Cover Image: Last Call at the Nightingale

Last Call at the Nightingale

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Fans of both historical fiction and mysteries will love the first in this new series from Katherine Schellman.

Last Call at the Nightingale is a new mystery series set in New York City during the Jazz Age. In 1924, Vivian and her sister, Florence spend their lives living in a tenement and working in a sewing factory all day. To escape the daily grind of this life, Vivian discovers the nighttime world of dancing and illegal drinking at a speakeasy called The Nightingale. Thrust into a world full of temptation and questionable choices, Vivian finds her nights of dancing and flirting interrupted by a murder in the back alley. Vivian develops her detective skills along with dancing skills to help find the murderer.

Danny, the bartender, Bea, the server and Honor Huxley, the owner, are each written with such detail portraying their unique personalities. The reader becomes invested in each character and feels like a part of the whole Nightingale crew. The setting of the novel becomes another character in the book with 1920s jazz details and New York City references.

Katherine Schellman's Last Call at the Nightingale sets up perfectly for this mystery series. I cannot wait to read the next one!

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the opportunity to review this book before its release.

Was this review helpful?

The jazz era.. a time when alcohol was illegal, music was changing, and speak easies were part of the night life. Last Call at the Nightingale is a wonderful novel that transports the reader back to this time period with the wonderfully descriptive prose. Vivian and her sister Florence work as seamstresses to try to survive but at night Vivian spends her time dancing away at The Nightingale. One night she finds a body in the alley and soon becomes immersed in a world that’s filled with secrets and crime. I felt that the author did a great job with being true to this time period and the story moved enough that I stayed invested.

Thank you to Netgalley and to the publishers for allowing me to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and St .Martin's Press for access to this arc


Whoever designed the cover of this book lured me right into wanting to read it however the book is more than that. What I found was a book with depth and layers. The murder mystery is certainly front and center but it’s back by great period feel, complex and often flawed characters plus what I love the most in this genre – both the clues to solve the mystery and yet one that kept me guessing until right when the killer is unveiled. Brava.

Yes, I inhaled this book. It’s dark and gritty but also filled with friendships. Vivian and Florence love each other but that doesn’t stop the fights, the silences, and the despair between them. Vivian’s best friend Bea, a waitress at the club, is Black and longs to sing there but that takes connections and as Bea bitterly tells Vivian, her family lost their connections when her father, a former Pullman porter whose job gave the family status, died of the influenza. Danny Chin, the smiling chatty bartender who is friends with a man showing Vivian attention, works nights at the club and days at his family’s restaurant and tells Vivian he learned his alley fighting skills because too many White men think of Asian men as punching bags.

Vivian starts investigating – well, careful listening really – to pay off her debt but discovers she’s the type who wants to know the answer. Clues are sprinkled lightly through the book but there are enough ambiguities and red herrings to allow a reader to follow down trails and wonder, along with Vivian, just who is who and what secrets they’re hiding. Since Vivian isn’t a detective and has never done this sort of thing, her missteps are expected but she’s shrewd and smart and willing to put on a front of bravado when needed. There weren’t too many times when I (mentally) shook my head at her and in the end, she gets the main answer plus negotiates a better deal from those who owe her.

The book wraps up the murder mystery and doesn’t end on a cliffhanger but there are some slightly unraveled threads left plus a maybe relationship that could take us into a sequel. I’d be happy to see what Vivian makes of her opportunities and what is in her future. B+

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this mystery set in prohibition-era New York City, where a modern girl could visit a speakeasy for a night of music and dancing, as long as she knows the password! I was really drawn into that world, of jazz and bribes and police raids, the contrast between the poor working class and the ultra-wealthy. Even the dialogue with its 20s slang was great—just enough to sound authentic but not cheesy. The mystery itself wasnt super compelling, it was really secondary to the vibrant setting & characters.

Was this review helpful?

The first novel in Schellman’s Jazz age mystery series, Last Call at the Nightingale sets us right in the middle of the speakeasy culture in NYC in the 1920s.

Anyone who knows me knows that speakeasies are my absolute jam and I love any story that takes place in the 1920s. Vivian Kelly was curious and courageous and immediately likable as a MC. I thoroughly enjoyed all the characters she met as the story unfolded and she unraveled the mystery. Highly recommend for a fun and quick mystery read. I can’t wait for the next book in the series!

