Member Reviews
Growing up with TV shows such as: Unsolved Mysteries, Dateline specials, City Confidential, and Cold Case Files, I am certainly no stranger to True Crime. Reading True Crime, however, is a first for me and it was Casey Sherman's 'Helltown' that roped me in and tempted me to give the genre a try.
Sherman weaves fact with fiction to outline the true story of Cape Cod serial killer Tony Costa. I was not previously familiar with Tony Costa's story, but Sherman's depictions were expertly narrated to provide thorough information throughout. Admittedly, I skimmed through the more gruesome details, which should only be a testament to Sherman's masterful writing – I was truly squeamish through the parts my eyes did brush over. This was a tough read for me in the sense that I had to remind myself that it was factual, and real victims were at the heart of a book I picked up for entertainment. That reflection had me wondering if perhaps I am not a right fit for this genre for the time being. While a parallel story of two writers ran between the telling of Costa's crimes, my attention toward their place in the big picture didn't hold. I chose not to finish the book at the half-way point, finding comfort with the events I ended on. Respectfully, I reviewed the Author's Notes and References at the end of the book, which I highly valued. I found Casey Sherman's dedication to the facts and details of the real life events admirable. The extensive research he completed to format this book is again, another testament to his mastery at his craft. I may not be the right reader for the entirety of this book but, Sherman offers True Crime enthusiasts a deeper look into a serial killer's story, the mindset of the small town he lived in, and the events of the world at that time as well. "Helltown' is a True Crime read that will certainly come to life for its audience.
I appreciate both the publisher, Sourcebooks (non-fiction), and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this electronic Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for my honest review.
Disclosure: This book was provided to me by Netgalley free of charge in return for an honest and unbiased review.
In all fairness to the author, this just is not my style when it comes to true crime. I prefer my true crime clinical, with facts, and with a glossy section sandwiched somewhere in the middle abundant with slightly scandalous pictures.
My impression of "Helltown" is that it is trying to evoke something akin to "The Devil in the White City" - a book that I thoroughly enjoy. "Helltown", however, ultimately misses its mark. Similar to "Devil in the White City", "Helltown" uses an alternating chapter format to set the scene of a late 1960's Provincetown, Massachusetts.
Half of the book's chapters revolve around Antone "Tony" Costa - hippie, budding cult leader? (this is touched-upon towards the end with no real evidence presented), and serial killer. While there are some facts hidden within these chapters, they are presented as a story with completely fictionalized, frankly, downright corny dialogue that never happened.
The rest of the chapters revolve around Kurt Vonnegut, Jr., Norman Mailer, and the late 1960's counter-culture. These chapters are less fictionalized, but are mostly comprised of random quotes made by or about Vonnegut and Mailer which are then mashed into something that resembles a narrative. The overall effect is clunky and awkward. In my opinion, these chapters were just trying to cover more than they needed to. There was a ton of skipping around and the overall read could have been greatly improved with some focus.
The sections on Mailer were of little significance and could have been weeded out completely. I didn't mind the sections on Vonnegut as he did write about and have some connection to Tony Costa (although the interactions between Edith Vonnegut and Costa were greatly exaggerated by Vonnegut himself in the July 25, 1969 article he wrote covering the murders for <i>LIFE</i> Magazine).
I also did not enjoy where, towards the end of the book, Sherman creates this "what if" scenario involving a follower of Costa, dubbed Strawberry Blonde, linking her to a completely unrelated unsolved murder. The implication is that the Cult of Costa lives on in Provincetown. Sherman explains that this part is completely fictionalized but not until the Author's Notes in the back and, realistically, how many people even read those? What a mess.
Oddly enough, my favorite part of "Helltown" is the Author's Notes. Sherman mentions his contact with Edith Vonnegut and Avis Johnson, Tony Costa's former wife. In the end, I would have preferred a book that incorporated more of the author's research presented as facts over the heavily fictionalized account that is "Helltown".
This book was fantastic! It was indeed dark, but the storyline was captivating and well-rounded. The doses of nostalgia, and the author's clear admiration for Cape Cod made this book very enjoyable despite the heavy topic! I have already recommended this to several family members and friends.
A fascinating look at a series of sociopathic killings that paralleled and yet was overshadowed by the Charlie Manson Family's Tate/LaBianca murders, which occurred around the same time. While those captured the world's attention, Tony Costa's activities slipped into obscurity. They are now resurrected in an excellent narrative by Casey Sherman. Beware that this is not a truly nonfiction work as broad poetic license is taken with many of the characters, including the very real life Normal Mailer and Kurt Vonnegut. Yet, the story captivates and drags you along into a dark tale of just how evil some killers can be. Tony Costa was every bit as charismatic and manipulative as Manson and had his own bevy of witchy devoted followers. Did he truly have q dual personality or was he running a game on everyone? What were his true motives? The reader will decide. Once you begin this tale you will undoubtedly squirm a bit but putting it down will not be an option.
DP Lyle, Award-winning author of the Jake Longly and Cain/Harper thriller series
I could not be pulled into this story although it is a story I'd never heard about before. The writing was drier than the Sahara and I had to keep putting it down because I just could not stay in the story.
