Cover Image: Haven

Haven

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I love Emma’s writing style since reading Room. This is super quick read. It’s a different book but in a good way. It’s not action packed but you will enjoy it. It would be a good book club pick since it would certainly spark interesting discussions.

Was this review helpful?

Oddly compelling, this story of faith and insanity is in essence as simple as a parable. But the author’s intensity and commitment lend it a depth. As claustrophobic as ‘Room’, it’s another example of empathy in isolation. The androgyny fulcrum, however, imports a kind of weakness. Necessary, perhaps, technically speaking, yet modish.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars An unusual, complex historical novel from Emma Donoghue about three 7th century Irish monks who form a settlement on a remote and inhospitable island off the southwest coast of Ireland. Artt is a well-travelled scholar-priest, a "living saint" who is visiting an Irish monastery when he has a dream compelling him to travel with two other monks - one old and one young - to set up an island monastery. Trian and Cormac are chosen and vow obedience to Artt before setting off in a small boat down the River Shannon and into the Atlantic Ocean on a perilous voyage to find the island from Artt's dream. The daily struggle for survival on an island that is only fit for sea birds is hindered by their leader, a zealot so firm in his belief that God will provide that he may destroy them all.

The stark island that the three monks settle on is now known as Skellig Michael - a UNESCO World Heritage Site and the site of a monastic settlement that dates to 600 AD. Donoghue's beautiful, atmospheric prose perfectly describes the starkness of this island and the struggle to survive under such harsh conditions. Haven is a quiet story about human character, religion and delusional leaders with a nod to environmental issues and a bit of suspense about how this will all end for the three monks. I can't say that I loved this book but it was definitely an interesting, thought-provoking read.

Thank you to NetGalley for the digital Advance Review Copy (ARC).

Was this review helpful?

I thought that Haven was a strange book. It is definitely unlike any other book I have read before, as I would never typically jump at a chance to read about two monks and a priest. I had a hard time getting through it, but I am glad I had the opportunity to read it.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautiful book about the agonies of the soul and the desperation of self-appointed religious leaders. Three monks set forth to live on a rocky and stark island today known as Skellig Michael.. Artt believes he has been chosen by God for this path, only to put faith before survival and pay the price for it; Cormac and Trian labor for Artt only to finally come to a decision that will not involve him. It's a quiet book, capturing the natural world of medieval Ireland. It moves in a slow and steady pace and presents and develops the world and the monks with great care. Early on, I knew there was a secret--Donoghue's books and stories often have these--that would led to betrayal, but I was surprised by the way that the betrayer realizes his mistake and seeks to rectify it in very real ways. This will be great for book groups.

Was this review helpful?

My first book to read by this author but definitely not my last! Such a gripping novel that made it hard for me to put his book down once I started it. Highly recommend!!

Was this review helpful?

Skellig Michael is as remote and inhospitable as an island can be off the coast of Ireland, but when Art has a vision that he and two other monks should live there the power and will of God compels them to make the journey. A mix of religion and mythology made this read interesting and the delusions of blinding following such leaders was interestingly addressed. A short and powerful read that will leave you thinking.

Was this review helpful?

I honestly had a hard time reading this. It is very descriptive and has great world building. The characters are greatly developed.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this gentle adventure-turned-survival novel. I found the historical aspects fascinating. I also liked that the author included notes on the current day status of Skellig Michael. I recommend this title to anyone who has read "The island of the lost" by Joan Druett.

Was this review helpful?

This story is unlike anything I've read before. I love this author's work, and her craft is evident throughout the book.

Three men, a scholar/priest and two monks in seventh-century Ireland leave their home and travel to a remote island based on a dream of the priest. They end up on a basically uninhabitable island, a rock in the Atlantic Ocean, and the rest of the story is one of survival.

I enjoyed the descriptions of the land and the work that the men did to survive - so interesting! The character development is amazing! I was hoping for more of a psychological thriller, which could have been included fairly easily with the different personalities of the three men. The plot twist at the end seemed a bit out of sync with the story and I wondered why the author included it.

All in all, it's a story that is a quick read, and I found myself thinking about the characters when not reading.

Thanks to NetGalley, Emma Donoghue, and Little, Brown and Company for the digital advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, I found this book a bit too slow to get into and have not completed the book beyond 30%. I hope to give it another try soon.

It is well written as all Emma Donague books are, but I found all three of the main characters difficult to parse beyond tropes, and the plot seemed to stagnate despite the characters going on what sounds like it should feel like an epic journey with very high stakes.

Was this review helpful?

I will read whatever Emma Donoghue cares to write about based on how much I have enjoyed her previous work. Her latest novel, "Haven," follows three monks in seventh-century Ireland who choose to leave the relative comforts of a monastery for a remote island where they plan to establish a new life dedicated to their faith. The island, known today as Skellig Michael, requires an austerity that is by turns inspiring and shocking. Donoghue — author of "Room" — excels at finding the humanity and drama in even the most confined spaces, and this book finds her in excellent form. As the three monks struggle to survive in these challenging circumstances, she explores the strength of the youngest monk, the wisdom of the oldest monk and the brilliance and cruelty of the man who had the vision to lead their quest.