Thank you Minotaur Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Trouble at a speakeasy might not be unexpected, but when Vivian stumbles across a body in the alley while getting some air with her friend Bea, it's only the start of how much her life is about to change. Over the course of just a few days, she finds herself in more new and sometimes dangerous situations. I enjoyed how the author kept every scene fresh, expertly revealing more about others and herself to Vivian as the story progressed. Every character is carefully crafted to reflect the ethnic, economic, and gender status represented, and the speakeasy setting provides an effective way for so many paths to cross. The mystery unfolds at a pace respectful to the reader, with the characters' actions and conversations leading the way. With some unresolved matters at the end unrelated to the main mystery, I look forward to a sequel.

Thank you to St. Martins Press, Minotaur Books, Netgalley, and the author Katharine Schellman for early access to this engaging read.

Was this review helpful?

**Many thanks to NetGalley, Minotaur/St. Martin's Press, and Katharine Schellman for an ARC of this book!**

I visited the Nightingale expecting flappers, moonshine, jazz, mystery, and an aura of danger...but what I got was a bit more of your standard 'corner bar and grill full of forgettable regulars watching a boring baseball game on a Tuesday night' instead.

Vivian sweeps away the long monotony of days sewing in the workhouse aside sister Florence once night falls at the Nightingale, a club featuring the illegal booze, wild dancing, and colorful crowds typical of such an establishment in 1924. Vivian's best friend Bea is her partner in crime, and the two while away many an hour together. One night, however, Vivian finds herself in EXACTLY the wrong place at PRECISELY the wrong time: she discovers a body in the alley by the club. Speechless and horrified, a police raid of the club then occurs, and Vivian finds herself in the whirlwind of this mysterious and ugly crime. Club owner Honor Huxley begs her to keep quiet, but Vivian can't help investigating, despite her secret affection for Honor AND a new man she has met at the club. Who is at the center of this ugly storm...and has Vivian set herself up to be the next target? Can the Nightingale keep its doors open...and keep its dangerous secrets under lock and key? And just how well DOES Vivian know the mysterious new man in her life?

I'll admit, I was absolutely lured to this book by its stellar and beautiful cover. I'm a sucker for literature set during this time period, from The Great Gatsby to Beautiful Little Fools, which was a surprise hit for me earlier this year, and I was hoping to strike gold yet again with Last Call at the Nightingale.

Unfortunately, the third time was NOT the charm with this read.

As much as I felt the cover drew me in initially, this is basically where the atmosphere stopped for me...and I picked this book up hoping that would at least account for 50% of my experience. if you hadn't told me this book was set in the 20's and you'd removed a few context clues, there was little to remind me that's where the story took place, and this setting just didn't come alive. I kept waiting for that immersive and magical experience where I felt thrust back in time, but there was a lot of telling rather than showing, and I had a hard time even picturing what was going on or the decor most of the time.

There's also nothing wrong with the plot, but nothing too memorable about it either. I usually lean towards thrillers over mysteries, so I knew I was a bit outside of my comfort zone here, but I was hoping to feel a bit more thrilled by the goings on than I was. Nothing wrong with a classic wjhodunit, and i can't say I guessed the perpetrator, but I wasn't wowed by the reveals either. The characters also weren't fleshed out enough for my taste, so they were pleasant enough but not as complex as they needed to be for any sort of an emotional connection. Granted, this IS a mystery rather than a drama, but there's always room for this sort of development in my opinion.

Honestly, the author's note at the ending gave some great references to her research, but also explained the the 1920s and the time period as though readers had never heard of it before, so it might feel a bit unnecessary if you're already familiar with the basics, but there are some decent resources listed if you're the researching sort. Sadly, I wonder if I might enjoy delving into nonfiction about the time period more than I enjoyed this particular book. I loved what I saw through the window of the Nightingale, but much like a glitzy outfit that looked better from far away, the spangles on this dress were simply a trick of the light.

3.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

I love the jazz age and I LOVE New York and as soon as I discovered the LGBT themes in Last Call At The Nightingale I was completely sold on this book AND anticipating more in the series. Schellman created a well-developed cast of unique characters including all races and sexual orientations in this 1920’s NYC speakeasy and painted a perfect picture steeped in the mystery of the dead man in the alley. From the lingo to the scenery, this book is fun and quick. I’d definitely recommend it to fans of the jazz age, New York City, and the LGBT community.

