Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I was a little weary when I approached this book as a review possibility. I'm glad I did take a chance on reading something that was out of my usual genre. While it took a bit to fall into the style of writing in the first couple of chapters, the story keeps you moving throughout the pages as you follow a young girl, trying to make it on the streets of Oakland. Oakland is a town near and dear to our main characters heart, as is her brother and the boy down the hall, Trevor, who is pretty much on his own after his mother doesn't return home. In order to make the monthly rent, Kiara must try to find ways to make a quick dollar since her brother is set on making it in the music industry but has yet to bring a penny home. While trying to figure out how to make it all work, Kiara finds herself in an awkward position, ending in a large amount of money being handed over by a gentleman she met that night. This one experience leads Kiara down the road of making difficult decisions and finding her way through uncomfortable situations with the best intentions in mind. The story is loosely based on true events that happened in the Bay Area. I found the narrative and thought process to be very well thought out and mature, especially when I found out how young the author was. After finishing the book, I felt it was very well written and a very intimate expression of a young persons thoughts and experiences on the streets of a large city. While the topics didn't bother me in this story, there could be triggering ideas and hard to read narratives for some readers that pick up this story.

Was this review helpful?

"Nightcrawling" by Leila Mottley is a gripping and potent debut that showcases a raw and unfiltered look at the underbelly of society through the eyes of Kiara, a young woman cornered by the inescapable pressures of systemic poverty and injustice.

Set against the backdrop of a dilapidated East Oakland, Mottley breathes life into the character of Kiara, whose resolve and resilience are pitted against the crushing instability of her world. Her life, already teetering on the edge due to socioeconomic brutality, devolves into nightcrawling, a term that takes on multiple meanings as Kiara navigates the perils of the night to survive.

Kiara’s relationship with her brother, Marcus, is a heartbreaking depiction of the love and tension that can coexist in family ties strained by adversity. Marcus’s dream for a better future through music stands in stark contrast to the bleakness that surrounds them. Further humanizing the narrative is Kiara's care for her young neighbor, a storyline that underscores her complexity and the tough choices she faces.

Mottley's prose is powerful and lyrical, with a pulse that beats with the urgency of Kiara's predicament. The author tackles themes of exploitation, corruption, and systemic abuse without flinching, holding a mirror up to the realities that many overlook or choose to ignore. Kiara's involvement in the Oakland Police Department scandal is both a plot device and a societal commentary, revealing the pervasive nature of power imbalance and the vulnerability of those caught in its wake.

Through Kiara's eyes, "Nightcrawling" explores the dynamics of a community bound by hardship and the flickers of hope that occasionally penetrate the darkness. Mottley's storytelling is immersive, and readers can't help but be moved by the authenticity of the protagonist's voice and the raw honesty of her journey.

Was this review helpful?

Gut wrenching and poignant, this is the story of Kiara. She would do anything for her brother and friends-even if that means falling into night crawling by accident , and helping to bring down corrupt cops taking advantage of it. A great read.

Was this review helpful?

Night crawling is a very tough book to read. The depiction of the characters could not be more desperate than they are in this story.V while I felt the book was extremely well-written with an enormous maturity that seems to be beyond the author’s age-I did feel uncomfortable with the endless,barrage of bleakness in the book. I’ve never lived the life of the central characters so I can’t say if the novel is accurate or not. It portrays a very bleak world of immense poverty and despair. I look forward to reading the next book this author puts forward.

Was this review helpful?

This story is set in Oakland, California, and while there are a few neighbourhoods in Oakland that are what some might consider relatively well-off, Kiara Johnson doesn’t live in one of those neighbourhoods. Kiara lives in a run-down Apartment building which is inappropriately named Regal-Hi Apartments, where the only thing high about it are some of the tenants. There is a pool, which is accessorized with used bags filled with dog poop floating on the surface. For Kiara, this is home, there is nowhere else to go.
This is just a little background of the book. There is so much more that I can write but I don't want to reveal more. You need to read and experience it.

Nightcrawling is a heart-wrenching debut. And I will highly highly recommend it to everybody.

