Cover Image: The Last Suspicious Holdout

The Last Suspicious Holdout

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

4 stars

This is a compulsively readable collection of interconnected short stories that I read in one day and likely would have read in one sitting if not for some mandatory errands.

The characters all exist in the same general space but reflect distinct relationships and experiences, and - especially for the abbreviated format - they are all remarkably well drawn. There wasn't a story in this collection I disliked, but I am partial to the titular event.

I was not aware of this author at all until a prominent review appeared on Goodreads recently. If you are experienced with Hubbard, you likely already know the gem within, but if you are also new to this author, I recommend taking the time to get to know them - and their intriguing characters - better through this collection.

Was this review helpful?

An excellent collection of interconnected stories of African American families sprawling over decades.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t know how Ladee Hubbard does it - these are interconnected short stories brilliantly written with complexity and a strength of purpose with thread after thread of humanity and human-ness juxtaposed with realities of life are cruel and familiar. This is superstar level writing that I relished. At times I slowed my reading speed and at other times I read aloud because the written words and cadence were so beautiful. Loads and loads to discuss in this one - fabulous book club discussion group choice. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This is a powerful collection of interconnected stories covering a huge range of topics from the war on drugs, eating disorders, bullying, and more. They all center the same neighborhood and are told in chronological order spanning about two decades. I don’t think their connections always worked for me. Sometimes I spent more time trying to figure out who the character was in relation to the other stories rather than focusing on theirs, and that wasn’t always revealed early or clear enough for me. Some stood out more than others, but that’s true for all short story collections. Overall this was a really meaningful look into a single community and the ways that their past have shaped the present. 3.5 Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

This is a collection of interconnected short stories following Black neighbors from an unnamed community from 1992-2007. Themes include subject matter that’s become expected from stories on Black American life, but told in unexpected ways: the war on drugs, the social safety net, prejudice, and microaggressions.

I will say, I think short story writing is VERY hard to do. It’s such a brief amount of time to establish place, characters, and conflict. I think Hubbard succeeded in this effort by plopping the reader right in. It worked for me sometimes, but didn’t in others. The opening entry “Flip Lady,” another titled, “Bitch: An Etymology of Family Values,” and the longest story (which shares the namesake of the book) were my favorites. But other stories I was too disoriented or not gripped enough to stay interested, and you really do need to read all of them to understand the cohesiveness of the 30-year timeline. I thought the breadcrumbs of interlocking relationships were clever, but wasn’t really entertained enough to follow up on them.

Was this review helpful?

"The Last Suspicious Holdout" is a collection of twelve stories that each take place in an advancing year, highlighting life in an unnamed suburban area in the US. Many of the stories are interconnected and reflect common experiences and struggles of the individuals living there. From roughly the Clinton administration and the war on drugs through the Obama administration where we see the results of those and other policies affecting entire communities. People arrested for drugs are deemed felons and unable to reintegrate into their communities and advance. Systemic racism is pervasive. Even when individuals have an opportunity to advance by gaining access to more privileged educations, they feel like outcasts and would rather stay in their own communities. The story sharing the title of the collection was especially strong about the ties between a community center and a corporation. Hubbard highlights a diverse community with examples of both negative experiences but also hope for the future.

Thank you to Amistad via NetGalley for the advance reader copy in exchange for honest review.

Was this review helpful?

**Thanks to NetGalley and Amistad Books for an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.**

I've been on a short story kick lately, so I was excited to read this collection. However, I was really disappointed with how this book was executed. Obviously, short stories don't have the same level of character and plot development as regular novels, but these stories were written in a way that made it extremely difficult to figure out what was happening and even how the characters within the same story were connected to one another. Additionally, all of the stories in this collection were supposed to be linked, which could have been really cool, but because none of the characters were introduced with a good foundation, I just got more confused when characters popped up again later in the collection. Ultimately, this one didn't do it for me, and I think there are much stronger story collections that focus on similar topics.

Was this review helpful?

Loved the author’s 2021 novel The Rib King, and her brilliant writing shines in this collection of short stories. Hubbard can build a scene very well, but I preferred the long game of her novel plotting (which is a general preference of mine) but would recommend this collection. There were a couple of stories here that I would love to hear Levar Burton read on his podcast.

Was this review helpful?

"You live in a society that has the idea that one Black person is three-fifths of a human being inscribed in its constitution. A society that believed that because certain people were born female, they were to feeble-minded to vote. You live in a world where people believe skin tone gives them special powers, and that those powers somehow justify them to brutalize other people for doing something as simple as trying to plant a seed." Ladee Hubbard's "The Last Suspicious Holdout" hit deep with that quote, those statistics, the deeply rooted systematic racism and sexism that plague those of color.

This book is set up as a collection of short stories, that can all be interconnected about a no-name town, "the southside", the "9th ward", gentle nods to setting location throughout the book. These short stories take place from 1992-2007, all encompassing the voices of the black community with the connection of the Equality Community Center. People should care about this novel because it points out the every day struggle that people of color go through trying to navigate this life, which is not something I generally have to think of as a white female.

The author speaks about the war on drugs, the lack of opportunities and infrastructural support, systematic racism, infidelity - every social issue is embedded. This book was a solid three stars from a relatively newly acclaimed author. I expect many more wonderful works from her. She has a in depth writing style and captures the voices of the black community well. Reading this book was like taking a walk through the neighborhood, chock full of characters you want to know more about, characters you love immediately, and antagonists that you hate. If you have ever seen the show Shameless, and you adore the Gallagher family - you will like this novel.

The short stories were thought provoking, vivid, but sometimes hard to follow. I am a character person and love a well developed character, which is hard to do in a collection of short stories, so my problems with the text are just that, my problems.

Was this review helpful?

The Last Suspicious Holdout is a collection of interconnected short stories centered in a common neighborhood and features a myriad of flawed, broken characters from all walks of life. While some of the stories were written more than a decade ago, the situations and circumstances are timeless and cyclical: for example, the challenges of single mothers, re-gentrification, the machinations of the prison industrial complex, the ramifications of the “War on Drugs” on impoverished and minority communities, etc. These stories are grounded in real-world problems and issues – marital problems, rebellious youth, financial struggles, scheming politicians, etc.

At its core, it is the story of a community – the good, the bad, and the ugly bits are on full display in each tale. Most stories and their characters are not “happy” and some stories appear to have open/implied endings - but that didn’t discount how much I enjoyed connecting the inter-relationships between each story. It’s hard to pick a favorite (although I loved the title story, There He Go, and Five People Who Crave Sauce) because each contains a character(s) that reappears or is mentioned in the following sequences or a seemingly random piece of information/mention evolves into a pertinent component in another story causing many refreshing “a-ha” moments.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an opportunity to review!

Was this review helpful?

Hubbard obviously writes well. While these are not happy stories, they are powerful and well-written, even though I didn't enjoy all of them (normal for a short story collection). Those interested in the black experience as well as good short stories will want to pick this one up.

I really appreciate the free ARC for review!!

Was this review helpful?