Was this review helpful?

This book makes you want to get your dancing shoes on! 💃

Last Call at the Nightingale is a murder mystery set in New York in 1924 during the Charleston era. The Nightingale is a illegal bar where people go to cut a rug, partake in alcoholic drinks and enjoy being accepted as themselves. Vivian Kelly goes there nightly to have fun and forget the worries of her day until she finds a dead body outside of the club. This spirals into a series of dangerous events that will forever change Vivian's life.

This is my first time to read a book by Katharine Schellman. She is recognized as a professional dancer and celebrated author. The book is well researched and visually takes readers to the dance floor with familiar themes of the era. The book has a few slow spots, but stick with it. The novel is a fun historical mystery that will have readers scratching their heads trying to figure out this "whodunit"! (3 ⭐⭐⭐)

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press, for this jazzy new book. I enjoyed reviewing it and appreciate your kindness.

Was this review helpful?

Last Call at the Nightingale is a fun romp through the Prohibition Era. Vivian is an Irish orphan, now in her early 20s with nothing but her sister Florence, her friend Bea, and her dancing at the Nightingale, a speakeasy run by some potentially shady characters, but it's the only place where she feels free. Vivian finds a dead body outside the Nightingale, and this mystery follows her through New York as she becomes more involved. The book has some holes, and maybe it's setting itself up for a sequel, but it is well written and fun to read. It's probably somewhat optimistic, but it's fun to imagine a place where people of all races, backgrounds, and sexual preferences come together to drink and dance and escape the dreary life outside.

Was this review helpful?

[Reviewed for Net Galley] This historical murder mystery is well written in the sense that it brings the reader back to the time of Prohibition so well that you think you’re there! The details are that amazing!

I quickly fell in love with Vivian’s character and her need to find a sense of life outside the hardship that her and her sister live in and have been living in since her mom left.

However, sometimes I had to think about how everyone fit in to the story because towards the end there were so many players into who killed Mr Wilson. I also wish that the story figured out the guy who knew claimed to know their mom.. that would have wrapped up the story a little better too. But definitely leaves it for sequel? All in all, a well written book, just some loose ends I wish were tied up!

Was this review helpful?

It's Prohibition and Vivian, a working girl, is a regular at the Nightingale, a speakeasy where she can dance, drink and enjoy herself for a few hours. Things get complicated when she needs to repay a favor. She needs to find information regarding a murdered man and it gets dangerous, but she is determined to make the most of it. That's the bare bones. The story is fleshed out in a most enjoyable way. The setting and characters are wonderfully drawn and the story pulls you along effortlessly. It also displays a realism about life, relationships and power in 1920's New York.

Was this review helpful?

Last Call at the Nightingale

I’m a sucker for a story set in the 1920s, especially in a fun setting like a jazz club/ speakeasy.

The author has such a knack for writing a period piece- she clearly does her research and keeps things authentic.

My favorite character was Vivian. She was not afraid to take chances to do what she wanted, even if that meant she disappointed her sister. I loved the sisters relationship. It was complicated but still rooted in love. I liked seeing them grow together and fight for each other. I would love to see these characters show up in later books.

This was such a fantastic mystery! It had me guessing till the end!

I highly recommend anything by Katherine Schellman. She is an auto read author for me!!

This is out June 7th!!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

An utterly intriguing murder mystery, set in 1920s New York. Filled with twists and turns, red herrings, snappy dialogue and clever characters, I loved every page.
Vivian Kelly is a likeable protagonist, a young queer woman who just wants freedom from her day job as a dressmaker, and she finds it at The Nightingale, a speakeasy in Prohibition era New York City. The club is run by bad ass lesbian Honor Huxley, who has a special spot for our Vivian, and the rest of the employees are just as amazing: from Danny, the bartender who can hold his own in an alley brawl, to Bea, the smart as hell waitress who also happens to be Viv's best friend. Rounding out our main characters are Leo Green, a friend of Danny's who has recently returned to town, with an eye for trouble and for Vivian, and Florence, Vivian's straight-laced older sister who definitely doesn't like Vivian's night-time antics.
When The Nightingale's relative safety is threatened when a body is found nearby, and the cops come calling, what will Vivian do to protect the place that most feels like home to her?
From the clues sprinkled throughout, to the reveals that I honestly didn't see coming, this book is a mystery lover's dream. Katharine Schellman is quickly becoming one of my favourite authors.