Was this review helpful?

In the 6th Century, three monks disillusioned with their religious order set sail from Ireland to find a new home.

Emma Donoghue"s "Haven" puts the reader in the boat, up the mountain and through the work of building a monastery on a barren rock.

She draws full portraits of the abandoned boy, the old widower and the zealous prior who leads them. Readers live through illness and starvation of the trio, anxious to know the outcome of the monks' endeavor.

Donoghue set her story on a real mountain in the sea, Skellig Michael, that did host a monastery long ago. Now a UNESCO World Heritage Site, visitation to the bird-filled rock is severely restricted, though scenes from one of the Star Wars movies were filmed here.

Was this review helpful?

Another eARC from NetGalley. I am always so thankful to get these ARCs to read, and even when I don't like a book I appreciate the opportunity.

I wanted to love this book, I really did.
I LOVE the author's other works but this one just didn't do it for me.
Three monks set off to an uninhabited island after their Prior (one of said three monks) has a dream that God wants him to go there.
Trian, Cormac, and Artt give it a valiant go on this desolate island full of birds, and not much of anything else living.
Artt "lords it" over the other two as their Prior and constantly brings them to the brink of starvation and insanity.
I wish that the book focused more on what happens after Trian and Cormac finally decide to leave but sadly that's pretty much where the books ends. I feel like the writing of the book was beautifully done but the subject matter was just a drag.
I was glad to see it done, honestly. I do have to say, however, that I am intrigued by the factual basis of the story and would love to learn more about the monks that actually journeyed to this desolate isle.

Was this review helpful?

2.5/5 stars. While I am very appreciative to receive an eARC of Haven, this book missed the mark. Overall, the story was too slow for me and I didn't feel a connection with any of the characters. It was well written, very descriptive, and with only three characters, easy to follow.

Was this review helpful?

First off, this was like any book that I have read so it is hard to give an honest review because I was so out of my comfort zone. Emma Donohue is an amazing writer and you can tell that she put a tremendous amount of work into this novel. That being said, I really did not enjoy this book. I trudged through it because I felt the author deserved that much but it was a struggle. The monk was not only unlikable, but his piety became such a turn off. The resolution at the end provided a measure of solace but it was not a feel good type of book by any means.

Was this review helpful?

I've been thinking a lot about how to review this book. I've read almost all of Donoghue's books and <i>Haven</i> is unlike anything I've read before by her. <i>Haven</i> takes place in the 600s in Ireland when a scholar-priest who is visiting a monastery gets a vision from God that he should take two monks, leave the world behind and set up a new monastery isolated on an island on the edge of the world. The 300+ pages follow the three monks as they do just that-a seemingly impossible task on an island inhospitable to anything other than birds.

I have such mixed feelings about this book. I can't say reading a survival tale about three monks was ever my dream book to read, yet I read the entire book in two days and spent hours looking up the Skellig. I hated Artt so much I kept hoping the other two monks would push him off the island. Did I enjoy the book? I honestly don't know, but I'll be thinking about it for a while.

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I’m not going to lie to you, this is a really weird book, but you will probably love it. I have been an Emma Donoghue fan since her book Room, which is also a novel that if you described it to me, I would never in a million years guessed I would have loved it. I love Haven just as much as Room, my first and favorite novel of hers.

In Haven, in which Donoghue explores her Irish heritage via an Irish monk who has a dream to start his own religion, we are taken on a wild ride through uniquely dreaming eyes. This is a novel that is practically poetry in motion. If you are a romantic you will love this dreamy little story with all the wit and soul we have come to expect from Donoghue. I hope she writes forever.

Was this review helpful?

A dream of one man, Artt, to settle a monastery on a deserted rocky island leads two other men to leave their monastery behind them. The vision of the island leads them off the coast of Ireland to what is now known as Skellig Michael, an island where even Luke Skywalker has more recently hidden away. Pursuing the dream of Artt and a vision of extreme worship and service to God, these 3 men—the leader, the young and the older holy men survive with puffins and birds, one craggy tree, and the pursuit of God. When winter arrives and the struggle to survive is intense, all face it different both physically and in their perceptions of worship. This is a story of morality, of how to praise God, what to believe and the sins of man. Depth of character, detail of setting and of the heart of man make this a book worth reading to help the reader understand the human pursuit to connect with God. The reader is left with a desire to understand what makes each of us uniquely holy.

Thanks to Little, Brown and Company and to Netgalley for providing a copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This one is going to be popular on BookTube! Emma Donoghue does it again. Highly recommend for a book club.

Was this review helpful?