I can't wait to see what the author writes next.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for sending a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A great debut novel from Leila Mottley. Set in the seedy side of East Oakland the nightmare for Kiara and her brother begins after their father dies. Mother is sent to prison and the siblings are on their own trying to hold on to the apartment they were raised in. Marcus (the brother) is just coasting along and Kiara is feeling it is all up to her to lose everything. This was a emotional story that helped me to acknowledge that sometimes there is no happy ever after.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. I’m not sure there are adequate words to describe the hurt and raw emotion brought on by reading Nightcrawling. Like the rest of the world, I am totally flabbergasted that this story was written by a teenager, but as someone who works with college students, and can see how the younger generations are fighting to create everlasting change in our society, I can’t say I’m actually surprised that a book such as this was written by someone so young. She is one of the fighters who is speaking up for those who’s voices have been taken from them, and I’m honestly just so impressed by Leila Mottley’s incredible talent. Somehow, reading this story has simultaneously given me hope for the future while also leading me to feel things will never be okay in our world.

This book is absolutely gut-wrenching and heart-breaking while also full of optimism in the worst situations. I recently read of how resiliency isn’t a compliment, though often meant to be, because having to be resilient stems from being marginalized and disadvantaged, generally because of how policies and laws are created to keep people in tough situations. This book rings true to that. Kiara, and those in her community, are incredibly resilient, though no matter how hard they try, their situations and the people around them continue to push back, unallowing progress.

Nightcrawling is beautiful in the worst way. An incredibly written book, with such an upsetting story it’s hard to believe it’s based on situations occurring day in and day out, situations no one works towards resolving because the system itself is built to keep certain groups of people in horrid situations. I can’t imagine the drain and trauma it took to write a book like this, but I think it’s so important to be read to bring light to horrid experiences people are facing. I am so sad for the characters in this book, and even sadder for the real-life folks who have experienced what this story describes. The book is fiction, but the situations are real. It took guts to write this book and share it. I condone Mottley for her bravery, and encourage those who can stomach it to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

First, thanks to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for allowing me the opportunity to review this book for free in exchange for my honest review.

This was a heavy read that I didn’t enjoy as much as I thought. Everything seemed to happen so quickly and at times, it felt over the top. I did finish it though so that’s a plus. While the author was a teenager when she wrote this, I do not feel this book should be ready by anyone younger that 16 or anyone who would be easily triggered by certain topics and situations in the story,

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 20%

I just could not get into this book. I tried reading it and on audio. I tried setting it aside and coming back later but it still didn’t work and I’m not quite sure why. I really wanted to like it.

Was this review helpful?

There is a really great book somewhere in this novel but I am afraid the overly poetic writing got in the way for me. Still, this is a very impressive book from such a young author.

Was this review helpful?

NIGHTCRAWLING IS SO GOOD. Okay, sorry for yelling. It is a scathing statement on our “justice” system, with a captivating narrative and really effective prose, absolute powerhouse character development, and a plot that is dynamic and enraging and brutally honest and is so very important that we are all exposed to. It’s a thought-provoking, immersive text that has stayed with me. Highly recommend this to…basically everyone. Thank you immensely to the publisher and NetGalley for this e-arc!

Was this review helpful?

WARNING: This is a doozie and left me emotionally exhausted. How did Mottley begin writing this when she was only SEVENTEEN?! This perspective is important, and I will be recommending this to many of my patrons.

Was this review helpful?

Kiara is just trying get by. Her family has been torn apart by death and prison, the rent in her building has doubled and her brother is intent on pursuing a music career despite his lack of talent. Seventeen years old and dropped out of college, Kiara has few choices but to turn waking the streets at night. But when her name is brought forward as a key witness in a scandal concerning corruption in the Oakland police department, the world she had hanging together by a thread is decimated.

***ALL THE TRIGGER WARNINGs***

I have a problem with Shakespearean tragedies because the bad things all seem to happen to the characters because of their own actions and choices. For me, true tragedies are when it’s a mix of circumstances and choices or when circumstances determine your choices. Leila Mottley does a great job at expressing this conflict in Nightcrawling and demonstrating how someone else’s choice may leave you with no choices.

The most telling part of Kiara’s character is how she interacts with her nine-year-old. In their relationship you see what she wants and needs from the adults in her life but they either refuse or unable to give it to her.

Nightcrawling is a devastating book and to go so hard so quickly with a debut is commendable. I’m excited for what Mottley has next for us.

Was this review helpful?

There's been a lot of buzz about this book, especially when it was first published, and it's all well-deserved. I first picked it up about a year ago and had to pause for a while as the subject matter was tough. The writing is compelling and powerful, but I knew I needed to have some dedicated time to really appreciate the many layers of the story. I also knew that I needed to be in the right mindset to read this.

