raw meat of who we are and what we put ourselves through, pertaining to the perceptions of beauty, both privately and publicly.

Many of the poems touched on the horror theme subtly and at times generically, like mentioning a knife was enough to qualify. Others turned their poems into something with a pulse that slowly seeped into and unraveled within your mind. There were only a few poems that really leaned into the theme, unfortunately.

Topics touched on include: pregnancy, childbirth, weight, plastic surgery, relationships, violence, etc.

While I enjoyed some of the poems, the majority didn’t meet the horror standard in my opinion. Furthermore, the strongest horror poems seemed to be clumped together in the beginning of the collection leaving the middle and end wanting.

With such a unique premise, I feel like this collection would have benefited by leaning into the horror theme a bit more than it ultimately did.

Thank you NetGalley for sharing this ARC with me!

Was this review helpful?