Thanks to Wednesday Books for the free book.
This book was executed so well. McQuiston drew me in right away with the clues and Shara's disappearance. This was so well thought out, and I loved the twists and turns along the way. I also enjoyed the pacing of the story. The author left plenty of time for the ending to wrap up and for misunderstandings to be explored - which is what made me love this book. I wasn't a fan of Chloe or Shara in the beginning, but getting the time to dig into their actions helped me come to love these young adults that were navigating so many things while in a restrictive environment. Like McQuiston's other books, this one also has a lovable, diverse cast of characters that are so accepting and loving - yet they also aren't afraid to call their friends out when their friend/s need it. I left this book with a big smile and feeling like I was wrapped in a hug, especially with how they came together at the end.

Casey McQuiston's first turn at ya didn't disappoint and will be a hit with my students. I enjoyed the story and mystery, but for me it wasn't as romantic as Red White and Royal Blue. Overall it was a good read, just not my favorite but this author. Thank you netgalley for this arc in exchange for my honest opinion.

Casey McQuiston cannot write a bad book. Their debut into young adult books has blown me away in the best way possible. I Kissed Shara Wheeler is now one of my favorite YA contemporaries of all time. I never for a single second knew where this book was going, what these characters were going to pull next. I loved every single one of them. I wish I had this book as a teenager and I'm so glad that teens now are going to be able to read this and connect with these characters.

My favorite thing about McQuiston's books is that their characters find power not only in themselves and their identities, but also find the power that comes from connecting with the people around them. Chloe Green is no different. Being a teenager is hard. Being a queer teenager in small town south is even harder. Seeing Chloe & Co. come together, at first because of Shara's mystery but then because of something more, was beautiful.

Chloe is going to mean so much to queer teen girls who need to hear that they can be exactly who they are, that it's okay to be messy and not quite put together and not have things turn out the way you see them.

Chloe Green and Shara Wheeler are going to take the world by storm and I'm so excited that I'm here to see it.

WARNING: THIS BOOK IS ADORABLE

You will find yourself smirking while reading this!

This book seemed to pile on the themes and tropes into one fun mound of pleasant: Enemies to Lovers, Sunshine vs Grump, West Coast vs the South, Theater/Goth/Alt Teens vs Jock/Popular Teens, Academic Rivals to Lovers, Found Family. The list goes on.

I do read a lot of what is current in LGBTQ+ Young Adult, especially if there is a romantic element. It is beyond cathartic to read books that I wish existed when I was in High School. This book very easily makes that list. I also found this book very relatable in many ways.

I am, indeed, in love with Shara Wheeler.

I think most of my teenagers will love this book. It felt super relatable (particularly as we approach the last few months of school for seniors). The variety of characters were great, I loved the process of getting to know them, I felt like for the most part the characters had depth and felt realistic. At first the story seemed a little abrupt and disjointed to me, why did Chloe even care so much about what happened to Shara? But I also think that is very appropriate for the age group, getting obsessed with a topic to avoid reality. I loved the quest to find Shara and the process of getting to know Smith, Rory and some of the other characters like Ace. There were a lot of characters by the end but I never felt overwhelmed. There were one or two parts that I was a little offended by (like a comment about gay individuals not being good at math, as a math teacher I think this is a completely false stereotype). I will definitely be recommending this for my students, I can think of a few in particular that will love it.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for providing the ARC.

I think at this point it's safe to say that I would read anything that Casey McQuiston wrote. I have yet to be disappointed.

That being said, I Kissed Shara Wheeler didn't quite pull me in the way Red, White & Royal Blue or One Last Stop did. It might be because it's YA, or it might just be the plot, but it just didn't land quite the way I wanted.

Chloe,.to me, was a bit too antagonistic than I liked, but I understood why she was the way that she was. And Shara seemed duplicitous to the point of not wanting any kind of good resolution. But the whole time I read this book, I couldn't keep my stupid smile off my face.

It's not my favorite of McQuiston's books, but it's still a great read.

I think this is my favorite of Casey McQuiston’s books so far. I was skeptical when I saw it was YA, but I could not put this book down and had such a good time reading it. All the side characters were full of life and charm, and I loved seeing everyone in this book grow as people. Chloe was a great protagonist; even though she was extremely self absorbed for most of the book, you could see why she got that way and she had some good development by the end.
Overall, a great YA debut and I can’t wait to read Casey McQuiston’s next book.