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This is not my first book on the Provincetown Murders and Tony Costa. I had hoped to have more facts and a different perspective on the serial killer and what took place. Helltown does not disappoint and offers well-researched insights into serial killer Tony Costa, his horrific crimes that are laid out in visceral detail, and his subsequent trial.
However, I did not like that more than half of the book focused on Kurt Vonnegut and Norman Mailer. I could not follow how that interruption was relevant or added to the book. It did not add to but took away from the focus on the serial killing and the other aspects of history occuring at that time.
3.5 rounded up.
This is a true crime novel fictionalizing the famous t Tony Costa of Cape Cod. Being a huge Cape Cod fan, I thought I might enjoy learning more about its mysterious and murderous side! This isn't your typical true crime novel though!
Set in 1969, in Provincetown, we learn more about the hippie movement and the dueling famous authors Vonnegut and Mailer. Through the novel we follow Antone "Tony" Costa on his murder spree and court hearings. The novel reads more like a television series and I have heard it is soon to be one!
If you like serial killers (the real kind), Cape Cod and history, this novel is for you!
#Sourcebooks #TrueCrime #NetGalley
Helltown by Casey Sherman is a great true crime story. Even though I had never heard of Tony Costa and the Cape Cod Murders it was a fascinating story that keep me turning pages. This happened just before the Manson murders and in my opinion was way more gruesome and sensational than Manson. Which is saying a lot cuz Manson’s was pretty bad. There was a lot about writers Norman Mailer and Kurt Vonnegut, Jr in the book. I believe it was necessary for the story, but maybe it didn’t need to go into quite as much detail of their lives as it did.
I was a teenager when this happened and devoured all books about serial killers back then, but I had never heard of this murderer till now. I like how it tells the story of these murders through the eyes of the serial killer.
If you like serial killer book this one is a must read.
Thanks to NetGalley for allowing me to read this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
#NetGalley #SOURCEBOOKS #Helltown
Thank you to SOURCEBOOKS (non-fiction) and NetGalley for allowing me to read and review this Digital ARC of Helltown.
All you had to say was murder mystery and I was sold on reading Helltown. In the late 1960s, Cape Cod was terrorized by the murders of an evil man. This book is graphic and not to be read lightly and it depicts the brutal destruction of the lives of many young women. The trial coverage was fascinating and Im surprise this story doesn't get more recognition. If you like true crime this is a book for you
A really great true crime book about Cape cod in the 1960s. I felt instantly transported to that time and place.
Very well researched and compelling, I almost forgot it was non-fiction at times.
Thank you Netgalley for this ARC for an exchange for an honest review.
Good book, I recommend reading it.
This is a meticulously researched, well written, and developed book. The setting is super memorable - Cape Cod in the late 1960s, with all the sociopolitical turmoil that categorized this time. Sherman is a talented writer, drawing readers into his tale. It's easy to forgot that this is a non-fiction tale; you get so lost in Sherman's descriptions and dialogue. Well worth a read for any true crime junkies.
Who's says that you can't learn something new ever day. I enjoyed this true crime book about a crime that wasn't technically solved. that was actually kind of scary. So don't read this one when your home alone or late at night.
Interesting and very well written book. I enjoyed reading this and will definitely look for more by author.
Thank you to NetGalley and the Publisher for the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
Unfortunately, this book was not for me. I wanted to love this story, since this kind of story is something that draws me in, however I could not connect to the story.
A definate MUST for those True Crime enthusiasts!
Excellent writing about the horrors that hit Cape Cod in the 1960's.
I had never heard of Costa before this book, so I am so glad to have read all about him. I did find the parts with Vonnegut and Mailer unnecessary and didn't really add anything to the book other than a few eyerolls.
Thanks to the Publisher and Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I’ve been trying to think over whether I’ve ever read a true crime book that was written quite like Helltown. Sherman is clear that this is non-fiction, but with some narratives that have been constructed with a best guess in mind.
I hadn’t heard of the Truro murders before reading this, which is unsurprising as they took place during the Charles Manson era. While gruesome and unsettling, the narrative that the author is able to create from well-researched sources is enlightening. Using Costa’s unpublished manuscript, Sherman is able to give an accurate look into the split personality of this twisted serial killer.
**I received this advance copy free from Sourcebooks via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.**
This is a fascinating story and well enjoyed. I love some true crime and drama! It was also a great depiction of the 60s and 70s. I had never heard of Costa before so it was fascinating to read (in a morbid kind of way!). If you are a fan of true crime I would definitely give this a go.
I can acknowledge the effort and research into the case this book revolves around however I found it a bit hard to hold my attention. I am a true-crime fan however I found there was a lack of cohesion from the author tying multiple narrative threads together that left me feeling impatient at times for things to move along. The additions of Vonnegut and Mailer didn't help the telling of the case in my opinion and they could be removed without impacting the story.
Thanks to netgalley and sourcebooks for the opportunity to read and provide an honest review.
This was an interesting storyline to begin with and is a nonfiction so I wasn't expecting much entertainment. It had a lot of really interesting facts but it had my head spinning for much of the book. I can tell a lot of effort and work was put into the book and it may be a very satisfying read for many.