After finishing the book, I am in awe of Mottley's voice as a writer and the fact that she wrote this book while still a teenager. Amid the poverty and desperation that she describes in a raw and poignant fashion, Mottley brings in beautiful moments of connection - family connections, close friends, lovers, people you look out for and people who look out for you. The story feels real on so many levels - people trying, people making mistakes, people treating each other horrifically, people caring for one another, people celebrating.

This is a book that will stay with you for a while.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a masterpiece on trauma, growing up to soon, and how children without parents have to navigate the world was to early. Which gets them into situations that are hard to come back from. I can't give enough to the author for writing this but some MAJOR Trigger WARNINGS are needed. It's hard to not feel for this character and her love for the people around her. As well as heartbreaking. Watching her fall into the deep end.

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of a young black woman who resorts to sex work to take care of her family when all other options fall through. It’s the story of a family with generational trauma. It shines the light on black girls caught up in sex trafficking, a group often ignored when this topic is discussed. Though the characters face many struggles through it all there is always love and a commitment to be there for each other no matter what. Highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely beautiful and gut wrenching story of family life in Oakland. This was not an easy read, but I found the story to be worthwhile and important.

Was this review helpful?

Writing a review for Leila Mottley's "Nightcrawling" is going to be a real challenge. I have to acknowledge this novel would be a triumph for any artist, let alone one who is so young. You can tell it was written by a poet by the careful crafting of each sentence, the beautiful turns of phrase, the vivid imagery and tenderness toward our protagonist Kiara. Mottley has an ear for language and I think she's going to make even more profound and award-winning work in the future.

That said, this was an absolutely brutal read. I was drawn in by the gorgeous book cover and mysterious one-word title, neither of which clued me in to how heartrending Kiara's story would be. There were times I had to set down the book and close my eyes for a moment's peace. While I understood Mottley's message and knew there could be no happy ending when one teenaged Black girl goes up against the Oakland Police Department, it was still punishing. I do not mean to be flip when I say I'll need to read several upbeat books to cleanse my mind after "Nightcrawling."

I wish this author the best and look forward to seeing what's next for her.

Was this review helpful?

This is a tough read, but even though it is hard to get through it is no less important or admirable. I recommend reading it with a book club, where the focus on discussion will make the most of it.

Was this review helpful?

This incredible debut novel, Inspired by the true story of a 2015 sexual exploitation and corruption scandal involving several members of the Oakland Police Department, is an absolute gut-punch, heartbreaking and raw in the most visceral way.

The story centers on Kiara, a 17-year-old girl living in Oakland with her increasingly-absent older brother, Marcus. Due to the death of their father and incarceration of their mother, Kiara and Marcus are left to fend for themselves. As Marcus becomes more distant from his little sister, chasing his dream of becoming a famous hip-hop artist, Kiara becomes the “parental” figure in their strained relationship, spending her days looking for work in order to make enough money to stave off the ever-present threat of eviction, while also becoming the de facto caregiver for 9-year-old Trevor, their next door neighbor, often left alone for days on end by his drug-addicted mother. It is this very real need to keep a roof over their heads that propels Kiara to pursue every job she can think of, including asking Marcus’ ex to hire her at the strip club where she tends bar. Unable to hire Kiara due to her being underage, this moment leads to a drunken “hookup” with a bar patron who mistakes underaged Kiara, who is still a virgin up to this point, for a sex worker. This is the inciting incident that leads Kiara to the revelation that she can make money through sex work, telling herself that “it’s just a body.” From here the story leads into a series of events that thrust Kiara into the dark underbelly of Oakland and her abuse at the hands of those that are sworn to protect the city and its residents.

While this is the basic plotline, this book is not a truly plot-driven story. Leila Mottley presents a story that is an examination of the human instinct to survive and the events that shape our experiences and propel our decisions. This book has a lot to say about family, loss, violence, sexual assault, poverty, and survival, and the often forgotten marginalized communities that struggle to meet humanity’s basic needs. It took me about 50 pages to really get into it, but after that, I could not put this down. I had to keep going; had to know exactly what was going to happen to Kiara and Trevor and Marcus. This is not a “fun” story to read, but it is a necessary one that everyone SHOULD read. Five stars from me!

Was this review helpful?