Three people have kissed Shara Wheeler, including Chloe Green. Chloe can’t stand Shara, and has been in competition with her for grades, and eventually Valedictorian, forever. But everything starts to change after Shara kisses her, because not only has Shara kissed Chloe, she’s also disappeared right after- and it’s up to Chloe to find her.

I really enjoyed this! RW and RB was amazing, but I wasn’t too fond of OLS. This was a good comeback! Even though this is YA, which I find harder to read nowadays, this wasn’t juvenile in any way. Chloe was a great character and reading her POV felt realistic and mature, she was funny and reflective. The story was interesting with diverse characters. I liked the mystery aspect as well. Chloe formed relationships throughout the story and the feelings of all the characters were so real and accurate. When Chloe was mad I was mad, when she understand how other characters felt and her opinion changed, mine did too. This book was really well written! It delved just enough into emotions and high school feelings and situations and how everyone isn’t how they seem at first. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the free preview in exchange for an honest review.

I absolutely loved this book! The dialogue was realistic and funny without any "teen-speak" and the characters felt realistic and complex. As someone who grew up as a queer kid in the South, I think McQuiston did an excellent job of addressing the hardships of that experience while also celebrating the strength of youth in southern communities and their determination to make a change. This was a great first YA and I would recommend this to the teens at my library as well as anyone who is a fan of McQuiston's adult novels.

"High school is over, and everything is ridiculous."

Is this the perfect YA novel? If you prefer the angst-ridden, tear-your-heart-out and leave you sobbing brand of YA novels, then no. If you want to leave it with a sense of pure joy? Then yes.

This book is Mean Girls with a kinder touch. Pretty Little Liars with writing that doesn't suck. The wonderful kitschiness of Glee (without the problematic overtones). The same balance of poignancy and humor in Sex Education.

I grew up in the same type of Bible Belt background as the characters in False Beach, and while I didn't go to a private religious school, I still saw so much of my own experience in our characters' adventures in and around Willowgrive Christian Academy. I also appreciated that even in capturing the casual bigotry and repression that runs through the town (and so many others like it), they don't it paint with broad strokes, nor villainize communities of faith as a whole. They treat this fictional community with a tenderness that can only come from living it, from seeing the kindness and beauty that can exist alongside traditions and idealogies that can cause pain and harm. What Casey McQuiston gave me in this book was a glimpse at how that world could be better. I'm a high school teacher now, and part of what I loved so much about this book is that she truly harnessed the spirit of the young people I teach today, their bravery, their effervescence, their willingness to fight for the right to be fully themselves. And I love that so much. This book was so fun, and yes, it was ridiculous, but in the ways that teenagers actually are and want to be ridiculous -- and for me, it sparkled, leaving me feeling warm and hopeful in a way that I truly needed.

I wasn’t sure if I would get into this since I don’t typically read YA, but I Kissed Shara Wheeler is great in all the ways Casey McQuiston is always great. Shara Wheeler is the most perfect princess at the Christian school in Alabama that Chloe Green attends. Shara randomly kisses Chloe and then disappears. Chloe joins up with Smith and Rory (also recently kissed) to solve the scavenger hunt that Shara has left behind. Is literally any part of this story believable? No way, but who cares. It’s so cute and fun and I loved imagining this Alabama private school filled to the brim with gays and theys.

I loved Red, White, and Royal Blue, but wasn't a big fan of One Last Stop, so I wasn't sure what to expect with I Kissed Shara Wheeler. Then I came across the line, "Get a clarifying shampoo and suck it up, Kylo Ren," and I was sold! Overall, this book was a fun adventure of teenage angst and identity in a small town.

I was SO excited and grateful to get this Arc from NetGalley! This is not my "normal" genre, but I adore anything written by Casey McQuiston. The whole story idea was intriguing. I loved the premise of Shara disappearing and leave a trail of clues for only a select few people to find and figure out. The main characters were what cemented my love of this book though. While trying to understand who Shara really was, we got to know Rory, Chloe and Smith; and they got to know themselves better as well. I keep thinking about these 4 people and wondering what they are up to. I want to know more about them, to go on another adventure with them, to see them grow into themselves more. I really hope Casey writes a spin-off! Maybe it can be centered around Rory and Smith this time!