Thank you to Minotaur Books for the digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a fan of Katharine Schellman's Regency-set Lily Adler series, so I was excited to learn she's starting another historical mystery series, this time in 1920s New York City. Happy to say, my expectations based on the Lily Adler books weren't just met, but surpassed!

Vivian Kelly is a fantastic protagonist, sensible and curious and endearing, and, just as with the Lily Adler books, the ensemble of supporting characters surrounding her shine as well. The mystery was well-plotted and solidly paced, and the set-up for a sequel and longer series works excellently, between the complications of a love triangle (no, really, it works in this one!), the hinted-at mystery of Vivian and her sister's own origins, and, most of all, the evocative, atmospheric, richly detailed world of Jazz Age NYC and the Nightingale speakeasy. I can't wait to read more of Vivian's adventures!

Thank you Minotaur Books for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I went into this uncertain about this book. 1920’s NYC, jazz age, prohibition, and seedy speakeasies. Nothing about that appeals to me. If there’s a decade I’m just not into the ‘20’s is it!!

All that aside, I read this book in one sitting! Seriously I was invested and engrossed from the beginning I did go to YouTube and find a 1920’s ambiance room to set the stage, reach out if you want to know the one I used because it really put me into the story completely.

Anyways this author has such a knack for writing characters that the murder mystery is honestly secondary. Every character is human, flawed, and complex. There’s representation in a realistic and believable way and honestly I loved it.

As for the murder mystery, I had many suspects, and facilitated back and forth till the very end. Needless to say I didn’t figure it out on my own, but once revealed it made complete sense and I felt stupid hahaha

Thank you to netgalley, the author, and the publisher for my advanced copy in exchange for my honest review. Highly recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?

I love this time period! It's so different than the present and in so many different ways. Katharine Schellman brought it alive right in my imagination. I love the scene underground and when the lights are finally turned on, Vivian's entire life shifts from safety to danger. I feel this could easily have become a Law and Order episode had there been television back in the 20's. Everything about this felt real and I found myself looking forward to reading it.

Was this review helpful?

The Nightingale is meant to be Vivian's escape from the drudgery of her work as a seamstress and her effort to keep herself and her sister Flo housed and fed. It's 1924 and the Nightingale, despite Prohibition, it thriving, especially because it caters to a diverse clientele. All is well and happy until one night Vivian discovers a dead body in the alley beyond the place- and finds herself first in jail and then in peril. She agrees to probe the mystery for Honor Huxley, who owns the speakeasy but this is easier said than done, especially given the identity of the victim. I liked this for the atmospherics and the characters. The sisters, orphans, are devoted to one another and Viv's friend Bea is aces. It's gut just enough red herrings to keep the reader guessing. Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC. Here's hoping we see more of Viv.

Was this review helpful?

Vivian Kelly is seamstress by day, in Jazz Age New York City. But she lives for her evenings at the Nightingale, where even a poor girl can dance her cares away, and maybe sip some illegal booze. One evening, Viv steps out behind the bar to get some fresh air, and discovers a dead body in the alley. After being blackmailed into discovering who killed him, Viv finds herself thrust into a world of bootleggers, the wealthy elite, and people who have secrets they desperately want to keep.

Was this review helpful?

Book Review:

Last Call at the Nightingale by Katherine Schellman

I really like this dark and glamorous, kind of gritty Prohibition mystery and I think you might too! At the Nightingale everyone is equal and no one asks questions as long as you can pay your tab. But when Vivian and her friend Bea find a dead man in the alley, Vivian gets in deeper than she ever expected and is determined to find out who killed the man. Could it be the mysterious man flirting with her? The dead man's wife? Or maybe Honor, the club owner?

For being set in the 20s, this book had a diverse cast of characters which I really enjoyed. I also liked Vivian's internal battle between right and wrong, and what she learned about all the people she interacted with in her normal day that also frequented the club.

Thanks to @netgalley and @minotaur_books for this advanced reader!

Make sure to pick up your copy of Last Call at the Nightingale next Tuesday, May 7th!

#BookReview #Bookstagram #KatherineSchellman #LastCallAtTheNightingale #MinotaurBooks #BookishLife #Reading #InstaBooks #BookPhotography #BookRecommendations #Bibliophile #GirlsWhoRead #BookNerd #Fiction #MysteryBooks

Was this review helpful?