Casey McQuiston’s first YA novel was a great blend of clever, queer, and quirky. This is an enemies-to-lovers sapphic romance of sorts, but mostly it’s about high school, friendship, and self-discovery. The second half of the novel worked much better for me as the characters find more of their authentic selves. There is some sexuality and gender awakening for many of the characters. I strongly recommend this book for high schoolers, especially LGBTQ+ readers, and anyone who truly enjoys YA contemporary as a genre.

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press for sending a digital ARC.

"I Kissed Shara Wheeler" follows Chloe Green, a senior at Willowgrove Christian Academy whose final academic goal is to win valedictorian against her rival, prom queen Shara Wheeler. But, a month before school ends, Shara kisses Chloe and vanishes. On a hunt for answers, she joins forces with an unlikely group, the school's quarterback Smith and bad boy next door Rory. Together, the three follow a trail of pink envelopes filled with cryptic clues in an attempt to solve the Shara mystery.

While I enjoyed "I Kissed Shara Wheeler," it didn't capture me emotionally in the same way "One Last Stop" and "Red, White and Royal Blue" did, as the main romance felt lackluster and underdeveloped. I failed to understand Chloe's obsession with Shara, who comes off as incredibly unlikeable through the letters left in her mist and I found it difficult to connect with the motivations behind Shara's "Gone Girl" disappearing act. It was farfetched to believe that no adults were concerned about a teenager going missing weeks before graduation.

That said, the overall themes were well done and the supporting characters have my absolute heart. Their journeys, specifically, brought energy to the story. This book dives deep into the complexities of having a queer identity while living in a southern Christian small town and learning how to own who you are in place where the majority of beliefs want you kept in a closet forever. I appreciated the diverse representation which included bisexual, lesbian, gay and non-binary characters.

I found the mystery aspect of the plot intriguing, but the end of the wild goose chase fell flat was anticlimatic. It just had so much potential that I'm bothered by the lack of character development put in Shara's character. This is also why the sapphic romance advertised is the least exciting part of "I Kissed Shara Wheeler" which is a shame in my opinion.

I absolutely LOVED this book. It was such a fun read. I have been enjoying YA novels lately. I thoroughly enjoyed every page of this one. I love the mystery aspects of it. The coming of age, finding one’s self and questioning one’s gender and sexuality made this book so much more meaningful. Highly recommend this wonderful read!

Casey McQuiston does it - yet again! How do they write just the most loveable characters!? Even flawed, dramatic teenagers? I just wanted to hug everyone (especially Smith!). I really enjoyed this ride and the mystery and hilarious moments throughout. It warmed my heart so so much. Thank you for letting me read an advanced copy - I will be forever grateful.

Casey McQuiston has done it again! Not only does she deliver a delightfully gripping queer love story, but in "I Kissed Shara Wheeler" we get dynamic teenage characters with REAL stories, and a coming-of-age tale for the modern age. Fifty years from now, we'll look back at this one as a classic, I'm sure of it.

This book is so representative of the current generation of teenagers, and I wish I had it myself back when I was going to a strictly Catholic private high school. While McQuiston panders to the youth of today with the perfect mix of TikTok slang and social media obsession, she also nails a universal experience for every teen in America. They're just trying to figure themselves out! McQuiston flawlessly captures the essence of every kind of teenager — whether it be jock, theater nerd, or valedictorian hopeful — and makes them worth rooting for. Even Shara Wheeler, who's seemingly ruining everyone's lives, turns out to be worthy of her happy ending.

I Kissed Shara Wheeler is a pure delight and an absolute must-read.

Delightful, charming, exciting, bursting with heart. I'd expect no less from a Casey McQuiston book.

I loved this adventurous story, and even though both Shara and Chloe are absolutely psychopaths I somehow love them, too.

This is everything I want from a Casey McQuiston. Found family, complicated characters, a lot of heart, and a touch of cheese that makes me cry and I'm not ashamed of that. I also found the transition from Adult to YA writing to be seamless. The range!

Thank you to the author, St. Martin's Press, and Netgalley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

In the last half, this becomes a thoughtful, quintessentially YA book that made me misty-eyed about my own high school graduation way too many years ago. The last 40% is really beautiful work, particularly the "Burn Pile" bits, which don't do much for the first part of the book but really come together in the end. I'll be recommending this to teens, and that's really the best compliment I give to YA books.